Aze18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

AZE18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] FedCFamC2G 1097

File number: MLG 528 of 2018
Judgment of: JUDGE FORBES
Date of judgment: 1 December 2023
Catchwords: MIGRATION – protection visa – judicial review of decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal – country information regarding prevalence of counterfeit documents - implicit finding that critical document was counterfeit or fraudulent – whether Tribunal should have invited applicant to comment prior to finding that document had little weight – where potential finding not put to applicant – whether Tribunal overlooked or failed to consider relevant material probative of applicant’s claim of detention – whether Tribunal overlooked translated video footage – whether Tribunal in as good a position as witness to identify the applicant – whether Tribunal’s evaluation of evidence irrational or illogical – Tribunal’s assessment of applicant’s credit – error identified
Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth) s 36, 65 and 425
Cases cited:

ABT17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection & anor (2020) 383 ALR 407

AVQ15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2018) 266 FCR 83

BEL16 v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCA 1678

BHY17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2022] FCA 1146

BWO19v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2020] FCAFC 181

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Ly & Anor [2018] FCAFC 123

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZMTA (2019) [2019] HCA 3

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZSRS (2014) 309 ALR 67

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v WZARH [2015] HCA 40

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZJSS [2010] HCA 48

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZMDS [2010] HCA 16

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZRKT (2013) 212 FCR 99

MZYTS v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2013) 230 FCR 431

National Disability Insurance Agency v WRMFI (2020) 276 FCR 415

Plaintiff M1/2021 v Minister for Home Affairs [2022] HCA 17

Revenue, Commissioner for Australian Capital Territory v Alphaone Pty Ltd [1994] FCA 293

SZLPH v Minister for Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 145

Viane v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 116

WACO v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCAFC 171

WAEE v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2003) 236 FCR 593

WAJR v The Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and Indigenous Affairs [2004] 204 ALR 624

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 117
Date of hearing: 7 November 2022
Place: Melbourne
Counsel for the Applicant: Ms Hamzi
Solicitor for the Applicant: Holding Redlich
Counsel for the First Respondent: Ms Amamoo
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Australian Government Solicitor

ORDERS

MLG 528 of 2018

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

AZE18

Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE FORBES

DATE OF ORDER:

1 DECEMBER 2023

THE…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Aze18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultu... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FedCFamC2G 1097
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Aze18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs involved a judicial review of a decision made by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) concerning the applicant's application for a protection visa. The applicant, an Iraqi citizen, claimed that he faced persecution in Iraq due to his Sunni Muslim faith, his membership of a particular social group, and his political opinions. A key element of his application was a Court Statement which he alleged documented his detention by Shi'a militias for two years. The AAT upheld the delegate's decision to refuse the visa, finding the applicant's claims lacked credibility.

The legal issues before the court were multifaceted. Firstly, whether the Tribunal should have invited the applicant to comment on the potential finding that the Court Statement was counterfeit or fraudulent, given that the Tribunal had inferred such a finding based on country information indicating the prevalence of counterfeit documents in Iraq. Secondly, whether the Tribunal overlooked or failed to consider material that could support the applicant's claim of detention, specifically translated video footage and statutory declarations identifying the applicant in the footage. Thirdly, whether the Tribunal's evaluation of the evidence was irrational or illogical, particularly in light of its assessment of the applicant's credibility.

The court found that the Tribunal had indeed made an implicit finding that the Court Statement was counterfeit or fraudulent, a highly prejudicial conclusion that the applicant should have been given an opportunity to comment on. The Tribunal's concern, based on country information about the prevalence of counterfeit documents, necessitated an invitation for the applicant to address this concern. Furthermore, the court determined that the Tribunal had failed to adequately consider evidence that could corroborate the applicant's claims, including translated video footage and statutory declarations identifying the applicant in the footage. The Tribunal's assessment of the applicant's credibility was found to be flawed, leading to an irrational or illogical evaluation of the evidence.

In conclusion, the court quashed the AAT's decision and remitted the matter to a differently constituted Tribunal to be determined according to law. The Minister was ordered to pay the applicant's costs. The court's decision highlights the importance of procedural fairness in migration cases, particularly when dealing with critical documentary evidence and the credibility of the applicant.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The decision of the Tribunal made on 6 February 2018 should be quashed and the application remitted to a differently constituted Tribunal to be determined according to law. It is appropriate that the Minister pay the applicant’s costs.BACKGROUND Unless otherwise stated, the following matters are uncontroversial or not contested. The applicant was born in Baghdad, Iraq and identifies as a Sunni Muslim. He is an Iraqi citizen and arrived in Australia on 18 November 2012 on a student visa. The applicant is currently 34 years old. On 7 July 2014, the applicant applied for a protection (Class XA) visa with the assistance of a migration agent. He claimed that he feared that he “would be murdered if [he] returned to Iraq for the reason of [his] religion, [his] membership of particular social group and [his] real and imputed political opinion[1]”. Relevantly, the applicant claimed that in Iraq he had been “held for 2.2 years in detention” in an “unknown address”[2]. [1] As summarised in the Applicant’s Outline of Submission at [4]; Court Book (CB) 41 at [18][2] Applicant’s Visa Application CB 41 at [18] The applicant provided a statement of claims alongside his protection visa application. The further detail of his claims may be summarised as follows[3]:(1)Prior to the invasion of Iraq in 2003, the applicant and his family were living happily. His mother worked for the Iraqi Government and, after his father was killed in the First Gulf war in 1991, the family received his father’s pension. Following the US invasion of Iraq, and the rise to power of a Shi’a government, the applicant’s mother lost her job as she was perceived to be a Ba’athist, and the family stopped receiving his late father’s pension. His older siblings were unable to enrol at university.(2)The applicant continued going to school and was supported by his siblings and two uncles. However, his uncles were respectively killed in 2006 and 2009 on account of being Sunni.(3)The applicant stopped going to school in 2006 due to ongoing threats and house searches. In 2007, his siblings escaped to Syria for their safety, but he stayed with his mother because he was young.(4)The applicant stated that in 2007, when he was 17, armed men raided his family home, searched the house, beat him and abused his mother, and then detained him. The applicant says he was accused of supporting terrorism and ultimately held in a juvenile detention centre in Baghdad “with a number of other young Sunni people”. His family were not allowed to visit him, and he was subjected to torture and mistreatment. After nearly two years in detention, the applicant was brought before a judge. The accusations against him were dropped, and, after a further two months, the applicant was released.(5)Following his release from custody, the applicant claims to have moved to Maysan Governorate in Southern Iraq where he found work with a construction company and pretended to be Shi’a to avoid harm. After one year, and having saved some money, he moved back to Baghdad and tried to return to school. He was over 18 at this point and therefore, in order to be permitted to re-enrol at school, he obtained a letter from the Iraqi Court confirming that he had been detained for two years. The applicant was permitted to re-enrol school following which he completed high school and began studying civil engineering at Baghdad University.(6)The applicant was awarded a scholarship to study in Australia, on the assurance that he would return to Iraq.(7)The applicant stated that while he was optimistic about returning to Iraq, following the 2014 election and ISIS’ seizure of Mosul, the Shi’a Iraqi Government began seeking revenge against Sunnis. Sectarian violence also increased. At one point, his older brother was kidnapped from the family home by armed men, who said they would be coming back to take the Applicant too. The applicant’s mother informed the men that the applicant was in Australia, to which they replied that they would “know” if the applicant returned.[3] Applicant’s Outline of Submission at [5]

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Further, the Minister submits that pursuant to section 425 of the Act, the applicant always knew that the genuineness of the Court Statement was in issue. The Minister says that the decision of the delegate[45] already put the applicant on notice about the nature of the concerns about the document and the applicant had been afforded an opportunity address those concerns in the pre-hearing submission.[45] CB 163Conclusion In my view, fairly read in the context of the reasons as a whole, paragraph [62] of the reasons reveals an implicit finding by the Tribunal that the Court Statement was counterfeit or the product of fraud. It is a highly prejudicial finding about which the applicant should have been put on notice and afforded the opportunity to comment. The paragraph is introduced by, and the Tribunal’s finding is substantially based on, the country information which notes that counterfeit or fraudulently altered/obtained documents are commonly and cheaply available. The country information suggests that there is a high prevalence of counterfeit documents in Iraq. The words of the Tribunal decision at [62] infer that the Court Statement on which the applicant relied was regarded by the Tribunal as a document of the type that fell within the class of documents about which the country information cautioned. The country information and the Tribunal’s decision not to lend weight to the Court Statement are inseparably linked and the connection between the two is conscious. I agree with the applicant that the Tribunal’s concern that the document might be fraudulent should have triggered an invitation to the applicant to comment. A finding or even a high suspicion of fraud or forgery, express or implied, is highly prejudicial and should not be made lightly. In the circumstances of this case, where the applicant’s period of detention was central to his claims for protection, any concern about the genuineness of documentary evidence which served to corroborate his claim should have been brought to the applicant’s attention for comment. I do not accept that the applicant was adequately on notice regarding the possibility of the finding that was made. Nor do I accept that the Tribunal was merely “not satisfied about the reliability or genuineness” of the Court Statement, such that it should be regarded as falling into the first categories of Justice French’s descriptors in WAJR. The Tribunal introduced the country information in its reasoning as a basis for not giving the document weight. Even if it was not the sole basis, it was certainly a substantive and operative factor in the reasoning process. Mention of the country information was not a mere passing observation. This was a different basis and level of concern to that expressed by the delegate and it does in my view infer a conclusion that the document might be bogus. Where country information ignites the Tribunal’s concern that a critical document might be counterfeit or the product of fraud, as opposed to merely lacking in reliability or genuineness, it is incumbent on the Tribunal as a matter of fairness to give the applicant an opportunity to comment upon or respond to the potentially more prejudicial finding. That is the essential distinction between the first and second categories drawn by French J in WAJR. If that were not so, any document, no matter how genuine or important to an applicant’s case, might be given little weight by a Tribunal on the basis of suspicion fuelled by generalised country information.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Further, in the post-hearing submissions the applicant’s representative explained that they had made efforts to provide the Tribunal with a facial recognition report to confirm the applicant’s identity as one of the detainees shown in the YouTube Video, however they had been unable to obtain such a report. Instead, the applicant provided the Tribunal with two statutory declarations from individuals who each deposed to have known the applicant since childhood (the Statutory Declarations), and stated that they had been able to identify a teenage version of the applicant within the YouTube Video screenshot[20]. [20] CB 235-240Tribunal reasons On 6 February 2018, the Tribunal delivered its reasons which affirmed the delegate’s decision to refuse the applicant’s visa, determining that the criteria stipulated in s 36(2)(a) or s 36(2)(aa) was not satisfied[21]. [21] Tribunal’s Reasons CB 256-257 The Tribunal found that the applicant’s evidence of his claims lacked credibility[22]. The Tribunal set out, in some detail, its consideration of the applicant’s claims and evidence, concluding that many aspects of the claims were inconsistent, implausible, unsupported and only recently proffered[23].[22] Tribunal’s Reasons CB 253 at [57][23] Tribunal’s Reasons CB 255-256 at [67]-[75] The reasons reveal a high degree of scepticism on the part of the Tribunal and a distinct lack of satisfaction that the applicant had given a true account of his circumstances and alleged fears of persecution. The Tribunal introduced its detailed consideration of the applicant’s claims with the observation that the applicant was not a “reliable, credible or truthful witness” and that “he had fabricated his claim in order to be granted a protection visa”[24].[24] Tribunal’s Reasons CB 253 at [57] Among other things, the Tribunal rejected the applicant’s claim that he had been held in detention by Shi’a militias before being released by a judge[25]. The Tribunal concluded that the claim lacked credibility. At [58] of its reasons, the Tribunal states that it took into account the pieces of evidence provided by the applicant, but afforded them little weight[26].[25] Tribunal’s Reasons CB 253 at [58][26] Tribunal’s Reasons CB 253 at [58] At [59] of its reasons, the Tribunal expressed its reluctance to give any weight to the YouTube Video or the screenshot image as evidence of the applicant’s detention, finding that the video was “not translated”, which made it difficult to place it into context. Further, the Tribunal held that given the passage of time, it was not satisfied that the person depicted in the still image was the applicant, and that even if he had been able to provide a facial recognition report which confirmed that it was him, any such report would not have been able to verify the context (ie detention) in which the video was taken. At [60] of its reasons, the Tribunal considered the two Statutory Declarations provided by the applicant post-hearing, but decided to give them little weight, finding that the declarations: “60.[…] simply say they recognise the face of the person in the video based on their knowledge of the applicant. I have had access to the same data as them and disagree with the claimed match – theirs are simply unscientific assertions. They also do nothing to contextualise the video/photo of the applicant.”(emphasis added)