Muirden and Australian National University (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 87 min read

Muirden and Australian National University (Compensation) [2019] AATA 5163 (2 December 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):     2018/5939          

Re:Linda Muirden

APPLICANT

AndAustralian National University

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member W Frost

Date:2 December 2019

Place:Canberra

The decision under review is affirmed pursuant to section 43(1)(a) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975.  

............................................................

Member W Frost

Catchwords

WORKERS COMPENSATION – where the Respondent refused a request for an extension of time – application for extension of time five years after determination – explanation for the delay - whether the Respondent is prejudiced by delay – decision under review affirmed

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – jurisdiction – whether the Applicant made a new claim for compensation or a request for reconsideration of a determination – whether the Tribunal has jurisdiction to consider a new claim – reviewable decision found to be refusal to grant an extension of time

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975

Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ss 5A, 5B, 14, 17, 54, 59, 60, 61, 62, 64, 65, 72

Cases

Batey and Minister of Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs [1991] AATA 295

Beecher and Telstra Corporation Limited [1994] AATA 6

Budd v Secretary, Department of Education, Employment and Workplace Relations [2008] FCA 1540

Brisbane South Regional Health Authority v Taylor (1996) 186 CLR 541

Comcare v A’Hearn [1993] FCA 498

Comcare v Smith [1997] FCA 140

Comcare v Willems (1996) 43 ALD 253

Hewson and Australian Postal Corporation [1998] AATA 71

Hunter Valley Developments Pty Ltd & Ors v Minister of Home Affairs and Environment (1984) 3 FCR 344

Lower and Comcare [2005] AATA 551

Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission v May [2016] HCA 19

Novosel v Comcare [2017] FCA 722

Phillips v Australian Girls’ Choir Pty Ltd & Anor [2001] FMCA 109

Saffioti and Comcare [2018] AATA 43

Secondary Materials

Peter H. Sutherland and John Oman Ballard with Allan Anforth, Annotated Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (The Federation Press, 11th ed, 2011)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member W Frost

2 December 2019

INTRODUCTION

  1. This proceeding involves tragic personal circumstances, lengthy delay and a difficult jurisdictional issue. Mr Andrew Muirden worked at the Australian National University (ANU) in Canberra as a nightwatchman, or security guard, from 2004 to 2011. In August 2011, Mr Muirden suffered an epileptic seizure at home and died aged 47.

  2. In March 2013, the Applicant, Mrs Linda Muirden, made a claim to Comcare (as ANU’s then insurer under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (SRC Act)) for compensation for the death of her husband. In May 2013, Comcare made a determination disallowing Mrs Muirden’s claim (Determination). Mrs Muirden did not request reconsideration by Comcare of its Determination within the 30 day timeframe required under section 62 of the SRC Act.

  3. In August 2018, more than five years after Comcare’s Determination, Mrs Muirden made a new claim for compensation for the death of Mr Muirden. The claim was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Muirden and Australian National University (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 5163
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mrs Muirden for an extension of time to request reconsideration of a 2013 determination made by the Australian National University (ANU) concerning her late husband's workers' compensation claim. The primary issue before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal was whether to grant this extension, which was intrinsically linked to the Tribunal's jurisdiction to consider a new claim made by Mrs Muirden in 2018.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether it had jurisdiction to consider Mrs Muirden's 2018 claim and, if not, whether to grant an extension of time under section 62 of the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* (SRC Act) for her to request reconsideration of the original 2013 determination. The Tribunal was required to determine if ANU's refusal of an extension of time constituted a reviewable decision and whether the circumstances warranted granting such an extension despite the significant delay.

The Tribunal noted that ANU had treated Mrs Muirden's 2018 application as a request for an extension of time to seek reconsideration of the 2013 determination and had refused it. The Tribunal's jurisdiction was engaged by Mrs Muirden's subsequent application for review of ANU's refusal. In considering the extension of time, the Tribunal was guided by section 72 of the SRC Act, which mandates that Comcare be guided by equity, good conscience, and the substantial merits of the case, without regard to technicalities. Mrs Muirden contended that the delay was attributable to factors including alleged advice from ANU regarding time limits, the trauma of her husband's death, her responsibilities as a single mother, difficulties securing legal representation, and delays in obtaining necessary medical evidence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The issue before the Tribunal is whether to grant Mrs Muirden an extension of time to request reconsideration by ANU of the 2013 Determination under section 62 of the SRC Act. Related to this issue is whether the Tribunal has jurisdiction to consider Mrs Muirden’s new claim made in 2018. BACKGROUND Because of the length of time that has elapsed and the significance of the events in this proceeding, it is necessary to set out the background in some detail. In February 2004, Mr Andrew Muirden commenced employment with ANU on a full-time casual basis as a ‘nightwatchman’, or security guard.[1] Mr Muirden worked on a rotating roster that comprised three shifts over a twenty-four hour period, with the following designated times: 12.00am to 8.00am; 8.00am to 4.00pm; and 4.00pm to 12.00am. [1] Document numbered ‘T7’ in the bundle of documents lodged on 12 November 2018, pursuant to section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, page 59 titled: Timeline for Comcare Concerning Andrew Muirden. In December 2004, Mr Muirden became a permanent full-time employee of ANU.[2] The Contract of Employment[3] noted that Mr Muirden’s appointment commenced on 16 December 2004 and stated that:Security Staff – 24 Hour Rotating shift / Extra leaveYour ordinary hours of work are 35 per week and are worked on a 24 hour, 7 day rotating shift basis with specified recreation leave. Your actual hours are determined by your supervisor and you must attend the University during these times except when you are on approved leave or your supervisor has agreed to alternative working arrangements.Staff of the University are entitled to 20 working days Annual Leave for each completed year of service. A staff member employed in areas of the University which close between Boxing Day and New Years Day will be entitled to those days as additional leave.In accordance with clause 35.2.1(b) you will be entitled to an additional 5 days annual leave whilst on rotating shifts.[2] T7, page 59 titled: Timeline for Comcare Concerning Andrew Muirden; T7B, page 66 titled: Offer of Appointment to The Australian National University; T4, pages 18-23 titled: Contract of Employment between The Australian National University and Andrew Muirden.[3] T4, pages 18-23 titled: Contract of Employment. In 2007, as stated by Mrs Muirden, her husband: began to have partial seizures upon wakening in January after the holiday period. The seizures were short and undiagnosed. He just had to lie down again and rest after wakening. These seizures occurred usually at the end of midnight-8am shift roster, every 3rd week and worsened each time.[4][4] T7, page 59 titled: Timeline for Comcare Concerning Andrew Muirden. On each day from 4 to 6 July 2007, that is, for three consecutive days, Mr Muirden worked the 12.00am to 8.00am shift at ANU.[5] Mr Muirden’s timesheets indicate that he was also rostered to work four additional 12.00am to 8.00am shifts from 7 to 10 July 2007.[6] [5] T33, Page 355, titled: ‘Summary of Hours and Days Worked for specified periods’, attached to email from Amy Seath, Human Resources Manager, to Comcare dated 28 May 2013.[6] T5, page 26, Mr Muirden’s ANU Timesheets.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

ANU treated Mrs Muirden’s 2018 claim as a request for an extension of time for reconsideration of the 2013 Determination and it declined such an extension (Reviewable Decision). Mrs Muirden subsequently applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal for review of ANU’s Reviewable Decision.ISSUE The issue before the Tribunal is whether to grant Mrs Muirden an extension of time to request reconsideration by ANU of the 2013 Determination under section 62 of the SRC Act. Related to this issue is whether the Tribunal has jurisdiction to consider Mrs Muirden’s new claim made in 2018. BACKGROUND Because of the length of time that has elapsed and the significance of the events in this proceeding, it is necessary to set out the background in some detail. In February 2004, Mr Andrew Muirden commenced employment with ANU on a full-time casual basis as a ‘nightwatchman’, or security guard.[1] Mr Muirden worked on a rotating roster that comprised three shifts over a twenty-four hour period, with the following designated times: 12.00am to 8.00am; 8.00am to 4.00pm; and 4.00pm to 12.00am. [1] Document numbered ‘T7’ in the bundle of documents lodged on 12 November 2018, pursuant to section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, page 59 titled: Timeline for Comcare Concerning Andrew Muirden. In December 2004, Mr Muirden became a permanent full-time employee of ANU.[2] The Contract of Employment[3] noted that Mr Muirden’s appointment commenced on 16 December 2004 and stated that:Security Staff – 24 Hour Rotating shift / Extra leaveYour ordinary hours of work are 35 per week and are worked on a 24 hour, 7 day rotating shift basis with specified recreation leave. Your actual hours are determined by your supervisor and you must attend the University during these times except when you are on approved leave or your supervisor has agreed to alternative working arrangements.Staff of the University are entitled to 20 working days Annual Leave for each completed year of service. A staff member employed in areas of the University which close between Boxing Day and New Years Day will be entitled to those days as additional leave.In accordance with clause 35.2.1(b) you will be entitled to an additional 5 days annual leave whilst on rotating shifts.[2] T7, page 59 titled: Timeline for Comcare Concerning Andrew Muirden; T7B, page 66 titled: Offer of Appointment to The Australian National University; T4, pages 18-23 titled: Contract of Employment between The Australian National University and Andrew Muirden.[3] T4, pages 18-23 titled: Contract of Employment. In 2007, as stated by Mrs Muirden, her husband: began to have partial seizures upon wakening in January after the holiday period. The seizures were short and undiagnosed. He just had to lie down again and rest after wakening. These seizures occurred usually at the end of midnight-8am shift roster, every 3rd week and worsened each time.[4][4] T7, page 59 titled: Timeline for Comcare Concerning Andrew Muirden.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 72 of the SRC Act notes that Comcare ‘shall be guided by equity, good conscience and the substantial merits of the case, without regard to technicalities’ when making determinations accurately and quickly in relation to claims made under the SRC Act. Reconsideration of determination The requirements for reconsideration of a determination are set out in section 62 of the SRC Act, which provides that:(1) A determining authority may, on its own motion: (a) reconsider a determination made by it…… whether or not a proceeding has been instituted or completed under this Part in respect of a reviewable decision made in relation to that determination.(2) A request to a determining authority to reconsider a determination made by it may be made by: (a) the claimant……(3) A request for reconsideration of a determination shall: (a) set out the reasons for the request; and(b) be given to the determining authority within 30 days after the day on which the determination first came to the notice of the person making the request, or within such further period (if any) as the determining authority, either before or after the expiration of that period, allows.(4) On receipt of a request, the determining authority shall reconsider the determination or cause the determination to be reconsidered by a person to whom its power under this section is delegated, being a person other than a person who made, or was involved in the making of, the determination.(5) Where a person reconsiders a determination, the person may make a decision affirming or revoking the determination or varying the determination in such manner as the person thinks fit.Applications to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Section 64 of the SRC Act provides that application to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal for review of a ‘reviewable decision’ may be made by, amongst others, a ‘claimant’. Section 60 of the SRC Act relevantly states that ‘reviewable decision’ means a decision made under section 62 of the SRC Act and that ‘claimant’ means a person in respect of whom a determination is made. In this proceeding, the Reviewable Decision is that made by ANU on 17 August 2018 denying Mrs Muirden an extension of time to request reconsideration of Comcare’s 2013 Determination. CONTENTIONSMrs Muirden’s contentions on Extension of Time Mrs Muirden contended that although the delay involved is ‘considerable’[81], it is not uniquely long. The cause of the delay was said to be: ANU’s alleged advice to Mrs Muirden that there was no time limit to bring an appeal; the trauma and her state of grief associated with Mr Muirden’s death; her duties as a single mother to four children; the difficulties engaging a solicitor on a ‘no-win/no-fee’ basis; the length of time to gather evidence for a new claim, including the related letters of administration process to bring a claim regarding Mr Muirden’s death and a delay in the provision of Dr McColl’s report, which was not received until 2018, despite being requested in 2017. It was also submitted that once Mrs Muirden had engaged her current solicitors, there were delays caused by the departure of the solicitor with carriage of the matter that should appropriately not be visited upon Mrs Muirden. [81] Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions dated 15 July 2019, page 4.