QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION
CITATION: | Kelsey v Logan City Council and Another (No. 2) [2018] QIRC 017 |
PARTIES: | Kelsey, Sharon v Logan City Council and Smith, Timothy Luke |
CASE NO: | PID/2017/3 |
PROCEEDING: | Application for interim orders |
DELIVERED ON: | 27 February 2018 |
HEARING DATE: | 14 February 2018 |
MEMBER: | Industrial Commissioner Fisher |
| ORDERS: | 1. The orders made on 4 and 20 December 2017 continue in force for a period of 10 days or until such time as the Draft Suppression Order is formally made. 2. Liberty to apply is granted. |
LEGISLATION: | Public Interest Disclosure Act 2010, s 55 Kelsey v Logan City Council and Another [2018] QIRC 009 |
APPEARANCES: | Mr C. Murdoch, QC instructed by Minter Ellison Lawyers for the Applicant. |
Decision
The Applicant filed an application on 1 December 2017 which was amended on 18 December 2017.
On 4 and 20 December 2017 the Commission as constituted made suppression orders under s 55 of the Public Interest Disclosure Act 2010 at the request of the Applicant and without objection from the Respondents.
The hearing of the interim injunction application was held on 25 January 2018 and the Commission's decision in relation to it was released on 1 February 2018. [1] That decision sets out the background and purpose of the application.
On 14 February 2018, the Commission listed a Mention of the application to raise with the parties whether a continuing need existed for the suppression orders. By that time the decision of the First Respondent in respect of the Applicant's employment was public knowledge and two of the parties to the proceedings had conducted media interviews. The Commission expressed the view that in light of those circumstances, the continuation of the suppression orders arguably may not be in the public interest. The parties were invited to make submissions about the issues raised.
At the hearing the Applicant advised that she intended to file and serve a further amended application on the Respondents by 20 February. Following discussion, the parties agreed the further amended application would be served on the Respondents but not filed in the Registry to allow the Commission to make its determination on the suppression orders.
The date for service of 20 February was not achieved but a further amended application has since been served. The Respondents' submissions on the state of the suppression orders were provided in advance of the receipt of the further amended application.
After receiving these submissions, the First Respondent…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Kelsey v Logan City Council (No. 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] QIRC 17
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to determine whether the suppression orders should remain in place or if they should be modified to reflect the changed circumstances. The legal issues included the principles applicable to making suppression orders, as outlined in J. v L. & A. Services Pty Ltd (No. 2), and whether the Commission had the authority to make such orders under the PID Act and the IR Act. The court also considered the public interest in open justice and the need to balance this with the privacy and other interests of the parties involved.
The court found that the Applicant's position on the suppression orders had changed, and that the circumstances present in December 2017, when the suppression orders were made, were different. While the Applicant initially argued for a blanket suppression order due to the sensitive nature of the information, the court considered that no unnecessary restriction on public access was permissible. The court acknowledged that the Commission had the authority to make suppression orders under the PID Act and the IR Act, but also noted that the Commission should balance the privacy interests of the parties with the public interest in open justice. The court concluded that it would be open to the Commission to order the anonymisation of individuals other than the Second Respondent in the PID.
The court ordered that the suppression orders made on 4 and 20 December 2017 continue in force for a period of 10 days or until such time as the Draft Suppression Order is formally made. The court also granted liberty to apply for further orders.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The orders made on 4 and 20 December 2017 continue in force for a period of 10 days or until such time as the Draft Suppression Order is formally made.
2. Liberty to apply is granted.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Applicant takes a more liberal approach. Her view is that no blanket suppression order is required in the circumstances now present on this case, however, it would be open to the Commission to order that the names of the persons other than the Second Respondent referred to in the PID be anonymised where they are named in the PID.Consideration Both the Applicant and the Second Respondent have referred me to the decision of the Queensland Court of Appeal in J. v L. & A. Services Pty Ltd (No. 2)[2] which sets out six principles applicable to making a suppression order. The Applicant specifically references the principle which provides that "no unnecessary restriction upon public access or publicity in respect of court proceedings is permissible" and the following remarks:"… information may not be withheld from the public merely to save a party or witness from loss of privacy, embarrassment, distress, financial harm or other 'collateral disadvantage' … Additionally, when it is the interests of a party or a witness which is relied on as the basis for a proposed restraint, those considerations must be balanced against other factors, including the interests of others involved in the proceeding and others who may be affected."[2] J. v L. & A. Services Pty Ltd (No. 2) [1995] 2 Qd R 10. The Commission, being a creature of statute, has no inherent power to prohibit publication, release or search of evidence or records.[3] The power to do those things is found in s 580 of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 and s 55 of the PID Act. I should also note that in Mayne Logistics Armaguard v Cochrane,[4] Hall P considered the effect of s 679(8) of the Industrial Relations Act 1999 (the predecessor provision to s 580 of the IR Act) in terms of other statutory obligations on the Commission when exercising its powers or carrying out its functions. While Hall P considered that s 679(8) imported the notion that justice should be public, the joint operation of several other sections meant that the Commission should also have regard to other considerations in determining how best to meet the public interest in a particular case. The IR Act provisions are relevant as the amended application is being prosecuted both under two Acts as it concerns reprisal under the PID Act and adverse action under the IR Act.[3] QNU v QCCI (2000) 165 QGIG 131, 131.[4] Mayne Logistics Armaguard v Cochrane (2003) QGIG 1139, 1140-1141. When the Commission made the suppression orders in December 2017 the circumstances were different to the present. At that stage the Applicant was an employee of the First Respondent and her application, amended application and affidavits canvassed certain conduct of the Second Respondent in connection with her employment, the reason she made the PID as well as other matters. The PID was attached to the Applicant's affidavit. The Commission accepted the Applicant's submissions that such matters were sensitive and may result in prejudice for the parties and employees of the First Respondent if the information referred to in the affidavits or attached to them was made public prior to the CCC investigation. The Applicant's position on the suppression orders has clearly changed.