Ditchfield and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

Ditchfield and National Disability Insurance Agency [2019] AATA 2121 (23 July 2019)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number:           2017/5697

Re:Gregory Ditchfield

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal:Member K. Parker


Date:23 July 2019

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and in substitution decides that Mr Ditchfield meets the access criteria under s 21 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth).

.....................[sgd]...................................................

Member K. Parker

Catchwords

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – access – leg length discrepancy – whether substantially reduced functional capacity – mobility – “commonly used items” – decision to set aside

Legislation

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Becoming a Participant) Rules 2016

Cases

Holmes and National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] AATA 2750

Mulligan v National Disability Insurance Agency [2015] FCA 544

Secondary Materials

Siffert RS, Current concepts review: lower limb length discrepancy. J Bone Joint Surg 1987;69:616-23

Kaufman KR, Miller LS, Sutherland DH.  Gait asymmetry in patients with limb-length inequality.  J Pediatr Othop 1996;16:144-50.

Gurney, B. Leg length discrepancy. Gait and Posture 15 (2002) 195-206

NDIA Operational Guidelines

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member K. Parker

23 July 2019

  1. 1.        This application is about whether Mr Gregory Ditchfield should be granted access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme (the NDIS).  He has a leg length discrepancy (LLD) of approximately 20mm that arose from surgery performed on his leg in 1973 following a motorbike accident.  This condition has impaired Mr Ditchfield’s ability to walk normally.  He has required assistance in the form of a raised or built up shoe and specially-fitted orthotics in order to equalise his leg length. 

  2. 2. Mr Ditchfield contends that he meets the access criteria under s 21 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (the Act).

  3. 3. To gain access to the NDIS, under s 21 of the Act Mr Ditchfield is required to meet:

    a.(a)       the “age” access criteria; and

    b.(b)       the “residence” access criteria; and

    c.(c)       either the “disability” access criteria or the “early intervention” access criteria.

  4. 4.        The National Disability Insurance Agency (the NDIA), being the relevant Commonwealth agency which administers and delivers the NDIS, accepts that Mr Ditchfield meets both the “age” and “residence” access criteria, but contends that he does not meet the “disability” or “early intervention” access criterion.

  5. 5.        For the reasons set out below the Tribunal is satisfied that Mr Ditchfield meets the “disability” access criteria. The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and substitutes it for a decision that Mr Ditchfield meets the access criteria under s 21 of the Act.

    background

  6. 6.        Mr Ditchfield stated that his involvement in a serious motorbike accident in 1973 caused him to sustain injuries to his right tibia, fibula and femur.  Surgery was performed on his leg and it has left him with a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ditchfield and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 2121
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Ditchfield against a decision by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) to refuse him access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme. Mr Ditchfield suffers from a permanent leg length discrepancy resulting from a motorbike accident in 1973, which necessitates the daily use of a specially fitted orthotic in his footwear to assist with mobility. The NDIA's decision was reviewed by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether Mr Ditchfield's leg length discrepancy, even with the use of his orthotic footwear, resulted in a substantially reduced functional capacity to undertake one or more of the relevant activities as defined by the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) and its associated Operational Guidelines. Specifically, the Tribunal was required to assess his capacity in relation to mobility, considering the evidence of his daily functioning and the necessity of his orthotic devices.

The Tribunal reasoned that access to the NDIS is based on a functional and practical assessment of a person's capabilities, rather than the severity of their impairment. It considered the evidence that Mr Ditchfield relied on his orthotic footwear for all activities outside of short distances within his home, and that without them, he experienced significant instability and a high risk of falling. The Tribunal noted that the orthotic footwear, which involved custom-built raised soles and moulded inserts, was essential for him to engage in everyday activities and maintain his mobility. The Tribunal was satisfied that the use of these "commonly used items" (his orthotic footwear) was necessary to mitigate a substantially reduced functional capacity in mobility, and that without them, his capacity would be severely compromised.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the NDIA's decision and substituted it with a decision that Mr Ditchfield meets the disability access criteria under section 21 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth).

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

5. For the reasons set out below the Tribunal is satisfied that Mr Ditchfield meets the “disability” access criteria. The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and substitutes it for a decision that Mr Ditchfield meets the access criteria under s 21 of the Act.background 6. Mr Ditchfield stated that his involvement in a serious motorbike accident in 1973 caused him to sustain injuries to his right tibia, fibula and femur. Surgery was performed on his leg and it has left him with a discrepancy in the length of his legs. Mr Ditchfield stated that he has used a specifically fitted orthotic to assist him with mobility “ever since”. He claimed that his disability was permanent and ongoing. 7. There is no dispute that Mr Ditchfield’s condition of leg discrepancy is permanent and ongoing. Mr Ditchfield stated that the only time he did not use the raised shoes fitted with orthotics was for mobilising short distances around the home, and that otherwise, he used them both inside and outside of the home. 8. Mr Ditchfield is aged in his 60s and lives with his wife in Delacombe, Victoria. At the hearing, he told the Tribunal that his present occupation was that of a “driver”. Mr Ditchfield said he worked on a part-time basis and that he mostly drove caravans for a “chap” and rental vehicles for Avis rental moving those vehicles from one location to another. Mr Ditchfield told the Tribunal he had previously worked in a bakery for 30 years. He said he had worked as a baker from the age of 15 until 1998 which required him to be on his feet. He said he worked six days a week; between eight and 12 hours per day. 9. Mr Ditchfield said that used to swim, but now all he did was fishing and hunting. He said he went for walks in the bush but “not so much lately”. He said he would go out hunting for the day, but he would not be walking for the whole day as he used either quad bikes or vehicles. 10. Mr Ditchfield gave evidence at the hearing that he had about three (pairs of) shoes “fitted or prescribed” per year. He told the Tribunal this involved stripping the soles off a pair of normal shoes and then raising or building up the soles by affixing a moulded orthotic as a new mid-layer of the shoe. He said the orthotic is moulded from a plaster cast taken of his feet and that a new mould was taken of his feet approximately once every three years. 11. Mr Ditchfield confirmed at the hearing that over time the “technology” had improved and it had been helpful in terms of his mobility. He stated: Yes, yes, because it’s straightened my back up and my body up and I don’t get back pain like I did and – yes, yes. Because of the footwear and the orthotics, I can do, within reason, most things I want to do, yes. 12. Mr Ditchfield told the Tribunal that he did not need to see any other specialist about his lower leg injury, other than the orthotist, and he stated:No, while I’m using it, it’s fine. If I was without it, it would change the thing completely.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

58. Mr Ditchfield was asked whether he thought he would be able to adjust with time and he answered “no” and then qualified this by saying he was “not saying never”.Mrs Ditchfield’s evidence 59. Mr Ditchfield is married to Anne Ditchfield who signed a witness statement dated 13 June 2018, relied upon by Mr Ditchfield in this application. In her statement, Mrs Ditchfield stated as follows:a.(a) she has been married to Mr Ditchfield for 41 years and they had two children in their 30s and five grandchildren aged under ten;b.(b) Mr Ditchfield had used his orthotics every day since the surgeries and that the only time he did not use it was to walk short distances around the home, at which time he was “much less stable” and at times she had seen him lose his balance completely;c.(c) Mr Ditchfield does not attempt to leave the house without his orthotics as he would not be able to do the activities he wanted to do and it would “mean a high risk of falling and injuring himself”;d.(d) she confirmed his involvement in the activities (past and present) involved in by Mr Ditchfield and that “all of these activities could not have occurred without the use of the orthotic”;e.(e) when Mr Ditchfield was wearing his orthotic, he has a small limp which became quite significant if he removed his shoe; and f.(f) she said that it was not sustainable for him to walk or run more than a few steps without his orthotic. 60. At the hearing, Mrs Ditchfield confirmed that Mr Ditchfield did not walk outside without his orthotics because he was “too unstable”. When asked what she meant by “unstable”, Mrs Ditchfield said:Well he’s basically unstable. He wobbles more than what he would normally do. 61. At the hearing, Mrs Ditchfield said she had seen Mr Ditchfield fall when he was outside without his orthotics on and when asked how frequently this had happened, she said “rarely”. Later, she said she had only seen him fall once. Upon being cross-examined about this fall, Mrs Ditchfield clarified that she was inside of the house at the time and Mr Ditchfield was outside of the house and that she had heard a noise following which she looked out the window to see that he had fallen. Mrs Ditchfield was asked why he was outside without wearing his orthotics and she responded: “Well he may have gone and let the dog out. I think – I think that’s what it was”. She said it was not normal for him to do so.Radiological findings 62. The Tribunal notes that Mr Ditchfield underwent a CT scan of his lumbar spine and right lower limb on 18 October 2010 and the following conclusions were made by Dr G Guirki:CT LUMBAR SPINECONCLUSION: Transitional L5-S1 segment. Broad based posterolateral disc protrusion at L4-5 (last mobile segment) with disc impinging on both L5 nerves, slightly more on the left than the right.RIGHT LOWER LIMBThe old fracture of the mid shaft of the femur is noted. Union has occurred but there is some angulation of the remaining distal fragment. The callus formation is remodelled but there is still a lot present. The knee joint shows minor degenerative change but no sign of a loose body. Gurney (review) article

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

20. The NDIA has also issued Operational Guidelines including in relation to the access criteria under the Act (Operational Guidelines). The Operational Guidelines are published on the NDIA’s website. 21. Section 8.3 of the Operational Guidelines deals with the access criteria under s 24(1)(c) of the Act as reproduced below:8.3 Substantially reduced functional capacity to undertake relevant activitiesThe NDIA must be satisfied that an impairment results in substantially reduced functional capacity of a prospective participant to undertake one or more relevant activities (section 24(1)(c)).The NDIA is required to consider whether any permanent impairment, or permanent impairments when considered together, result in substantially reduced functional capacity to undertake one or more of the following activities:• Communication: includes being understood in spoken, written or sign language, understanding others and expressing needs and wants by gesture, speech or context appropriate to age;• Social interaction: includes making and keeping friends (or playing with other children), interacting with the community, behaving within limits accepted by others, coping with feelings and emotions in a social context;• Learning: includes understanding and remembering information, learning new things, practicing and using new skills;• Mobility: this means the ability of a person to move around the home (crawling/walking) to undertake ordinary activities of daily living, getting in and out of bed or a chair, leaving the home, moving about in the community and performing other tasks requiring the use of limbs;• Self-care: means activities related to personal case, hygiene, grooming and feeding oneself, including showering, bathing, dressing, eating, toileting, grooming, caring for own health care needs; or• Self-management: means the cognitive capacity to organise one's life, to plan and make decisions, and to take responsibility for oneself, including completing daily tasks, making decisions, problem solving and managing finances.The NDIA does not need to be satisfied that a person's impairment is 'serious', or more serious than another person's. Rather, access to the NDIS is based on a functional, practical assessment of what a person can and cannot do (see Mulligan and NDIA [2015] FCA 44 at [56]).The NDIA will not need to consider whether a prospective participant's impairment results in substantially reduced functional capacity in relation to all of the relevant activities for every access request.It is sufficient for a prospective participant to have substantially reduced functional capacity in relation to one activity (see Mulligan and NDIA [2015] FCA 44 at 67).Which activity the NDIA will need to consider will depend on the circumstances and the evidence presented by the prospective participant. For example, if a prospective participant has an impairment which results in substantially reduced functional capacity to undertake mobility, but otherwise has full cognitive capacity, it may not be necessary for the NDIA to consider whether the impairment results in substantially reduced functional capacity to undertake activities related to cognition.