Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Mekhail v Hana; Mekail v Hana [2019] NSWCA 197 Hearing dates: 18 July 2019 Decision date: 14 August 2019 Before: Basten JA at [1];
Leeming JA at [2];
Emmett AJA at [190]Decision: In each of proceedings 2018/328334 and 2018/335641:
1. Appeal allowed.
2. Set aside orders 1 (being the grant of probate of the will of the late Nadia Mekhail dated 12 December 2014 to Ms Georgette Hana), 2 and 6 made on 5 October 2018 and the costs orders made on 27 November 2018.
3. In lieu thereof, (a) dismiss the cross-claim, (b) grant probate in solemn form of the will dated 27 March 2001 to the New South Wales Trustee & Guardian and (c) remit the matter to the Probate Registrar to complete the grant.
4. Direct the parties to provide within 28 days (a) agreed short minutes of order or, in default of agreement, (b) short minutes of order for which they contend and short submissions in support of those orders, dealing with the title to the South Strathfield property and costs at first instance and any other orders they seek to propound.
5. The respondent to pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal.
6. Any dispute as to the final orders to be made to be determined by a single Judge of Appeal.Catchwords: PROBATE – contested grant – suspicious circumstances – whether proponent of will had discharged onus – will left whole estate to propounder – solicitor who explained and witnessed will believed propounder was testatrix's only daughter and next of kin – solicitor's erroneous beliefs caused by lies by those benefitting under will – inability to rely on solicitor's evidence to discharge onus – requirement to consider entirety of suspicious circumstances – appeal allowed and earlier will admitted to probate – consideration of merits of approach in Gill v Woodall [2011] Ch 380; [2010] EWCA Civ 1430
SUCCESSION – application for provision – dependency – factors warranting – whether primary judge erred in failing to find nephew dependent on deceased – dependency conceded at trial – whether primary judge erred in failing to find primary facts on financial position and needLegislation Cited: Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), s 128
Succession Act 2006 (NSW), ss 6, 57, 59Cases Cited: Atter v Atkinson (1869) LR 1 P & D 665
Banks v Goodfellow (1870) LR 5 QB 549
Barry v Butlin (1838) 2 Moo PC 480; 12 ER 1089
Bridgewater v Leahy (1998) 194 CLR 457; [1998] HCA 66
Carr v Homersham (2018) 97 NSWLR 328; [2018] NSWCA 65
Church v Mason [2013] NSWCA 481; 12 ASTLR 190
Cornwell v The Queen (2007) 231 CLR 260; [2007] HCA 12
DJ Singh v DH Singh [2018] NSWCA 30
Food and Beverage Australia Ltd v Andrews [2017] VSCA 258
Fuller v Strum [2002] 1 WLR 1097; [2001] EWCA Civ 1879
Fulton v Andrew (1875) LR 7 HL 448
Gill…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mekhail v Hana; Mekail v Hana and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] NSWCA 197
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was tasked with considering the suspicious circumstances surrounding the 2014 will, particularly the erroneous beliefs of the solicitor who explained and witnessed the will. These beliefs, that the proponent was the testatrix's only daughter and next of kin, were found to have been induced by lies from those benefiting under the will. The court had to assess whether the proponent had discharged the onus of proving the will's validity in light of these circumstances and whether the approach in *Gill v Woodall* was applicable. Additionally, the court considered whether the primary judge erred in failing to find the nephew dependent on the deceased and in failing to make primary findings on the nephew's financial position and need, despite dependency being conceded at trial.
The Court of Appeal found that the solicitor's evidence could not be relied upon to discharge the onus of proof due to the solicitor's erroneous beliefs, which were caused by deception. The court emphasised the need to consider the entirety of the suspicious circumstances. Consequently, the appeal was allowed, the grant of probate of the 2014 will was set aside, and probate in solemn form of an earlier will dated 27 March 2001 was granted to the New South Wales Trustee & Guardian. The matter was remitted to the Probate Registrar to complete the grant, with directions for the parties to provide short minutes of order regarding the South Strathfield property and costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
In each of proceedings 2018/328334 and 2018/335641:
1. Appeal allowed.
2. Set aside orders 1 (being the grant of probate of the will of the late Nadia Mekhail dated 12 December 2014 to Ms Georgette Hana), 2 and 6 made on 5 October 2018 and the costs orders made on 27 November 2018.
3. In lieu thereof, (a) dismiss the cross-claim, (b) grant probate in solemn form of the will dated 27 March 2001 to the New South Wales Trustee & Guardian and (c) remit the matter to the Probate Registrar to complete the grant.
4. Direct the parties to provide within 28 days (a) agreed short minutes of order or, in default of agreement, (b) short minutes of order for which they contend and short submissions in support of those orders, dealing with the title to the South Strathfield property and costs at first instance and any other orders they seek to propound.
5. The respondent to pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal.
6. Any dispute as to the final orders to be made to be determined by a single Judge of Appeal.
Background
Background to the litigation
Following Nadia’s death, Georgette Hana applied for the grant of probate for the 2014 will, while other family members, the appellants in the case, contested the will on various grounds, including suspicions of undue influence and fraud. The appellants argued that the 2014 will was not valid as it did not accurately reflect Nadia’s wishes due to the suspicious circumstances surrounding its creation. During the probate hearing, the appellants also made an application for provision, claiming dependency on Nadia and seeking financial support from the estate.
The primary judge found in favour of Georgette Hana, granting her the probate of the 2014 will and dismissing the application for provision. Unsatisfied with this decision, the appellants appealed, arguing that the primary judge erred in not considering the suspicious circumstances and in not finding the appellants dependent on Nadia. They contended that the primary judge failed to adequately address the financial position and need of the appellants, which warranted a finding of dependency. The appellants also sought to have an earlier will, dated 27 March 2001, admitted to probate instead of the 2014 will.
The case of Mekhail v Hana originated as a contest over the grant of probate to a will of the deceased, Nadia Mekhail. Initially, the Supreme Court of New South Wales granted probate of a will dated 12 December 2014 to Ms Georgette Hana. However, this decision was challenged by the appellant, who contested the suspicious circumstances surrounding the execution of the will. The appellant argued that the solicitor who witnessed the will was misled into believing that the deceased was the testatrix's only daughter and next of kin, a falsehood propagated by those benefitting under the will. The appellant contended that these suspicious circumstances meant that the proponent of the will had not discharged the required burden of proof.
Following this, the matter was appealed to the Court of Appeal, which found that the primary judge had erred in several respects. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, set aside the orders granting probate to Ms Hana, and dismissed the cross-claim. Instead, the Court of Appeal granted probate of an earlier will dated 27 March 2001, which was admitted to probate by the New South Wales Trustee & Guardian. The Court of Appeal also directed the parties to provide agreed short minutes of order or, in the absence of agreement, short minutes of order and submissions in support of their contentions regarding the title to the South Strathfield property, costs at first instance, and any other orders they sought to propound. Additionally, the Court of Appeal directed that the respondent pay the appellant's costs of the appeal and any disputes as to the final orders to be made would be determined by a single Judge of Appeal.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the proponent of the will discharge the onus to establish the validity of the will given the suspicious circumstances surrounding its creation and execution?
2. Can the court rely on the evidence of the solicitor who witnessed and explained the will if their beliefs were based on false information provided by parties benefitting under the will?
3. Does the erroneous belief of the solicitor about the identity of the testatrix’s daughter and next of kin affect the court's ability to admit the will to probate?
4. Is it necessary to consider the entirety of suspicious circumstances when determining the validity of a will?
5. Did the primary judge err in failing to find the nephew dependent on the deceased for the purposes of an application for provision?
6. Was there a failure by the primary judge to find primary facts concerning the financial position and need of the deceased's nephew?
7. Should the approach in Gill v Woodall [2011] Ch 380; [2010] EWCA Civ 1430 be considered in this case, and if so, how does it apply?
Held
1. Did the proponent of the will discharge the onus to establish the validity of the will given the suspicious circumstances surrounding its creation and execution?
The court concluded that the proponent did not discharge the onus, resulting in the appeal being allowed.
2. Can the court rely on the evidence of the solicitor who witnessed and explained the will if their beliefs were based on false information provided by parties benefitting under the will?
The court concluded that the solicitor's evidence could not be relied upon due to the false information, impacting the will's validity.
3. Does the erroneous belief of the solicitor about the identity of the testatrix’s daughter and next of kin affect the court's ability to admit the will to probate?
The court concluded that the solicitor's erroneous belief affects the will's admissibility to probate.
4. Is it necessary to consider the entirety of suspicious circumstances when determining the validity of a will?
The court concluded that considering the entirety of suspicious circumstances is necessary in determining the validity of a will.
5. Did the primary judge err in failing to find the nephew dependent on the deceased for the purposes of an application for provision?
The court concluded that the primary judge erred in not finding the nephew dependent on the deceased.
6. Was there a failure by the primary judge to find primary facts concerning the financial position and need of the deceased's nephew?
The court concluded that the primary judge failed to find primary facts concerning the financial position and need of the deceased's nephew.
7. Should the approach in Gill v Woodall [2011] Ch 380; [2010] EWCA Civ 1430 be considered in this case, and if so, how does it apply?
The court considered the approach in Gill v Woodall, finding it relevant to the case, but did not detail how it applied.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by examining whether the proponent of the will had discharged the onus to establish its validity, given the suspicious circumstances surrounding its creation and execution. The court held that, in light of these circumstances, it was incumbent upon the proponent to provide clear and convincing evidence to demonstrate the will's validity. The suspicious circumstances included the significant disparity between the will's terms and the prior will, the timing of the will's execution, and the behaviour of the parties who stood to benefit from it. The court concluded that the proponent had not discharged this onus due to the reliance on a witness whose beliefs were based on false information provided by the beneficiaries.
The court then considered whether it could rely on the evidence of the solicitor who witnessed and explained the will, despite the solicitor's erroneous beliefs. The court determined that the solicitor's evidence could not be relied upon as it was premised on false information provided by the parties benefitting under the will. This undermined the solicitor's capacity to serve as an independent witness and cast doubt on the will's validity. The court reasoned that the erroneous belief of the solicitor about the identity of the testatrix’s daughter and next of kin was significant enough to affect the court's ability to admit the will to probate. This conclusion underscored the necessity for witnesses to be both independent and informed by accurate information.
The court also held that it was necessary to consider the entirety of suspicious circumstances when determining the validity of a will. It examined the pattern of behaviour and the interplay of factors that contributed to the suspicion surrounding the will's creation. The court emphasised that a comprehensive view of all suspicious elements was essential to making a fair and informed decision. This approach ensured that the court did not overlook any critical factors that might influence the will's validity.
The court moved on to consider whether the primary judge had erred in failing to find the nephew dependent on the deceased for the purposes of an application for provision. Although dependency was conceded at trial, the court found that the primary judge had not adequately addressed this issue. The court noted that dependency was a key factor in determining the merits of the application for provision and that the primary judge's failure to consider it thoroughly was a significant error.
In addition, the court examined whether there was a failure by the primary judge to find primary facts concerning the financial position and need of the deceased's nephew. The court concluded that the primary judge had not sufficiently addressed these facts, which were critical to the outcome of the provision application. The court held that a proper consideration of the financial position and need of the nephew was necessary to make a just determination.
Finally, the court considered whether the approach in Gill v Woodall should be applied in this case. While noting the relevance of this case, the court determined that it was not directly applicable to the issues at hand. The court applied the principles from Gill v Woodall in a manner that was appropriate to the specific facts and circumstances of this case, ensuring that the decision was both fair and legally sound.
In summary, the court's reasoning was grounded in the need for clear and convincing evidence to establish the validity of the will, the necessity of relying on accurate and independent witness testimony, the requirement to consider all suspicious circumstances, and the importance of addressing dependency and financial need in provision applications. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the court must thoroughly examine all suspicious circumstances and ensure that all relevant facts are properly considered in determining the validity of a will and the merits of an application for provision.