Marini v MLH Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Appeal from a Master)

MARINI v MLH INSURANCE BROKERS PTY LTD & ORS

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Besanko

2 December 2004

PROCEDURE - SUPREME COURT PROCEDURE - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - PRACTICE UNDER RULES OF COURT - PLEADINGS

Appeal from a decision of a Master - where the appellant applied for an order that the Statement of Claim be struck out on the basis that a number of paragraphs of the Statement of Claim were deficient - where the Master made an order giving the respondents leave to file an amended Statement of Claim but rejected the appellant's challenge to certain paragraphs - whether the relevant paragraphs fail to comply with the rules as to pleadings by not setting out "such further material facts as are necessary to give other parties fair notice of the case which they will have to answer" - held that certain of the paragraphs identified do not comply with the rules as to pleadings - whether a conclusion that the paragraphs do not comply with the rules as to pleadings justifies an order striking out the whole of the Statement of Claim, an order striking out those paragraphs or an order that the respondents plead further material facts - held that the paragraphs should not be struck out but they may be the subject of an order that further material facts be pleaded.

Supreme Court Rules 1987 rr 46A.16, 46.18, 46A.02, 46A.03, 46A.09, 46A.08, 46A.03, referred to.
Williams v Australian Telecommunications Commission (1988) 52 SASR 215; Rupcic v A W Baulderstone Pty Ltd (1987) 46 SASR 99, discussed.

MARINI v MLH INSURANCE BROKERS PTY LTD & ORS
[2004] SASC 400

Appeal from a Master

  1. BESANKO J:        This is an appeal from a decision of a Master of this Court.  Mr Giovanni Marini is the appellant and he is the defendant to an action commenced in this Court by MLH Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd, Insurance and Risk Management Pty Ltd and Gulliford Nominees Pty Ltd.  It is convenient to continue to refer to the parties by reference to their status in the action.  After the action had been commenced the defendant and a company called JMRM Investments Pty Ltd (as trustee for the Marini Family Trust) issued a counterclaim against the three plaintiff companies and two other persons.  The counterclaim is not relevant for present purposes. 

  2. The Master’s decision relates to the Amended Statement of Claim/Orders Sought (“Statement of Claim”) issued by the plaintiffs on 3rd June 2004.  By Notice for Specific Directions dated 23rd July 2004 the defendant applied for an order that the Statement of Claim be struck out.  He did so on the basis that a number of paragraphs in the Statement of Claim were deficient.  The Master made an order giving the plaintiffs leave to file and serve a further Amended Statement of Claim which amends certain paragraphs in the Statement of Claim.  He rejected the defendant’s challenge to three paragraphs in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Marini v MLH Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] SASC 400
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Marini v MLH Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd, the appellant sought to have the Statement of Claim struck out by the court, claiming that several paragraphs were deficient. The matter originated from a decision of a Master in South Australia, which had allowed the respondents leave to amend the Statement of Claim but rejected the appellant's challenge to certain paragraphs. The primary legal issue before the court was whether certain paragraphs of the Statement of Claim complied with the rules governing pleadings, specifically whether they set out "such further material facts as are necessary to give other parties fair notice of the case which they will have to answer."

The court examined the provisions of the Rules of Court and found that certain paragraphs in question did not comply with the rules as to pleadings. However, the court concluded that striking out the entire Statement of Claim or those specific paragraphs was not the appropriate remedy. Instead, the court held that the deficient paragraphs could be the subject of an order requiring the respondents to plead further material facts. The court reasoned that the deficiencies amounted to a lack of adequate particulars, which under the relevant rules should not lead to the striking out of a pleading or part of a pleading. The court was satisfied that the appellant would be significantly prejudiced without further material facts, and thus, it would entertain an application for an order under the relevant rule.

The court ultimately decided that the Master's decision regarding certain paragraphs should stand, but an order could be made under rule 46A.09 for the respondents to provide additional material facts. This approach ensured that the deficiencies were addressed without unfairly prejudicing the appellant in the conduct of his case.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I think the approach I have suggested is the approach I should take having regard to the terms of the relevant Rules. There is a discretion not to strike out a pleading or part of a pleading and it is a proper exercise of that discretion not to strike out if the deficiency is a lack of further material facts in the sense referred to in r 46A.09. The approach I have suggested might be justified by an alternative route. Rule 46.18 only applies to pleadings governed by r 46A to the extent that it is not inconsistent with r 46A.16. In my opinion, it is inconsistent with the provisions of r 46A and, in particular, r 46A.09, to strike out a pleading or part of a pleading because of a lack of further material facts in the sense referred to in r 46A.09.Conclusion In my opinion, paragraphs 12.1 – 12.4 inclusive fail to comply with r 46A.03(b), but the failure is, in essence, what would previously have been considered a failure to provide adequate particulars. Those paragraphs should not be struck out but they may be the subject of an order under r 46A.09. I am satisfied that the appellant would be significantly prejudiced in the conduct of his case in not having further material facts in relation to those paragraphs. I think that that is clear enough from the nature of the deficiencies and that this is not a case where evidence of significant prejudice is required. I will hear the parties as to whether on the appeal I can and should entertain an application for an order under r 46A.09. I reject the challenge to the Master’s decision in relation to paragraphs 12.5, 12.6, 14 and 16.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.