Abela v State of Victoria

Link copied
Case Copied 89 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Abela v State of Victoria [2013] FCA 832

Citation: Abela v State of Victoria [2013] FCA 832
Parties: BEAU ABELA (BY HIS NEXT FRIEND LITIGATION GUARDIAN, PETER ABELA) v STATE OF VICTORIA (DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION AND EARLY CHILDHOOD DEVELOPMENT)
File numbers: VID 405 of 2011
VID 1102 of 2011
Judge: TRACEY J
Date of judgment: 16 August 2013
Catchwords: HUMAN RIGHTS – Discrimination – disability – educational services – direct discrimination – whether failure to provide reasonable adjustments has the effect that person with disability is treated less favourably – ground not made out – indirect discrimination – whether requirements or conditions imposed upon an aggrieved person are unreasonable – requirements or conditions to be construed broadly – reasonable degree of precision necessary in formulation – requisite precision absent - ground not made out – alleged breach of Disability Standards – no contravention of standards – application dismissed
Legislation:

Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth) – ss 4, 5, 6, 11, 22, 31, 32, 34
Disability Discrimination and Other Human Rights Legislation Amendment Act 2008 (Cth)
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) – s 140
Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission Act 1986 (Cth) – s 46PH, s 46PO
Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth)

Commonwealth, Disability Discrimination and Other Human Rights Legislation Amendment Bill 2008, Explanatory Memorandum (2008) 7
Disability Standards for Education 2005 – Parts 3, 4, 5, 6, 7

Cases cited: Australian Iron & Steel Pty Ltd v Banovic (1989) 168 CLR 165 - followed
Australian Medical Council v Wilson (1996) 68 FCR 46 - cited
Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336 – followed
Catholic Education Office v Clarke (2004) 138 FCR 121 – followed
Charles v Fuji Xerox Australia Pty Ltd (2000) 105 FCR 573 – followed
Forbes v Australian Federal Police (Commonwealth of Australia) [2004] FCAFC 95 – referred to
Hurst v Queensland (2006) 151 FCR 562 - discussed
Minns v New South Wales [2002] FMCA 60 – discussed, followed
New South Wales v Amery (2006) 230 CLR 174 - followed
New South Wales (Department of Education) v Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission (2001) 186 ALR 69 – referred to
Nojin v The Commonwealth (2012) 298 ALR 410 – discussed
Purvis v New South Wales (2003) 217 CLR 92 - applied
Qantas Airways Limited v Gama (2008) 167 FCR 537 - followed
Re Australian Education Union; Ex parte Victoria (1995) 184 CLR 188 – followed
Travers v New South Wales (2001) 163 FLR 99 - discussed
Walker v State of Victoria (2011) 279 ALR 284 – applied
Walker v State of Victoria [2012] FCAFC 38 - applied
Waters v Public Transport Corporation (1991) 173 CLR 349 –applied, followed
Zhang v University of Tasmania (2009) 174 FCR 366 – referred to
Date of hearing: 30 April 2012 - 25 May 2012
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 221
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr D Hancock and Mr P Baume
Solicitor for the Applicant: MLC Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Abela v State of Victoria and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 832
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Abela v State of Victoria involved a claim by Beau Abela against the State of Victoria for alleged discriminatory actions under the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth). Beau, who has been diagnosed with various disabilities, alleged that the Department of Education and Early Childhood Development, which managed the schools he attended, had engaged in direct and indirect discrimination against him, as well as failing to comply with the Disability Standards for Education. The legal issues in this case revolved around whether the Department's actions amounted to discrimination against Beau, and if the failure to comply with the Disability Standards for Education constituted discrimination.

The court examined the requirement for Beau to prove that the Department's actions were discriminatory by reason of his disabilities, and that he was treated less favourably than someone without disabilities would have been in similar circumstances. The court referenced the High Court decision in Purvis v New South Wales, which emphasised the importance of identifying the true basis for the treatment in question. The court had to determine whether the Department treated Beau less favourably because of his disabilities, or for some other reason.

In reaching its decision, the court found that the Department's actions were not discriminatory, as there was no causal nexus between Beau's disabilities and the conduct of which he complained. The court determined that the Department treated Beau less favourably because of his violent conduct, and not because of his disabilities. The court concluded that the Department's responsibilities towards other students and staff justified their decision to suspend and expel Beau.

In conclusion, the court found in favour of the State of Victoria and dismissed Beau's claims for discrimination and failure to comply with the Disability Standards for Education. The court determined that the Department's actions were justified and not discriminatory, as they were based on Beau's violent conduct and not his disabilities.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Between 1999 and 2010 Mr Beau Abela attended several schools which were conducted by the State of Victoria acting through its Department of Education and Early Childhood Development (“the Department”). In these reasons I will refer to the applicant (who makes his application through his litigation guardian and father Mr Peter Abela) as “Beau” to distinguish him from his father to whom I will refer as “Mr Abela”. Beau alleged that the Department, during the relevant period, committed various acts and omissions constituting indirect and direct discrimination under the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth) (“the DDA”). He also complained that the Department had contravened the DDA by failing to comply with Disability Standards for Education prescribed under that Act. He seeks a number of remedies.BACKGROUND Beau was born on 28 September 1993. He claimed that he suffered from a number of disabilities including:· mild intellectual disability / borderline IQ / low average IQ;· impaired short term auditory memory;· significant motor difficulties; and · language impairment, diagnosed as “mild”; severe pervasive reception, expressive and pragmatic language impairment. This assessment of Beau’s disabilities was disputed in part by the Department. The Department alleged that the evidence established that Beau had:· an intellectual disability, indicated by his IQ of 62 which was diagnosed in May 2006; · short term auditory processing difficulties in respect of some more complex verbal information (known from 2007); and· attention deficit hyperactive disorder (from at least 2001) (“ADHD”). It was not in dispute that each of the conditions attributed to Beau, as part of his own case or by the Department, constituted disabilities within the meaning of the DDA. Because of the view I have taken about other aspects of Beau’s case it will not be necessary for me to seek to resolve the differences between the parties as to the diagnosis of Beau’s medical conditions. Between 1999 and 2005, Beau attended school at Panton Hill Primary School (“Panton Hill”), with the exception of terms 3 and 4 of 2000 when he attended Diamond Creek Primary School. In January 2006 Beau commenced attending Eltham High School (“Eltham”). Beau stopped attending Eltham on 15 May 2008 and did not again attend school until 21 July 2008, when he commenced at St Helena Secondary School (“St Helena”). Beau ceased attending St Helena on 2 December 2009 and did not attend school again until he commenced at Collingwood Alternative School (“Collingwood”) on 12 April 2010. He remained at Collingwood until 23 June 2010. The movement between schools in the course of Beau’s secondary education occurred because Mr Abela was dissatisfied with the treatment of Beau by the teachers and administrators at the schools and because of his negative reaction to their responses to his complaints.THE TWO APPLICATIONS Beau has made two applications. The first (VID 405 of 2011) was originally commenced in this Court as VID 558 of 2008 on 18 July 2008. It was transferred to the Federal Magistrates Court in 2008 and was later transferred back this Court as VID 405 of 2011. This application related to a complaint of discrimination, made on 15 January 2008, by Mr Abela on behalf of Beau. The complaint was lodged with and considered by the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission (“the Commission”). By notice, dated 25 June 2008, the Commission terminated the complaint pursuant to s 46PH(1)(i) of the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission Act 1986 (Cth) (“the HREOCA”). By reason of the provisions of s 46PO of the HREOCA this first application could only deal with acts or omissions on the part of the Department which occurred on or before the date on which the complaint was lodged with the Commission: see Charles v Fuji Xerox Australia Pty Ltd (2000) 105 FCR 573 at 579-580.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Astley confirmed that the letter accurately reflected the reasons why Collingwood considered that the application should be refused.Consideration In order for him to establish this part of his case, it was necessary for Beau to demonstrate that the Department failed to re-enrol him at Collingwood (or any other school) “on the ground of” his disabilities thereby treating him less favourably than the Department would have treated someone without his disabilities in the same, or not materially different, circumstances. There must, therefore, be a causal nexus between Beau’s disability and the conduct of which he complains. In Purvis v New South Wales (2003) 217 CLR 92, Gummow, Hayne and Heydon JJ held (at 163) that:“… the central question will always be – why was the aggrieved person treated as he or she was? If the aggrieved person was treated less favourably was it “because of”, “by reason of”, that person’s disability? Motive, purpose, effect may also bear on that question. But it would be a mistake to treat those words as substitutes for the statutory expression “because of””.In his judgment Gleeson CJ (at 102) was also concerned to identify “the true basis” of a decision to expel a student from school. His Honour said that:“The fact that the pupil suffered from a disorder resulting in disturbed behaviour was, from the point of view of the school principal, neither the reason, nor a reason, why he was suspended and expelled … If one were to ask the pupil to explain, from his point of view, why he was expelled, it may be reasonable for him to say that his disability resulted in his expulsion. However, ss 5, 10 and 22 [of the DDA] are concerned with the lawfulness of the conduct of the school authority, and with the true basis of the decision of the principal to suspend and later expel the pupil. In the light of the school authority’s responsibilities to the other pupils, the basis of the decision cannot fairly be stated by observing that, but for the pupil’s disability, he would not have engaged in the conduct that resulted in his suspension and expulsion. The expressed and genuine basis of the principal’s decision was the danger to other pupils and staff constituted by the pupil’s violent conduct, and the principal’s responsibilities towards those people.”See also at 143-4 (per McHugh and Kirby JJ); Forbes v Australian Federal Police (Commonwealth of Australia) [2004] FCAFC 95 at [68]-[70]. The Court is, therefore, required to determine, as a question of fact, why (in the sense of the “real reason” or “true basis”) the impugned conduct occurred. It must also be shown that the Department treated Beau less favourably than it would have treated other students who did not suffer from his disabilities in the same or substantially similar circumstances. The importance of identifying and bringing into account the relevant circumstances when making the comparison required by s 5 was emphasised by members of the High Court in Purvis. In their joint judgment Gummow, Hayne and Heydon JJ said (at 160-1):“It may readily be accepted that the necessary comparison to make is with the treatment of a person without the relevant disability. Section 5(1) makes that plain. It does not follow, however, that the “circumstances” to be considered are to be identified in the way the appellant contended. Indeed, to strip out of those circumstances any and every feature which presents difficulty to a disabled person would truly frustrate the purposes of the Act. Section 5(2) provides that the relevant circumstances are not shown to be materially different by showing that the disabled person has special needs. …In requiring a comparison between the treatment offered to a disabled person and the treatment that would be given to a person without the disability, s 5(1) requires that the circumstances attending the treatment given (or to be given) to the disabled person must be identified. What must then be examined is what would have been done in those circumstances if the person concerned was not disabled. The appellant’s argument depended upon an inversion of that order of examination. Instead of directing attention first to the actual circumstances in which a disabled person was, or would be, treated disadvantageously, it sought to direct attention to a wholly hypothetical set of circumstances defined by excluding all features of the disability.The circumstances referred to in s 5(1) are all of the objective features which surround the actual or intended treatment of the disabled person by the person referred to in the provision as the “discriminator”. It would be artificial to exclude (and there is no basis in the text of the provision for excluding) from consideration some of these circumstances because they are identified as being connected with that person’s disability. There may be cases in which identifying the circumstances of intended treatment is not easy. But where it is alleged that a disabled person has been treated disadvantageously, those difficulties do not intrude. All of the circumstances of the impugned conduct can be identified and that is what s 5(1) requires. Once the circumstances of the treatment or intended treatment have been identified, a comparison must be made with the treatment that would have been given to a person without the disability in circumstances that were the same or were not materially different.In the present case, the circumstances in which [the student] was treated as he was, included, but were not limited to, the fact that he had acted as he had. His violent actions towards teachers and others formed part of the circumstances in which it was said that he was treated less favourably than other pupils. Section 5(1) then presented two questions: (i) How, in those circumstances, would the educational authority have treated a person without [the student’s] disability? (ii) If [the student’s] treatment was less favourable than the treatment that would be given to a person without the disability, was that because of [the student’s] disability? Section 5(1) could be engaged in the application of s 22 only if it were found that [the student] was treated less favourably than a person without his disability would have been treated in circumstances that were the same as or were not materially different from the circumstances of [the student’s] treatment.” (Emphasis in original).See also at 100-101 (per Gleeson CJ); Zhang v University of Tasmania (2009) 174 FCR 366 at 384-5 [63]-[64] (per Jessup and Gordon JJ).