Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Web3 Ventures Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Web3 Ventures Pty Ltd [2025] FCAFC 58

Appeal from: Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Web3 Ventures Pty Ltd [2024] FCA 64
File number(s): NSD 775 of 2024
Judgment of: O’CALLAGHAN, ABRAHAM AND BUTTON JJ
Date of judgment: 22 April 2025
Catchwords: CORPORATIONS – where primary judge held that a product that allowed customers to “loan” specified cryptocurrency in return for interest paid at a fixed rate was a “financial product” because it involved the respondent/cross-appellant: (i) operating a managed investment scheme as defined in s 9 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Act); and (ii) offering a financial investment facility as defined in s 763B of the Act – where primary judge made declarations that the respondent/cross-appellant contravened ss 911A(5B) and s 601ED(8) of the Act (the primary judgment) – where primary judge ordered pursuant to s 1317S(2) of the Act that the respondent/cross-appellant be relieved from liability to pay a pecuniary penalty for the contraventions (the penalty judgment) – where ASIC appealed from the whole of the penalty judgment – where respondent/cross-appellant cross-appealed contending that the primary judge erred in the primary judgment in finding that the provision of the product constituted a “financial product” for the purposes of the Act, as it was neither a managed investment scheme nor a facility by which a person made a financial investment – where ASIC relied on a notice of contention, to the effect that if the primary judge was wrong to find that the provision of the product constituted a financial product on the basis that it involved the respondent/cross-appellant operating a managed investment scheme or offering a financial investment facility, then it was a “derivative” within the meaning of s 761D of the Act – whether the arrangements were to be treated as if they together constituted a single arrangement pursuant to s 761B of the Act – appeal dismissed – cross-appeal allowed
Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 9, 601EB, 601ED, 601FC, 761A, 761B, 761D, 762C, 763A(1)(a), 763B, 764A, 765A, 766A–766E, 911A and 1317S(2)

Corporations Regulations 2001 (Cth) regs 7.1.04(2)(b) and 7.1.06

Cases cited:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Great Northern Developments Pty Ltd [2010] NSWSC 1087; (2010) 242 FLR 444

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Hutchings [2001] NSWSC 522; (2001) 38 ACSR 387

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Pegasus Leveraged Options Group Pty Ltd [2002] NSWSC 310; (2002) 41 ACSR 561

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Secure Investments Pty Ltd (No 2) [2020] FCA 1463; (2020) 148 ACSR 154

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Web3 Ventures Pty Ltd [2024] FCA 64

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Web3 Ventures Pty Ltd(Penalty) [2024] FCA 578

Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118

Impiombato v BHP Group Limited [2025] FCAFC 9

International Litigation Partners Pte Ltd v Chameleon Mining NL (2012) 246 CLR 455

International Litigation Partners Pte Ltd v Chameleon Mining NL [2011]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Web3 Vent... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCAFC 58
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Web3 Ventures Pty Ltd, the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) sought to enforce compliance with financial services laws against Web3 Ventures Pty Ltd, trading as Block Earner, concerning the provision of cryptocurrency-related products known as the Earner and Access products. The Federal Court was tasked with determining whether these products constituted "financial products" under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), and consequently, whether Block Earner had contravened licensing and registration requirements. ASIC argued that the Earner product, which allowed customers to loan specified cryptocurrency in return for interest, constituted a financial product as it involved Block Earner operating a managed investment scheme and offering a financial investment facility. Block Earner, on the other hand, contested these characterisations, asserting that the provision of the Earner product did not amount to a financial product under the Act.

The court's primary challenge was to interpret the relevant statutory definitions and determine whether the Earner product fit within them. The court assessed whether the cryptocurrency loans constituted a managed investment scheme or a financial investment facility. The court concluded that the primary judge had erred in finding that the Earner product was a financial product. The court found that the customers' contributions were not made in consideration for acquiring rights to benefits produced by the scheme, as required by the definition of a managed investment scheme. Instead, the loaned cryptocurrency was entirely at Block Earner's discretion, and any interest paid was unrelated to Block Earner's activities with the loaned cryptocurrency. Consequently, the product did not constitute a financial investment facility either.

In light of these findings, the court allowed Block Earner's cross-appeal, set aside the primary judge's declarations of contravention, and dismissed ASIC's proceeding. The appeal by ASIC against the penalty judgment was dismissed, and costs orders were made in favour of Block Earner. This decision highlights the importance of precise statutory interpretation in determining the scope of financial services regulation and the need for clear evidence to support allegations of regulatory breaches.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The cross-appeal be allowed.

3. The declarations of contravention made by the primary judge be set aside.

4. The proceeding be dismissed.

5. The appellant pay the respondent’s costs of the appeal and the cross-appeal, together with the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the trial up to and including 9 February 2024.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth).

Background

Background to the litigation

There was no factual controversy below or on appeal. The relevant facts were contained in a document entitled “Narrative of facts on liability” on which the parties agreed below (the Agreed Facts or AF) and in the unchallenged affidavit evidence of Block Earner’s CEO and co-founder, Mr Karaboga. The dispute between the parties below centred on whether the Earner and Access products were “financial products” within the meaning of the Act. ASIC contended that each product was a financial product because each was: (i) a managed investment scheme; (ii) a facility by which a person made a financial investment; or (iii) a derivative. It was common ground that if either Earner or Access was a financial product, then Block Earner had contravened s 911A of the Act by carrying on a financial services business without holding an Australian financial services licence (AFSL). It was also common ground that if either the Earner or Access products was a managed investment scheme, then Block Earner had contravened s 601ED(1) of the Act by operating a managed investment scheme that was not registered under s 601EB. The Earner product was offered from 17 March 2022 until 16 November 2022 (the Relevant Period). It allowed customers to “loan” specified cryptocurrency in return for interest paid at a fixed rate. The primary judge accepted ASIC’s case that the Earner product was a financial product — because it involved Block Earner: (i) operating a managed investment scheme as defined in s 9 of the Act; and (ii) offering a financial investment facility as defined in s 763B of the Act — and made declarations accordingly. See Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Web3 Ventures Pty Ltd [2024] FCA 64 (the primary judgment or PJ). Because the primary judge found that the Earner product was a managed investment scheme (and was not registered and had more than 20 members), it followed that it was not a derivative within the meaning of s 761D of the Act. See PJ at [54]; ss 761D(3)(c), 764A(1)(ba) and 601ED(1)(a) of the Act. As such, his Honour did not have to deal with the third alternative aspect of ASIC’s case. The primary judge found that ASIC’s case in relation to the Access product failed and he dismissed the Access claim. No issue arises on appeal about that order or about the Access product. After a separate hearing, the primary judge ordered pursuant to s 1317S(2) of the Act that Block Earner be relieved from liability to pay a pecuniary penalty for contraventions of s 911A(5B) (the requirement to hold an AFSL) and s 601ED(8) (the requirement to register a managed investment scheme) of the Act, in summary because his Honour found that Block Earner had acted honestly, it had obtained legal advice about the Earner product, it made only a modest profit on the product, it had suffered adverse publicity (including in a misleading ASIC press release) and no Earner customer suffered any loss or damage. See Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Web3 Ventures Pty Ltd (Penalty) [2024] FCA 578 (the penalty judgment).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

After a separate hearing, the primary judge ordered pursuant to s 1317S(2) of the Act that Block Earner be relieved from liability to pay a pecuniary penalty for contraventions of s 911A(5B) (the requirement to hold an AFSL) and s 601ED(8) (the requirement to register a managed investment scheme) of the Act, in summary because his Honour found that Block Earner had acted honestly, it had obtained legal advice about the Earner product, it made only a modest profit on the product, it had suffered adverse publicity (including in a misleading ASIC press release) and no Earner customer suffered any loss or damage. See Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Web3 Ventures Pty Ltd (Penalty) [2024] FCA 578 (the penalty judgment). ASIC appealed from the whole of the penalty judgment, contending that the primary judge erred in the exercise of his discretion not to penalise Block Earner, and submitted that, on a re-exercise of that discretion, Block Earner should pay a penalty of as much as $350,000. Block Earner cross-appealed, contending that the primary judge erred in finding that the provision of the Earner product constituted a “financial product” for the purposes of the Act, because it was neither a managed investment scheme nor a facility by which a person made a financial investment. On the cross-appeal, ASIC relied on a notice of contention, to the effect that if the primary judge was wrong to find that the provision of Earner constituted a financial product because it involved Block Earner operating a managed investment scheme or offering a financial investment facility, then it was a “derivative”. Block Earner disputed this contention. For the reasons that follow, in our view the cross-appeal should be allowed, the declarations of contravention made by the primary judge should be set aside and ASIC’s proceeding should be dismissed. THE RELEVANT FACTS Block Earner operates an online platform through its website which offers to its customers various products, including the Earner product during the Relevant Period. Block Earner also operates a digital currency exchange service (Exchange service), registered with the Australian Transaction Reports and Analysis Centre, that allows users to exchange Australian dollars (or AUD) into cryptocurrencies and to buy and sell over 100 different cryptocurrencies. The nature of cryptocurrencies Cryptocurrency refers to digital tokens that are created from code, can be used to make payments and do not exist physically in the form of notes or coins. It is created using blockchain technology. A blockchain is a ledger method for recording transactions, where data is organised in blocks or groups across many computers that are linked and secured. Each block can only hold a certain amount of information, so new blocks are added to the ledger and this forms a chain. Each block has its own unique identifier, which is known as a cryptographic hash. The hash protects the information in the block from anyone without the required code and protects the block’s place on the chain from being tampered with. See PJ at [7].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It was common ground that the Court’s review of the primary judge’s findings of fact and inferences drawn from those facts are subject to the principles stated in Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118 and Warren v Coombes (1979) 142 CLR 531. Here, no witness gave oral testimony and no witness was cross-examined. It was thus accepted by the parties that the Court is in as good a position as the primary judge to make findings of fact on the evidence that was adduced at the hearing. See, for example, Impiombato v BHP Group Limited [2025] FCAFC 9 at [193] (Beach and O’Bryan JJ) and [342]–[345] (Lee J). Was the contribution of money or money’s worth made by Block Earner’s customers in consideration for the acquisition of rights to benefits produced by the scheme? As Mr Free SC (who appeared with Mr B Smith for Block Earner) submitted, the terms that governed the relationship between Block Earner and its Earner product customers unequivocally provided that the cryptocurrency was being “loaned” in return for daily interest payments. Clause 4.3(a) provided: “Under Lend, in accordance with these Terms including the terms contained at this section 4.3 (Loan Terms), users can lend Eligible Cryptocurrency to Block Earner in return for daily interest payments paid in the same Eligible Cryptocurrency loaned to Block Earner”. The only relevant right acquired by customers under the Loan Terms was the right to payment of the Final Amount upon termination of the loan, being the amount of the borrowed cryptocurrency plus the interest accrued, as provided in cl 4.3(j), viz:Upon the term of the loan of your Eligible Cryptocurrency ending Block Earner will return the borrowed Eligible Cryptocurrency and deliver any interest accrued under the Loan Terms (Final Amount), in each case by Block Earner converting the Final Amount to an equivalent value of Australian dollars under the exchange service and this value will be held in the Account. … And the Loan Terms expressly provided that the loaned cryptocurrency was “Block Earner’s to use, without limitation and at Block Earner’s sole absolute discretion” (cl 4.3(l)(i)); that “any interest paid … [was] not referable to the activities Block Earner undert[ook] with respect to the loaned Eligible Cryptocurrency” (cl 4.3(l)(ii)); and that “the only amounts” to which a customer had any “right” were “the amount of Eligible Cryptocurrency initially loaned … and any interest earned on that amount” (cl 4.3(l)(ii)). The primary judge found that the first FAQ response constituted a representation that customers had a right, even an unenforceable right, to acquire benefits produced by Block Earner’s business because that response indicated that customers were acquiring a right to interest that was funded by Block Earner’s activities in on-lending the borrowed cryptocurrency to third parties. See PJ at [40]–[41]. The critical paragraph of his Honour’s reasons is [40], which relevantly stated as follows:40… Users thus contributed money or money’s worth jointly with all other users, as consideration to acquire the right to the promised fixed interest yield under the Earner product which Block Earner represented it would be able to pay because of the benefit produced by the scheme of enabling Block Earner to earn revenue in a greater amount by deploying the pooled contributions from users (as well as its own cryptocurrency) in lending the aggregated cryptocurrency to third parties at a higher rate. …(Emphasis added.)