National Australia Bank Ltd v Norman

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

National Australia Bank Ltd v Norman [2009] FCAFC 152

BANKRUPTCY – orders for the administration of a deceased person’s estate – vesting of the divisible property of the estate in the Official Trustee or registered trustee – what constitutes the divisible property of the estate – exclusion of property held in trust for another person 

CORPORATIONS – appeal against winding up order in respect of unregistered managed investment scheme – whether unregistered managed investment scheme within meaning of s 9 Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – whether investors contributed money as consideration to acquire rights (interests) to benefits produced by the scheme – whether any of the contributions were to be pooled to produce benefits for the people who hold interests in the scheme – funds obtained by accountant, now deceased, for individual investment and deposited into trust account – monies not invested but misappropriated by accountant – no evidence of objective intention to make contributions to acquire benefits produced by a scheme – no evidence of objective intention that contributors monies were to be pooled to produce benefits for people who hold interests in a scheme – monies were not “to be pooled” – not a managed investment scheme – appeal allowed.

WORDS AND PHRASES – para (a)(ii) under definition of managed investment scheme in s 9 Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – “to be pooled” – requires proof of objective prior intention that monies contributed are to be pooled in order to produce financial benefits for members who hold interests in the scheme – absent such objective intention mere deposit of monies from investors into trust account insufficient to meet statutory requirement that monies are to be pooled.

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth), ss 116(2)(a), 156A, 244, 247A, 248(1) and (3) and 249
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), ss 9 and 601EA-601EE, 601FC, 601FD, 601FE, 601HA

Corporations Regulations 2001 reg 5C1.01

Federal Court Rules Order 6 rule 15, Order 9 rule 4

Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000 rule 1.3(2)

Australian Securities & Investments Commission v Enterprise Solutions 2000 Pty Ltd (1999) 33 ACSR 403 referred to
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Enterprise Solutions 2000 Pty Ltd [2003] 1 Qd R 135 discussed
Australian Securities & Investments Commission v GDK Financial Solutions Pty Ltd (2006) 236 ALR 699 cited
Australian Securities & Investments Commission v Hutchings(2001) 38 ACSR 387 referred to
Australian Securities & Investments Commission v Knightsbridge Managed Funds Ltd [2001] WASC 339 referred to
Australian Securities & Investments Commission v Primelife Corporation Limited (2006) 235 ALR 328 cited

Australian Securities & Investments Commission v Takaran Pty Ltd (2002) 43 ACSR 46 referred to
Australian Softwoods Pty Ltd v Attorney-General (NSW) (1981) 148 CLR 121 cited
Burton v Arcus (2006) 32 WAR 366 discussed
Re Magarey Farlam Lawyers Trust Accounts (No 3) (2006) 96 SASR 337 at 373 cited
Sutherland Re; French Caledonia Travel Service Pty Ltd (In Liq) (2003) 59 NSWLR 361 referred to

Australian Law Reform Commission Report, “Collective Investments: Other People’s Money”,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read National Australia Bank Ltd v Norman and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCAFC 152
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In National Australia Bank Ltd v Norman, the Court addressed the appeal by National Australia Bank (NAB) against the winding up order made by Mansfield J (the primary judge) on 28 November 2008. The primary judge had declared that a managed investment scheme operated by the deceased Allan McFarlane was unregistered and ordered its winding up. Mr Norman, the applicant, sought the appointment of liquidators for the scheme, and the primary judge granted his application. NAB was not a party to the original application but was later joined as a party to the appeal after demonstrating sufficient interest. The primary judge's orders were predicated on the assumption that McFarlane operated an unregistered managed investment scheme. However, the court found that the evidence did not substantiate the existence of such a scheme, as the investments were made individually rather than pooled together.

The court's reasoning hinged on the interpretation of the evidence presented. Mr Norman's affidavit and the accompanying documents did not provide clear evidence of a managed investment scheme as defined by the Corporations Act. The bank accounts in question were simply accounts where funds were deposited by individual clients, and there was no evidence of a pooling of funds or the creation of a single investment entity. The court concluded that the primary judge's finding was not supported by the evidence, and thus the orders made on 28 November 2008 should be set aside. The appeal was allowed, and the orders were dismissed. Additionally, the court ordered Mr Norman to pay NAB's costs of the appeal and the application for leave to appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The declaration and orders of Mansfield J made on 28 November 2008 as varied on 2 June 2009, be set aside and in their place the application for a winding up order dated 8 September 2008 be dismissed.

3. The first respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the application for leave to appeal, and of the appeal, to be taxed if not agreed.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Under the heading ‘Background Facts’ Mr Fabbro’s affidavit continued as follows:‘3.McFarlane corresponded with various clients and associates and invited those clients and associates to invest funds in the Scheme which funds were generally deposited into the McFarlanes Accountants Trust Account (“Trust Account”), under the care and control of McFarlane. …’ It will be appreciated that Mr Fabbro’s affidavit presupposes the existence of a scheme which answers the description of a managed investment scheme as defined in s 9 of the Corporations Act. None of the items of correspondence to which Mr Fabbro referred mentioned any ‘Scheme’ nor did they invite clients and associates of McFarlane to invest funds in a Scheme. Whether McFarlane solicited the provision of funds by gullible clients and associates under the pretext that they would be deposited in a bank account styled a ‘trust account’ in his name is a matter of irrelevance for present purposes. National Australia Bank Limited, which appears to have had McFarlane or MCFARLANES as a customer, was not, as a result, a trustee of monies standing to the credit of an account which McFarlane may have styled as a ‘Trust Account’. The Bank was simply a debtor of the relevant account holder for the whole of the amount standing to the credit of the account from time to time (see per Campbell J in Sutherland Re; French Caledonia Travel Service Pty Ltd (In Liq) (2003) 59 NSWLR 361 (the ‘Travel Service case’ at [61]). A credit in a bank account is not a chose in possession. Rather it is an inchoate chose in action (inchoate because of the need to make demand before there is a cause of action that can be sued on). A debt owed by a banker to a customer is a single thing – an obligation to pay $X – and the client’s paying more money into a bank account results in the creation of a different thing – an obligation to pay some larger amount than $X (see per Campbell J in the Travel Service case at [61]). The presumption that a trustee has intended to act honestly is one which arises between trustee and beneficiary. There is no reason why a banker ought be presumed to know of or be in any way affected by such a presumption of honest intention as between trustee and beneficiary (per Campbell J in Travel Service case at [65]). Mr Fabbro’s affidavit of 8 September 2008 continued:‘4.A number of clients and associates (“Members”) of McFarlane accepted the offer to invest funds with McFarlane. …’ Mr Fabbro’s affidavit, by using the word ‘Members’ to describe clients and associates of McFarlane, again presumes, inaccurately and without any foundation, that a client or associate of McFarlane who invests money with McFarlane is ‘a Member’ of a ‘managed investment scheme’ within the meaning of the Corporations Act. Later in his affidavit Mr Fabbro said:‘9.Upon examination of the documents presently available it would appear that:9.1the funds of each of the Members [Mr Fabbro’s definition of “clients and associates of McFarlane”] were pooled together into the Trust Account [A bank account or bank accounts apparently maintained by McFarlane and variously styled, according to MCFARLANES’ acknowledgements of indebtedness, ‘MCFARLANES CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS TRUST ACCOUNT BANK FUNDS’, ‘MCFARLANES TRUST ACCOUNT BANK FUNDS Bank of America’, ‘MCFARLANES CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS BANK FUNDS (with a reference thereafter to Bank of America)’, ‘MCFARLANES TRUST ACCOUNT BANK FUNDS Bank of America (Australian bank funds)’, ‘MCFARLANES CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS TRUST ACCOUNT AUSTRALIAN BANK FUNDS (CAPITAL GUARANTEED)] and invested on their behalf by McFarlane;9.2The Scheme [Mr Fabbro’s definition of an unregistered managed investment scheme of McFarlane of which Mr Norman was said to be an “Applicant Creditor”] has more than twenty members [there was no evidence of any clients and associates of McFarlane being Members of an unregistered management investment scheme]; and9.3McFarlane was in the business of promoting the Scheme [there is no doubt that McFarlane was involved in the solicitation of funds for investment by him on behalf of clients and associates which he may well have misappropriated but no evidence that the solicitation was referable to the acquisition of interests in a managed investment scheme].’

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

What is clear is that there was no contradictor before the Court on 28 November 2008 in respect of the orders sought by Mr Norman in his Application. Plainly, the primary judge was without assistance as to reasons why the orders sought by Mr Norman ought not to be made. Relevant evidence When asked to identify the high point of the evidence relied upon by Mr Norman to support the orders made by the primary judge on 28 November 2008, his senior counsel directed the Court’s attention to an email apparently sent by the late Mr McFarlane to a Mark Bateup at 11:41am on Friday 6 June 2008. That email was headed ‘RE: interested in interest’. It relevantly provided:‘Minimumamount is usually $20,000 but $10,000 will be OK if that is convenient for you now. I can link you as a client with Mum.Minimumterm is 30 days.Yes the funds are available according to what deposit term you choose, but of course if you had an emergency I would always endeavour to get around that. Draws may be by cheque mailed to you or direct into your designated bank accountCurrent rates are 30days call 12.50%pa. 45 days call 13.25%pa and 60 days call 13.95% pa. We place them on a 6 months rollover basis with one of the aforesaid call terms designated.All our funds placed through MCFARLANES Trust Account are fixed term with the 4 pillar banks, ANZ, NAB, WESTPAC and COMMONWEALTH. Therefore they are capital guaranteed. We place funds for some very large clients.Mark, we have large funds being placed today and on Tuesday next. You could bank your $10,000 direct to any NAB bank branch into the following account:I can then guarantee the above figures.NABMCFARLANES CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS TRUST ACCOUNTBSB NO 085 005ACCOUNT NO 04909 7085I would then email you confirmation and you could then advise me as to where you wanted our Certificate of Deposit mailed.We are looking forward to seeing your chirpy Mum tomorrow morning.Cheers,Allan McFarlaneMCFARLANES’ At 2:24pm on 29 April 2008 McFarlane sent an email to Marlene HUTCHINS under the heading ‘Update’ which provided as follows:‘Dear Marlene,Thought I would update you and also ask how you fared with Mark LeCornu. Hopefully he was able and willing to meet your needs.Now a further TX [transaction] is on the table and the terms are the best yet. A 120 days (you can have 90 days also) placement attracts a record gain of 11% with record low total costs of A$1,100. This because of the US dollar being at an all-time low and the Aussie dollar being at a near-record all-time high. Additionally and unusually I have been allocated 5 business class return air tickets Adelaide/HongKong (or alternate approved route of equivalent cost) with Qantas or Cathay as rewards up to 30.06.08 for use within the next 12 months. One needs to place new funds of at least A$30,000 for one such ticket but I have been comining (sic) smaller amounts for the purpose. Let me know pronto if you are interested.Thought you may like to have this news update.’ The reference to combining smaller amounts in this email is the closest one comes to notification to an intending investor of a possible pooling of funds.

Decision

Reasons for decision

SPENDER, GRAHAM AND GILMOUR JJ
The several certificates which have been placed in evidence demonstrate a principal and agent relationship between investors and McFarlane with each individual investment of funds made separately and apart from the investments made by others. In my opinion the evidence does not allow the finding of any managed investment scheme.Conclusion It follows that there was nothing in relation to which a winding up order could be made in accordance with s 601EE(1) of the Act on 28 November 2008. Accordingly, the appeal should be allowed. The orders of the primary judge of 28 November 2008 should be set aside. In lieu thereof an order should be made dismissing the application filed 8 September 2008.In the circumstances it is unnecessary to make any orders in respect of the first order made by the primary judge on 2 June 2009 which proceeded on the assumption that the orders made on 28 November 2008 had been within power. In my opinion it is unnecessary to make any order dealing with the other procedural orders made by the primary judge on 2 June 2009. Mr Norman, the first respondent, should be ordered to pay National Australia Bank Limited’s costs of its application for leave to appeal and of the appeal. The appellant, National Australia Bank (NAB), appeals pursuant to leave granted against the declaration and orders of Mansfield J (the primary judge) made on 28 November 2008. The declaration and orders of the primary judge The primary judge declared that a scheme operated by Allan McFarlane (deceased) (“McFarlane”) was a managed investment scheme as defined in s 9 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (‘the Act’) which was required to be registered pursuant to s 601ED(1) of the Act; that it was not so registered; and that it was operated by McFarlane. A winding up order was made pursuant to s 601EE of the Act. Mr Nicholas Cooper and Mr Andre Strazdins were appointed joint and several liquidators of the scheme. The winding up orders provide:For the purposes of this Order “the Scheme” means the managed investment scheme operated by Allan McFarlane (deceased) (“McFarlane”) whereby: (a)members of the public (the “scheme investors”), at the request of McFarlane, invested moneys with McFarlane to be held on trust for them, by way of payments into [the Account];(b)the investors’ moneys were pooled in the Account;(c)the purpose of the investment and of the pooling was for McFarlane to invest the pooled moneys in other investments to achieve further financial benefits for scheme investors; (d)McFarlane had day to day control over the moneys obtained from investors; (e)McFarlane misappropriated the moneys of scheme investors. NAB was not a party to the original application. It was not served with, nor heard on, the application for the winding up orders in relation to the managed investment scheme as declared by the primary judge (‘the Scheme’). Nonetheless the application by NAB for leave to appeal was granted, following argument, immediately prior to the hearing of the appeal. The Court concluded that NAB had demonstrated the necessary interest and ordered that it be joined as a party to the original application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: SPENDER, GRAHAM AND GILMOUR JJ

In an affidavit sworn on 19 November 2008 by Mr Carter, presumably as trustee of the estate of the late Allan McFarlane the administration of which under Part XI of the Bankruptcy Act was apparently ordered on 3 September 2008, he deposed to convening a meeting of creditors of McFarlane on 19 September 2008, which was apparently attended by 70 creditors. To his affidavit he attached a list of creditors, whom he identified as ‘Investor’ Creditors, claimed to be owed a total of $16,961,448.52. The list was headed ‘Creditors Present at First Meeting of Creditors of the Administration of the Deceased Estate of Allan McFarlane In Person or by Proxy’. The list of ‘Investor’ Creditors included the ‘Applicant’, Trevor G Norman, who was said to be owed $275,976.00. In an affidavit bearing the typed date 4 September 2008 but apparently sworn on 8 September 2008 Michael Allan Fabbro of Ezra Legal, the solicitors for the applicant, stated under the heading “Purpose of Affidavit’:‘2.I swear this affidavit for the purpose of supporting the application made by the Applicant Creditor (sic) for the appointment of Nicholas David Cooper and Andre Janis Strazdins … as joint and several liquidators of the unregistered managed investment scheme (“the Scheme”) of Mr Allan McFarlane (“McFarlane”). The description of Mr Norman as ‘the Applicant Creditor’ does not fit comfortably with his desire to have liquidators appointed to ‘the unregistered managed investment scheme’ of McFarlane. Managed investment schemes have ‘members’ with ‘interests’. Under the heading ‘Background Facts’ Mr Fabbro’s affidavit continued as follows:‘3.McFarlane corresponded with various clients and associates and invited those clients and associates to invest funds in the Scheme which funds were generally deposited into the McFarlanes Accountants Trust Account (“Trust Account”), under the care and control of McFarlane. …’ It will be appreciated that Mr Fabbro’s affidavit presupposes the existence of a scheme which answers the description of a managed investment scheme as defined in s 9 of the Corporations Act. None of the items of correspondence to which Mr Fabbro referred mentioned any ‘Scheme’ nor did they invite clients and associates of McFarlane to invest funds in a Scheme. Whether McFarlane solicited the provision of funds by gullible clients and associates under the pretext that they would be deposited in a bank account styled a ‘trust account’ in his name is a matter of irrelevance for present purposes. National Australia Bank Limited, which appears to have had McFarlane or MCFARLANES as a customer, was not, as a result, a trustee of monies standing to the credit of an account which McFarlane may have styled as a ‘Trust Account’. The Bank was simply a debtor of the relevant account holder for the whole of the amount standing to the credit of the account from time to time (see per Campbell J in Sutherland Re; French Caledonia Travel Service Pty Ltd (In Liq) (2003) 59 NSWLR 361 (the ‘Travel Service case’ at [61]).