Mitchell Ogilvie Menswear Pty Ltd v Rapid Edge Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Mitchell Ogilvie Menswear Pty Ltd v Rapid Edge Pty Ltd [2019] QSC 136

PARTIES:

MITCHELL OGILVIE MENSWEAR PTY LTD
ACN 010 162 222

(plaintiff)

v
RAPID EDGE PTY LTD
ACN 120 248 968

(defendant)

FILE NO:

2178 of 2014

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Claim

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

31 May 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

20, 21 and 22 May 2019

JUDGE:

Applegarth J

ORDERS:

Judgment for the plaintiff for:

(a)    damages in the sum of $1,278,708;

(b)    interest thereon from 29 September 2010 to 31 May 2019 in the sum of $795,799

CATCHWORDS:

DAMAGES – MEASURE AND REMOTENESS OF DAMAGES IN ACTIONS FOR TORT – DAMAGE TO CHATTELS – where suits and other items were damaged by smoke and soot from a fire in a basement tenancy close to the plaintiff’s menswear store – where the defendant admits liability in tort for property damage or economic loss caused to the plaintiff as a result of the fire - where the plaintiff claims the diminution in the wholesale value of the stock – whether the plaintiff’s proposed measure of damages is appropriate - whether the salvage value of the stock contended for by the plaintiff is established

Civil Proceedings Act 2011 (Qld), s 58

Boland v Yates Property Corporation Pty Ltd (1999) 167 ALR 575; [1999] HCA 64, cited
British Westinghouse Electric & Manufacturing Co Ltd v Underground Electric Railways Co of London Ltd (No 2)
[1912] AC 673, cited
Cerutti v Crestside Pty Ltd [2016] 1 Qd R 89; [2014] QCA 33, cited
Davidson v J S Gilbert Fabrications Pty Ltd [1986] 1 Qd R 1, cited
Franke v CIC General Insurance Ltd (1994) 33 NSWLR 373, cited
Hadzigeorgiou v O’Sullivan [1983] 1 Qd R 55, cited
Interchase Corporation Ltd v Grosvenor Hill (Qld) Pty Ltd (No 3) [2003] 1 Qd R 26; [2001] QCA 191, cited
Johnson v Perez (1988) 166 CLR 351; [1988] HCA 64, cited
Keeley v Horton [2016] QCA 253, cited
Koch Marine Inc v D’Amica Societa di Navigazione ARL (The Elena d’Amico) [1980] 1 Lloyd’s Rep. 75, cited
Payton v Brooks [1974] RTR 169, cited
Ruthol Pty Ltd v Tricon (Australia) Pty Ltd [2005] NSWCA 443, cited
Spencer v The Commonwealth (1907) 5 CLR 418, cited
Westpac Banking Corporation v Jamieson [2016] 1 Qd R 495; [2015] QCA 50, cited

COUNSEL:

C C Heyworth-Smith QC and S M McNeil for the plaintiff

J B Sweeney and K J Horsley for the defendant

SOLICITORS:

Hall & Wilcox for the plaintiff

Carter Newell Lawyers for the defendant

  1. The essential issue in contest is the salvage value of suits and other items that were affected by smoke and soot from a fire which started in a basement tenancy, close to the plaintiff’s menswear store.  The smoke and soot that entered the plaintiff’s tenancy damaged most of the store’s stock as well as fittings, furniture and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mitchell Ogilvie Menswear Pty Ltd v Rapid Edge Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QSC 136
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Mitchell Ogilvie Menswear Pty Ltd v Rapid Edge Pty Ltd involved a dispute between the plaintiff, a luxury menswear store, and the defendant, a company that caused a fire in a basement tenancy. The fire resulted in smoke and soot damage to the plaintiff's stock and store. The defendant admitted liability for the damage caused by the fire but contested the plaintiff's proposed measure of damages. The plaintiff sought compensation for the diminution in the wholesale value of the stock, while the defendant argued for an alternative measure. The court was required to determine the appropriate measure of damages for the plaintiff's loss and whether the salvage value of the stock contended by the plaintiff was established.

The court concluded that the measure of damages proposed by the plaintiff, which was acknowledged to be the normal measure, should not be departed from. The court found that the salvage value of the property, assessed by reference to the price that would be paid in such a transaction in early October 2010, was the best evidence available of the value of the salvaged stock. The court rejected the defendant's submission that a figure of $325,000 as the post-fire value of the stock would be appropriate. The negotiated price of $225,000 was $30,000 more than the price guaranteed by the plaintiff's expert, and the insurer was not willing to take the risk of achieving a higher sale price. The court found that the plaintiff's proposed measure of damages was an appropriate one in the circumstances.

The court awarded judgment for the plaintiff for damages in the sum of $1,278,708 and interest thereon from 29 September 2010 to 31 May 2019 in the sum of $795,799. This decision highlights the importance of considering the appropriate measure of damages in cases of property damage and the need for evidence to support the value of salvaged stock in such cases.

Orders

Orders of the court

Judgment for the plaintiff for:

(a) damages in the sum of $1,278,708;

(b) interest thereon from 29 September 2010 to 31 May 2019 in the sum of $795,799

Background

Background to the litigation

The defendant has not persuaded me that the measure of damages proposed by the plaintiff, which is acknowledged to be the normal measure, should be departed from. I conclude that the measure of damages proposed by the plaintiff is an appropriate one in the circumstances.The facts in more detail The plaintiff’s business, Mitchell Ogilvie Menswear, was established by Mr Ogilvie in 1981. It stocks luxury Italian suits and business shirts, made-to-measure luxury suits, everyday business attire as well as casual wear and high‑end accessories. In 2010, the retail store was located at 190 Edward Street. The fire which originated on 29 September 2010 in a vacuum cleaner in the basement tenancy of a jewellery business caused soot and smoke to enter into the plaintiff’s store. It had wood grain wall panelling, parquetry flooring, wool carpets and decorative lighting throughout. Most of the stock was hanging on display. There was some stock folded on tables and shelves throughout the store, with a small amount of stock behind glass cabinets or in cupboards or drawers. The fire caused a fine layer of soot to cover most, if not all, of the clothing stock in the store, the store fit out, floor coverings, horizontal surfaces (shop counters, cabinetry and display tables), and even in drawers. The store and its contents had a strong smoke odour. The soot fell predominantly on horizontal surfaces, as it fell from the ceiling once it cooled. The soot had a greasy residue, which is caused by synthetics burning. It appeared on clothing to be a grey film, but when touched, the soot left a black mark on a person’s skin. There was a pungent smoke odour throughout the premises after the fire. The clothing stock had a smoke odour, caused by soot particles impregnating the stock. This occurs when the room pressurises and fills with smoke, which envelopes the items and enters the weaving of the fabric. At the time of the fire, the plaintiff had a Commercial Special Risks policy of insurance with Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd. The policy insured the stock in the store. The plaintiff made a claim on that policy and Allianz engaged Cunningham Lindsey loss adjusters to assess the property damage at the store. Mr Hanlon of Cunningham Lindsey then engaged CIRiS Commercial Industrial Restoration Insurance Services (“Ciris”), a business which supplied commercial decontamination and restoration services. On and from 30 September 2010, Mr Haynes of Ciris began to project manage the restoration works (being the cleaning and decontamination) of the store and stock. Mr Ogilvie wanted to get his business operational as quickly as possible, and Mr Hanlon gave Mr Haynes authority to commence work as quickly as possible. They discussed the potential restoration of the stock against the replacement of the stock and the possibility of dry-cleaning the garments. Mr Haynes expressed the view that: (a)the soot as well as odour which impregnates into the fabric of the material would need to be dealt with; (b)the only way to remove the odour was dry-cleaning (to remove all carbon residue from within the clothing materials).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The salvage value of the property in question in this case, assessed by reference to the price that would be paid in such a transaction in early October 2010, should not be confused with a different price from a different kind of transaction. It should not be confused with, for example:(a)the prices which an auctioneer might obtain from members of the public at an auction at some later date (less sales costs) together with the value of the residue of stock that could not be sold at auction; or(b)the prices a hypothetical retailer, having purchased all of the salvaged stock, might achieve in selling at an established retail store, or at a “pop up store” for fire damaged stock, over some period of time (less sale costs), together with the value of the residue of unsold stock; or(c)the prices that the plaintiff in fact achieved in selling the fire damaged stock at a “fire sale” in October/November 2010 and in subsequent sales in 2011.The evidence relied upon by the plaintiff The plaintiff places particular reliance in its case about the value of the salvaged stock as at October 2010 upon the expert evidence of Mr Webber and the view formed by three commercial entities at the time (an experienced auctioneer and valuer, a commercial insurer and the plaintiff) about what the stock was worth. Particular reliance is placed upon:(a)the plaintiff’s original offer to purchase the salvaged stock for $150,000 to $200,000;(b)Mr Webber’s assessment of its value and the range from $220,000 (gross) to $450,000 (gross) which he thought the stock might achieve at an auction conducted by his organisation;(c)the minimum auction guarantee of $195,000 offered to the insurer;(d)the plaintiff’s offer of $225,000; and(e)the insurer’s acceptance of this offer. The relevant market for the sale of fire damaged suits and other stock is entirely different to the market for sale of new suits to retailers or consumers. There is not the same “established market” or “readily identifiable market”.[16] However, there is a market for the sale of damaged stock of high quality clothing brands, and Mr Webber of Lloyds Auctioneers and Valuers has considerable experience in the valuation and sale of damaged stock. This includes the salvage sale of suits. When consulted in October 2010 by the loss adjuster, Mr Hanlon, Mr Webber recommended conducting a well-advertised public auction where all of the stock would be auctioned at Lloyds’ premises at Carrara. He outlined a marketing program and its cost, together with a commission structure whereby Lloyds would receive 12.5 per cent up to $210,000, and 22 per cent thereafter. This commission structure was one that placed the risk that the stock would sell for less than $220,000 upon Lloyds, given its minimum net return guarantee of $195,000.[16] Boland at 595 [79]. Mr Webber’s proposal of 7 October 2010 gave an estimate of realisation at the proposed auction of between $220,000 and $450,000. His expert report and affidavit explained that, based on his experience and his inspection of the stock, an appropriate estimate of the realisation of the pre-damaged retail value for the damaged stock was between five and ten cents to the dollar. He explained in his evidence, persuasively, that his figures took into account that the customer base that would be interested in a smoke or soot damaged suit were not the plaintiff’s usual customers. The market to buy the damaged suits would be people who were expecting to pay very low prices for the damagedhigh-end stock. Mr Webber gave oral evidence, which I accept, about his inspection of the relevant stock.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In addition to matters relating to the assumptions and data upon which Mr Haley’s analysis and opinion is based, there is a significant issue concerning the methodology by which he ventures opinions about the wholesale value of the damaged stock. In essence, his approach, on the basis of incomplete data, is to attempt to determine a loss of gross profit margin, either by reference to a period of 12 or 15 months or by reference to some shorter period. This is done by attempting to determine what the stock sold for, arriving at a figure for the loss of gross profit and then applying that per centage loss to the wholesale value. This proceeds on the basis that the ultimate sale price is relevant to determining the loss of wholesale value. Mr Box correctly questions the correctness of an assumption that the per centage loss of wholesale value of stock would be the same as the per centage loss of receipt upon sale. Most importantly, as previously discussed, such an approach does not take into account the risks as to the price the damaged stock could be realised for in the immediate aftermath of the fire. It does not take into account the then unknown, adverse consequences of selling fire damaged stock on the plaintiff’s normal trade, goodwill and reputation. In early October 2010 a person in the plaintiff’s position would expect a large discount on the normal wholesale value of the relevant stock in order to take these unknown and unpredictable risks.Conclusion on salvage value The arm’s-length transaction between the plaintiff and its insurer in relation to the actual subject matter to be valued, being a transaction which occurred at the time which is relevant for the assessment of loss, is the best evidence available of the value of the salvaged stock. This conclusion does not depend upon whether the transaction is characterised as one in which title to the salvaged goods passed to the insurer and was immediately transferred back to the plaintiff for $225,000, or one in which the plaintiff’s insurance claim was settled on the basis that the plaintiff could retain the salvaged stock with an adjustment of $225,000 to the insurance payout on account of its value. The defendant’s submission that a figure of $325,000 as the post-fire value of the stock would be appropriate is not supported by the evidence. The fact that that figure falls within the range given by Mr Webber is an insufficient justification. That range relates to the sale price which might be expected at a Lloyds’ auction before deduction of sale costs and commission. To achieve a net return of $325,000 would require total auction sales to gross at the top of that range. Moreover, the submission begs the question as to why the insurer, with the advice available to it from experienced adjusters, auctioneers and valuers, was prepared to accept a figure of $225,000, rather than take its chances that Lloyds’ auction might achieve gross sales of more than $275,000. The answer would appear to be that the insurer was not willing to take that risk. The negotiated price of $225,000 was $30,000 more than the price guaranteed by Mr Webber.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Not all of the damaged stock was sold during the fire sale. The leftover stock was put away in the storeroom to be brought out during the next sale in January/February 2011. When the stock was brought out at the end of season sale period it remained at fire sale prices. Customers were told it was fire damaged stock.Operation of the business after the fire sale Sales after the fire sale were not as strong as usual, as some customers’ suiting needs had already been met. This was particularly the case with the January/February 2011 end of season sale. After the fire the business had a reduced amount of stock. However, new stock which had been ordered before the fire began to arrive from 1 October 2010. Over time, stock levels built up again. Between the date of the fire and 21 December 2010, the plaintiff received deliveries of new stock (which had already been ordered) in store which had a wholesale value of $511,256.90. There was also stock undamaged by soot and smoke available for sale at this time, with a wholesale value of $184,376. Consequently, by around January 2011, the wholesale value of brand new stock available for sale in the store was approximately $695,632. The business continued to trade throughout 2011. By the end of that year, arrangements were in place for the store to move premises. In October 2011 a moving sale was held. A significant amount, if not all, of the fire damaged stock had been sold or disposed of before the move.Business records and the inability to accurately assess the sale price of salvaged stock The plaintiff’s employees included an operations manager, a stock manager (Ms Braadvedt) and a bookkeeper. In 2010, another employee, Ms Guyatt, created monthly MYOB reports and spreadsheets based on data that had been entered by the stock manager and reconciled the business accounts. The MYOB reports then were used to create the business’ annual financial returns. The data entered by the bookkeeper, which Ms Guyatt accessed, was entered into a system called “ICAD”. “Swingtag” is effectively the next model of ICAD. This program has been used by the plaintiff since 2008. In 2010, when stock arrived at the business, it was Ms Braatvedt’s responsibility to enter information about the new stock into Swingtag. The process she followed was as follows:· With the invoice received with the stock, determine the cost price which may include calculating an exchange rate from Euro or USD to Australian dollars;· Factor in if the plaintiff received a discount;· Add Duty, GST and freight charges;· Then calculate the retail price of the stock and enter all information into the Swingtag system. In addition to determining the above costs and retail price of an item of stock, Ms Braatvedt was responsible for entering further information about a stock item into Swingtag, as well as the database holding additional information about the items, which included:· An SKU identification number;· A description of the item, including design, colour and size;· How many of the item there were;· The date the item arrived into the shop, and if the item was sold, the date it sold; and· Information about who it was sold to, and any discounts given.