Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Ly

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Ly [2018] FCAFC 123

Appeal from: Ly v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2018] FCCA 409
File number: NSD 541 of 2018
Judges: RARES, ROBERTSON AND FARRELL JJ
Date of judgment: 8 August 2018
Catchwords: MIGRATION – appeal from Federal Circuit Court of Australia – judicial review by that Court of decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal decision refusing prospective marriage visas – Tribunal noting review applicant had not provided evidence of hotel stays in Cambodia with her intended spouse – hotel receipts subsequently provided – Tribunal finding that although receipts were dated different years they appeared to be in the same handwriting and doubting genuineness of the receipts and giving little weight to them – whether genuineness of the receipts was an issue that should have been raised with review applicant either pursuant to s 360 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) or by virtue of procedural fairness under the general law
Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth) s 360
Cases cited:

Commissioner for ACT Revenue v Alphaone Pty Ltd [1994] FCA 1074; 49 FCR 576

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v CZBP [2014] FCAFC 105

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZGUR [2011] HCA 1; 241 CLR 594

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZKTI [2009] HCA 30; 238 CLR 489

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZMOK [2009] FCAFC 83; 247 FCR 404

SZBEL v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2006] HCA 63; 228 CLR 152

WAJR v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCA 106; 204 ALR 624

Date of hearing: 8 August 2018
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 53
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr G Johnson SC with Mr T Reilly
Solicitor for the Appellant: Mills Oakley
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr DA Hughes with Ms R Thrift
Solicitor for the First Respondent: D’Ambra Murphy Lawyers

ORDERS

NSD 541 of 2018
BETWEEN:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION

Appellant

AND:

MEI LY

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

JUDGES:

RARES, ROBERTSON AND FARRELL JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

8 AUGUST 2018

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be dismissed, with costs.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

THE COURT:

Introduction

  1. This appeal involves a single ground which is whether the judge of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia erred in concluding that the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal) was affected by jurisdictional error on the basis of a denial of procedural fairness.

  2. The primary judge allowed an application for review of a decision of the Tribunal made on 14 November 2016 refusing the visa applicants Prospective Marriage (Temporary) (Class TO) visas.

  3. The ground of appeal is as follows:

    1.The Honourable Federal Circuit Court Judge erred at…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Ly and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCAFC 123
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the court was asked to review a decision made by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) that refused to grant prospective marriage visas to the applicants. The applicants, Mei Ly and her intended spouse along with his three children, were seeking to enter Australia for the purpose of marriage. The AAT had raised concerns about the genuineness of hotel receipts provided by Ly, which were meant to corroborate her claims of having stayed with her intended spouse in Cambodia. The Federal Circuit Court had upheld the AAT’s decision, and Ly appealed that decision to the Federal Court. The key legal issue in this case was whether the AAT was required to invite Ly's comment on the veracity of the hotel receipts submitted after the hearing, and if the failure to do so constituted a jurisdictional error. The court found that the AAT was indeed required to invite Ly's comment on the hotel receipts, as the Tribunal had doubts about their genuineness based on the fact that the receipts were dated different years but appeared to be in the same handwriting. This raised the implication that the receipts might have been concocted for the purpose of the application. The court held that procedural fairness required an opportunity to be given to Ly to comment on the genuineness of the receipts. Since the AAT failed to do so, it fell into jurisdictional error, which was significant enough to affect the outcome of the case. The appeal was dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed, with costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The ground of appeal is as follows:1.The Honourable Federal Circuit Court Judge erred at [44] in concluding that the Tribunal was required to invite the review applicant’s comment on the veracity of hotel receipts submitted after the hearing.Particulars:The hotel receipts did not raise a new issue in the review, and procedural fairness did not require that the Tribunal give its preliminary views about them to the review applicant, or invite comment from the review applicant about such preliminary views, before giving them little weight (at [115]).Background Before the Tribunal, the present first respondent, Ms Mei Ly, was the review applicant. (We shall refer to her as the review applicant.) There were four visa applicants, being her intended spouse (the visa applicant) and three of his children. The primary judge set out the following chronology. The review applicant made an application for review to the Tribunal on 6 March 2015. On 11 March 2016, the Tribunal invited the review applicant to attend a hearing scheduled for 18 May 2016. On 9 May 2016, the review applicant provided further documentary evidence and a completed Response to Hearing Invitation form. The review applicant, her representative, the visa applicant and witnesses attended a hearing before the Tribunal on 18 May 2016. During the hearing, the Tribunal enquired whether certain corroborating material existed. In particular, the Tribunal asked if hotel receipts existed to corroborate the review applicant’s claims that she and the visa applicant had stayed together at a hotel. The review applicant stated that she had the receipts. After the hearing, on 26 May 2016, the review applicant provided, amongst other documents, further documents relating to holidays that she and the visa applicant had taken, including receipts for hotel accommodation. More particularly, under cover of the letter dated 26 May 2016 by the review applicant’s solicitor there was provided to the Tribunal receipts for the Asia Hotel in the years 2010, 2012, 2013, 2014 and 2015 in the joint names of the visa applicant and the review applicant. In that letter it was stated that in their evidence the review applicant and the visa applicant said they had stayed at the Asia Hotel together and the receipts were provided as corroboration of that. It was said that the receipts being in joint names was further confirmation they stayed together in the hotel as a couple and presented as such. On 30 August 2016, the Tribunal sent a letter to the review applicant inviting her to comment on or respond to information purportedly pursuant to s 359A of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). No mention was made of the hotel receipts. That is, that letter did not say anything about the receipts for the Asia Hotel provided by the review applicant’s solicitor on 26 May 2016. The review applicant responded to the Tribunal’s 30 August 2016 letter on 23 September 2016 together with further supporting documents. On 14 November 2016, the Tribunal affirmed the decision of a delegate of the Minister not to grant prospective marriage visas to the visa applicants. The Tribunal’s reasons

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

At [122], the Tribunal said that it was not satisfied that the visa applicant and the review applicant had stayed together at the hotels in Cambodia, in part “because of the concerns the Tribunal has about the genuineness of the hotel receipts from Asia Hotel.”The primary judgment At [36] and following, the primary judge reasoned as follows (omitting citations):36.… First, this is not a case where Ms Ly’s credibility was so gravely damaged prior to the submission of the documents in issue that they could not have made any difference to the outcome. The Tribunal made clear at its hearing that it was concerned that Ms Ly had not provided any documentary evidence of her asserted hotel stays in Cambodia. The Tribunal’s concern was repeated several times. 37.At [87] the Tribunal states that it provided additional time for further evidence and submissions to be made. The Tribunal notes at [89] that hotel receipts for the Asia hotel in Phnom Penh for various dates were provided. The Tribunal further notes at [92] that it wrote to Ms Ly on 30 August 2016 to invite comment on what the Tribunal saw as inconsistencies in the evidence, including oral evidence given by Ms Ly and the visa applicant about the asserted hotel stays.…39.It is clear from the Tribunal’s reasons that it had a number of concerns about the asserted relationship between Ms Ly and the visa applicant. The question of whether Ms Ly and the visa applicant stayed together at a hotel in Cambodia on particular dates need not logically have assumed particular significance in view of the Tribunal’s other concerns. However, the Tribunal gave that issue particular significance. …40.By that reasoning, the Tribunal elevated to the status of important issues in the review, the inconsistencies in the evidence between Ms Ly and the visa applicant about the asserted hotel stays and the genuineness of the hotel receipts provided by Ms Ly. Having elevated those two issues to the status of important issues in the review, procedural fairness (either under s.360 or the general law) required the Tribunal to invite comment on those issues. 41.The Tribunal did invite comment in its letter dated 30 August 2016 on the issue of the inconsistent evidence. It appears from that letter that the Tribunal proceeded on the basis that the letter was required by reason of s.359A of the Migration Act. It would follow, by extension of that reasoning, that the Tribunal may have laboured under the misapprehension that nothing was required in relation to the authenticity of the hotel receipts because those were documents provided by Ms Ly to the Tribunal. However, it is in my view highly doubtful that s.359A of the Migration Act required the written invitation to comment in relation to the inconsistent oral evidence. That is because inconsistencies in evidence are not in themselves information for the purposes of s.359A. 42.In my opinion, either s.360 or the general law required the invitation to comment on the inconsistencies rather than s.359A. I am fortified in that view by the reasons of the Full Federal Court in Minister for Immigration v SZMOK at [65].43.In the present case, it was not a jurisdictional error by the Tribunal to apply the wrong statutory provision in sending the letter. The error arises because the Tribunal confined its invitation to comment too narrowly. The difficulty is that while procedural fairness required an invitation to comment or respond to the two issues identified by the Tribunal at [122] (the inconsistent oral evidence and the dubious hotel receipts), the Tribunal’s letter of 30 August 2016 only dealt with the first issue. It needed to deal with both. It did not. The failure of the Tribunal to raise with Ms Ly the issue of the veracity of the hotel receipts goes to jurisdiction, given the significance of that issue to the Tribunal. It follows that the Tribunal fell into jurisdictional error by failing to raise the issue with Ms Ly.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Further, the issue of obviousness was not raised by the appellant in the Court below. This was of significance because the documents were in fact provided to the Tribunal in colour. One could see that the receipts from 2010 and 2012 were blue, and the later receipts were in brown, and on a slightly different form. These were not issues agitated before the primary judge, and affected the question of obviousness.Consideration A matter which appears to be in dispute is whether the Tribunal doubted that the receipts were genuine. In our view it is clear that the Tribunal did make that finding at [115] and for that reason placed little weight on the receipts: see also [122] of the Tribunal’s reasons. More importantly, the Tribunal doubted that the receipts were genuine at least in part, if not wholly, because they were dated different years but appeared to be in the same handwriting. In our opinion this is the same as the point dealt with by French J in WAJR at [56], where his Honour distinguished between a mere lack of satisfaction about the reliability or genuineness of particular documents, on the one hand, and where, on the other hand, there was a clear implication in the Tribunal’s reasoning by reference to the appearance of the documents that they were concocted. His Honour said:[56] It may be that procedural fairness would not require the Tribunal to invite comment prior to finding no more than that it was not satisfied about the reliability or genuineness of particular documents. But where as here, there is a clear implication in the Tribunal’s reasoning by reference to the appearance of the documents, that they were concocted for the purposes of the application, then on the authorities I have referred to, procedural fairness would require an opportunity be given to the appellant to comment. I took a similar approach in WAGU v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCA 912. In Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v CZBP [2014] FCAFC 105 at [103] the Full Court cited this paragraph with approval. In our opinion, the submission on behalf of the Minister that the review applicant ought already to have been aware from what had been said by the delegate and by the Tribunal during the hearing that there was an issue about whether the review applicant and the visa applicant had stayed together in hotels, and that the Tribunal was interested in receipts or supporting evidence in relation to that question, highlights the problem rather than resolving it. We understand it to be common ground that the Tribunal regarded the receipts as important. We do not accept the Minister’s submission that it was obvious from the Asia Hotel receipts that an issue may arise whether the various receipts were contemporaneous as at the dates that they bore, or worthy of persuasive weight, when they were in the same hand and were only produced to a decision-maker after the hearing. As we have indicated, any issue as to the genuineness that the Tribunal had in mind from the appearance of the hotel receipts supports, if not requires, the need for that matter to be brought to the attention of the review applicant. Presumably the Tribunal’s thinking was that the visa applicant had readily to hand blank printed receipts from the Asia Hotel, in different colours and different typefaces over the years 2010 and 2012 as compared to 2013, 2014 and 2015 and different email addresses for the hotel which she could readily fill in, together with her apparent signature and the apparent signature of the visa applicant. This confirms, in our opinion, that the Tribunal should have given the review applicant an opportunity to be heard as to the genuineness of the receipts on the basis that, although dated different years and in different printed formats, they appeared to be completed in the same handwriting.