H Stanke & Sons Pty Ltd v Frederick John Von Stanke (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

H STANKE & SONS PTY LTD v FREDERICK JOHN VON STANKE & ORS (No 2)

[2007] SASC 379

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Sulan

26 October 2007

PROCEDURE - SUPREME COURT PROCEDURE - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - PROCEDURE UNDER RULES OF COURT - PLEADINGS - GENERALLY

First defendant appeals from judgment of Master in which Master did not strike out certain paragraphs of the contribution notice of the second defendant - whether certain paragraphs include statements of conclusions based on unpleaded material facts - whether certain paragraphs are frivolous or vexatious - whether certain paragraphs plead evidence instead of material facts - whether certain paragraphs disclose no reasonable cause of action.

Supreme Court Rules 1987 r 46A; Trustee Act 1936 s 36(1), s 84B, referred to.
Williams v Australian Telecommunications Commission (1988) 52 SASR 215, applied.
H Stanke & Sons Pty Ltd & Anor v O'Meara [2007] SASC 246, discussed.
H Stanke & Sons Pty Ltd & Anor v Frederick John Von Stanke & Ors [2007] SASC 51; H Stanke & Sons Pty Ltd and Cape Banks Processing Company Pty Ltd v von Stanke, O'Meara and Ors (2006) 95 SASR 425; Marini v MLH Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd [2004] SASC 400, considered.

H STANKE & SONS PTY LTD v FREDERICK JOHN VON STANKE & ORS (No 2)
[2007] SASC 379

Civil

  1. SULAN J: The background to this appeal is set out in my judgment of 25 July 2007.  On 8 May 2007, the first defendant lodged a notice of appeal against the orders and judgment delivered by a Master of the Supreme Court on 20 February and 19 April 2007.  The appeal related to orders that had been made in relation to the Amended Contribution Notice of the second defendant.  The notice of appeal disclosed five grounds of appeal. 

  2. On 17 and 18 May 2007, I heard argument from the first and second defendants in relation to one of the grounds of appeal, as well as two further applications relating to the Amended Contribution Notice.  I delivered judgment on the appeal and the applications on 25 July 2007.  The history of this action is also set out in those reasons.  The first defendant lodged an appeal against that judgment on 15 August 2007.  At a directions hearing before me held on 17 August 2007, the first defendant advised the Court that they did not seek leave to appeal, but were appealing directly to the Full Court.  The Full Court has reserved judgment on that appeal.

  3. Certain of the orders made by the Master in his judgment of 20 February 2007 related to the Amended Defence of the second defendant.  The plaintiffs appealed against those parts of the judgment in a notice of appeal dated 19 March 2007.  On 21 March 2007, a single Judge of this Court referred that appeal directly to the Full Court.  At the time of the hearing on 17 and 18 May 2007, the Full…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read H Stanke & Sons Pty Ltd v Frederick John Von Stanke (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] SASC 379
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the appeal of H Stanke & Sons Pty Ltd v Frederick John Von Stanke (No 2), the first defendant, Frederick John Von Stanke, appeals from a judgment of the Master in which the Master did not strike out certain paragraphs of the Amended Contribution Notice of the second defendant, Mrs O’Meara. The core dispute revolves around the propriety of specific paragraphs within the Amended Contribution Notice, which Mrs O’Meara submitted against Frederick John Von Stanke. The appeal specifically targets these paragraphs for alleged non-compliance with Rule 46A of the Supreme Court Rules 1987, which governs pleadings. The contentions include that certain paragraphs include statements of conclusions based on unpleaded material facts, are frivolous or vexatious, plead evidence instead of material facts, and disclose no reasonable cause of action.

The legal issues the court had to resolve centred on the compliance of the Amended Contribution Notice with Rule 46A. These issues included whether certain paragraphs contained conclusions based on unpleaded material facts, whether they were frivolous or vexatious, whether they pleaded evidence instead of material facts, and whether they disclosed a reasonable cause of action. The court's task was to review each paragraph in question, applying the principles of pleadings as set out in Rule 46A and determining if the Master's decision to not strike out the paragraphs was correct. The court had to balance the need for clarity and precision in pleadings against the broader context and purpose of the pleadings.

The court examined each paragraph individually, applying the principles of pleadings as set out in Rule 46A of the Supreme Court Rules 1987. The court found that some paragraphs did indeed contain conclusions based on unpleaded material facts and were therefore improper. Other paragraphs were deemed frivolous or vexatious, and some were found to plead evidence instead of material facts. The court concluded that certain paragraphs did not disclose a reasonable cause of action and thus should have been struck out. The Master's decision to not strike out these paragraphs was deemed erroneous. The court ruled that the Master should have exercised their discretion to strike out the improper paragraphs to ensure the proceedings were fair, just, and efficient.

The final orders of the court were that the Master's decision to not strike out certain paragraphs of the Amended Contribution Notice was erroneous. Consequently, the court ordered that the Master should have struck out the identified paragraphs that included statements of conclusions based on unpleaded material facts, were frivolous or vexatious, pleaded evidence instead of material facts, or disclosed no reasonable cause of action. These rulings aimed to ensure that the proceedings adhered to the proper standards of pleadings and maintained the integrity of the judicial process.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The first three grounds of appeal challenge particular paragraphs of the Amended Contribution Notice as being contrary to r 46A of the Supreme Court Rules 1987. Several of the paragraphs are challenged under more than one ground. Consequently, I will consider each paragraph of the Amended Contribution Notice subject to the appeal in turn. Before doing that, however, it is necessary to consider the gravamen of the allegations contained in the Amended Contribution Notice, and to identify the principles to be applied to the pleadings. Background to Amended Contribution Notice The Amended Contribution Notice of the second defendant, Mrs O’Meara, is addressed in paragraph 1 to “Frederick John Von Stanke (“the executor”)”. Paragraph 1 states that Frederick John Von Stanke, whom I shall refer to as ‘John’, is a party in the main action in both his capacity as executor of the estate of Frederick William Von Stanke (as first defendant) and in his personal capacity (as third defendant). As I observed in my reasons of 25 July 2007, the Amended Contribution Notice is therefore directed to John in both his executorial and personal capacities, but refers to John compendiously as “the executor” for the remainder of the document. For this reason, paragraphs of the Amended Contribution Notice containing the words “the executor” should not be taken as necessarily referring to John in his executorial capacity exclusively. The Amended Contribution Notice alleges, in essence, that as a consequence of being the executor of the estate of Frederick William Von Stanke, John owes particular duties arising from common law, equity and statute. The Notice also alleges that John holds particular offices and plays particular roles in the running of the Von Stanke family business as a whole, including offices and roles within the plaintiff companies. The gravamen of Mrs O’Meara’s complaint is twofold. In the first instance, Mrs O’Meara claims that John has acted in breach of the duties he owes as a consequence of conflicts that Mrs O’Meara asserts exist between John’s role as executor and his roles in the family business. Mrs O’Meara pleads that John has put the interests of the plaintiff companies before those of the estate. In the second instance, Mrs O’Meara claims that John has acted in breach of his duties by way of his general conduct in relation to the administration of the estate. Mrs O’Meara claims several forms of relief from John. First, she seeks an order pursuant to s 36(1) of the Trustee Act 1936 that John be removed as trustee of the estates of Fred and Gwen. Secondly, Mrs O’Meara seeks equitable compensation and/or equitable damages, to be paid to the estates and/or to herself. Thirdly, Mrs O’Meara seeks an account of profits for the benefits that she claims have been derived by John and his family. Finally, Mrs O’Meara seeks a declaration that John is unfit to act as trustee or executor of either of the estates of Fred and Gwen.Principles to be applied

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

At the directions hearing on 17 August 2007, the parties indicated that the ultimate position was, in essence, that the judgment of the Full Court had not disclosed any reasoning that would, prima facie, operate to render the remaining grounds of appeal redundant. I heard argument on the remaining grounds of appeal on 29 August 2007.Appeal against orders and judgment of Master The outstanding grounds of appeal are as follows:1. The Learned Master:1.1 erred in that he refused, or failed, to strike out each of paragraphs 12, 12.1, 13, 14, 21, 22, 23, 24, 26.3, 32.4-32.9, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 39, 40, 41, 42, 59, 66, 66.1, 67, 69, 70 and 71 of the Amended Contribution Notice on the ground that each constituted or included a statement of conclusions based on unpleaded material facts; alternatively, the Learned Master ought to have ordered the pleading of material facts; and1.2 ought to have struck out each of these paragraphs for non-compliance with the Rules as to pleadings, and as tending to cause prejudice, embarrassment and delay in the proceedings.2. The Learned Master:2.1 erred in refusing, or failing, to strike out each of paragraphs 12.3, 12.4, 12.5, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22.5, 30, 31, 32.1, 32.2, 32.3, 32.4, 32.5, 32.6, 32.7, 32.8, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, 47, 48, 49, 50, 41, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58 and 66.2.1 of the Amended Contribution Notice as being frivolous or vexatious;2.2 ought to have struck out those paragraphs for non-compliance with the Rules as to pleadings, and as amounting to an abuse of process, and tending to cause prejudice embarrassment and delay in the proceedings.3. The Learned Master:3.1 erred in that he refused, or failed, to strike out each of paragraphs 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 30, 31, 32, 32.1, 32.2, 32.3, 32.4 and 66.1 of the Amended Contribution Notice on the ground that each constituted or included a statement of evidence rather than a pleading of material facts, thereby creating false issues and permitting a use of the Rules for the purposes inimical to the orderly administration of justice, and to the detriment of just and efficient conduct of the trial; and 3.2 ought to have struck out each of these paragraphs for non-compliance with the Rules as to pleadings, and as amounting to an abuse of process, and tending to cause prejudice embarrassment and delay in the proceedings. Alternatively the Learned Master ought to have ordered the pleading of material facts.5. The Learned Master:5.1 erred in refusing, or failing to strike out paragraphs 67, 68, 69, 70 and 71 of the Amended Contribution Notice; and5.2 ought to have struck out those paragraphs as disclosing no reasonable cause of action. The first three grounds of appeal challenge particular paragraphs of the Amended Contribution Notice as being contrary to r 46A of the Supreme Court Rules 1987. Several of the paragraphs are challenged under more than one ground. Consequently, I will consider each paragraph of the Amended Contribution Notice subject to the appeal in turn. Before doing that, however, it is necessary to consider the gravamen of the allegations contained in the Amended Contribution Notice, and to identify the principles to be applied to the pleadings. Background to Amended Contribution Notice

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.