O'Keeffe and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

O'Keeffe and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 82 (2 February 2023)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number:          2020/4934

Re:Justin O'Keeffe

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal:Dr Stewart Fenwick, Senior Member

Date:2 February 2023

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review dated 15 July 2020 and in substitution decides the Applicant meets the disability requirements in section 24 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013.

...................[sgd].....................................................

Dr Stewart Fenwick, Senior Member

Catchwords

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – access to scheme – various conditions including chronic pain and degenerative spinal disease – whether impairments result in substantially reduced functional capacity to undertake one or more specified activities – mobility and self-care – decision set aside and substituted

Legislation

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)

Cases

Mulligan v National Disability Insurance Agency [2015] FCA 544
National Disability Insurance Agency v Davis [2002] FCA 1002

Rooney and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 3523

Secondary Materials

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Becoming a Participant) Rules 2016

REASONS FOR DECISION

Dr Stewart Fenwick, Senior Member

2 February 2023

background

  1. Mr O’Keeffe applied on 14 August 2020 for review of the decision of a delegate of the Respondent agency dated 15 July 2020 that he did not fulfil the access requirements for participation in the NDIS.

  2. Mr O’Keeffe once led a physically active work life but experienced a dramatic spinal injury while swimming in 2015. He now has a number of medical conditions, but of particular relevance are the degenerative change in his spine and the chronic pain that affect his mobility and independence.

  3. The hearing of this application commenced in March 2022. However, it immediately became apparent that Mr O’Keeffe had moved interstate to a town in rural Queensland a few months earlier. His own Occupational Therapist (OT) had prepared a report including observations about Mr O’Keeffe’s previous residence in rural Victoria. For this reason, and my own concerns to properly appreciate Mr O’Keeffe’s lived experience at home and in his community, the hearing was adjourned.

  4. Mr O’Keeffe subsequently lodged an updated Statement of Lived Experience, and his legal representatives lodged an updated Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (SFIC), as well as the updated report of Ms Kym Fitzgerald, OT, dated 11 May 2022. The Applicant also lodged material from Bendigo Health comprising a joint report by Ms Fay Wallis, OT, and a physiotherapist colleague, dated 21 September 2020, a further letter from Ms Wallis of 20 September 2021, a further joint report dated 7 December 2020, and a letter from Ms Keely Trew, Senior Physiotherapist, dated 22 September 2021. A report from the Applicant’s new General Practitioner, Dr Nirupama Nimmala, dated 7 October 2022 was also lodged, and Mr O’Keeffe’s patient notes were received in evidence (Exhibit A1). The Applicant and the named medical experts all gave evidence at the hearing.

  5. The Respondent lodged documents under s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (T documents), an updated SFIC,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read O'Keeffe and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 82
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr O’Keeffe for access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS), with the dispute centering on whether his impairments, including chronic pain and degenerative spinal disease, resulted in a substantially reduced functional capacity to undertake activities of mobility and self-care. The decision was made by Dr Stewart Fenwick, Senior Member, of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether Mr O’Keeffe met the disability requirements under section 24 of the *National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013* (Cth). Specifically, the court had to assess if his impairments substantially reduced his functional capacity in relation to mobility and self-care, taking into account the evidence presented regarding his physical limitations, pain levels, and reliance on assistive devices and adaptations.

The Tribunal found that Mr O’Keeffe had a substantial impairment with respect to mobility. This conclusion was based on evidence detailing his struggles with balance, frequent falls, difficulty with transfers, and limited reach for personal hygiene tasks, even when using assistive devices such as a walking stick. The Tribunal considered that Mr O’Keeffe had exhausted reasonable steps to mitigate his functional limitations and that his capacity to move around his home was substantially reduced.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the previous decision of the National Disability Insurance Agency dated 15 July 2020 and substituted it with a decision that Mr O’Keeffe meets the disability requirements for participation in the NDIS.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

With the acknowledgment that a decision-maker must be satisfied as to all relevant statutory criteria, I note that this matter was conducted specifically upon the basis that the parties disagree as to whether Mr O’Keeffe meets the disability requirement in s 24 with respect to the activities of mobility and self-care.evidenceMr O’Keeffe In his initial Statement of Lived Experience (SLE), Mr O’Keeffe describes living with exhaustion and experiencing frequent falls. He struggles with dressing, housework, and cooking resulting in him choosing to eat food requiring little preparation. He states that he drives as little as possible due to pain, and his situation has caused him anxiety and embarrassment, limiting his outings. In his updated SLE, Mr O’Keeffe confirms his move to Queensland in late 2021, noting that he lived in a caravan prior to securing his new residence. He states:(a)that he lives with chronic neck and back pain (which does not go away) and struggles with tasks that allow him to live independently, and is in receipt of the Disability Support Pension ([5], [11]);(b)due to fatigue and weakness in the back he collapses ‘often’, and leans on objects or ‘locks’ his knees to aid with balance ([8]); (c)he participated in OT and physiotherapy programs with Bendigo Health in 2020. An exercise program did not remove difficulty with balance and pain, and a walking stick provided ‘some improvement’ but did not stop falls because he struggled to coordinate himself. He found a walking frame very ‘restrictive’ ([12]-[15]);(d)he has ‘limited reach with [his] arms and poor flexibility so cannot reach the top of [his] head or lower parts of [his] body to wash’ even when seated. He considers he is assisted by grab rails and seating, but he has trouble with transfers. When staying at the caravan park, he made the sixty-metre trip to the amenities block every three to four days and fell ‘about five times’ in the three months he was resident there ([19]-[20]);(e)he purchased a four-wheel drive last year which requires less bending to enter, and he drives every three to four days and is able to drive up to four to five hours at a time ([28]);(f)the move to Queensland was driven by budget considerations and warmer climate. The new house only has one step to enter and a shower cubicle with a level entry, and should he not become an NDIS participant he will make changes to the kitchen and bathroom, modifying bench height and installing rails ([41]-[46]). In his oral evidence, Mr O’Keeffe described losing feeling in his arms, and stated that he was suffering more pain through the arms than previously. With respect to his program with Bendigo Health, he stated that he found a lot of the exercises aggravating, but that he had learned about three points of contact, stretches, and received training about his stance. When asked about the trial of a walking stick, Mr O’Keeffe stated that he has ‘permanent nerve pain’ down his arms. For this reason, he stated that a walking stick was to hold him up, but he asked rhetorically ‘what with?’. Mr O’Keeffe stated that his arms are better when straight down and he could not coordinate because they feel like they are sunburnt.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I have found that Mr O’Keeffe has a substantial impairment with respect to mobility. For this reason, together with the associated findings, it follows that he should become a participant in the NDIS. It is also not necessary for this reason to consider the early intervention requirements (s 25).decision For the reasons given above, the Tribunal sets aside the decision under review dated 15 July 2020 and substitutes it with a decision that Mr O’Keeffe meets the disability requirements in section 24 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

A further letter from Dr Gonzales of the same date (T6, p 77) indicates that the cause of Mr O’Keeffe’s relapse after his initial cervical spine surgery was a car accident. The Applicant apparently reported right arm symptoms, which were evaluated by Dr Gonzales. The letter notes some changes in sensation in the right arm, but this did not conform to a typical distribution. Dr Gonzales organised nerve conduction studies. He noted that strength was preserved throughout, and reflexes were present and symmetrical. considerationApplicant submissions In closing submissions, it was submitted that there is substantial evidence as to Mr O’Keeffe’s impairments, and that his chronic neck and back pain arising from degenerative spinal disease is ‘centre stage’ in this application. As a result, it was submitted Mr O’Keeffe’s functional capacity is impaired to the requisite degree, and account should be taken of the risk he faces of experiencing pain or falls. It was acknowledged that the oral evidence of Ms Wallis was constrained by her inability to speak directly to mobility issues. Ms Fitzgerald, however, presented evidence about a range of physical assessments she conducted. This, and other material from Bendigo Health, evidenced gait issues, unsteadiness and pain, and demonstrated that Mr O’Keeffe’s safety is compromised. The evidence was said further to demonstrate that while the Applicant can move around the home, his capacity to do so is substantially reduced, and he experiences falls and transfer issues. With respect to the use of assistive devices, in the context of what is commonly available, it was contended that Mr O’Keeffe had trialled a walking stick for approximately four weeks but found that its positive impact was extremely limited. The evidence was to the effect that the Applicant had exhausted all reasonable steps in this regard. He also contended that home modifications in the form of grab rails are, upon the evidence, a matter requiring specialist advice concerning installation. It was further contended that some other forms of assistance may alleviate functional impairment, but not sufficiently to remove the substantial reduction in capacity. The evidence indicates for example that a bed and couch are required. With respect to self-care, it was submitted that Mr O’Keeffe’s abilities in the bathroom have deteriorated. While he expressed reluctance to receive personal help, this presents as a requirement, not a matter of preference. It was submitted that the evidence of the OTs in the hearing demonstrates that installation of grab rails required assessment and proper installation, albeit the items themselves may be considered readily accessible. The expense of installation should also be understood in the context of individual circumstances. The evidence also demonstrated, it was contended, that Mr O’Keeffe has sought to adapt his cooking style in response to his impairment, but that risks remain. There is also evidence his partner takes responsibility for cleaning and that alternative approaches do not alleviate risk or reduce fatigue.