(In Liquidation) v Tumut River Orchard Management Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

HP Mercantile Pty Limited; in the matter of Tumut River Orchard Management Ltd (In Liquidation); in the matter of Merilbah Investments Pty Limited
(In Liquidation) v Tumut River Orchard Management Ltd
(In Liquidation), [2009] FCA 1456

CORPORATIONS – managed investment scheme (MIS) – whether circumstances of liquidator soliciting funding from contingent creditors constituted unlawful MIS – earlier MIS in which company, TROM, financed investors into that MIS by lending them money – TROM assigned the debts to other companies which, in turn, assigned them to Merilbah, which assigned them to HPM – attempts by HPM to recover the debts from numerous investor-debtors in Supreme Court and District Court – question whether assignments were valid – liquidators of TROM and Merilbah now soliciting funding from the numerous investor-debtors to enable them to challenge validity of assignments with a view to debts remaining the property of TROM or Merilbah – solicitation of funding on basis that any investor-debtor who provided funding would or might obtain a release of his or her debt from the liquidators – present application by HPM for interim injunction under s 1324(4) of Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) restraining TROM, Merilbah and their liquidators from attempting to raise further funds and from expending any of the funds already raised on basis that the obtaining of the funding in all of the circumstances constituted an MIS that was required to be registered but which was unlawful for non-registration.
Held:  modified form of injunctive relief granted on interim basis.

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 9 (definition of “managed investment scheme”), 1324

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Mauer-Swisse Securities Ltd (2002) 42 ACSR 605 referred to
Brookfield Multiplex Ltd v International Litigation Funding Partners Pte Ltd (2009) 260 ALR 643 referred to
National Australia Bank Ltd v Norman [2009] FCAFC 152 referred to

IN THE MATTER OF TUMUT RIVER ORCHARD MANAGEMENT LTD (IN LIQUIDATION)
(ACN 003 501 611)
IN THE MATTER OF MERILBAH INVESTMENTS PTY LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)
(ACN 002 979 893)

HP MERCANTILE PTY LIMITED (ACN 097 362 877) v TUMUT RIVER ORCHARD MANAGEMENT LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) (ACN 003 501 611), NICHOLAS DAVID JAMES CROUCH IN HIS CAPACITY AS LIQUIDATOR OF TUMUT RIVER ORCHARD MANAGEMENT LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) (ACN 003 501 611), MERILBAH INVESTMENTS PTY LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) (ACN 002 979 893), NICHOLAS DAVID JAMES CROUCH AND SHABNAM AMIRBEAGGI IN THEIR CAPACITY AS JOINT LIQUIDATORS OF MERILBAH INVESTMENTS PTY LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) (ACN 002 979 893), NICHOLAS DAVID JAMES CROUCH and SHABNAM AMIRBEAGGI

NSD 1267 of 2009

LINDGREN J
4 DECEMBER 2009
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1267 of 2009

IN THE MATTER OF TUMUT RIVER ORCHARD MANAGEMENT LTD
(IN LIQUIDATION) (ACN 003 501 611)

IN THE MATTER OF MERILBAH INVESTMENTS PTY LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) (ACN 002 979 893)

HP MERCANTILE PTY LIMITED
(ACN 097 362 877)
Plaintiff

TUMUT RIVER ORCHARD MANAGEMENT LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) (ACN 003 501 611)
First Defendant

NICHOLAS DAVID JAMES CROUCH IN…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read (In Liquidation) v Tumut River Orchard Management Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 1456
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of (In Liquidation) v Tumut River Orchard Management Ltd, the plaintiff sought an injunction to prevent the defendants from using funds raised from investor-debtors to challenge the plaintiff’s claims. The defendants, including liquidators of Tumut River Orchard Management Ltd (TROM) and Merilbah, were accused of soliciting funds through misleading statements about the potential discharge of debts if certain assignments were deemed invalid. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the funds solicited from investor-debtors could be lawfully used for the purposes intended by the defendants. The court had to balance the protective purpose of Pt 5C of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) with the equitable considerations typically associated with granting an injunction.

The court found that while the defendants’ actions might seem to contravene Pt 5C, the statute also allows for creditors to indemnify a liquidator to recover property. However, this power does not extend to sanctioning an unlawful managed investment scheme. Therefore, the funds could not be used to defeat the plaintiff's claims on the basis of invalid assignments or to establish their invalidity. Consequently, the court issued an interlocutory injunction restraining the defendants from soliciting further funds from investor-debtors and from expending the funds already raised, except for the purposes of conducting public examinations under ss 596A and 596B of the Act. The proceedings were to be expedited to a final hearing.

The court also ordered that the costs of the interim application be part of the parties' costs of the proceeding. The injunction was to remain in effect until the final hearing or further order of the court. The case underscores the importance of ensuring that liquidators do not misuse funds raised from creditors in ways that contravene the legislative intent of protecting investors in managed investment schemes.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Upon the plaintiff’s giving the usual undertaking as to damages, until the final hearing and determination of this proceeding or further order of the Court,

(a) the defendants shall not solicit funds from persons who borrowed money for the purpose of investing in any managed investment scheme (investor-debtors) for the purpose of creating or increasing a fund to enable proceedings, present or future, by the plaintiff against any of the investor-debtors to be defeated on the ground of the invalidity of assignments or otherwise to establish the invalidity of assignments; and

(b) the defendants shall not expend, use, apply or otherwise dispose of any funds already paid by investor-debtors pursuant to any such solicitation, whether by the defendants or by Horticultural Operations Ltd or any other person, except for the purpose of the conducting of public examinations under s 596A or s 596B of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).

2. The parties have liberty to apply on 24 hours’ notice.

3. The costs of the plaintiff’s application for interim relief be part of the parties’ costs of the proceeding.

4. The proceeding be stood over to a date to be advised for the making of directions with a view to progressing the matter to a final hearing.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Accordingly, so it is said (para 35 of the SOC), HPM is a person whose interests are or would be affected within s 1324 of the Act by the continued operation of the scheme.Further Facts Consequent upon a creditors’ voluntary winding up on or about 28 April 1999, Maxwell William Prentice and Vince Christopher Barilla of Prentice Parbery & Barilla were appointed joint liquidators of TROM. TROM was deregistered on 7 January 2006. On 7 July 2008 the Supreme Court of New South Wales ordered that the registration of TROM be reinstated and it appointed TROM’s Liquidator. On 7 February 2008 the Supreme Court of Western Australia ordered that Merilbah be wound up and it appointed Merilbah’s Liquidators. Funds were sought from the investor-debtors to constitute a “Fighting Fund” to enable the validity of the assignments to be tested. The money raised was paid into a bank account in the name of Merilbah. It seems that a company named Horticultural Operations Ltd (HOL) has played a leading role in the soliciting of the funds, but there is evidence that Mr Crouch has sought funds from the investor-debtors too. A firm of solicitors named Galic & Co Lawyers and a chartered accountant named Barry Coates have also been involved. In its circular to investor-debtors, HOL has misleadingly asserted that if the assignments are held to be invalid so that title to the debts remains with TROM or Merilbah, the debt of a funding investor-debtor will be discharged. For example, in its circular dated 19 May 2009 HOL stated: “Growers contributing to the HOL Legal Fund will obtain a discharge of loan obligations from the Liquidator”. By contrast, in his circular to investor-debtors Mr Crouch has pointed out that while he will seek approval from the Court for such a favourable treatment of a funding investor-creditor, the matter is within the discretion of the Court (and see para 26(vi) of the statement of claim set out at [23] above). There is in evidence a statement of receipts and payments of Merilbah’s Liquidators in relation to Merilbah. This shows an opening balance as at 7 February 2008 of $63,445.81 followed by numerous receipts extending from 16 September 2009 to 2 November 2009 credited to a “TROM Fighting Fund” totalling $97,350. As well, the statement shows payments of “Legal Fees” of $9,570 to counsel and $47,586.28 to solicitors, totalling $57,156.28. If one deducts this amount from the total amount of $160,795.81 (being $63,445.81 + 97,350), one arrives at a balance of $103,639.53. However, the evidence is that the amount in fact held by Merilbah’s Liquidators (as at 2 November 2009) was $103,642.49 (I was told that there had been minor adjustments that explain the discrepancy, the nature of which does not matter). By its interlocutory application, HPM seeks to restrain Merilbah’s Liquidators from expending any part of this sum as well as from raising any further funds from “any member of the public”. In his circulars to investor-debtors soliciting funding, Mr Crouch signed both as liquidator of TROM and as liquidator for Merilbah. I do not know how it comes about that the money subscribed by investor-debtors was deposited into an account in the name of Merilbah alone.CONSIDERATION

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

LINDGREN J
What should occur is that, subject to the views of the parties, the proceeding should be given an early final hearing. In the meanwhile, TROM’s Liquidator and Merilbah’s Liquidators (or whichever of them is appropriate) should have access to the funds already raised but only to enable them to pursue the public examinations under ss 596A and 596B of the Act that are about to take place. Pending the final hearing no further solicitation of funds should take place. The costs of the plaintiff’s application for interim relief should be the parties’ costs of the proceeding.CONCLUSION Upon the plaintiff’s proffering to the Court the usual undertaking as to damages, there should be a modified injunction of the form just described.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: LINDGREN J

In his circulars to investor-debtors soliciting funding, Mr Crouch signed both as liquidator of TROM and as liquidator for Merilbah. I do not know how it comes about that the money subscribed by investor-debtors was deposited into an account in the name of Merilbah alone.CONSIDERATION The present application is one for an interim injunction under s 1324(4) of the Act. I am not determining the substantive application and make no final findings of fact or express any final conclusions of law. Subsequent to the hearing I raised with the parties the possibility of converting the nature of the hearing and therefore of my decision into final ones. While counsel for the defendants agreed to that course, counsel for HPM indicated that his client had always anticipated adducing further evidence on the final hearing. In these circumstances, the hearing, like my present decision, remain interlocutory only. In the present context the word “interlocutory” must be used with caution. Palmer J pointed out in Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Mauer-Swisse Securities Ltd (2002) 42 ACSR 605 that when granting an injunction under s 1324(1) or (4) of the Act the Court is not exercising the traditional equitable jurisdiction to grant final or interlocutory injunctions. While considerations that are customarily relevant to the exercise of that jurisdiction may be also relevant to the exercise of the discretion under s 1324(1) or (4), the dominant consideration in cases under the section is the purpose of the provision of the Act that is said to have been contravened. Unfortunately, to a large extent the parties have not joined issue in their submissions. HPM emphasises that the purpose of Pt 5C of the Act is to establish a régime to protect those who contemplate acquiring or have acquired interests in MISs. Counsel for HPM submits that the arrangement established and implemented by the defendants was the very kind of arrangement that the legislature intended should be registered and regulated by Pt 5C. This submission, however, assumes what is to be decided – that there was an MIS in the first place. Counsel for the defendants, on the other hand, places heavy reliance on s 564 of the Act. That section expressly contemplates the possibility that a creditor or creditors will indemnify a liquidator and so enable the liquidator to recover property which would not otherwise have been recovered. The section empowers the Court to make such orders as it deems just with respect to the distribution of the property recovered with a view to giving the funding creditor or creditors an advantage over others in consideration of the risk assumed. Counsel correctly points out that the notion of “creditors” for this purpose includes contingent creditors. It seems not to be disputed by HPM that the various investor-borrowers are contingent creditors of TROM or Merilbah or of both of them. Again, however, counsel’s submission does not carry the day. As counsel for HPM points out, a conclusion that there was an unlawful MIS in the present case and that the funds raised may therefore not be lawfully used for their intended purpose would not be inconsistent with s 564: a liquidator would be at liberty to take an indemnity for costs of litigation from creditors but not by means of an unlawful MIS.