OE & DR Pope Pty Ltd v Harris & Orchard (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

OE & DR POPE PTY LTD v HARRIS & ORCHARD (No 3)

[2010] SASC 10

Reasons of Judge Lunn a Master of the Supreme Court

1 February 2010

PROCEDURE

Pleadings - application to file amended statement of claim - held new cause of action not properly pleaded - defendant not to be held to its previous admission made in the context of a significantly different basis of claim - held impermissible to give particulars of breach by reference to an expert's report - application refused.

OE & DR POPE PTY LTD v HARRIS & ORCHARD (No 3)
[2010] SASC 10

Reasons on the plaintiff’s further application to amend the statement of claim.

  1. JUDGE LUNN:     In this action the plaintiff sues the defendant as its accountant for professional negligence.  The action was commenced in 2001, but the plaintiff has not as yet been able to finalise a statement of claim on which it is prepared to go to trial.  The action is governed by the 1987 Rules.

  2. By an application of 1 December 2009 the plaintiff sought leave to file a 3rd further amended statement in the terms of a draft exhibited to the affidavit of its solicitor filed on that day (“the ASOC”).  I refuse the application for the following reasons (which are not exhaustive of the defects in it):

    1      New Cause of Action not properly pleaded.

  3. It is necessary to see the proposed new 23.15-23.15.6 of the ASOC in the context of the existing 2nd further amended statement of claim filed on 21 December 2007 (“the existing SOC”).  That statement of claim pleaded, inter alia:

    7      At all times material to this action the defendants:

    7.1carried on a business as a firm of certified practicing accountants or chartered accountants practising in partnership and providing accountancy, auditing, financial, commercial, taxation and business advice and services (“professional accounting services”);

    …..

    8At all times material to this action there was an Agreement or Agreements between Harris & Orchard and the Company that Harris & Orchard would provide professional accounting services to the Company and other entities in the Pope Group (“the Retainer”).

    9Pursuant to the Retainer Harris & Orchard:

    9.1Prepared the financial statements of the Company the Trust and all of the members of the Pope Group;

    …..

    9.7Assisted the Company and other entities in the Pope Group with matters relevant to securing finance from the group’s principal lender Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (“the ANZ Bank”);

    9.8 Provided auditing services to the Company …..

    9.9Provided general accountancy, financial, commercial and business advice to the Company, the Trust and other members of the Pope Group.

    (referred to in this pleading as “the general services”)

    …..

    14The material times are from 1987 to 1997.

    15It was an implied term of the Retainer that Harris & Orchard would perform the professional accounting services pursuant to the Retainer and provide the general services and specific advice…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read OE & DR Pope Pty Ltd v Harris & Orchard (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] SASC 10
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of OE & DR Pope Pty Ltd v Harris & Orchard (No 3) involved the plaintiff, OE & DR Pope Pty Ltd, bringing an application to file an amended statement of claim against the defendant, Harris & Orchard. The primary dispute was over the admissibility of the amended statement of claim, which introduced a new cause of action based on the defendant's alleged auditing duties. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of South Australia.

The central legal issues the court had to address were whether the defendant could be held to its previous admission concerning the provision of auditing services in light of the plaintiff's new cause of action, and whether the plaintiff could rely on an expert's report to particularise the breach of duty. The court had to determine whether the defendant was obligated to respond to a significantly altered basis of claim and whether the expert's report could be used as a substitute for proper pleading under the relevant rules.

In addressing these issues, the court held that the defendant was not bound by its previous admission since the new cause of action required a proper pleading of the precise nature of the auditing services. The court ruled that it was not permissible to give particulars of the breach by reference to an expert's report. The reasoning was that the purpose of pleadings under Rule 46A is to inform the court of the case, and the court does not have access to documents outside the pleadings. The report could not substitute for the proper pleading of the issues under Rule 46A.05. Consequently, the application to file the amended statement of claim was refused.

The court's final orders were that the particulars 1-4 of the proposed amended statement of claim were to be struck out. The plaintiff's application to file the amended statement of claim was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The plaintiff argues that as the defendant has already admitted that it has provided auditing services it is not necessary for it now to have to plead in any detail the retainer’s nature and the scope of the auditing services. I do not accept this. On the existing statement of claim the only significance of the plea of the auditing services was as an indicator of the scope of the general services provided by the defendant to the plaintiff. The defendant properly admitted that it had provide some such services, but only in a context of a claim where the precise nature of the auditing services had no bearing on the relief sought. As the plaintiff seeks to introduce an entirely new cause of action based on the defendant’s duty as auditor, the defendant is entitled to have the proper basis of the claim properly pleaded, and is not to be restricted by its previous admission.4 Plea of breach by incorporation of an expert’s report. The defendant’s counsel objected to the particulars of breach in the proposed 23.15.3-23.15.5 being specified largely by reference to an expert’s report of Mr Kirk which had been delivered by the plaintiff to the defendant. The defendant’s counsel cited what I had said in Coonawarra Premium Vineyards Ltd v Nugan Group Pty Ltd on December 2005, Judgment No [2006] SASC 5 at [15], where I said:Again, the provision of particulars by reference to other documents is objectionable. I ascertained it was not the documents themselves which the defendant was seeking to plead. The plea is an unacceptable shorthand way of seeking to plead the contents of the documents. It is no answer that because of these documents the plaintiff is well aware of the case which the defendant is seeking to make out through the particulars. R 46A requires that the facts relied upon be pleaded, which means them being expressly incorporated into a form of pleading which is in accordance with the rules and filed at Court. The purpose of pleadings under R 46A is also to inform the Court the case of the party who files it. The Court does not have access to these other documents. The report of Robert Paul of 19 March 2003, which is referred to in the particulars, has no special status because it is an expert’s report to which R 38.01 applies. Although R 46A.10(b) refers to a trial Judge being able to refer to experts’ reports in determining whether a party has suffered prejudice or embarrassment from some matters contained in the expert’s report not being pleaded, that is not meant to be a substitute for a proper pleading of the issues under R 46A.05. The particulars 1-4 are to be struck out. I adhere to what I said there. However, there is not necessarily a total prohibition against particulars being given by reference to other documents. It must be assessed on whether the object and purpose of pleadings are fulfilled by what is pleaded. That did not occur in that case, and it is not the case here. The cases in which it is permissible are likely to be rare and relate to matters of peripheral detail rather than to the substance of the breaches, as is the case here.