Schwartz and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

Schwartz and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 311 (19 February 2021)

Division:National Disability Insurance Scheme Division

File Number(s):      2018/4212

Re:Wendy Schwartz

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member I Thompson

Date:19 February 2021

Place:Adelaide

The reviewable decision is set aside and substituted for a decision that the Applicant meets the access criteria under s 24 of the NDIS Act.

......................[sgnd]..............................

Member I Thompson

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – access to the scheme – disability requirements – complex medical history – decision set aside and substituted

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Becoming a Participant) Rules 2016

CASES

Arnell v National Disability Insurance Agency [2019] AATA

Ditchfield v NDIA [2019] AATA 2121.

Mulligan v NDIA (2015) FCA 544

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Operational Guideline – Access to the NDIS

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member I Thompson

19 February 2021

INTRODUCTION

  1. The applicant, Wendy Schwartz, made an access request to the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) to become a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). 

  2. Mrs Schwartz’s request for access to the NDIS specified her primary impairment as reflex sympathetic dystrophy in her left arm, with chronic pain and inability to use it for 14 years following a fracture.  Other impairments that were listed in the supporting evidence form were bronchiectasis, recurrent bowel obstruction and recurrent urinary infection.[1]

    [1] Exhibit F, T5, Access Request – Supporting Evidence Form dated 9 August 2017, p 24.

  3. The NDIA declined the request by letter dated 31 October 2017.[2]  Mrs Schwartz sought an internal review of that decision which was subsequently affirmed by a delegate of the NDIA on 14 March 2018.[3] The NDIA was satisfied that Mrs Schwartz meets the age and residency criteria outlined in sections 22 and 23 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (NDIS Act), however it was not satisfied that she meets the disability or early intervention requirements in sections 24 and 25 of the NDIS Act.

    [2] Exhibit F, T6, Access not met letter dated 21 October 2017, p 29.

    [3] Exhibit F, T2, Internal review decision letter dated 14 March 2018, p 6.

  4. The NDIA delegate considered that Mrs Schwartz meets some, but not all, of the disability criteria in relation to her impairment of reflex sympathetic dystrophy with chronic pain and none of the criteria for early intervention. The delegate confirmed with Mrs Schwartz that:

    recurrent bowel obstruction and bronchiectasis are medical conditions with treatment options and will not be considered further in this review process. The supports and services you require for these impairments are most appropriately met by other health and mainstream services.[4]

    Reflex sympathetic dystrophy is now more commonly known as complex regional pain syndrome and is referred to in these reasons as CRPS.

    [4] Exhibit F, T2, Internal review decision letter dated…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Schwartz and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 311
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mrs Schwartz against a decision by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) regarding her eligibility for the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). The core of the dispute revolved around whether Mrs Schwartz met the disability requirements stipulated in section 24(1) of the NDIS Act. The case was heard by I Thompson M.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were to determine if Mrs Schwartz satisfied the disability requirements under sections 24(1)(c), (d), and (e) of the NDIS Act, following concessions made by the NDIA regarding sections 24(1)(a) and (b). This required an assessment of the permanence of her impairments and their impact on her functional capacity.

The Tribunal considered extensive evidence, including Mrs Schwartz's own statement of lived experience detailing the chronic pain and functional loss in her left arm and hand due to Complex Regional Pain Syndrome (CRPS) following a fall in 2004. It also took into account evidence from medical practitioners and an occupational therapist engaged by the NDIA. The Tribunal was satisfied that Mrs Schwartz's impairments, resulting from CRPS and bronchiectasis, were permanent and significantly impacted her daily life, including self-care, mobility, and social engagement.

Ultimately, the Tribunal found that Mrs Schwartz met the disability requirements under section 24(1) of the NDIS Act. Consequently, the reviewable decision of the NDIA was set aside, and a substituted decision was made that Mrs Schwartz meets the access criteria for the NDIS.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The next step is to decide whether Mrs Schwartz meets the requirements which are set out in s 24(1)(c), (d) and (e) of the NDIS Act.EVIDENCEMrs Schwartz In her statement of lived experience, Mrs Schwartz described the effects of CRPS:I suffer from permanent flexed fingers on my left hand. This, in addition to the problems with my left arm leads to a complete loss of any functional use in my arm and hand. The arm remains highly sensitive and I experience constant pain… My brain will never accept my broken arm pain. Now, some fourteen (14) years later, it is still as if I am carrying a broken arm with the same pain, as well as complications from my frozen shoulder.[16][16] Exhibit E, Statement of lived experience – Mrs Wendy Schwartz, undated, pp 188–189. At the time of giving evidence Mrs Schwartz was 64 years old. Married since 1994, she resides with her husband who is now her full-time carer and has been for about nine years. She described the impact of injuries sustained from a fall onto ceramic tiles which occurred in August 2004 when she broke her left arm. She said the pain in that arm has never ceased. The arm has been constantly sensitive to touch to clothing, heat, cold, and water. Three fingers on her left hand have been permanently flexed since the fall. She is right hand dominant. In her statement Mrs Schwartz described the impact of her medical conditions on her daily life, and she was questioned in considerable detail about them in her oral evidence. Mrs Schwartz told the Tribunal about her daily routine. She does not sleep well and regularly goes to bed around 2:00AM, if not later, and on some days, she does not get out of bed until the afternoon. She has problems with back spasms, and she cannot get into bed by herself. She still has problems arising from a gall bladder operation seven years ago, which also lead to pneumonia while she was in hospital. She has problems with self-care that include issues with showering, toileting and dressing. Her husband does most of the preparation for meals and the cooking. She generally does not access items above eye level and carrying things is not easy. Her husband does most of the cleaning and she can only do some of the light tasks such as dusting and folding clothes by using her right hand. She has difficulties with mobility, for example standing up from her lounge chair and getting out of bed and losing balance. She uses pillows and a rotating action to pull herself up and get out of bed. She is restricted with walking. She avoids the external steps at the front of her house. She finds carpets the easiest surface to walk on. She said she is conscious about her balance and gets anxious about falling, particularly a fear of falling backwards. She could not get up from a fall without nearby furniture to lean on. Socially, Mrs Schwartz is affected. Occasionally she attended meetings of the local neighbourhood watch group, and she used to enjoy outings with a carers group which included going out in a bus for meals and the cinema. She enjoys weekly phone conversations with a friend and she also talks on the phone to her brother and sister. Mostly, however, she tends to stay at home and avoid social and community activities. Mrs Schwartz had finished working in 2002. She stopped driving a car many years ago, and rarely drove prior to the fall in 2004.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As Mrs Schwartz satisfies the disability requirements under s 24(1) of the NDIS Act, she therefore meets the access criterion under s 21 of the NDIS ActDECISION The reviewable decision is set aside and, in substitution for such decision, there is a decision that Mrs Schwartz meets the access criteria under s 24 of the NDIS Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The NDIA summonsed three medical practitioners; Dr Clothier, Dr Carter and Dr Herriot. The NDIA arranged for an occupational therapist, Ms Welshe, to assess Mrs Schwartz. Ms Welshe provided a written report and gave evidence. CONSIDERATION The Tribunal is satisfied on the evidence that the concessions by the NDIA regarding s 24(1)(a) and (b) of the NDIS Act are correct. The Tribunal finds that Mrs Schwartz has a disability which results from impairments caused by CRPS and bronchiectasis. The Tribunal finds that those impairments are permanent. The next step is to decide whether Mrs Schwartz meets the requirements which are set out in s 24(1)(c), (d) and (e) of the NDIS Act.EVIDENCEMrs Schwartz In her statement of lived experience, Mrs Schwartz described the effects of CRPS:I suffer from permanent flexed fingers on my left hand. This, in addition to the problems with my left arm leads to a complete loss of any functional use in my arm and hand. The arm remains highly sensitive and I experience constant pain… My brain will never accept my broken arm pain. Now, some fourteen (14) years later, it is still as if I am carrying a broken arm with the same pain, as well as complications from my frozen shoulder.[16][16] Exhibit E, Statement of lived experience – Mrs Wendy Schwartz, undated, pp 188–189. At the time of giving evidence Mrs Schwartz was 64 years old. Married since 1994, she resides with her husband who is now her full-time carer and has been for about nine years. She described the impact of injuries sustained from a fall onto ceramic tiles which occurred in August 2004 when she broke her left arm. She said the pain in that arm has never ceased. The arm has been constantly sensitive to touch to clothing, heat, cold, and water. Three fingers on her left hand have been permanently flexed since the fall. She is right hand dominant. In her statement Mrs Schwartz described the impact of her medical conditions on her daily life, and she was questioned in considerable detail about them in her oral evidence. Mrs Schwartz told the Tribunal about her daily routine. She does not sleep well and regularly goes to bed around 2:00AM, if not later, and on some days, she does not get out of bed until the afternoon. She has problems with back spasms, and she cannot get into bed by herself. She still has problems arising from a gall bladder operation seven years ago, which also lead to pneumonia while she was in hospital. She has problems with self-care that include issues with showering, toileting and dressing. Her husband does most of the preparation for meals and the cooking. She generally does not access items above eye level and carrying things is not easy. Her husband does most of the cleaning and she can only do some of the light tasks such as dusting and folding clothes by using her right hand. She has difficulties with mobility, for example standing up from her lounge chair and getting out of bed and losing balance. She uses pillows and a rotating action to pull herself up and get out of bed. She is restricted with walking. She avoids the external steps at the front of her house. She finds carpets the easiest surface to walk on. She said she is conscious about her balance and gets anxious about falling, particularly a fear of falling backwards. She could not get up from a fall without nearby furniture to lean on.