SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Applications Under Various Acts or Rules: Civil)
COONAWARRA PREMIUM VINEYARDS LTD v NUGAN GROUP PTY LTD & ANOR
Reasons of Judge Lunn a Master of the Supreme Court
18 January 2006
PROCEDURE
Pleading under R 46A - effect of failing to plead with proper particularity - operation of R 46A.09(1) - particulars referring to other documents struck out as contrary to the rules of pleading.
COONAWARRA PREMIUM VINEYARDS LTD v NUGAN GROUP PTY LTD & ANOR
[2006] SASC 5Reasons on Plaintiff’s Application to strike out various paragraphs of the Defences
JUDGE LUNN: The plaintiff has sued the defendants for damages for breaches of an alleged agreement for the supply of wine grapes. There is a dispute about whether the other contracting party was the first or the second defendant. The pleadings raise numerous issues between the parties, but these reasons are confined to the issues which are the subject of the present application by the plaintiff.
On 9 November 2005, the first defendant filed a further amended defence (“the defence”). On that day the second defendant filed an amended defence. On 24 November 2005 the plaintiff filed an application to strike out various paragraphs of the defence and of the amended defence of the second defendant or alternatively seeking that the defendants plead further material facts of those paragraphs. The application was brought under RR 46.18 and 46A.09. It is only necessary to give reasons for my ruling on the application relating to the defence as the issues relating to the defence of the second defendant are identical.
The obligations of the defendants in pleading their defences
R 46A made major changes to the previous law and practice on pleadings. Many of the authorities on the previous rules about pleadings, and many previously accepted practices in pleading, have been significantly changed by it.
R 46A.05 stipulates:
(2)the defence must plead, but plead only:
(a)what parts, if any, of the statement of claim are admitted;
(b)the material facts relied upon to constitute any grounds of defence on which the defendant bears an evidentiary or legal onus of proof;
(c)such further material facts as are necessary to give other parties fair notice of the defendant’s case which they will have to meet.
Subparagraphs (2)(b) and (2)(c) correspond to R 46A.03(a) and (b) which stipulate the similar requirements for statements of claim. (In these reasons references to (2)(b) and (2)(c) are also references to (a) and (b) and vice versa). Whether a pleading comes within subparagraphs (2)(b), or only within subparagraph (2)(c), is of considerable significance when considering the available remedies for breaches of these subparagraphs. In Irving v Starmaker (No 51) Pty Ltd 17 August 2005, Judgment number [2005] SASC 309, unreported, Layton J said:
The dividing line between the two categories may at times be fine, but the consequences of their non-provision are significantly different. The remedy in relation to a successful claim under the first category is that if “material facts” are not…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Coonawarra Premium Vineyards Ltd v Nugan Group Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2006] SASC 5
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that certain paragraphs in the defences were insufficiently particularised and contravened the rules of pleading. Notably, paragraphs 6.1B and others that referenced other documents were struck out because pleading by cross-reference to discovered documents is impermissible. The court also held that paragraphs 6.1, 6.1A, 6.1C, 6.1D, 15.9C, and 15.9D were too vague to provide fair notice to the plaintiff, necessitating further particulars to avoid significant prejudice. However, the court found that the plaintiff had not demonstrated significant prejudice regarding the agency claims or the implied terms, and thus denied the application for further material facts on those grounds. Consequently, the court ordered the defendants to re-plead certain paragraphs and to provide further material facts where necessary.
The court made several orders, including striking out certain paragraphs, requiring further particulars, and allowing amendments to the defences. The defendants were also ordered to pay the plaintiff's costs of the application. The case was adjourned to a directions hearing to address any further pleadings and to prepare for the trial.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi