Mr A v Viva Energy Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 57 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:

Mr A v Viva Energy Australia Pty Ltd [2021] QIRC 309

PARTIES:

Mr A
(Applicant)

v

Viva Energy Australia Pty Ltd
(Respondent)

CASE NO.:

AD/2021/37

PROCEEDING:

Application for order protecting complainant's interests

DELIVERED ON:

7 September 2021

HEARING DATE:

11 August 2021

MEMBER:

HEARD AT:

Merrell DP

Brisbane

ORDER:

The Applicant's application for an order pursuant to s 144 of the Anti-Discrimination Act1991 is dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

HUMAN RIGHTS - DISCRIMINATION LEGISLATION - GENERALLY - applicant is an employee of respondent - respondent commenced disciplinary action against applicant - respondent indicated that termination of employment a possible outcome of disciplinary action - applicant invited by respondent to provide information for respondent to take into account in making a decision concerning applicant's ongoing employment - applicant lodged complaint with the Queensland Human Rights Commission - complaint that subjecting him to disciplinary action was direct and indirect discrimination contrary to the Anti‑Discrimination Act 1991 on the basis of his attributes of sex and, or in the alternative, sexuality - complaint of victimisation - complaint accepted by the Queensland Human Rights Commission - application by applicant pursuant to s 144 of the Anti‑Discrimination Act 1991 for an order halting the progression of the disciplinary action - matters to be considered by the Queensland Industrial Relations Commission in exercising discretion as to whether or not to make an order pursuant to s 144 of the Anti‑Discrimination Act 1991 - application refused

LEGISLATION:

Acts Interpretation Act 1954, s 14A

Anti-Discrimination Act 1991, s 129, s 130, s 134, s 135, s 136, s 144, s 154A, s 158, s 174B, s 174C, s 191 and s 209

Australian Human Rights Commission Act1986, s 46PP

Industrial Relations Act 2016, s 9, s 314, s 473, s 580, sch 1 and sch 5

Industrial Relations (Tribunals) Rules 2011, r 97

CASES:

Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O'Neill [2006] HCA 46; (2006) 227 CLR 57

Australian Rail, Tram and Bus Industry Union v Metro Trains Melbourne Pty Ltd [2021] FCA 458

Beecham Group Ltd v British Laboratories Pty Ltd [1968] HCA 1; (1968) 118 CLR 618

Bond v Multicap Ltd [2020] QIRC 051

Certain Lloyd's Underwriters v Cross [2012] HCA 56; (2012) 248 CLR 378

Coop v State of Queensland [2014] QCATA 205

Jones v Queensland Health [2010] QCAT 700

Luthje v State of Queensland & Ors [2014] QCAT 417

McGee v Sanders (No 2) [1991] FCA 554; (1991) 32 FCR 397

McIntyre v Hastings Deering (Australia) Ltd and Anor [2012] QCAT 438

McRostie v Boral Resources (Qld) Pty Ltd [1999] QADT 4

Project Blue Sky Inc. v Australian Broadcasting Authority [1998] HCA 28; (1998) 194 CLR 355

R v A2 [2019] HCA 35; (2019) 93 ALJR 1106

Samsung Electronics Company Ltd v Apple Inc and Another [2011] FCAFC 156; (2011) 217 FCR 238

Seen v Rebel Sport Limited [2021] QIRC 086

Toodayan & Anor v Anti-Discrimination…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mr A v Viva Energy Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QIRC 309
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Mr A v Viva Energy Australia Pty Ltd, Mr A, an employee of Viva Energy Australia, sought an order from the Queensland Industrial Relations Commission (QIRC) under section 144 of the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (the Act) to halt the progression of disciplinary action taken against him. Mr A lodged a complaint with the Queensland Human Rights Commission (QHRC) alleging that the disciplinary action was discriminatory on the basis of his sex and/or sexuality, as well as a complaint of victimisation. The QHRC accepted the complaint, and Mr A subsequently applied to the QIRC for an order to halt the disciplinary proceedings. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the QIRC should exercise its discretion under section 144 of the Act to make an order halting the progression of the disciplinary action. The court considered the test for exercising the discretion under section 144, which involves determining whether there is a serious question to be tried and whether the balance of convenience favours the applicant. The court found that Mr A's substantive case was not particularly strong and that the balance of convenience did not favour him. Consequently, the court dismissed Mr A's application for an order under section 144 of the Act. The QIRC concluded that the facts of the case did not warrant the exercise of its discretion to halt the disciplinary proceedings. The court's decision highlights the importance of establishing a strong prima facie case and demonstrating that the balance of convenience favours the applicant when seeking an order under section 144 of the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Applicant's application for an order pursuant to s 144 of the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

In addition, by consent of the parties,[3] pursuant to r 97(3) of the Industrial Relations (Tribunals) Rules 2011, I have modified this decision by anonymising the applicant's name and the name of the female employee the subject of the findings made in the April 2021 investigation. I will refer to the female employee as 'Ms B.' Background[3] T 1-7, ll 4-19.The January 2021 warning The January 2021 warning was issued because Viva found that Mr A had engaged in the following conduct:·he would flick the back of the other male employee's ear, which Viva viewed as behaviour that was unacceptable in the workplace and inconsistent with the culture that it expected from all team members, let alone its leaders, and was demonstrative of Mr A's lack of judgment and perception of appropriate workplace behaviour in which he should partake as a leader;·he would engage in arguments with the other male employee and although Mr A's interactions with the other male employee were in response to inappropriate conduct initially directed at him, Mr A's apparent tendency to respond in kind, in circumstances where he was a leader and was expected to uphold Viva's expected standards of behaviour, was unacceptable and inconsistent with Viva's expectations of him; and his conduct was demonstrative of his lack of judgment as a leader and his failure to uphold appropriate standards of workplace behaviour; and·he used sexist and derogatory language to discuss a female employee which Viva found to be completely inappropriate and inconsistent with Viva's Code of Conduct ('the Code') expectation to treat others with respect and avoid situations that may be perceived as inappropriate and to never make inappropriate jokes or comments; and Viva found that the conduct was demonstrative of Mr A's lack of judgment as a leader and a failure to uphold appropriate standards of work behaviour, particularly in his behaviour towards females and, or in the alternative, other colleagues.[4][4] Exhibit 3, exhibit 'VN-01' first and second pages. In his complaint to the QHRC, Mr A refers to this matter as the 'December 2020 allegations' (Exhibit 1, exhibit 'PH-01'). This is not an accurate description. Whilst the original allegations against Mr A (that he had bullied the other male employee the subject of the January 2021 warning) were not substantiated, Viva found that the three aspects of Mr A's conduct, referred to above, were such that he should receive a written warning in relation to that conduct. The January 2021 warning was conveyed to Mr A by a letter from Mr Daryl Scott, Viva's Queensland Operations Manager, in which Mr Scott relevantly stated:Having regard to all the information available, Viva Energy is issuing you with a Written Warning in respect of the identified Code breaches. Any further instances of inappropriate workplace conduct or behaviour outside Viva Energy's required standards may result in further disciplinary action, which may include your employment being terminated. Please note that this warning will be placed on your personnel file.…We now consider this matter to be finalised. We look forward to supporting you to improve your behaviours and avoid future issues.[5][5] Exhibit 4, exhibit 'NC-5', third page.The findings made in the April 2021 investigation and the show cause letter

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

At the date of the hearing of Mr A's s 144 application, his complaint had not been referred to the QIRC under the Act.Mr A's evidence and submissions Mr A submitted that the QIRC and the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal ('the QCAT') have approached the exercise of the discretion under s 144 of the Act in a way similar to that used in the courts in applications for injunctions, namely, that he has to establish '… an arguable case for relief, and second, where does the balance of convenience lie.'[16] [16] Mr A's written submissions filed on 10 August 2021 ('Mr A's submissions'), para. 27. Mr A also submitted that the approach of Industrial Commissioner Power in Bond v Multicap Ltd ('Bond')[17] should be followed, namely, that he has to make out a prima facie case in the sense that if the evidence remains as it is, there is a sufficient likelihood of success to justify the preservation of the status quo pending the trial, and whether the inconvenience or injury which he would be likely to suffer if an injunction was refused outweighs, or is outweighed by, the injury which Viva would suffer if an injunction was granted.[18][17] [2020] QIRC 051 ('Bond').[18] Mr A's submissions, para. 31. Mr A then submitted:32. While the test directly lifted from s 144 of the AD Act provides that the Tribunal may make; an order prohibiting a person from doing an act that might prejudice-(a) the investigation or conciliation of the complaint; or(b) an order that the tribunal might make after a hearing.it is submitted that this is a threshold question only, associated with injury suffered by the Complainant as a result of the act the Complainant seeks restrained.33. In determining this question, "the applicant only has to show that prejudice might occur. The obligation on the applicant is to show that a possibility of prejudice exists that is tangible or, at least perceptible and plausible and not too remote or unlikely..." .34. The balance of convenience test, it is submitted, is one that should not be rigidly held to a strict application of s 144(1)(a) and (b) of the AD Act, and instead is one that is guided only by s 144(1)(a) and (b) to ensure any order made by the Commission are appropriately proximal to the subject of the QHRc [sic] Complaint.35. The discretion to make an order under s 144 of the AD Act, it is submitted, is to be exercised in a way that recognises that it is intended principally to protect the interests of the complainant before reference and/or resolution of the Complaint to and/or by the QHRC.36. Consequently, it is submitted, for orders to be made pursuant to s 144 of the AD Act, the QIRC must be satisfied that;a.there is a serious question to be tried insofar as the applicant made out a prima facie case; and b.the acts which the Complainant seeks to prohibit are;i.acts that may prejudice the investigation or conciliation of the complaint, or any order the QIRC; andii.acts that may, if the injunction is refused, cause injury to the Complainant that outweighs the injury the Respondents would suffer if an injunction were granted.[19][19] Citations omitted.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In my view, for the reasons I have given above, the strength of Mr A's substantive case is not particularly strong which also weighs against making the order he seeks.Conclusion The question in the present proceeding is whether or not I should make an order, pursuant to s 144 of the Act, of the kind sought by Mr A. For the reasons I have given, this is not a case where I am persuaded that the facts are such that I should exercise my discretion and make an order of the kind sought by Mr A in his s 144 application.Order I make the following order:1. The Applicant's application for an order pursuant to s 144 of the Anti‑Discrimination Act1991 is dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.