Nika & National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

Nika and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 2127 (6 July 2021)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):      2019/6512

Re:Etleva Nika

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal:Deputy President F Meagher

Date:6 July 2021

Place:Brisbane

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review pursuant to paragraph 43(1)(a) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth).

......................[SGD]......................

Deputy President F Meagher

Catchwords

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – access criteria – whether applicant meets disability requirement – complex facture of left leg – chronic post-traumatic musculoskeletal pain – adjustment disorder with anxiety and depressed mood – post-traumatic stress disorder  – whether impairments substantially reduce functional capacity – whether impairments affect applicant’s capacity to undertake social interaction, mobility and or self-care – whether applicant likely to require support under NDIS for lifetime – whether early intervention requirements met – decision under review affirmed

Legislation

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) ss 3, 4, 13, 21, 24, 25, 27 209

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Becoming a Participant) Rules 2016 (Cth) r 5.8

Cases

G v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2018) 266 FCR 511

Mulligan and National Disability Insurance Agency (2015) 149 ALD 408

Mulligan v National Disability Insurance Agency (2015) 233 FCR 201

Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority (1998) 194 CLR 355

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

Secondary Materials

‘Access to the NDIS Operational Guidelines’, National Disability Insurance Agency (Web Page, 6 July 2021) < cl 8.3

Explanatory Memorandum, National Disability Insurance Scheme Bill 2013 (Cth)

Explanatory Statement, National Disability Insurance Scheme (Becoming a Participant) Rules 2016 (Cth)

REASONS FOR DECISION

INTRODUCTION

  1. This is a decision about whether Ms Etleva Nika (the Applicant), 45 years old, meets the access requirements to become a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (the NDIS).

  2. On 21 September 2018, the Applicant made an application to become a participant in the NDIS by way of an Access Request Form stating that her disabilities were ‘[c]hronic post traumatic musculoskeletal pain and adjustment disorder with anxious and depressed moods…’.[1] The Applicant subsequently included complex fracture of the left leg and PTSD  as disabilities  for the purpose of requesting access to the NDIS.

    [1] Exhibit 1, T4, 47 and 50.

  3. On 13 May 2019, that application was refused as set out in a decision of a delegate of the National Disability Insurance Agency (the Respondent)  on the basis that the Applicant did not meet the disability requirement nor the early intervention requirements necessary to access the NDIS. [2]

    [2] Ibid T6, 57.

  4. The Applicant requested review of that decision on 17 June 2019.[3] On 13 September 2019, the internal review decision affirmed the original decision on the basis that, as regards the complex fracture of the left leg, the delegate was not satisfied that the Applicant had substantially reduced functional capacity, or psychosocial function, to undertake communication, social interaction, learning, mobility, self-care and/or self-management (the decision…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nika & National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 2127
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for review of a decision by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) to refuse access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). The applicant, who had sustained significant injuries in a motor vehicle accident in 2005, including complex fractures to her left leg and subsequent psychological conditions such as adjustment disorder, PTSD, and chronic pain, sought access to the NDIS. The NDIA's internal review had affirmed the original decision, finding that the applicant's impairments did not substantially reduce her functional capacity in areas such as social interaction, mobility, or self-care, nor were they likely to be permanent. The Tribunal was asked to determine whether the applicant met the access criteria for the NDIS.

The core legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the applicant's physical and psychological impairments substantially reduced her functional capacity to undertake social interaction, mobility, and self-care, and whether these impairments were likely to be permanent. Additionally, the Tribunal considered whether the early intervention requirements for NDIS access were met, specifically whether providing support would be considered early intervention and likely to reduce the applicant's future need for disability-related supports. The Tribunal had to assess the evidence presented, including medical reports and the applicant's statements of lived experience, against the criteria set out in the *NDIS Act 2013* (Cth).

Deputy President F Meagher P affirmed the NDIA's decision. The Tribunal found that while the applicant had experienced significant injuries and ongoing pain, and had received substantial support from family and allied health professionals, the evidence did not establish that her impairments substantially reduced her functional capacity in the specified areas to the degree required for NDIS access. The Tribunal noted the applicant's ability to work as a business manager, albeit with adjustments, and the long-standing nature of her conditions, which led to the conclusion that they were not likely to be permanent for the purposes of the NDIS Act. Furthermore, the Tribunal determined that the early intervention requirements were not met, as the long duration of the impairments meant that current support would not be considered early intervention and was unlikely to reduce future needs. Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the decision under review.

Background

Background to the litigation

The application was heard by video hearing by the Tribunal in Brisbane on 28, 29 and 30 September 2020. The Applicant had legal representation for the duration of the hearing process. Closing submissions were provided respectively as follows: by the Applicant on 1 October 2020, the Respondent on 9 October 2021 and in reply by the Applicant on 15 October 2020. BACKGROUND The Applicant was involved in a motor vehicle accident on her way to work in June 2005 which led to injuries including compound fractures of her tibia and fibula and right ankle, and ongoing pain. The brakes on the vehicle she was driving failed and she crashed into a metal barrier. Since June 2005, the Applicant has undergone numerous surgeries on her legs for injuries resulting from the accident and was referred to a psychologist in October 2005, with psychological treatment continuing until around 2009. She was also, as part of her rehabilitation, referred to a physiotherapist and consulted a psychiatrist. Prior to the accident, the Applicant lived alone in an apartment. After the accident she was assisted by her sister and her parents who came from Albania to help and support her. Her mother remains living in Australia, although her father has returned to Albania. The Applicant’s mother no longer lives with her, although lives in a unit nearby. Other members of the Applicant’s family, including her brother and sister-in-law also live nearby. The Applicant met her husband in 2013, they married in September 2014, and moved in together in 2015. The Applicant and her husband built a house together, to which she contributed the proceeds of her compensation claim. They moved into that home in May 2017. The Applicant’s husband works as a project manager, and prior to COVID 19 travelled internationally for work three to four nights per week, during which time the Applicant lived alone. Since the accident the Applicant has worked as a business manager at several schools. In 2016 the Applicant’s pain exacerbated, and on 9 May 2016 she was referred to Dr Graham Rice, Psychiatrist, Pain Medicine Psychiatry. According to the closing submissions of the Respondent, which were, in this regard, accepted and adopted by the Applicant, the referral to Dr Rice was to help the Applicant understand the link between pain and mood, and how to handle stressors differently so that they did not cause anxiety and influence her pain tolerance.[5] Low doses of medication were given to help both mood and pain.[6] [5] Respondent’s Outline of Submissions (in closing) dated 9 October 2020, [16]; Exhibit 1, T3L. [6] Exhibit 1, T3L. On or around 11 July 2016, the Applicant commenced a return to work program at a state primary school, initially working three hours per day for three days per week. That was progressively upgraded such that by May 2017 she was working in a permanent position as business manager of the school. At the time of the hearing the Applicant was working five hours per day four days a week (not Wednesdays).[7] The Applicant remains subject to a Work Restrictions and Approved Reasonable Adjustments Plan.[7] Respondent’s Outline of Submissions (in closing) dated 9 October 2020, [17]. LEGISLATION

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Also, before the Tribunal is material relating to the Applicant’s WorkCover claim including: ·decision of the Medical Assessment Tribunal dated 9 December 2008 ·letters and/or reports from medical and allied health practitioners who have treated and/or examined and/or assessed the Applicant dated between 2005 – 2009, including: oProfessor Ivor Jones, Consultant PsychiatristoDr David Hayes, Orthopaedic SurgeonoMr Greg Farrugia, PsychologistoMs Stephanie Johnson, Occupational TherapistoMs Tertia Ferreira, Physiotherapist oMr Barry Matthews, Podiatrist. Evidence of the Applicant The Applicant provided two statements of lived experience to the Tribunal, one undated[25] and one dated 5 June 2020.[26] In summary they set out the impact felt by the Applicant as a result of the accident including that she takes strong medication, balances her lifestyle very carefully to ensure that she can work and has been unable to follow her chosen career path as a result of the accident.[27] [25] Exhibit 7. [26] Exhibit 4. [27] Ibid [9], [10], [11] and [14]. The Applicant’s statements of lived experience also set out the specific ways the Applicant claims to be impaired,[28] the limitations she says these impairments impose upon her[29] and the way she manages to work, including that she is subject to a Work Restrictions and Approved Reasonable Adjustments Plan.[30][28] Ibid [4] – [9].[29] Ibid [12] and [13].[30] Ibid [15]. The Applicant identifies the support she currently receives including, in particular, from her husband. That support encompasses assistance with shopping, kitchen cleaning, laundry, garden maintenance, rubbish disposal, household general maintenance, meal preparation, car cleaning, driving to and from appointments over 15 to 25 minutes away, and if possible driving to and from work, and additional care when her pain is aggravated.[31] The Applicant also receives assistance from her mother and CentaCare, and has a disabled parking permit.[32][31] Exhibit 4 [28], [31] and [32].[32] Ibid [29], [33] and [34]. The Applicant sets out the support she says she needs and how that support would assist her to achieve her goals.[33] She says that other systems of support are inappropriate as CentaCare and other informal supports have been unsuccessful,[34] and reliance on her family, especially her husband, has a negative impact on them.[35][33] Ibid [35] – [38].[34] Ibid [39].[35] Ibid [40]. The Applicant also explains why she considers allied health and other therapeutic supports will assist in managing and maintaining her functional capacity and assist in preventing functional decline, which otherwise would increase the type and quantity of future supports.[36][36] Ibid [41] and [42]. The Applicant told the Tribunal that she currently works as a business manager at a local School.[37][37] Transcript page 18 lines 31 – 32. The Applicant described having a motor vehicle accident in June 2005, arising through no fault of her own, from the failure of the brakes on the vehicle. She described her injuries and explained that she had a number of surgeries to her leg, that there were episodes of serious infection flowing from the surgeries and treatment, that she was at risk of losing her leg,[38] and unable to weight bear on it for three years.[39][38] Ibid page 21 lines 7 – 15.[39] Ibid page 21 lines 33 – 34.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Applicant requested review of that decision on 17 June 2019.[3] On 13 September 2019, the internal review decision affirmed the original decision on the basis that, as regards the complex fracture of the left leg, the delegate was not satisfied that the Applicant had substantially reduced functional capacity, or psychosocial function, to undertake communication, social interaction, learning, mobility, self-care and/or self-management (the decision under review). As regards the mental health conditions generally, the delegate made no finding in relation to diagnosis but was not satisfied that the conditions were permanent for the purposes of the NDIS Act. Further, the delegate was not satisfied that the early intervention requirements were alternatively met because given the long standing nature of the impairments, providing support now would not be considered early intervention and supports now would not be likely to reduce the Applicant’s future need for disability related supports.[4] [3] Ibid T7, 59.[4] Ibid T2, 4. On 8 October 2019, the Applicant made an application for review of the decision under review to the NDIS Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The application was heard by video hearing by the Tribunal in Brisbane on 28, 29 and 30 September 2020. The Applicant had legal representation for the duration of the hearing process. Closing submissions were provided respectively as follows: by the Applicant on 1 October 2020, the Respondent on 9 October 2021 and in reply by the Applicant on 15 October 2020. BACKGROUND The Applicant was involved in a motor vehicle accident on her way to work in June 2005 which led to injuries including compound fractures of her tibia and fibula and right ankle, and ongoing pain. The brakes on the vehicle she was driving failed and she crashed into a metal barrier. Since June 2005, the Applicant has undergone numerous surgeries on her legs for injuries resulting from the accident and was referred to a psychologist in October 2005, with psychological treatment continuing until around 2009. She was also, as part of her rehabilitation, referred to a physiotherapist and consulted a psychiatrist. Prior to the accident, the Applicant lived alone in an apartment. After the accident she was assisted by her sister and her parents who came from Albania to help and support her. Her mother remains living in Australia, although her father has returned to Albania. The Applicant’s mother no longer lives with her, although lives in a unit nearby. Other members of the Applicant’s family, including her brother and sister-in-law also live nearby. The Applicant met her husband in 2013, they married in September 2014, and moved in together in 2015. The Applicant and her husband built a house together, to which she contributed the proceeds of her compensation claim. They moved into that home in May 2017. The Applicant’s husband works as a project manager, and prior to COVID 19 travelled internationally for work three to four nights per week, during which time the Applicant lived alone.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal began by examining whether the Applicant met the disability requirement under the NDIS Act due to her complex fracture of the left leg. The Tribunal acknowledged the severity of the Applicant's injuries and the subsequent surgeries she underwent. However, it concluded that the Applicant did not meet the disability requirement based on the complex fracture alone. The Tribunal relied on the evidence presented, which showed that while the Applicant's injuries were significant, they did not result in a substantial reduction in her functional capacity.

Next, the Tribunal considered whether the Applicant's chronic post-traumatic musculoskeletal pain substantially reduced her functional capacity. The Tribunal accepted that the Applicant experienced ongoing pain following the accident, which impacted her daily activities and required ongoing medical treatment. However, it found that the evidence did not conclusively demonstrate that her pain resulted in a substantial reduction in her functional capacity. The Tribunal emphasised the importance of substantial reduction in functional capacity as a criterion for accessing the NDIS.

The Tribunal then assessed whether the Applicant's adjustment disorder with anxiety and depressed mood and post-traumatic stress disorder resulted in impairments that substantially reduced her functional capacity. The Tribunal recognised that the Applicant's mental health conditions were a direct consequence of the accident and had a significant impact on her life. However, it concluded that the evidence did not demonstrate that these conditions resulted in a substantial reduction in her functional capacity. The Tribunal noted that the Applicant had made progress in managing her conditions and had returned to work, albeit with some limitations.

The Tribunal also examined whether the Applicant's impairments affected her capacity to undertake social interaction, mobility, and/or self-care. The Tribunal found that while the Applicant's impairments did impact her daily activities, they did not substantially affect her capacity to undertake social interaction, mobility, or self-care. The Tribunal relied on the evidence of the Applicant's ability to live independently, manage her household, and maintain a part-time job.

The Tribunal then considered whether the Applicant was likely to require support under the NDIS for her lifetime. The Tribunal noted that the Applicant's injuries and conditions were long-standing, but found that the evidence did not conclusively demonstrate that she would require ongoing support for her lifetime. The Tribunal emphasised that the NDIS is intended to provide early intervention and support to individuals whose impairments are likely to have a long-term impact on their functional capacity.

Finally, the Tribunal assessed whether the early intervention requirements under the NDIS Act had been met in this case. The Tribunal found that the early intervention requirements had not been met, as the Applicant's impairments had been long-standing and providing support now would not be considered early intervention. The Tribunal concluded that the delegate's decision to affirm the original decision was reasonable, as providing support now would not be likely to reduce the Applicant's future need for disability-related supports.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Tribunal will consider the severity of an applicant's injuries and conditions, but will not grant access to the NDIS if the evidence does not conclusively demonstrate a substantial reduction in functional capacity. The Tribunal will also consider whether the applicant's impairments are likely to have a long-term impact on their functional capacity and whether the early intervention requirements have been met. In this case, the Tribunal found that the Applicant's injuries and conditions, while severe, did not result in a substantial reduction in her functional capacity, and that the early intervention requirements had not been met. Therefore, the Tribunal affirmed the delegate's decision to deny access to the NDIS.