Background
Background to the litigation
The parties have agreed on a document entitled “Narrative of facts on liability” (the Agreed Facts). Those Agreed Facts include that, at all times, the Exchange Service and the Earner and Access services were provided in accordance with Block Earner’s Terms of Use. The Terms of Use were amended from time to time, but the key features relevantly remained the same during the relevant period (Agreed Facts at [11]). I set out below cl 4 of the Terms of Use taken from the version which appeared on Block Earner’s website as at 8 November 2022, shortly before Block Earner ceased to offer the Earner product on 16 November 2022:4.1 Exchange servicea.Under the exchange service, users transfer Australian dollars to a fiat account with an Australian authorised deposit taking institution in Block Earner’s name (Account) for the purpose of exchanging such dollars for:i.Aave USDC (aUSDC) or Compound USDC (cUSDC) to participate in the access services, known as ‘Aave USD Coin Variable Yield (DeFi-based)’ and ‘Compound USD Coin Variable Yield (DeFi-based)' (see section 4.2); orii.certain cryptocurrency as stated in the Block Earner Platform (Eligible Cryptocurrency) to participate in the loan service under which users can lend their Eligible Cryptocurrency to Block Earner in exchange for interest payments, known as ‘Block Earner USD Coin Fixed Yield (Lending-based)’ (Lend) (see section 4.3).b.There are no restrictions on the amount of Australian dollars that users can transfer to the Account. Users do not earn any interest on their Australian dollars held in the Account and are not permitted to make payments or instruct Block Earner to make payments from the Account. Users can only exchange their Australian dollars for aUSDC, cUSDC or Eligible Cryptocurrency to access the Services or withdraw their Australian dollars to an Australian bank account in the name of the user.c.Once Block Earner receives a user’s fiat deposit in the Account, the user is permitted to nominate whether the user wishes to participate in the access service or Lend. Participating in the access service requires the user to have certain cryptocurrency, being cUSDC for Compound and aUSDC for Aave. Participating in the loan service requires the user to have Eligible Cryptocurrency.d.There are limits on how much users can exchange under the exchange service:i.Users can only exchange up to A$20,000 in Australian dollars for aUSDC, cUSDC or Eligible Cryptocurrency per 1 calendar day; andii.there is an exchange limit of up to A$25,000 per 1 calendar day with respect to exchanging aUSDC, cUSDC or Eligible Cryptocurrency to Australian dollars. Where a user nominates to cease using the access service or Lend and wishes to exchange more than A$25,000 of aUSDC, cUSDC or Eligible Cryptocurrency to Australian dollars, Block Earner will split the transaction into parcels of A$25,000 per 1 calendar day until the nominated amount has been exchanged.e. You acknowledge and agree that:i.Block Earner will facilitate the exchange process by exchanging your Australian dollars in the Account;ii.for the access service, Block Earner facilitates the exchange by exchanging the user’s Australian dollars for USDC and then exchanging that USDC for the corresponding amount of cUSDC or aUSDC;iii.for Lend, Block Earner facilitates the exchange by exchanging the user’s Australian dollars for the Eligible Cryptocurrency nominated by the user;iv.each transaction constitutes a transaction between you and Block Earner as principal. Block Earner facilitates transactions with you through back to back transactions with third parties that may correlate to transactions entered into with you, however Block Earner is not acting on your behalf in relation to a transaction with such third parties. All monies owed by you under a transaction are owed to us as a principal counterparty and not to any other person. You do not have any relationship or engage in any transaction directly with any third parties through the exchange service; andv.once you have nominated to proceed with exchanging your Australian dollars for aUSDC, cUSDC or Eligible Cryptocurrency, this nomination is irrevocable. We may (in our absolute discretion) but are not required or obliged to, stop, refund, suspend or reverse any change of Australian dollars into aUSDC, cUSDC or Eligible Cryptocurrency (or vice versa).f.Block Earner charges the user a conversion fee to exchange Australian dollars to aUSDC, cUSDC and Eligible Cryptocurrency and vice versa. The conversion fee will be included in the exchange rate at the time of the transaction.g.Users can withdraw from the Account at any time. There is up to two business days processing time for withdrawals.4.2 Access servicea. Under the access service, Block Earner:i.streamlines user access to certain yield generating platforms, currently being Aave and Compound;ii. aggregates the cUSDC and aUSDC exchanged under the exchange service from all users who have nominated Compound or Aave and holds such cUSDC and aUSDC in its Block Earner omnibus account on each platform (ie Compound or Aave). Access to Aave or Compound commences at the time the user’s cUSDC and aUSDC is received by Block Earner and moved to Block Earner’s omnibus account on each platform (as at the date and time stamped on the blockchain confirmation). Each user’s cUSDC and/or aUSDC holding is reflected in the user’s Block Earner Platform account. By using the access service, you acknowledge and agree that Block Earner will use an omnibus account on Compound and Aave; and iii.is responsible for tracking and calculating returns on cUSDC and aUSDC for each user on its ledger. Block Earner will perform daily reconciliation procedures and update the displayed user holdings on Block Earner Platform accounts for any yield earned the previous day.b.Block Earner displays performance data for Compound and Aave. Such data is updated daily and displays data for each platform for the last business day. You agree and acknowledge Block Earner produces such data as communicated to it by Compound and Aave and Block Earner is not responsible for any loss, damage or expense suffered or incurred arising from incorrect or erroneous data, excluding any mistake, fraud, negligence or wilful misconduct on the part of Block Earner.c.Users can nominate to cease using the access service at any stage. Upon notifying Block Earner that a user wishes to cease using the access service, Block Earner will convert the nominated value of cUSDC or aUSDC to Australian dollars under the exchange service and transfer this to the Account. For cUSDC and aUSDC, Block Earner redeems the cryptocurrency with Compound and Aave respectively and receives USDC (including any yield earned), which Block Earner then exchanges to Australian dollars and transfers to the account for the relevant user. The user (ie, you) may elect to use these funds to participate in Lend or the access services again or can request a withdrawal from the Account (see section 4.1(g)).d.All yield earned from cUSDC or aUSDC is passed through to the user. Block Earner does not pass along additional incentives or promotions offered by the underlying yield platforms (eg, deposit incentives on Aave where tokens are locked up for one year).4.3 Lenda.Under Lend, in accordance with these Terms including the terms contained at this section 4.3 (Loan Terms), users can lend Eligible Cryptocurrency to Block Earner in return for daily interest payments paid in the same Eligible Cryptocurrency loaned to Block Earner.b.The Lend product suite includes USD Earner (Fixed yield product), Gold Earner (Gold Fixed product), Crypto Earner (Bitcoin, and Ethereum). Block Earner will from time to time add or remove existing products on the menu.c.The rate of interest paid to users under the loan arrangement in return for such users lending Eligible Cryptocurrency to Block Earner will be calculated by Block Earner and published on the Block Earner Platform. Block Earner reserves the right to change the rate of interest paid on a monthly basis, with the new interest rate effective on the first [calendar day] of each month. Block Earner will provide seven (7) calendar days’ written notice of any such change, to be published on the Block Earner Platform and sent to the email address you used to sign up for your Block Earner account. By continuing to participate in Lend on the first calendar day of each month, you agree to the new rate of interest as published by Block Earner.d.There are no minimum or maximum amounts that can be loaned however Block Earner may put limits on amounts to be loaned from time to time at its own discretion in line with our risk management processes. Such limits will be notified to the user (ie, you) as needed.e.To activate Lend, you must log into your account on the Block Earner Platform and follow the prompts to:i. select Lend from the available services;ii.nominate the Eligible Cryptocurrency which you wish to lend to Block Earner and consequently receive interest payments in that Eligible Cryptocurrency; andiii.reconfirm your acceptance of these Terms including the Loan Terms.f.Once you have completed the actions at paragraph (d), your Australian dollars in the Account will be exchanged for the nominated Eligible Cryptocurrency under the exchange service. The Eligible Cryptocurrency will then be transferred to Block Earner under Lend. By lending Eligible Cryptocurrency to Block Earner, you agree to grant Block Earner all rights and title to such Eligible Cryptocurrency for Block Earner to use in its sole discretion during the term of the loan under Lend.g.The loan commences at the time the Eligible Cryptocurrency is received by Block Earner. Any Eligible Cryptocurrency received under Lend will be treated by us as being received at the date and time stamped on the blockchain confirmation.h.The balance of Eligible Cryptocurrency loaned by you to Block Earner, and any interest earned (as denominated in the Eligible Cryptocurrency) will be visible in your Block Earner account.i.The term of the loan of your Eligible Cryptocurrency will end:i.at the expiry of the fixed term selected by you when you elected to use Lend, if we provide this option;ii.upon termination of your account, subject to clause 17(b); oriii. when you elect to terminate your use of Lend. You may terminate your loan at any time.j.Upon the term of the loan of your Eligible Cryptocurrency ending Block Earner will return the borrowed Eligible Cryptocurrency and deliver any interest accrued under the Loan Terms (Final Amount), in each case by Block Earner converting the Final Amount to an equivalent value of Australian dollars under the exchange service and this value will be held in the Account. The user (ie, you) may elect to use these funds to participate in the access services or Lend again or can request a withdrawal from the Account (see section 4.1(g)).k.By agreeing to these terms (including the Loan Terms) and transferring Australian dollars to the Account for the purposes of conversion to Eligible Cryptocurrency that is then loaned to Block Earner (which, for the avoidance of doubt, shall be deemed as completed only upon the receipt of such Eligible Cryptocurrency by Block Earner), you agree to lend such Eligible Cryptocurrency to Block Earner in accordance with these Terms (including the Loan Terms).l.You acknowledge and agree that:i.all Eligible Cryptocurrency that is loaned to Block Earner by you under Lend is Block Earner’s to use, without limitation and at Block Earner’s sole absolute discretion;ii.any interest paid to you under Lend is not referrable to the activities Block Earner undertakes with respect to the loaned Eligible Cryptocurrency and the only amounts to which you have a right to [sic.] are the amount of Eligible Cryptocurrency initially loaned to Block Earner and any interest earned on that amount as determined under these Loan Terms;iii.by participating in Lend, you do not intend for Block Earner to use the loaned Eligible Cryptocurrency to generate a financial benefit or act as an investment for you; andiv.any benefit gained or loss incurred by Block Earner’s use of the loaned Eligible Cryptocurrency will not be passed onto you. The loan arrangement under Lend, interest payments and the rate at which interest is calculated are subject to all applicable laws and regulation, and to the extent we are limited or restricted from providing Lend or paying interest for any reason by applicable law or regulation, we will do so and will notify you as soon as practicable.4.4 Service discontinuationa.Block Earner reserves the right to cease offering the access service or Lend, in its discretion (Discontinued Service).b.Where Block Earner does cease offering the Discontinued Service, Block Earner:i.will provide you with at least 7 calendar days’ notice of any such cessation (Notice Period); andii.may, at its discretion, offer a new Service to which your aUSDC, cUSDC or Eligible Cryptocurrency under the Discontinued Service may be migrated (New Service). Block Earner will communicate the terms of this migration to you (including notice of any additional fees).c.Upon receiving notice of the Discontinued Service, you may end your use of the Discontinued Service in accordance this section 4 or, where a new Service is available, elect to migrate to the New Service in accordance with the terms communicated to you by Block Earner.d.At the end of the Notice Period, if you have not taken any action under paragraph (c), you acknowledge and agree that Block Earner will exchange your cryptocurrency under the Discontinued Service and credit the Account with the corresponding Australian dollar value (using the exchange service), the balance of which will be displayed on your Block Earner Platform account. You may elect to use these funds to participate in the available Services or can request a withdrawal from the Account (see section 4.1(g)).
Decision
Reasons for decision
There is considerable force in ASIC’s submissions to the effect that s 761D(1) is satisfied, but I need not decide that question in view of the conclusion to which I have come that the Access product constitutes a contract for the future provision of services within the meaning of s 761D(3)(b), and is therefore excluded from being a derivative. The substance of the Access service is that users are given streamlined access to DeFi protocols (Mr Karaboga’s first affidavit at [87]), and obtain rights to require Block Earner to carry out certain steps that allow the users to generate yield from their cryptocurrency through the DeFi protocols and the digital tokens in which users “retain ownership” (in the language of the Agreed Facts at [29]). Those services include exchanging AUD and cryptocurrency to tokens (cll 4.1(a)(i) and (e)(i), 4.2(a)(ii)), aggregating users’ tokens in an omnibus account that provides access to Aave and Compound and holding tokens in that omnibus account (cl 4.2(a)(ii)), tracking and calculating returns earned on their tokens (cl 4.2(a)(iii)), and ultimately remitting the tokens and any yield earned to the user when they elect to cease using Access (cl 4.2(c), (d)). The exemption in s 761D(3)(b) requires focus on the purpose or object of the contract, objectively ascertained from the contractual terms, and involves looking at the substance of the contract: Joffe v The Queen [2012] NSWCCA 277; (2012) 82 NSWLR 510 at [20] (Bathurst CJ), [165]–[167] (Barrett JA). The future provision of those services was at least the primary, if not the only, subject matter of the Access product. The future provision of those services could not be regarded as merely incidental or ancillary to some other purpose. In those circumstances, the exclusion from the definition of “derivative” relating to a contract for the future provision of services applies.Conclusion It follows that ASIC has succeeded in establishing contraventions of s 601ED and 911A of the Act in relation to the Earner product, but has failed in relation to the Access product. I will make declarations accordingly. Both parties have expressed the view that I should reserve costs at this stage, and decide the question of costs when I have determined the next stage of the proceedings concerning the amount of any pecuniary penalty. That appears to me to be the appropriate course.