Patterson v State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services)

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:

Patterson v State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services) [2024] QIRC 193

PARTIES:

Patterson, Gail
Appellant

v

State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services)
Respondent

CASE NO:

PSA/2024/47

PROCEEDING:

Application in existing proceedings

DELIVERED ON:

7 August 2024

HEARING DATE: 

Friday, 21 June 2024

MEMBER:

HEARD AT:

Pratt IC

Brisbane

ORDER:

1.     The application is dismissed

CATCHWORDS:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – PUBLIC SECTOR APPEAL – APPLICATION IN EXISTING PROCEEDINGS – where respondent in substantive matter seeks suppression order – where substantive matter is an appeal against a disciplinary decision made against the appellant for conduct towards a prisoner – where respondent seeks suppression of the prisoner’s name – where respondent seeks suppression of materials that it filed with the Commission in the substantive matter – where the material sought to be suppressed includes correspondence between the appellant and the respondent, briefing notes, an investigation report, and camera footage – section 451(2)(c) and 580(5) of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 – consideration of Practice Direction Number 3 of 2023 – Modification of a Document Before Publication and Practice Direction Number 4 of 2023 – Guideline for the Modification of a Document Before Publication -  consideration of legal principles of suppression orders generally – where respondent submits making the suppression order would  be in the public interest because of sensitive nature of the materials – where respondent submits the proposed suppression order does not infringe on open justice principles because the prisoner is not a party to, or witness in, the proceedings – where respondent submits that not making the suppression order may cause harm to the prisoner and may cause the prisoner to lose privacy – where respondent submits that suppression order should be made because camera footage may disclose the layout of the correctional facility – where respondent submits that not making suppression order may lead to unauthorised persons gaining access to procedures and codes of practice – where appellant neither opposes nor supports the suppression order – held that consideration of the substantive matter will require consideration of  all materials – held that submissions relating to safety and privacy of the prisoner amount to an argument that the prisoner will be embarrassed, distressed or lose privacy if the suppression order is not made – held that nothing in training manuals or relevant codes of practice that is particularly sensitive – held that camera footage does not reveal layout of correctional facility or pose risk to security of the facility – application dismissed.

LEGISLATION & OTHER INSTRUMENTS:

CASES:

Corrective Services Act 2006 (Qld) s 341

Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld) s 451, s 580

Industrial Relations (Tribunals) Rules 2011 (Qld), r 97

Practice Direction Number 3 of 2023 – Modification of a Document Before Publication

Practice Direction Number 4 of 2023 – Guideline for the Modification of a Document Before Publication

Public Sector Act 2022 (Qld) s 91, s 130

Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld) s 191

AB v State of Queensland (Department of Education) [2024] QIRC 49

Alderding…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Patterson v State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Servi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QIRC 193
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Patterson v State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services) involved a Correctional Supervisor appealing a disciplinary decision made against her by Corrective Services. The disciplinary action was a result of an incident on 14 January 2023, where the Appellant used a chemical agent on a prisoner during an incident at Brisbane Correctional Centre. Corrective Services found the Appellant guilty of misconduct and demoted her, a decision which she appealed. Corrective Services sought a suppression order to prevent the disclosure of certain materials, including the prisoner’s name, correspondence between the parties, briefing notes, an investigation report, and camera footage.

The legal issues before the court were whether there were compelling reasons to deviate from the principle of open justice and grant the suppression order. The court had to assess whether the materials in question, if disclosed, would cause significant harm or embarrassment to the prisoner, and if so, whether this justified a suppression order. Corrective Services argued that the sensitive nature of the materials, potential harm to the prisoner's privacy, and the risk of unauthorised access to the correctional facility’s layout and security codes warranted a suppression order. The Appellant neither opposed nor supported the suppression order, focusing instead on the substantive appeal.

In its reasoning, the court emphasised the high threshold required to justify a suppression order, noting that mere privacy loss, embarrassment, or distress were insufficient grounds. The court found that the submissions regarding potential harm to the prisoner were speculative and lacked specific evidence. Additionally, the court determined that the camera footage did not reveal sensitive information about the correctional facility’s layout or security. The court concluded that the principle of open justice, which ensures transparency in legal proceedings, was paramount and that the submissions did not sufficiently justify an exception to this principle. Therefore, the application for a suppression order was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is dismissed

Background

Background to the litigation

The Appellant neither opposes nor supports the orders that are sought by Corrective Services.Background The Appellant is a Correctional Supervisor at Brisbane Correctional Centre. After an investigation, Corrective Services determined that on 14 January 2023, at the Brisbane Correctional Centre, the Appellant used force that was not reasonably necessary against the Prisoner by deploying a chemical agent on the Prisoner while the Appellant and other officers restrained and ground stabilised the Prisoner (‘14 January 2023 Incident'). The investigation process that preceded those findings involved the review of body worn camera footage, written statements, incident reports and records of interview from several prison officers who were involved in the relevant incident or who witnessed it. On 26 February 2024, Corrective Services issued the disciplinary decision based on the finding that the Appellant was guilty of misconduct pursuant to section 91(1)(b) of the Public Sector Act 2022 (Qld) ('PS Act'). Corrective Services proposes to discipline the Appellant by demoting her from Correctional Supervisor (GS 3.4) down to a Custodial Correctional Officer (GS 2.4) for a period of 18 months and directing her to undertake specified training ('Decision'). The Appellant, pursuant to s 130 of the PS Act, appeals the demotion part of the Decision. The Appellant's appeal of the Decision is the substantive proceeding to which this application within an existing proceeding relates. On 26 March 2024, I issued orders requiring Corrective Services to file and serve a copy of each relevant document that was before the decision-maker at the time the Decision was made, save for any documents that Corrective Services claimed immunity or privilege over, that are already with the Commission, or that are publicly available. Corrective Services filed material in response to those orders and those materials included ('Materials'):(a)submissions;(b)correspondence between the Corrective Services and the Appellant and the Appellant's then solicitor;(c)various briefing notes in relation to the 14 January 2023 Incident and the investigation of it, including the recommendations to take disciplinary action;(d)an Ethical Standards Group Investigation Report, along with 33 attachments which included:(i) the Code of Conduct for the Queensland Public Service;(ii) the Custodial Operations Practice Directive - Use of Force;(iii) the Queensland Corrective Services Control and Restraint Manual, version 7;(iv) the Queensland Corrective Services Tactical Options Manual, V2-2021;(v) exams and training carried out by the Appellant in relation to the deployment of chemical weapons;(vi) incident reports by Corrective Services Officers involved in or who witnessed the incident;(vii) transcripts of interviews given by Corrective Services Officers involved in or who witnessed the incident; and(e)Body worn camera footage, cell CCTV footage and recordings of interviews of several Corrective Services Officers involved in the incident.Issues

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Appellant is not opposed to the application, nor particularly in favour of it. Understandably, her primary focus is the substantive appeal. Given her significant experience in the field, I asked the appellant to comment on Corrective Services' submissions regarding potential 'standover' by prisoners of a perceived weaker prisoner. The Appellant speculated that it can happen.Consideration In light of the above authorities, and with particular regard to, L & A Services, O'Dempsey, and Aurizon, my task is to assess whether there are any compelling reasons to deviate from the principles of open justice and make the suppression order in the terms sought. Mere loss of privacy, embarrassment, distress, financial harm, or other collateral damage will be insufficient. I am guided by the paramountcy of the principle of open justice as his Honour, Deputy President Merrell, highlighted in Lee, Smith and Viva Energy. I am also guided by the observations of her Honour, Deputy President Hartigan, in Montesin and Edgar regarding the need for specific and convincing evidence in these types of proceedings and of the need to make suppression orders only to the extent that they are necessary. I have also had regard to the numerous other cases relating to suppression orders explored above. As a preliminary matter, I note that in some of the decisions I have discussed above, regard was had to whether the other party consented to the application. The relevant parties’ views are always an important consideration when determining issues put before the Commission. However, the parties’ views do not feature anywhere in the principles guiding the discretion to make suppression orders. The bar is set very high for making out an exception to the open justice principles. That bar is not cleared because those who happen to be involved in the matter do not oppose the suppression sought. On my reading of those decisions that I have referred to, they merely mention in passing that the parties consented. I do not construe those decisions to be saying that party consent had any real influence on whether an exception to the principles of open justice was made out. Application to suppress the Prisoner's name I see no reason why I would need to use the Prisoner’s name in a decision. But I am not persuaded by suggestions that other prisoners might harm him if those prisoners deduced, from gaining access to some of the Materials, that there were mental health issues and formed a view that such health issues constituted weakness. I appreciate that the submission is coming from a place of concern. However, it is no more than speculation. Much of the same can be said about Corrective Services’ submissions concerning the potential impact on the Prisoner’s mental health if he were to read about the 14 January 2023 Incident in a decision. That too is speculation, albeit well-meaning. Corrective Services puts nothing forward proving that there is a real and specific risk of harm. I cannot therefore accept that the Prisoner is exposed to a real risk of harm if the orders sought are not granted.