McIlwain v Ramsey Food Packaging Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 83 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

McIlwain v Ramsey Food Packaging Pty Ltd
[2005] FCA 1233

DISCOVERY – exercise of subpoena power and orders for non-party and particular discovery close to trial – factors relevant to discretion whether to grant leave – interpretation of O 15, R 8, O 15A, R 8 and O 27A.

Industrial Relations Act 1996 (NSW)
Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) ss. 83BA, 83BB, 298K; 298L; 298T, 298V; 412.
Federal Court Rules O 15A, R 8, O 27A

Maritime Union of Australia & Ors v. Geraldton Port Authority & Ors (1999) 93 FCR 34 referred to
Australasian Meat Industry Employees’ Union v. Belandra Pty Ltd (2003) 126 IR 165 referred to
Maritime Union of Australia v. CSL Australia Pty Ltd (2002) 113 IR 326 referred to
Employment Advocate v. Williamson & Anor (2001) FCR 20 referred to
Mulley v. Manifold (1959) 103 CLR 341 explained
Murex Diagnostics Australia Pty Ltd v. Chiron Corporation (No. 2) (2995) 62 FCR 424 cited
Diddams & Ors v. Commonwealth Bank of Australia & Anor [1998] FCA 497 referred to, cited
ACCC v. Shell Co of Australia Ltd (1999) 161 ALR 686 discussed
McLernon Group Insurances Pty Ltd v. Biron Corporation Ltd [1995] FCA 500 referred to
Richardson Pacific Ltd v. Fielding & Ors (1990) 26 FCR 188 cited
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v. Shell Company of Australia Ltd (1999) 161 ACR 686
Re La Rosa; Ex parte Norgard (unreported, French J, 26 October 1992) cited
The Adelaide Steamship Company v. Spalvins (unreported, O’Loughlin J, 1 August 1997) cited
The Commissioner for Railways v. Small (1938) SR (NSW) 564 cited
Hennessy v. Wright (1888) 21 QBD 509 cited
Griebart v. Morris [1920] 1 KB 659 cited
Australian Gas Light Company v. Australian Competition & Consumer Commission [2003] FCA 1101 referred to
Dorajay Pty Ltd v. Aristocratic Leisure Ltd [2005] FCA 588
Seven Network Limited v. News Limited (No. 5) (2005) 216 ALR 147 cited
Hamilton v. Oades (1989) 166 CLR 486 cited
Oceanic Sun Line Special Shipping Co Inc. v. Fay (1988) 165 CLR 1997
Hughes v. Western Australian Cricket Association (1986) 66 ALR 541 cited

Guidelines for the conduct of trials and pre-trial steps.

MCILWAIN v RAMSEY FOOD PACKAGING PTY LTD & ORS

QUD66 of 2003

GREENWOOD J
2 SEPTEMBER 2005
BRISBANE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

Q66 OF 2003

BETWEEN:

PETER LESLIE MCILWAIN
APPLICANT

AND:

RAMSEY FOOD PACKAGING PTY LTD
FIRST RESPONDENT

RAMSEY FOOD PACKAGING NO. 2 PTY LTD
SECOND RESPONDENT

RAMSEY BUTCHERING SERVICES PTY LTD
THIRD RESPONDENT

RAMSEY FOOD SERVICES PTY LTD
FOURTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

GREENWOOD J

DATE OF ORDER:

2 SEPTEMBER 2005

WHERE MADE:

BRISBANE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.That leave be granted to each of the Secretary (or appropriately designated office holder by name and title) of the Australasian Meat Industry Employees’ Union (otherwise described as the Federal Union), the Newcastle and Northern Branch of the Australasian Meat Industry Employees’ Union (otherwise described as the State Branch of the Federal Union) and the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McIlwain v Ramsey Food Packaging Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] FCA 1233
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

McIlwain v Ramsey Food Packaging Pty Ltd was a case in the Federal Court of Australia involving a complex dispute over employment conditions and union negotiations at the South Grafton Abattoir. The case had undergone extensive case management, with numerous directions and orders to manage the discovery of documents, the filing of pleadings, and the scheduling of the trial. The Applicant sought to amend their claim multiple times, and the Respondents filed defences and counter-motions throughout the case.

The central legal issues in the case revolved around the discovery of documents and the admissibility of certain evidence. The Applicant sought to compel the Respondents to produce various documents related to union negotiations and meetings, while the Respondents argued that some of the requested documents were irrelevant or privileged. The Court was required to decide whether the documents sought by the Applicant were necessary for the fair administration of justice and whether they should be disclosed to the Applicant.

In its decision, the Court granted the Applicant leave to compel the production of certain documents related to union negotiations at the abattoir, while denying leave for other documents that were deemed irrelevant or privileged. The Court also granted the Respondents leave to subpoena specific documents from a third party, John Graham Broadway. The Court reserved costs and scheduled a further directions hearing to address any objections to the subpoenas.

The outcome of the case was a partial victory for the Applicant, who obtained access to key documents related to union negotiations, while the Respondents successfully protected some documents from disclosure. The case highlights the importance of thorough case management and the need for courts to balance the interests of both parties in discovery disputes.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. That leave be granted to each of the Secretary (or appropriately designated office holder by name and title) of the Australasian Meat Industry Employees’ Union (otherwise described as the Federal Union), the Newcastle and Northern Branch of the Australasian Meat Industry Employees’ Union (otherwise described as the State Branch of the Federal Union) and the Newcastle and Northern Branch of the Australasian Meat Industry Employees’ Union (otherwise described as the State Union), to produce to the Court:

(a) all documents including minutes of meetings, notes of meetings or notes of discussions between representatives of the (relevant) Union and representatives of any of the respondents in relation to the re-opening of the South Grafton Abattoir in March 1998;

(b) all documents including minutes of meetings, notes of meetings or notes of discussions between representatives of the (relevant) Union and representatives of any of the respondents in relation to conditions of employment to apply at the South Grafton Abattoir upon the re-opening of the abattoir in March 1998;

(c) all documents including minutes or notes of meetings (including resolutions) and notes of discussions concerning the representation by the (relevant) Union, of employees of any one of the respondents in the principal proceeding (the respondents) at the South Grafton Abattoir relating to negotiations by or on behalf of the first, second or third consultative committees of employees and any one of the respondents in the period March 1998 to 30 September 2002, but not including the following documents:

(i) any documents relating to the termination of employment of Stephen Blackadder on or about 5 October 1999 or proceedings before the Australian Industrial Relations Commission commenced by Stephen Blackadder on or about 29 March 2000 seeking reinstatement and other orders;

(ii) any documents relating to the termination of employment of Colin James Hambly on or about 1 July 1999 or proceedings before the Australian Industrial Relations Commission taken by Hambly seeking reinstatement and other relief;

(iii) documents relating to proceedings commenced by Jason Robertson seeking reinstatement before the Australian Industrial Relations Commission and other relief and documents relating to the role of Paul Francis McKenzie in those proceedings;

(iv) documents relating to the termination of employment of Paul Gerard Swain on or about 15 April 1999 or proceedings commenced by Swain seeking reinstatement and other relief before the Australian Industrial Relations Commission.

by 10.00am on Wednesday, 28 September 2005.

2. That leave be granted under O 27A of the Federal Court Rules to any or all of the named respondents to issue a subpoena addressed to John Graham Broadway requiring production by him of the documents identified by him at paragraphs 10.2 and 10.3 of his report dated 12 August 2003 and filed in the proceedings save for documents obtained from any of the named respondents returnable at 10.00am on Wednesday, 28 September 2005.

3. The respondents’ motion be otherwise dismissed.

4. Costs reserved.

THE COURT FURTHER DIRECTS THAT:

1. The matter will be listed for directions at 10.00am on 28 September to provide for the return of the subpoenas and to enable any objections to be heard.

2. The respondents submit draft subpoenas to the Court by 6 September 2005.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The principal proceeding has been the subject of extensive case management and many orders for directions in order to ensure that the matter is in a position to proceed to trial. Some aspects of the interlocutory steps (not all) which give an indication of the extent of the case management of the matter are as follows:1.9 May 2003, the Applicant filed the Application and Statement of Claim.2.29 May 2003, Kiefel J made the following directions:‘(a)Each Respondent file and serve a Defence to the Statement of Claim by 3 July 2003.(b)The Applicant give discovery of documents with verification by 25 July 2003.(c)Each respondent give discovery of documents with verification by 14 August 2003.(d) The parties attend mediation by 29 August 2003.(e) Matter listed for further Directions on 26 September.’3.9 July 2003, the then Respondents (First and Second Respondents) filed their Defence.4.11 July 2003, the Applicant sought particulars of the Defence as to paragraphs 130(a), 130(b), 130(e) and paragraph 131.5.12 August 2003, the Applicant filed a Notice of Motion seeking leave to join the Third and Fourth Respondents and leave to file an Amended Application and Amended Statement of Claim.6.25 August 2003, Kiefel J granted leave to amend the Application and Statement of Claim and leave to join the Third and Fourth Respondents and made the following Directions:‘(a)Respondents provide particulars in compliance with the Applicant’s request of 11 July 2003 by 12 September 2003.(b)Applicant provide particulars of paragraph 12A of the proposed Amended Statement of Claim by 3 October 2003.(c) Respondents file and serve an Amended Defence by 24 October 2003.(d)Applicant give discovery of documents with verification by 8 November 2003.(e)Respondents give discovery of documents with verification by 22 November 2003.(f) Matter listed for further Directions on 25 November 2003.’7.26 September 2003, the Applicant served an Amended Application and Amended Statement of Claim.8.24 October 2003, Respondents filed an Amended Defence.9.11 November 2003, the Applicant filed a List of Documents in the Court.10.24 November 2003, Respondents served unverified list of documents.11.25 November 2003, further Directions made by Kiefel J:(a)Each of the Respondents provide particulars of paragraph 130 of the Amended Defence as sought in the request made by the Applicant on 11 July 2003 within 10 days of the date of this order.(b)Each of the Respondents give discovery of documents with verification by 2 December 2003.(c) Inspection of documents be completed by 21 January 2004.(d)The Applicant file and serve the affidavits and expert reports upon which he intends to rely by 18 February 2004.(e)Each of the Respondents to file and serve the affidavits and expert reports upon which they intend to rely by 18 March 2004.(f) The Applicant to file and serve affidavits in reply by 31 March 2004.(g) The Matter to be adjourned for further Directions to 7 April 2004.12.28 November 2003, Respondents filed the verified list of documents.13.18 February 2004, Applicant advised Respondents that the Applicant’s affidavits could not be provided by the due date but nominated 27 February 2004 for compliance.14.Applicant served filed copies of Affidavits on 9, 10 and 11 March 2004.15.7 April 2004, Kiefel J made the following Directions: ‘(a)the Respondents file and serve their affidavits, including expert reports by 17 May 2004;(b) the Applicant file and serve any affidavits in reply by 9 June 2004;(c) Further Directions Hearing, 11 June 2004.’16.12 May 2004, Applicant claimed Respondents had not discovered a number of identified documents. 17.14 May 2004, Respondents advised they could not file affidavits in compliance with the timetable.18.17 May 2004, Applicant advised that all affidavits filed on his behalf would be read at the hearing.19.26 May 2004, the Respondents filed a Notice of Motion seeking the vacating of previous Directions, removal from the Court file of nominated affidavits filed by the Applicant and further orders.20.23 June 2004, Respondent’s Notice of Motion seeking to have a substantial part of the Applicant’s evidence struck out as irrelevant, heard. seeking to have a substantial part of the Applicant’s evidence struck out as irrelevant to the facts in issue. The Court (Kiefel J) made the following Directions:- ‘(a) Notice of Motion dismissed.;(b)Respondents file and serve Affidavit material on or before 21 July 2004.;(c)Applicant file and serve Affidavit material in reply on or before 11August2004; and(d) Matter listed for further directions on 20 August 2004.’21.29 June 2004, Applicant advised the Respondents that it they intended to file and serve further affidavits from each of the deponents who had sworn affidavits previously (apart from John Graham Broadway) and the and that tprofurther affidavits were intended to replace the sworn affidavits previously filed. To accommodate the provision of the Applicants revised affidavits a A revised timetable was agreed, as follows:(a)The directions of 23 June 2004 vacated.(b)The Aapplicant file and serve further affidavits upon which he intends to rely by 20 August 2004.(c)The Respondents file and serve any affidavits upon which they intend to rely by 24 September 2004.(d)The Applicant file and serve any affidavits in reply by 14 October 2004; and(e)Further directions, 15 October 2004.22.16 July 2004, Kiefel J made orders in terms of the revised timetable.23.23 August 2004, the Applicant filed further affidavits. 24.14 September 2004, Applicant advised Respondents that save for the affidavit of John Graham Broadway no reliance would be placed on the prior affidavits. they would not be reading any of the March 2004 Affidavits apart from that sworn by John Broadway.25.7 October 2004, ApplicantRespondents filed a Notice of Motion seeking leave Amendments to amend the Amended Application and Amended Statement of Claim and vacate orders made 16 July 2004 by Kiefel J.1.15 October 2004, Kiefel J made the following orders: as filed by the Applicant is heard as to amending the Amended Application and Amended Statement of Claim. Further Directions are made by Court (Kiefel J):26.By way of consent:‘(a)The Amended Application and Amended Statement of Claim be further amended in accordance with the documents marked “A” and “B” respectively attached to the Applicant’s Notice of Motion dated 7 October 2004;(b) The orders of 16 July 2004 be vacated.(c)The Respondents file and serve any affidavits upon which they intend to rely by 17 November 2004 and no later; (d) The matter listed for trial directions on 3 December 2004.’27.29 October 2004, Applicant filed a Ffurther aAmended Application and fFurther aAmended Statement of Claim.28.2 November 2004, Applicant servedfiled Further Amended Application and Further Amended Statement of Claim.29.17 November 2004, Respondents filed affidavits in reply.30.17 and 18 November 2004, Respondents served filed affidavits in reply.31.3 December 2004, Kiefel J made the following Directions:‘(a)Applicant request further discovery from Respondents and file and serve a consolidated request for further and better particulars by 17 December 2004;(b)The Respondents file and serve an Amended Defence within seven (7) days;(c)Respondents provide disclosure and further and better particulars by 28January2005;(d) Applicant put on affidavits in reply by 28 March 2005;(e)Matter set down for trial for three (3) weeks commencing 12 July 2005 and ending 29 July 2005;(f) Further directions to be given on 15 April 2005.’32.9 December 2004, Respondents filed their Defence to Further Amended Statement of Claim.33.10 December 2004, Respondents served Defence to Further Amended Statement of Claim on Applicant.34.20 December 2004, Applicant served Notice for Discovery.35.20 December 2004, Applicant served notice requesting particulars and requested outstanding particulars previously requested on 17 December 2003.36.23 February 2005, Applicant filed Notice of Motion seeking verified discovery and particulars.37.16 March 2005, Kiefel J made the following orders:‘(a) Orders of 3 December 2004 be vacated;(b)Respondents have 7 days to consider whether to file an amended defence deleting paragraph 130 and correcting paragraph 131(vi) and to file such pleading if necessary;(c)if paragraph 130 of the Defence is not deleted or amended then the particulars sought in the request of 20 December 2005 be provided within 30 days;(d)the Respondents provide verified disclosure requested on 20 December 2004 within 60 days; but(e)if paragraph 130 of the Defence is deleted the disclosure required in paragraph 1.5 of the request is no longer to be provided.38.22 March 2005, the Respondents filed an Amended Defence to fFurther Amended Statement of Claim in accordance with dDirections of Kiefel J made 16 March 2005 deleting paragraph 130 and amending paragraph 131(vi).39.22 March 2005, Respondents served Amended Defence to Further Amended Statement of Claim.40.13 May 2005, Respondents filed a List of Documents and provideding verified discovery. losure41.13 May 2005, Respondents served a List of Documents providing verified discovery. losure42.28 June 2005, the Court advised the parties that the matter was listed for hearing for a period of three (3) weeks commencing 10 October 2005.43.21 July 2005, Applicant filed Notice of Motion seeking orders for and order third party discovery and subpoenaed and leave to issue subpoenas.44.22 July 2005, Applicant requested inspection of Respondent’s documents. Inspectionhas been arranged to take place at the offices of the Respondent’s Solicitors on Monday, 22 August 2005.45.22 July 2005, the Applicant advised Respondents that Affidavits in reply withto be served progressively upon the Respondents over a period of within three (3) weeks from 22 July.46.22 July 2005, Applicant served Notice to Produce upon Respondents. s to be made available on the same date for inspection being Monday 22 August 2005.THE AFFIDAVIT EVIDENCE

Decision

Reasons for decision

GREENWOOD J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GREENWOOD J

Full text does not contain this section.