Cooper and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

Cooper and National Disability Insurance Agency [2024] AATA 420 (12 March 2024)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME 

File Number(s):      2021/3852

Re:Belinda Cooper

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Mischin

Date:12 March 2024

Place:Perth

The decision under review is affirmed.

........................ [Sgd]................................................

Deputy President Mischin

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE AGENCY – access to scheme – disability requirements – Obesity – sleep apnoea – vertigo and dizziness – ovarian cysts and endometriosis – past diagnosis of Burkitt’s Lymphoma – lumbar back pain – whether the Applicant meets the disability requirements in section 24 or the early intervention requirements in section 25 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) – whether conditions/impairments are permanent – whether the applicant’s impairments result in substantially reduced functional capacity to undertake one or more activities listed in section 24(1)(c)

LEGISLATION

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) sections 18, 20-25, 27, 99, 100(6), 100, 103, 209

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Becoming a Participant) Rules 2013 (Cth) rules 5.4-5.8, 6.1-6.9

CASES

Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634
Madelaine and National Disability Insurance Agency [2020] AATA 4025
Mulligan v National Disability Insurance Agency [2015] FCA 544
National Disability Insurance Agency v Davis [2022] FCA 1002
National Disability Insurance Agency v Foster [2023] FCAFC 11
Nika and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 2127
Rooney and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 3523

Schwass and National Disability Insurance Agency [2019] AATA 28

SECONDARY MATERIALS

National Disability Insurance Scheme – Operational Guidelines – Access

National Disability Insurance Scheme – Operational Guidelines – Applying to the NDIS

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Michael Mischin

12 March 2024

BACKGROUND

  1. The Applicant is a 45 year old non-binary person[1] who seeks access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS or the Scheme). The Applicant has a number of conditions including bipolar disorder, post-traumatic stress disorder, depression, anxiety, obesity, sleep apnoea, vertigo and dizziness, ovarian cysts and endometriosis, past diagnosis of Burkitt’s Lymphoma, and back pain in the lumbar region from a potential L4 nerve impingement.

    [1] At the hearing, the Applicant advised that she was agreeable to being addressed as ‘Ms’ and so, for convenience and clarity, will be referred to as ‘she’ and ‘her’ for the purposes of these reasons.

  2. On 5 February 2021, a delegate of the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA or Agency) decided under section 20 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (NDIS Act) to refuse the Applicant’s request for access to the NDIS (the Reviewable Decision) on the basis that the Applicant did not meet all the statutory criteria for access to the Scheme.

  3. On 19 February 2021, the Applicant sought, under section 99 of the NDIS Act, an internal review of the Reviewable Decision.

  4. On 17 May 2021, a delegate of the CEO made an internal review decision under section 100(6)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cooper and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 420
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by the Applicant for access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). The Applicant sought to challenge a decision by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) to refuse her access. The core of the dispute revolved around whether the Applicant met the disability requirements under section 24 or the early intervention requirements under section 25 of the *National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013* (Cth). The Tribunal was required to determine if the Applicant's various health conditions, including obesity, sleep apnoea, vertigo, dizziness, ovarian cysts, endometriosis, a past diagnosis of Burkitt’s Lymphoma, and lumbar back pain, constituted impairments that resulted in a substantially reduced functional capacity.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the Applicant's impairments were permanent, and critically, whether these impairments resulted in a substantially reduced functional capacity to undertake one or more of the activities listed in section 24(1)(c) of the Act. The Tribunal also considered whether the Applicant met the early intervention requirements under section 25, specifically whether early intervention supports were likely to benefit her by reducing her future need for supports or providing benefit in specified aspects. The Tribunal's reasoning focused on the nature of impairments as defined by the legislation, which involves the loss of or damage to a physical, sensory, or mental function, rather than merely a reduction in capacity.

The Tribunal accepted that the Applicant had a disability attributable to impairments arising from her psychiatric conditions, namely bipolar disorder, PTSD, depression, and anxiety. However, the Tribunal found insufficient evidence to support impairments arising from sleep apnoea, ovarian cysts, endometriosis, or the past Burkitt’s Lymphoma. While obesity was accepted as a disability, it was not found to be an impairment or caused by an impairment, as the evidence did not demonstrate a loss or damage to a physical, sensory, or mental function. Furthermore, the Tribunal was not satisfied that the Applicant's psychiatric impairments resulted in a substantially reduced functional capacity to undertake the activities specified in section 24(1)(c), nor that she met the early intervention requirements under section 25.

Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the NDIA's decision to refuse the Applicant access to the Scheme. The Tribunal concluded that generalised prognostications about improved functional capacity were not a substitute for specialist evidence addressing the specific criteria for early intervention.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

I have considered the relevant factual and expert evidence and refer to parts of the evidence in these reasons. FACTSThe Applicant The Applicant testified that she lived in a unit in government housing in South Perth.[31] [31] Transcript 5. The Applicant was just commencing her career as a schoolteacher in 2006 when she was diagnosed with Burkitt’s Lymphoma, a rare and fast-acting blood-based cancer that almost escaped timely diagnosis – ‘most people die in the first two weeks of diagnosis’.[32] Despite organ failure, [33] she survived and has been ‘in remission for over a decade now, officially about six years’.[34] It appears that it is not a cancer that recurs and she is at no further risk from it.[35][32] Ibid 7.[33] Ibid 6-7.[34] Ibid 7.[35] Ibid. The Applicant’s current health problems began just after surviving cancer, and she attributes them to the long-term consequences of her chemotherapy.[36] The Applicant’s chemotherapy took various forms, including the administration of steroids. Injections directly into her spine resulted in nerve damage. Her mental stability was a casualty of her condition and chemotherapy treatment.[37] [36] Ibid 5.[37] Ibid 6. Although after overcoming cancer the Applicant resumed teaching in 2007 and for several years, her mental health declined until it was ‘not appropriate’ for her to teach any more:[38] … within one year of surviving cancer, one to two years after that I was diagnosed with bipolar and I had rapid mood disorder, meaning I would have a manic state and a depressive state in about 15 to 20 minutes and as a school teacher it meant I couldn’t maintain things … because it was rapid swing bipolar, I didn’t have control about the consistency of having an even keel for my students, which made it difficult to control my classroom and it also made it difficult to control a professional environment … I was talking about inappropriate things to other staff members.[39] [38] Ibid 5.[39] Ibid 6. When in a manic state, the Applicant would lose control of what she was saying, doing, and how she was spending money. She sought help and ‘treatment’, but this had the side-effect of tiredness. She would drive to work when she shouldn’t have and put herself in risky situations.[40] [40] Ibid 8. The Applicant said she was ‘made redundant’ and has been on a disability pension since 2010. She tried to push herself to study, and for several years tried to study part-time, but eventually realised study was making her sick and had to accept that she ‘was unable to get back to my life before all this happened’.[41][41] Ibid. The Applicant focuses now on making sure she is as much as possible in ‘control of my environment and my mental health’ but never has complete control over it. She recounted how the receipt of an unexpected letter from the NDIA in January before the hearing had triggered a ‘manic episode’ and how, despite having as many things in place as possible to make her ‘environment safe’, it only took ‘one outside incident to wreck all my careful work and I have to spend months trying to fix [it]’.[42] [42] Ibid.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Applicant’s advice that she is no longer relying on her back pain and possible lumbar spine nerve impingement as a basis for her disability focusses the Tribunal’s inquiry into whether her psychiatric condition qualifies her for entry into the Scheme. EVIDENCE The application was heard by the Tribunal on 21 March 2023. The Applicant was unrepresented. She, her supporters, and a witness called by the Respondent, Occupational Therapist Jayne Cruttenden, attended via audio-visual link. The Respondent’s counsel, Mr French, attended in person. The Tribunal was provided with a tender bundle incorporating the T-documents.[18] A further ‘evidence bundle’ was provided at the hearing,[19] as was a Professional Profile for Ms Cruttenden.[20] All materials were admitted into evidence, albeit subject to submissions regarding relevance and the weight to be accorded to evidence. The documents admitted into evidence included:(a)A NDIS ‘Supporting Evidence Form’ completed by Clinical Psychologist Linda Welsh dated 29 June 2020,[21] and reports from her dated 26 February 2020,[22] 9 April 2020,[23] 23 February 2021,[24] and 1 September 2022;[25] (b)A NDIS ‘Supporting Evidence Form’ completed by General Medical Practitioner Dr Asiri Baduge dated 3 January 2021;[26](c)A ‘Letter of Support’ from Psychosocial Recovery Coach and Support Worker Mandi Whyte dated May 2021;[27] (d)A ‘Letter in support of NDIS access request’ from Senior Occupational Therapist Heidi Perera dated 27 October 2021;[28](e)A letter of Consultant Psychiatrist Professor Sean Hood of Marian Centre dated 19 November 2021;[29] and(f)An ‘Occupational Therapy Functional Assessment’ report of Occupational Therapist Jayne Cruttenden dated 1 March 2022.[30] [18] Exhibit R1; Transcript 20.[19] Exhibit R2; Transcript 20.[20] Exhibit R3; Transcript 65.[21] Exhibit R1 T1C 11.[22] Exhibit R1 T1A 8.[23] Exhibit R1 T1B 9.[24] Exhibit R1 T1D 18.[25] Exhibit R2 Document 3 9-12.[26] Exhibit R1 T1E 20-26. [27] Exhibit R1 T1F 27-31.[28] Exhibit R2 Document 1 3-6.[29] Exhibit R2 Document 2 7-8.[30] Exhibit R2 Document 5 17-32. The Applicant gave oral evidence at the hearing and was cross-examined by Mr French. None of the report writers were called to give evidence other than Ms Cruttenden. Other than the Applicant and Ms Cruttenden, no other witnesses were called to give evidence or speak to their reports. The parties filed written submissions following the hearing. I have considered the relevant factual and expert evidence and refer to parts of the evidence in these reasons. FACTSThe Applicant The Applicant testified that she lived in a unit in government housing in South Perth.[31] [31] Transcript 5. The Applicant was just commencing her career as a schoolteacher in 2006 when she was diagnosed with Burkitt’s Lymphoma, a rare and fast-acting blood-based cancer that almost escaped timely diagnosis – ‘most people die in the first two weeks of diagnosis’.[32] Despite organ failure, [33] she survived and has been ‘in remission for over a decade now, officially about six years’.[34] It appears that it is not a cancer that recurs and she is at no further risk from it.[35][32] Ibid 7.[33] Ibid 6-7.[34] Ibid 7.[35] Ibid.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The state of the evidence is that the Applicant’s bipolar disorder has stabilised, and she has medications and strategies to manage it. There is insufficient evidence to support my being satisfied that the provision of early intervention supports is likely to benefit the Applicant by reducing her future need for supports (section 25(1)(b)) or provide benefit to her in any of the aspects specified by section 25(1)(c). Generalised prognostications that providing wide-ranging supports will arrest the decline of the Applicant’s ‘mental health’ and ‘wellbeing’, which in turn will translate into improved functional capacity, are no substitute for evidence from suitably qualified specialists in the relevant fields addressing the criteria in section 25(1)(c)(i)-(iv).CONCLUSION Having regard to the above, I am not satisfied that the Applicant’s impairments attributable to her psychosocial conditions of bipolar disorder, PTSD, depression and anxiety result in a substantially reduced functional capacity to undertake any of the activities specified in section 24(1)(c) of the NDIS Act. I am not satisfied that the Applicant satisfies the early intervention requirements for entry to the Scheme. Accordingly, I affirm the decision under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ms Cruttenden was not cross-examined. I accept that the Applicant is not learned in the law and was unrepresented, and would have found the hearing process unfamiliar. However, she was invited to ask Ms Cruttenden questions about her evidence and her report and did not do so. CONSIDERATIONSection 24(1)(a): Disability attributable to impairments The legislative scheme focusses not on the name of a person’s disability, nor the diagnosis given to it, but rather on what impairments are experienced by a person which may require supports so that they can participate in all aspects of personal and community life. The impairment is what the scheme contemplates may affect the ‘functional capacity’ of a person.[161] An impairment is not defined in the legislation, but is generally understood to involve the loss of or damage to a physical, sensory, or mental function.[162] It is not merely a reduction in a person’s capacity to do things which an unimpaired person would be able to do.[163][161] National Disability Insurance Agency v Davis [2022] FCA 1002 (Davis), per Mortimer J at [69].[162] Mulligan v National Disability Insurance Agency [2015] FCS 544 at [51]; Schwass and National Disability Insurance Scheme [2019] AATA 28 (Schwass) at [35]-[37].[163] Schwass (n 162) at [34]-[35]. On the evidence available to the Tribunal, the Respondent’s concession that the Applicant has a disability attributable to one or more impairments attributable to a psychiatric condition (in the case of her bipolar disorder, PTSD, depression, and anxiety) is reasonable and proper. The evidence does not support the Applicant having any impairment to function arising from sleep apnoea, ovarian cysts and endometriosis, or the past diagnosis of Burkitt’s lymphoma. To the extent that there is evidence concerning them, the Applicant’s vertigo and dizziness appear to be a side-effect of one or more of the medications she takes, rather than due to loss or damage to a physical, sensory, or mental function. Obesity The Respondent accepts that the Applicant’s obesity is a disability, but not attributable to an impairment rather than being descriptive of her weight. Dr Baduge’s ‘Letter of Support’ advises that the Applicant’s obesity affects her physical ability and mobility and plays a ‘big role’ in her chronic pain, and fatigue. It appears that the Tribunal is invited to infer that the Applicant’s mental disorders require her to take medications that increase her craving for sugar, and that is resulting in her gaining and being unable to shed weight. However, the causes of the Applicant’s weight gain and retention, and her inability to shed it, were not the subject of medical evidence. I accept that the Applicant has a disability due to her obesity, but I am not satisfied on the evidence available to me that her obesity is an impairment or caused by an impairment. The evidence does not support the Applicant’s obesity necessarily entailing a loss of or damage to a physical, sensory, or mental function.