Goodwin and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

Goodwin and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 1438 (21 May 2021)

Division:National Disability Insurance Scheme Division

File Number(s):       2019/5752

Re:Shane David Goodwin  

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal: Member I Thompson 

Date:21 May 2021

Place:Adelaide

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

............................[Sgnd]............................................
 Member I Thompson

Catchwords

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – access to the scheme – disability requirements – early intervention requirements – consideration of medical history – decision affirmed

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Becoming a Participant) Rules 2016

Cases

Mulligan v NDIA (2015) FCA 544

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

Kilgallin and National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] AATA 186

Secondary Materials

Operational Guideline – Access to the NDIS

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member I Thompson

21 May 2021

INTRODUCTION

  1. The applicant, Shane Goodwin, made an access request to the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) to become a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). 

  2. Mr Goodwin’s request for access to the NDIS listed his disabilities as a right shoulder injury, chronic pain disorder, lower back pain and visual impairment together with difficulties in his short term memory associated with anxiety, depression and a pain disorder. [1]

    [1] Exhibit A, p 20

  3. The NDIA declined the request by letter dated  15 October 2018.[2] Mr Goodwin sought an internal review of that decision which was subsequently affirmed by a delegate of the NDIA on 13 August 2019.[3] The NDIA was satisfied that Mr Goodwin meets the age and residency criteria outlined in ss 22 and 23 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (the NDIS Act), however it was not satisfied that he meets the disability or early intervention requirements in ss 24 and 25 of the NDIS Act. Mr Goodwin applied to the Tribunal for a review of that decision.

    [2] Exhibit A, p 26

    [3] Exhibit A, p 5

  4. The hearing in the Tribunal took place on 1 February 2021. Mr Goodwin attended in person and was self-represented. The NDIA was represented by counsel, Mr Lipari.

  5. Mr Goodwin is 57 years old. He gave evidence at the hearing. He was honest and forthright in giving evidence. He provided written statements [4]prior to the hearing and his wife, Karen Goodwin, also provided a written statement about his daily activities and routines. The NDIA had arranged for Mr Goodwin to be assessed by an occupational therapist, Ms Carly Clarke. She wrote a detailed report following the assessment and gave evidence by telephone.[5] The Tribunal received in evidence a quantity of documents which comprised numerous medical reports, medical notes, hospital discharge summaries, letters, and other documents relating to Mr Goodwin.

    [4] Exhibit C, attachments 6,7,8,18

    [5] Exhibit E, p 50

  6. Mr Goodwin has a complex medical history and suffers from several conditions which include chronic pain disorder, sciatica, depression, anxiety, conversion disorder, congenital toxoplasmosis, blepharitis…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Goodwin and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 1438
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr Goodwin for access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). The Administrative Appeals Tribunal was required to determine whether Mr Goodwin met the disability requirements for NDIS participation. The primary dispute centred on whether Mr Goodwin's permanent impairments resulted in a substantial reduction in his functional capacity, as required by section 24(1)(c) of the *NDIS Act 2013* (Cth).

The Tribunal was tasked with assessing Mr Goodwin's eligibility against the criteria set out in the *NDIS Act 2013*. Specifically, it needed to consider whether his permanent impairments, including a right shoulder injury, lower back injury, visual impairment, chronic pain disorder, depression, and anxiety, led to a substantially reduced functional capacity in one or more of the specified activities: communication, social interaction, learning, mobility, self-care, and self-management. Additionally, the Tribunal considered whether Mr Goodwin met the early intervention requirements under section 25 of the Act.

The Tribunal found that while Mr Goodwin met several NDIS access requirements, including age, residence, and certain disability criteria under sections 24(1)(a), (b), and (d), he did not satisfy the crucial requirement under section 24(1)(c). The Tribunal concluded that his impairments did not result in a substantially reduced functional capacity in any of the listed activities. Furthermore, regarding the early intervention requirements, the Tribunal determined that Mr Goodwin's conditions were long-standing, with interventions occurring over 14 years prior, placing them outside the scope of "early intervention" as contemplated by the Act, which aims to alleviate the impact of impairments at the earliest possible stage.

Consequently, the Tribunal ordered that Mr Goodwin does not meet the disability access criteria to become a participant in the NDIS. As he failed to satisfy section 24(1)(c), it was unnecessary to consider section 24(1)(e). The Tribunal was also not satisfied that the early intervention requirements were applicable to his circumstances.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As a result of the NDIA concessions, s 24(1)(a) and (b) were not in contention, which meant that a principal issue in dispute was whether Mr Goodwin’s permanent impairments led to a substantial reduction in his functional capacity.[10]EVIDENCE[10] Exhibit BMr Goodwin Mr Goodwin gave evidence by affirmation. He told the Tribunal that he resides in a regional town with his family where he has lived since 1989. His last employment was in 2007 and it came to an end because of an accident at work. He receives the disability support pension which was granted about 2 years ago. Mr Goodwin currently divides his time between his family home and his brother’s place nearby. He stays at his brother’s place so that he can drive his 7-year-old grandson to school in the morning and home again in the afternoon. Each trip is about a 5-minute drive. He said in evidence that he enjoys that activity and his involvement with his grandson gives him “reason for living.” During the day he does not do very much, he makes a few cups of coffee for himself. He no longer does any cooking which he used to enjoy but does not enjoy anymore. Before the hearing Mr Goodwin provided 3 written statements which provide information about his medical problems and their effects. In evidence he confirmed information in the statements was accurate to the best of his ability. Mr Goodwin was aware of a written statement provided by his wife but was not familiar with its contents. Prior to recent retirement, Dr Wells was Mr Goodwin’s general medical practitioner for many years. Mr Goodwin is now seeing other doctors at the same medical practice and currently he is being examined because of pain in his chest and left arm. He thinks it is different from the chronic pain that he suffers. Mr Goodwin gave evidence about continuing problems arising out of the injuries in the workplace accident which occurred in February 2007. He said that he has undergone 3 operations on his right shoulder, and he continues to have pain when he moves the shoulder. He tore a muscle in his left calf and had problems with his stomach. Several years later he was suffering pain in his back which he understands is attributed to the workplace accident and two operations followed. He has pain in the central area of his back and pain which radiates down his legs, more so on the left leg. He has pain in the balls of his feet and numbness. He has difficulty wearing shoes because of the pressure on the sides of his feet. He said that he has had quite a few falls and near falls. Mr Goodwin described chronic pain which affects his right shoulder, lower back and legs. A specialist, Dr Clothier, treated him for chronic pain. He was unable to get a referral to a pain management unit because of the long waiting lists. He said that chronic pain has affected him for 13 years. He described the pain as constant, sharp and it affects him, at times, as nerve pain and at other times a muscle pain throughout his body. Mr Goodwin told the Tribunal about his hearing loss and his understanding about a tumour which he has on a nerve in the right ear. He described a noise which he has in his head as buzzing and whirring. He has suffered with tinnitus from his teenage years. He said there are 3 letters which he does not hear properly and misinterprets. Background noise in social situations is more problematic for him, otherwise he does not have much difficulty with hearing in face to face conversations.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Goodwin does not meet the requirements of s 24(1)(c) of the NDIS Act to become a participant in the NDIS. Accordingly, it is not necessary for the Tribunal to decide whether he meets the criteria in s 24(1)(e) of the NDIS ActDISABILITY REQUIREMNTS - CONCLUSION Mr Goodwin meets the age requirements under s 22 and the residence requirements under s 23 of the NDIS Act. Mr Goodwin meets the requirements under s24(1)(a), (b), and (d) of the NDIS Act. Mr Goodwin does not satisfy the requirements under s 24(1)(c) the NDIS Act. He must satisfy all the requirements in s 24(1) in order to meet the disability requirements. Accordingly he does not fulfil the disability access criteria to become a participant in the NDIS.EARLY INTERVENTION REQUIREMENTS Section 25 of the NDIS act sets out the requirements for access to the NDIS under the early intervention criteria. Those provisions have been set out earlier. The NDIA contended that Mr Goodwin’s conditions were long-standing, and they were investigated and treated in the process of his workers compensation claim in the years that more closely followed his accident at work. Section 2.5(b) of the NDIS Rules includes the following passage about the rationale for the early intervention requirements as an alternative to accessing the scheme through the disability requirements: – “… A person can access the NDIS through the early intervention requirements without having substantially reduced functional capacity. Instead, the early intervention requirements consider the likely trajectory and impact of a person’s impairment over time and the potential benefits of early intervention on the impact of the impairment on the person’s functional capacity.” As already discussed and determined, Mr Goodwin’s impairments are permanent and therefore s 25(1)(a) of the NDIS Act is satisfied. Section 9 of the Operational Guidelines provides guidance about the purpose and potential benefits of early intervention. It states: – “Early intervention support is available to both children and adults who meet the early intervention requirements. The intention of early intervention is to alleviate the impact of a person’s impairment upon their functional capacity by providing support at the earliest possible stage. Early intervention support is also intended to benefit a person by reducing their future needs for supports.” [58] Mr Goodwin’s work accident occurred in 2007. Fourteen years have passed with multiple medical interventions which take this case well away from the expectations of possible benefits through early intervention. Provision of support for Mr Goodwin now and into the future does not come within the concept of early intervention support being provided “at the earliest possible stage.” The Tribunal is not satisfied that the provision of early intervention supports which is contemplated by s 25(1)(b) & (c) of the NDIS Act is applicable to Mr Goodwin’s long-standing conditions. Section 25(3) of the NDIS Act applies even if Mr Goodwin satisfies s 25(1) and (2) in that he may not meet the early intervention requirements because the supports are not most appropriately funded or provided through the NDIS and are more appropriately funded or provided through other systems or support services.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Significantly, Dr Harvey distinguished Mr Goodwin’s chronic pain disorder from the pain associated with his musculo--skeletal right shoulder injury. Dr Harvey wrote to Centrelink that the chronic pain disorder is a psychiatric condition. In a letter dated 14 August 2017 Dr Harvey wrote: – “the diagnosis of a pain disorder is based on the definition of DSM 4 and DSM 5 with the characteristics of the pain being- 1 Pain is spread more generalised. 2. It cannot be explained by organic pathology. 3. Is associated with psychiatric symptoms. – (in this patient’s case, mild depressed mood, anxiety symptoms and functional neurological symptoms such as his visual difficulties and blackouts). 4. There is increasing dysfunction associated with it; and 5. The pain is the focus of clinical attention.”[18]Dr Harvey described the functional impact on activities involving Mr Goodwin’s mental health function as severe. The description was given in a letter to Centrelink in the context of criteria relevant to Mr Goodwin’s claim for the disability support pension. Those criteria do not apply to an assessment of eligibility for the NDIS. Nonetheless, opinions and conclusions which Dr Harvey conveyed in that letter about difficulties which Mr Goodwin has in carrying out activities of daily living can be considered in the context of the relevant criteria under the NDIS Act.[18] Exhibit E, p 148CONSIDERATION Dr Harvey provided written information in support of Mr Goodwin’s access request to join the NDIS in which recorded Mr Goodwin’s disabilities as the right shoulder injury, chronic pain disorder, lower back pain and visual impairment.[19] [19] Exhibit A, p 19 The Tribunal is satisfied on the evidence that the concessions by the NDIA regarding s 24(1)(a) and (b) of the NDIS Act are correct. The Tribunal finds that Mr Goodwin has a disability which results from impairments caused by right shoulder injury, low back injury, poor vision in the left eye, chronic pain disorder together with depression and anxiety. The Tribunal finds that those impairments are permanent. The next step is to decide whether Mr Goodwin meets the requirements which are set out in s 24(1)(c), (d) and (e) of the NDIS Act. Section 24(1)(c) NDIS Act - Whether the impairments result in substantially reduced functional capacity to undertake one or more of the following activities: communication, social interaction, learning, mobility, self-care, self-management Each of the activities specified in s 24(1)(c) NDIS Act and their impact on functional capacity will be examined in relation to Mr Goodwin’s impairments. The legislation requires: a relatively high degree of precision by decision- makers (see, for example, the six activities in s 24(1)(c) in assessing what a person can or cannot do. The assessment to be undertaken is avowedly functional and multi-faceted.[20][20] Mulligan v NDIA [2015] FCA 544 at [55]. It is enough for a prospective participant to have substantially reduced functional capacity in relation to one activity: ‘If the outcome or effect is any of the outcomes or effects specified in r 5.8(a), (b) or (c), the deeming effect of r 5.8 operates’.[21] [21] Ibid, at [67].