Phillips and National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIS)

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

Phillips and National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIS) [2025] ARTA 159 (1 February 2025)

Applicant:Gary PHILLIPS

Respondent:  National Disability Insurance Agency

Tribunal Number:                2024/2648

Tribunal:General Member W Strange

Place:Brisbane

Date:February 2025

Decision:The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

.........................................

Statement made on 25 February 2025 at 12:48pm...............................

General Member W Strange

Catchwords

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – access criteria – stroke related impairments – whether Applicant meets disability criteria – likely permanency of impairments – whether impairments result in substantially reduce functional capacity – early intervention requirements – decision under review affirmed

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (Cth)
Administrative Review Tribunal (Consequential and Transitional Provisions No.1) Act 2024 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme Amendment (Getting the NDIS Back on Track No 1) Act 2024
National Disability Insurance Scheme (Becoming a Participant) Rules 2016 (Cth)

Cases

Beezley v Repatriation Commission [2015] FCAFC 165

Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 2 ALD 60

FBJV and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 913

G v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCAFC 79

Galea and National Disability Insurance Agency [2022] AATA 2263

Ghezzaoui and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 2835

Holmes and National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] AATA 2750

James and National Disability Insurance Agency [2019] AATA 4248

Kelly v National Disability Insurance Scheme [2024] FCA 1462

Madelaine and National Disability Insurance Agency [2020] AATA 4025

McLeod and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 913

Mulligan v National Disability Insurance Agency [2015] FCA 544

Mulligan and National Disability Insurance Agency [2015] AATA 974

MZHQ and National Disability Insurance Agency [2019] AATA 810

National Disability Insurance Agency v Davis [2022] FCA 1002

National Disability Insurance Agency v Foster (2023) FCAFC 11

Nika and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 2127

Power and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 3357

Puster and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 1760

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No. 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

Rooney and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 3523

Shi v Migration Agents’ Registration Authority (2008) 235 CLR 286

Sutherland v National Disability Insurance Scheme [2024] AATA 411

Timofticiuc and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 3015

XVYL and National Disability Insurance Agency [2024] AATA 498

Secondary Materials

National Disability Insurance Agency, NDIS Operational Guideline, Applying to the NDIS (14 October 2024 applicable to NDIS requests made before 3 October 2024)

National Disability Insurance Agency, NDIS Operational Guideline, Assistive Technology (equipment, technology and devices), 20 December 2023

Statement of Reasons

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr Gary Phillips is a 62 year old man, who is the Applicant in this review. He lives with his wife, Mrs Kerry Phillips, and other family members in Brisbane. While holidaying in New South Wales in 2015 Mr Phillips unfortunately suffered a heart attack, requiring hospitalisation and coronary surgery (a quintuple bypass procedure). He subsequently suffered a stroke. These medical events and their resulting consequences have had ongoing…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Phillips and National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIS) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 159
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Phillips and National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIS) involves a dispute regarding the eligibility of Mr Phillips for the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). The case was heard by the Tribunal, which had to decide if Mr Phillips’ impairments, resulting from a stroke, meet the disability criteria under the NDIS Act and if he is eligible for early intervention supports.

The primary legal issues were whether Mr Phillips’ impairments resulted in substantially reduced functional capacity in self-management and other activities, and whether his impairments were likely to be permanent. The court also considered if the provision of early intervention supports would benefit Mr Phillips by reducing future needs for supports or mitigating the impact of his impairments.

The Tribunal concluded that Mr Phillips did not meet the disability requirements under the NDIS Act because his impairments did not substantially reduce his functional capacity. The Tribunal noted that while Mr Phillips experienced physical, cognitive, and sensory impairments due to his stroke, there was no evidence that these impairments would not improve with further treatment. The Tribunal also found that Mr Phillips’ impairments were likely to be permanent, satisfying one of the early intervention requirements. However, the Tribunal determined that the provision of early intervention supports was unlikely to benefit Mr Phillips, as there was insufficient evidence to show that such supports would improve his functional capacity or reduce future support needs.

In summary, the Tribunal decided that Mr Phillips did not meet the disability requirements for NDIS access and did not qualify for early intervention supports.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Having regard to all of the evidence and the functional, practical nature of the assessment that the Tribunal is required to make,[152] the Tribunal is satisfied that Mr Phillips does not have a substantially reduced capacity in the activity of self-management.[152] Mulligan, [55]. Conclusion As the Tribunal is not satisfied that Mr Phillips’ impairments result in substantially reduced functional capacity to undertake one or more of the six activities specified in section 24(1)(c) of the NDIS Act, it follows that Mr Phillips does not meet disability requirements necessary to meet the access criteria in the NDIS Act. Having regard to the cumulative nature of the disability requirements in section 24(1), it is not necessary for the Tribunal to proceed to determine if Mr Phillips meets the criteria in paragraphs (d) and (e) of section 24(1); namely, whether Mr Phillips’ impairments affect his capacity for social and economic participation, and whether Mr Phillips is likely to require NDIS supports under the Scheme for his lifetime. The Early Intervention Requirements Having determined that Mr Phillips does not meet the disability requirements of the NDIS Act, it remains for the Tribunal to determine if he meets the early intervention requirements. In Mulligan, the Federal Court noted a recommendation made in the Productivity Commission’s 2011 Inquiry Report, “Disability Care and Support”[153] which said that individuals receiving support through the NDIS should have a disability that is or is likely to be permanent, and would meet one of two conditions, with (relevantly) those “in an early intervention group, comprising individuals for whom there is good evidence that the intervention is safe, significantly improves outcomes and is cost effective.”[154][153] Which informed the establishment of the NDIS.[154] Mulligan, [54] The Tribunal has determined that Mr Phillips’ physical, cognitive and sensory impairments are, or are likely to be permanent, meaning that he meets the requirement in section 25(1)(a). Paragraph (b) of section 25(1) requires, in the context of this review, that the Tribunal be satisfied that the provision of early intervention supports for Mr Phillips is likely to benefit him, by reducing his future needs for supports in relation to disability. Additionally, paragraph (c) requires the Tribunal to be satisfied that the provision of early intervention supports for Mr Phillips is likely to benefit him by mitigating or alleviating the impact of Mr Phillips’ impairment(s) upon his functional capacity in the six domains already discussed; or by preventing the deterioration of such functional capacity or improving it; or strengthening the sustainability of informal supports available to Mr Phillips. Part 6 of the NDIA’s Access Rules addresses the early intervention requirements. Rule 6.9 sets out the issues to be considered in in deciding whether the provision of early intervention supports is likely to benefit the person in the ways set out in paragraphs (b) and (c) of section 25(1) of the NDIS Act:Where evidence is required 6.9In deciding whether provision of early intervention supports is likely to benefit the person in the ways mentioned in paragraphs 6.2(b) and (c) above, it is expected that the CEO would consider:(a) the likely trajectory and impact of the person's impairment over time; and(b) the potential benefits of early intervention on the impact of the impairment on the person's functional capacity and in reducing their future needs for supports; and(c) evidence from a range of sources, such as information provided by the person with disability or their family members or carers. The CEO may also in some cases seek expert opinion.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Part 6 of the Access Rules addresses ‘[W]hen does a person meet the early intervention requirements?’ and again addresses the requirement of ‘permanency’, and additionally ‘deciding whether provision of early intervention supports is likely to benefit the person.’The NDIS Operational Guidelines The Agency has also issued some Operational Guidelines which are relevant to applications to access the NDIS. These guidelines are published on the NDIS website and are described by the NDIA as guidelines that set out some of the NDIA’s ‘operational information’: ‘[T]hey explain what we need to consider and how we make decisions based on the legislation.’ [21] The guidelines of relevance to this review are those entitled Applying to the NDIS (the Access Guidelines), being that version of the Access Guidelines relating to requests for access to the NDIS made before 3 October 2024. [21] See >Unlike the NDIS Rules, the NDIS Guidelines are not made pursuant to a power conferred by the NDIS Act; they are issued in an exercise of executive power.[22] As such, the Guidelines set out the NDIA’s policy and provide guidance in how relevant powers are to be exercised. Ordinarily the Tribunal will apply such policy in reviewing a decision, unless the policy is unlawful, or unless its application tends to produce an unjust decision in the circumstances of the particular case.[23]DOES MR PHILLIPS MEET THE DISABILITY REQUIREMENTS?[22] G v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCAFC 79, [18].[23] Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No. 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634, 645 (President Brennan J).Section 24(1)(a) – disability attributable to impairmentsThe first of the section 24 disability requirements is that the person applying for access to the NDIS has a disability that is attributable to one or more intellectual, cognitive, neurological, sensory or physical impairments, or the person has one or more impairments to which a psychosocial disability is attributable.The medical records lodged in support of Mr Phillips’ application to access the NDIS establish that while holidaying in New South Wales in November 2015 Mr Phillips experienced chest pain and was admitted to Gosford District Hospital and later transferred to Royal North Shore Hospital in Sydney. He spent approximately one month in hospital and was diagnosed with an ST elevation myocardial infarction (a heart attack) and cardiac arrest, accompanied by ischaemic stroke and pneumonia. He underwent coronary artery bypass surgery (x 5) and received an intra-aortic balloon pump and other forms of treatment.[24][24] Joint Hearing Bundle, Discharge referral report of the Royal North Shore Hospital, 14 December 2015, pages 85-91.In applying to access the NDIS, Mr Phillips listed his stroke as his main disability, and listed other disabilities of heart disease, diabetes and renal impairment.[25] As noted, during the course of this review Mr Phillips confirmed that he was seeking access to the NDIS only on the basis of impairments arising from his stroke, and the evidence provided by him addressed those impairments. [25] JHB, NDIS Access Request Form dated 7 October 2022, pages 30 and 34.That evidence, which is discussed in more detail in the following sections of this decision, illustrates the physical, cognitive and sensory impairments that Mr Phillips has faced in his daily living activities since suffering his stroke. For present purposes it will suffice to note that the Agency accepts that Mr Phillips experiences a disability attributable to physical, cognitive and sensory impairments, attributable to his stroke. The Tribunal therefore finds that Mr Phillips satisfies the requirement in section 24(1)(a). Section 24(1)(b) – permanencyThe Agency’s contentionsIn making the decision under review, the Agency accepted that Mr Phillips’ cognitive impairments are, or are likely to be, permanent.[26] However, in this review the Agency contended that none of Mr Phillips’ impairments meets the requirement that they are, or are likely to be, permanent.[27] Noting Rules 5.4 to 5.6 of the Access Rules, the Agency submitted that in respect of each of Mr Phillips’ physical, cognitive and sensory impairments, the detailed supporting evidence provided was old (almost 10 years old); that various recommendations for treatment to support Mr Phillips’ recovery had been made and that his prognosis was optimistic; and that there was insufficient evidence to establish that there are no known, available and appropriate evidence-based clinical, medical or other treatments that would be likely to remedy these impairments. More specifically, the Agency contended that in the evidence provided by Mr Phillips there was no detailed treatment history which outlines the types of treatments undertaken in relation to each of the conditions; the frequency and duration of such treatments; and Mr Phillips’ compliance with such treatments and outcomes. The Agency provided detailed submissions relating to Mr Phillips’ physical, cognitive and sensory impairments arising from his stroke. [26] JHB, NDIA Internal Review Decision, page14.[27] Agency’s SFIC, [22] – [32].Regarding Mr Phillips physical impairments, the Agency noted the contents of documents included with Mr Phillips’ discharge referral report from the Royal North Shore Hospital in December 2015, and specifically the observations and recommendations provided by three allied health professionals who had provided rehabilitative treatment to Mr Phillips, as follows:[28](a)An Occupational Therapist – who reported that Mr Phillips was toileting and showering on his admission to rehabilitation. He was assessed by a neuropsychologist and found to have some visuo-perceptual changes and reduced attention. Mr Phillips also presented with reduced strength and coordination of his left hand and was provided with a program, in which he participated daily. Mr Phillips was referred ‘ … to a community rehabilitation program at Gold Coast Hospital and Health Service[29] with goals to return to higher level ADLs[30] such as community access, and advice about return to work and driving.’(b)A Physiotherapist – who reported that Mr Phillips presented with weakness to his left upper limb range of motion and strength. On discharge Mr Phillips was independent with all transfers, mobility and performing stairs. He had regained full range of movement of his left shoulder but fatigued after exercise. He was referred to Gold Coast Cardiac rehabilitation for ongoing cardiac therapy and progression of exercise tolerance.(c)A Speech Pathologist – who reported that Mr Phillips presented with a mild oral dysphagia (swallowing difficulties) for solids and a mild dysphonia (voice hoarseness) and reduced voice volume, possibly due to an intubation injury arising from his surgery and expected to resolve within 6 to 8 weeks. Mr Phillips also presented with a mild unilateral UMN dysarthria (upper motor neuron speech disorder), although he was 100% intelligible in conversation. While the recommendations made by the speech pathologist were not included in the T-JHB, documents before the Tribunal, the report did note that no formal therapeutic intervention was required. The Agency contended that Mr Phillips had not provided any evidence demonstrating that he had complied with the recommendations of his treating practitioners or therapists, and that he also had not provided any further evidence demonstrating that he had completed further therapies to improve his physical impairments.[28] JHB, Allied Health Assessment at Discharge (within Royal North Shore Hospital Discharge report), page 91.[29] At this time Mr Phillips resided on the Gold Coast in Queensland.[30] Activities of Daily Living.Turning to Mr Phillips’ cognitive impairments, the Agency noted the contents of a neuropsychological assessment conducted around the time Mr Phillips was discharged from the Royal North Shore Hospital.[31] This report observed that Mr Phillips had reported that he had not noticed major changes to his cognition since the stroke, but had noticed on occasions he missed things (visual information) on his left side, although this was improving. The Clinical Neuropsychologist who examined Mr Phillips noted that he was able to follow conversation and instructions, respond appropriately, ask good questions and understand recommendations. There was some mild difficulty in holding information and using it, and in dividing attention. There was some difficulty with spatial awareness on occasions. Mr Phillips’ ability to learn and remember new verbal information was normal, although there were some difficulties in retrieving information. His higher-level cognitive skills (problem-solving and planning) were reduced on visual tasks and he could get stuck on, or rush through, some tasks. In summary, the neuropsychologist concluded that there were areas of thinking skills that had changed since Mr Phillips’ stroke, but many were not affected, noting the assessment had taken place less than one month after the stroke, which was early in recovery. Some ongoing recovery was expected, although it was noted “ … but we cannot predict what prove or how much it might improve by.” Ongoing community rehabilitation was recommended and arranged, to continue to help Mr Phillips with high-level tasks such as paying bills/banking and accessing the community, and to provide advice about returning to work and driving at a more appropriate time in his recovery.Again, the Agency contended that Mr Phillips had not provided any evidence demonstrating that he had complied with the recommendations of his treating practitioners or therapists around the time of his stroke, and that he also had not provided any further evidence demonstrating that he had completed further therapies to improve his cognitive impairments.[31] JHB, Confidential Neuropsychological Assessment Summary, pages100-101.Finally, regarding Mr Phillips’ sensory impairments, the Agency noted the evidence provided by Mrs Phillips in her carer’s statement[32] about Mr Phillips’ loss of feeling in the left side of his body. The Agency contended that Mr Phillips had not provided any evidence demonstrating that he has sought treatment or completed any therapies to improve these sensory impairments. [32] JHB, Carer Statement of Mrs Phillips (undated), page84.Mr Phillips’ contentionsIn the carer’s statement, Mrs Phillips stated that she has ‘ … had to undertake the role of carer for Gary since his Ischaemic Stroke … Gary has a lifelong disability as outlined in the medical reports previously provided through Royal North Shore neurologists. He has undergone inpatient and outpatient rehab and no further improvement to his condition or functional capacity has been seen since he was discharged from these programs.’[33] Mrs Phillips further noted that prior to acquiring his disability Mr Phillips had worked full time, but was medically retired after attempting to return to the role that he had been working in (in Rugby League),[34] and had later been ‘exited’ from disability employment services ‘ … due to concerns he was unable to be safely supported in the workplace’ [35][33] Ibid page83.[34] JHB, Mr Dwyer’s report,’page141[35] JHB, Carer Statement of Mrs Phillips, page 84.Further, in responding to the Agency’s contentions about permanence,[36] Mrs Phillips advised that in the absence of her care Mr Phillips “ … has permanent limitations and impairments that require ongoing support. Further, his rehab and support post rehab was non existent and he was not connected to other community and mainstream services in order for him to continue to access interventions that could have increased his capacity. He was transferred between two different state systems and never having had experience in understanding what disability supports were available at that time he has effectively fallen through the cracks and was and is unable to have sufficient capacity to engage in meaningful social and economic participation.” [36] Response to the Agency’s SFIC, prepared by Mrs Phillips, dated 26 November 2024.Other evidenceDr Hung Tran is Mr Phillips’ General Practitioner, and began treating him around three years prior to Mr Phillips seeking access to the NDIS in 2023. In that capacity, Dr Tran completed the relevant section of Mr Phillips’ Access Request Form,[37] in which he advised that Mr Phillips’ impairment was not currently being treated, noting specifically the reason for that was ‘complete rehabilitation.’[38] Dr Tran further noted that Mr Phillips’ previous treatment was rehabilitation at the Gold Cost University Hospital, and indicated that there were no available, evidence-based treatments/interventions that are likely to substantially relieve Mr Phillip’s impairment.[39] [37] JHB, Access Request Form, dated 7 October 2022, pages 21-48.[38] JHB, Access Request Form, page 34.[39] JHB, Access Request Form, page 35.Additionally, Dr Tran completed two NDIS Access Request – Supporting Evidence Forms for Mr Phillips. The first of these was dated 17 December 2022 (first Supporting Evidence Form).[40] Therein he noted ‘stroke’ as Mr Phillips’ primary impairment, also noting ‘ischaemic heart disease, pacemaker’. Treatments of ‘long term medication’ and ‘regular cardiologist review’ were noted. In the section of the form asking about other significant impairments, Dr Tran noted ‘some weakness left side of body;’ that Mr Phillips has had this impairment since 2016, and answered ‘yes’ to the question asking if the impairment is likely to be lifelong. In the section about relevant treatment undertaken in relation to this impairment, Dr Tran wrote ‘need physiotherapy’. [40] JHB, First Supporting Evidence Form, dated 17 December 2022, pages 49-57.Dr Tran also completed a second Supporting Evidence Form on 3 July 2023 (second Supporting Evidence Form),[41] which was closer to the date of Mr Phillips applying to access the NDIS. Again, in this version of the form, ‘stroke’ was noted by Dr Tran as Mr Phillips’ primary impairment, which he has had since 2015, which is treated by medications, and is likely to be lifelong (with heart failure noted as another significant impairment). [41] JHB, Second Supporting Evidence Form, dated 3 July 2023, pages 58-64.The Tribunal also notes that Dr Tran furnished a brief letter dated 3 February 2024,[42] noting Mr Phillips’ application to access the NDIS and stating “I agree with the statement in the letter from his wife.” Presumably this references Mrs Phillips’ carers’ statement. [42] JHB, Letter from Dr Tran, 3 February 2024, page 84.The Royal North Shore Hospital discharge report noted that Mr Phillips “[P]articipated in rehabilitation program well” and noted his plan upon discharge home interstate to the Gold Coast involved “community and cardiac rehab follow-up” and that Mr Phillips’ General Practitioner was to assist in organising cardiology and neurology follow-up.[43][43] JHB, Royal North Shore Hospital Discharge Report, page 90.Mr Glen Dwyer is an Occupational Therapist, who was engaged by the Agency to undertake a Functional Capacity Assessment of Mr Phillips and to provide a report for consideration in this review. Mr Dwyer’s report is dated 30 August 2024.[44] He was provided with the available medical evidence and noted, in relation to Mr Phillips’ medical condition arising from his stroke in November 2015, the following current symptoms:[44] JHB, Mr Dwyer’s Report, pages114-164. The Agency’s Letter of Instruction to Mr Dwyer, dated 24 July 2024, was also provided in the JHB (pages102-113).·Left-sided weakness, with diminished strength and coordination of left upper and lower limb movements· Diminished sensation in the left upper limb (including the left hand) and the lower part of the left leg · Diminished dexterity and fine motor function of the left (non-dominant) hand· Reduction in hearing in the left ear (right side is normal)· Occasional word-finding difficulties· Reported high levels of frustration and anxiety· Vulnerability to becoming easily agitated/upset, including self-reported episodes of anger whilst driving.[45]Mr Dwyer noted that Mr Phillips had ‘ … engaged in post-stroke rehabilitation, which facilitated a reasonable improvement in his physical tolerances compared to his immediate post-stroke status. He stated formal rehabilitation finished in 2016, following which he has not engaged in any regular physical therapy.’ Mr Dwyer further noted that Mr Phillips had not engaged with any psychological treatment to date, despite reporting issues such as anxiety, frustration and agitation, although it was also noted by Mr Dwyer that there was no medical evidence of a recommendation for this form of treatment, and he would defer to Mr Phillips’ treating doctor to specify such treatment. He did note Dr Tran’s recommendation for ‘physiotherapy’, and Mr Phillips’ advice that he had not engaged in this therapy since completing his rehabilitation in 2016. Mr Dwyer concluded:The medical evidence indicates that Mr Phillips is expected to experience incapacity arising from his stroke for the rest of his life. The medical evidence also indicates that physiotherapy treatment has been recommended for Mr Phillips, however he has not engaged in that treatment.Further, as stated in Section 3.3, it is my professional opinion that Mr Phillips may benefit from psychological treatment to address psychological symptoms that have yet to be addressed in any meaningful capacity since his stroke in 2015.Therefore, for the purpose of this report I have assumed that Mr Phillips’ prognostic picture is likely associated with ongoing functional impairment at similar levels to his current functional capacity, with some scope for improvement in his physical and psychological health in the event he engages in further treatment such as physiotherapy and psychological counselling.Should Mr Phillips obtain benefit from the recommended treatments, this would be anticipated to reduce the impact of some of his impairments and consequently have a positive impact on his capacity for participation in his activities of daily living. I defer to medical opinion to confirm treatment recommendations for Mr Phillips, and the impact such treatment may have on his functional incapacity in the future.[46][45] JHB, Mr Dwyer’s Report, page120.[46] JHB, Mr Dwyer’s Report, at page 122.Discussion