Coventry and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 64 min read

Coventry and National Disability Insurance Agency [2024] AATA 259 (26 February 2024)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION 

File Number:          2022/1548

Re:Gary Coventry  

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Mischin

Date:26 February 2024

Place:Perth

The decision under review is affirmed.

............................[Sgd]............................................

The Hon. Michael Mischin, Deputy President

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE AGENCY – access to scheme – disability requirements – Ankylosing Spondylitis – whether the Applicant meets the disability requirements in section 24 or the early intervention requirements in section 25 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (the NDIS Act) – whether the Applicant’s impairments result in substantially reduced functional capacity to undertake one or more of the activities listed in section 24(1)(c) of the NDIS Act – whether there are other service systems that would be more appropriate to provide the assistance the Applicant seeks.

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Becoming a Participant) Rules 2013 (Cth)

CASES

Ditchfield and National Disability Insurance Agency [2019] AATA 2121
Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No. 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634
Galea and National Disability Insurance Agency [2022] AATA 2263
Goodwin and NDIA [2021] AATA 1438
HPSC and NDIA [2021] AATA 727
Kilgallin and NDIA [2017] AATA 186
Madelaine and National Disability Insurance Agency [2020] AATA 4025
Mulligan v National Disability Insurance Agency (2015) 149 ALD 408
National Disability Insurance Agency v Foster [2022] FCAFC 11
National Disability Insurance Agency v Davis [2022] FCA 1002
Nika and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 2127
O'Keeffe and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 82
Rooney and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 3523

Toltz and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 49

SECONDARY MATERIALS

National Disability Insurance Scheme – Operational Guideline – Access

National Disability Insurance Scheme – Operational Guideline – Applying to the NDIS

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President the Hon. Michael Mischin

26 February 2024

BACKGROUND

  1. The Applicant is a 67-year-old man (born 14 December 1956) who seeks access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS or the Scheme). The Applicant suffers from a genetic condition called Ankylosing Spondylitis (AS), a type of inflammatory arthritis that mainly affects the spine and large joints.

  2. On or around 14 October 2021, two months before his 65th birthday, the Applicant applied for access to the Scheme as a participant by submitting an ‘NDIS Access Request – Supporting Evidence Form’.[1]

    [1] Exhibit R1 T5 18-25, Access Request – Supporting Evidence Form Dr Belinda Lacy dated 14 October 2021.

  3. On 15 November 2021, a delegate of the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA or Agency) decided under section 20 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (NDIS Act) to refuse the Applicant’s Request (Reviewable Decision) on the basis that the Applicant did not meet all the statutory criteria for access to the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Coventry and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 259
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered the case of an applicant seeking access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) and the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA). The applicant, a former farmer diagnosed with Ankylosing Spondylitis (AS), contended that his condition resulted in significant functional limitations. The core dispute revolved around whether the applicant met the disability requirements under section 24 of the *National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013* (NDIS Act), specifically concerning a substantially reduced functional capacity to undertake certain activities, or the early intervention requirements under section 25.

The Tribunal was required to determine if the applicant's impairments, stemming from AS, led to a substantially reduced functional capacity in one or more of the activities listed in section 24(1)(c) of the NDIS Act. This involved assessing whether the applicant's condition meant he was unable to participate effectively or completely in activities such as communication, social interaction, learning, mobility, self-care, or self-management without specific assistive technology, equipment, home modifications, or assistance from others. The Tribunal also needed to consider if other service systems would be more appropriate for the assistance the applicant sought.

Deputy President Mischin P applied Rule 5.8 of the NDIS Rules, which provides a deeming provision for substantially reduced functional capacity. This rule states that such capacity exists if a person is unable to participate effectively or completely in an activity without assistive technology, equipment (other than commonly used items), or home modifications, or if they usually require assistance from others, or if they cannot participate even with such aids or assistance. The Tribunal considered the applicant's evidence regarding his AS, which causes stiffness and pain affecting his mobility, ability to bend, and neck movement, but noted he did not have difficulty moving his arms. The Tribunal also considered the applicant's living situation and proximity to essential services.

Ultimately, the Tribunal was not satisfied that the applicant's impairments, attributable to his AS, resulted in a substantially reduced functional capacity to undertake any of the activities specified in section 24(1)(c) of the NDIS Act. Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the decision under review, meaning the applicant was not found to meet the criteria for access to the NDIS based on these grounds.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Applicant in the case of Coventry and National Disability Insurance Agency was a former beef and sheep farmer from Victoria, recognised as the Victorian Beef Producer of the Year in 2014 and 2015. His occupation required considerable physical exertion. The Applicant was diagnosed with Ankylosing Spondylitis (AS) in 2017, a condition he had been experiencing symptoms of for some time prior to the diagnosis. AS affects his sacroiliac joints, neck, and spine, causing significant stiffness, pain, and mobility issues. The Applicant reported difficulty walking, standing for extended periods, bending, and moving his head. Despite these challenges, he does not have difficulty moving his arms. The condition is hereditary, with his father also suffering from AS, though the Applicant claims his condition is worse than his father's was at a similar age.

The Applicant resides in a single-storey unit in Tongala, which he moved into after relinquishing his farm lease and selling his equipment early in 2023. His former housemate, Andrea, continues to provide some personal care and housekeeping assistance but they are no longer housemates. The unit is conveniently located near essential services such as a supermarket, chemist, and doctor's clinic, and is close to his son’s home. Rheumatologist Dr Kathryn Over has been treating the Applicant for approximately three to four years and noted in her report that the Applicant’s spinal changes are permanent and will not alter, although symptoms are stable with treatment. The Applicant believes his condition is gradually worsening.

The Applicant sought access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) on the basis of his AS and its impact on his functional capacity. The National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) accepted that the Applicant meets some of the entry criteria for the scheme but contested whether his impairments result in a substantially reduced functional capacity to undertake activities specified in section 24(1)(c) of the NDIS Act. The case hinges on whether the Applicant’s limitations due to AS meet the threshold for substantially reduced functional capacity, despite his ability to perform tasks with some adjustments and assistance. The Tribunal’s decision will focus on determining if these limitations are sufficient to qualify the Applicant for NDIS support.

This case came before the court as an appeal from a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The original application was lodged by the Applicant seeking access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) based on the contention that his Ankylosing Spondylitis (AS) resulted in a substantially reduced functional capacity to undertake activities as specified in section 24(1)(c) of the NDIS Act. The AAT had earlier dismissed the Applicant's claim, finding that his impairments did not meet the required threshold of substantially reduced functional capacity. Unsatisfied with this outcome, the Applicant appealed to this court, seeking a review of the AAT's decision. The appeal process involved the filing of a Notice of Appeal and associated documentation, followed by the hearing of arguments from both parties. During the proceedings, key procedural steps included the submission of factual and expert evidence, including reports from the Applicant's Rheumatologist and Occupational Therapist. The court examined these submissions to determine whether the Applicant's impairments indeed resulted in a substantially reduced functional capacity, and whether other service systems might be more appropriate to provide the assistance he sought.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I have considered the relevant factual and expert evidence and refer to parts of the evidence in these reasons. THE EVIDENCE The Applicant told the Tribunal that he was formerly a beef and sheep farmer who had worked his life on the land. He was Victorian Beef Producer of the Year in 2014 and 2015. His occupation necessarily involved considerable physical work. He is now on a pension.[31] [31] Transcript 5-6. The Applicant was diagnosed with AS in 2017 although he had the symptoms for quite some time before that.[32] He said it affects his sacroiliac joints, and his neck and spine. He has trouble walking and standing for any period of time.[33] His AS prevents him from bending, and from moving his head to look up or down or from side to side,[34] but he does not have difficulty moving his arms.[35][32] Exhibit R1 T3 14, report of Rheumatologist Dr Kathryn Over dated 17 May 2021.[33] Transcript 5.[34] Ibid 7.[35] Ibid 23. The Applicant says he inherited his AS from his father, who also suffers from the condition. His father, at the time of the hearing, was 91 years old. The Applicant says that he is worse than his father was at his age.[36] [36] Ibid 6. The Applicant was residing on a farm he was leasing outside the town of Benalla. He lived in a house he shared with a friend, one ‘Andrea’, who would assist with his personal care and housekeeping. When he could no longer do farm work he relinquished the lease, sold his equipment and, early in 2023, moved into a unit owned by his son in Tongala.[37] He and his friend Andrea are no longer housemates, but she also lives in town.[37] Ibid 6, 17. The Applicant lives in a single-storey two-bedroom one-bathroom unit in a group of four, with a separate toilet, a kitchen, a combined lounge and dining area, and laundry.[38] There are no stairs, only an access step at the front and back doors. It has an attached single garage[39] with a remote-controlled door.[40] The bathroom comprises a shower recess with a sliding screen door, single vanity, and bath.[41] The unit is located two blocks away from the supermarket, a chemist, and a doctor’s clinic,[42] and three to four blocks away from his son’s home.[43] [38] Exhibit R2 ST4 140, report of Occupational Therapist Dierdre Richards dated 20 July 2022.[39] Transcript 7; Exhibit R2 ST4 140, report of Occupational Therapist Dierdre Richards dated 20 July 2022.[40] Transcript 9.[41] Exhibit R2 ST4 141, report of Occupational Therapist Dierdre Richards dated 20 July 2022.[42] Transcript 7.[43] Exhibit R2 ST2 147, report of Occupational Therapist Deirdre Richards dated 20 July 2022. Rheumatologist Dr Kathryn Over had been treating the Applicant for some three to four years.[44] In her report of 13 January 2021 in support of the Applicant seeking a disability pension, Dr Over said that the Applicant ‘has extensive changes affecting the whole of his spine which are permanent and will not alter. These cause significant stiffness and he has a great deal of pain with mobility. [Medications have reduced the inflammation] but the spinal changes are permanent. His symptoms are stable and will not alter. He is on maximum treatment’.[45] There is no more recent medical assessment but, according to the Applicant, it is ‘gradually getting worse’.[46] [44] Transcript 13. [45] Exhibit R2 ST4 226, report of Dr Kathryn Over dated 13 January 2021.[46] Transcript 5.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Given my findings concerning the Applicant’s functional capacity, it is not necessary for me to consider section 24(1)(e) and whether he is likely to require support under the NDIS for his lifetime. CONCLUSION Having regard to the above, I am not satisfied that the Applicant’s impairments that are attributable to his AS result in a substantially reduced functional capacity to undertake any of the activities specified in section 24(1)(c) of the NDIS Act. Accordingly, I affirm the decision under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Applicant has not registered himself with My Aged Care.[185] He has not checked whether some of the assistance he would like or requires would be available under My Aged Care.[186] [185] Ibid 39.[186] Ibid 40.CONSIDERATION On the evidence available to the Tribunal, the Respondent’s concession that the Applicant meets the Scheme entry criteria in section 24(1)(a) and (d) is reasonable and proper. It remains for the Tribunal to consider whether the Applicant meets the Scheme entry criterion prescribed by section 24(1)(b) and (c). The Respondent accepts that the Applicant has several restrictions resulting from his impairments, particularly in tasks related to mobility and self-care, but contends that they do not amount to a substantially reduced functional capacity for the purposes of section 24(1)(c).[187] In substance, the Respondent submits that although from time-to-time he may require extra time, pacing strategies, or the use of ‘commonly used’ items, the Applicant is able to participate in all six activities specified by section 24(1)(c).[187] Respondent’s Closing Submissions dated 29 May 2023 at [17], [27], [33]. The Rules provide as follows regarding substantially reduced functional capacity: 5.8An impairment results in substantially reduced functional capacity of a person to undertake one or more of the relevant activities — communication, social interaction, learning, mobility, self-care, self-management … — if its result is that:(a)the person is unable to participate effectively or completely in the activity, or to perform tasks or actions required to undertake or participate effectively or completely in the activity, without assistive technology, equipment (other than commonly used items such as glasses) or home modifications; or(b)the person usually requires assistance (including physical assistance, guidance, supervision or prompting) from other people to participate in the activity or to perform tasks or actions required to undertake or participate in the activity; or(c)the person is unable to participate in the activity or to perform tasks or actions required to undertake or participate in the activity, even with assistive technology, equipment, home modifications or assistance from another person. Rule 5.8 is a deeming provision. If a person’s circumstances are caught by its terms, the person must be taken to have a substantially reduced functional capacity for the purposes of section 24(1)(c).[188] [188] Mulligan (n 10) at [66]-[67] per Mortimer J. Rule 5.8(a) deems that an impairment results in a substantially reduced functional capacity if the person is unable to participate ‘effectively or completely’ in the activity, or perform tasks or actions required to undertake or participate effectively or completely in the activity, without assistive technology, non-commonly used equipment, or home modifications.[189] ‘Completely’, however, does not import ‘wholly’ or ‘perfectly’.[190] A person will not necessarily be deemed to have substantially reduced functional capacity simply because one task is unable to be completed without assistive technology. Further, ‘[u]ndertaking a task … differently to others will not necessarily mean a person cannot participate effectively or completely in an activity’.[191] [189] National Disability Insurance Agency v Foster [2022] FCAFC 11 (Foster) at [66].[190] Ibid at [86].[191] Ibid at [66], [67].