Makasa v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection
Link copied
CaseCopied
40 min read
Full text
FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Makasa v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 1639
File number(s):
NSD 2053 of 2017
Judge(s):
BURLEY J
Date of judgment:
31 October 2018
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – s 501 of Migration Act 1958 (Cth) – prior criminal convictions led to failure of character test and cancellation of visa – whether there was legal unreasonableness in the decision of the Minister
Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Category:
Catchwords
Number of paragraphs:
55
Counsel for the Applicant:
Mr J Donnelly with Mr A Ahmad
Solicitor for the Applicant:
Morning Star Legal and Migration Services
Counsel for the Respondent:
Mr D Hughes
Solicitor for the Respondent:
Sparke Helmore
ORDERS
NSD 2053 of 2017
BETWEEN:
LIKUMBO MAKASA
Applicant
AND:
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION
Respondent
JUDGE:
BURLEY J
DATE OF ORDER:
31 OCTOBER 2018
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The application for review be dismissed.
2.The applicant pay the respondent’s costs.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
1 INTRODUCTION
[1]
2 BACKGROUND
[3]
3 THE MINISTER’S DECISION
[9]
4 STATUTORY FRAMEWORK
[24]
5 THE GROUNDS OF REVIEW
[27]
6 GROUND 1 – LEGAL UNREASONABLENESS
[28]
6.1 The arguments
[28]
6.2 Relevant principles
[33]
6.3 Consideration
[35]
7 GROUND 2: NO POWER
[50]
8 DISPOSITION
[55]
[]
BURLEY J:
1. INTRODUCTION
The applicant, Mr Likumbo Makasa, seeks judicial review of a decision of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Minister) made under s 501(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (Act) to cancel his Class BS Subclass 801 Partner (Residence) Visa.
At the hearing of the application, Mr Makasa, who was represented by Mr J Donnelly of counsel, sought leave to rely on an Amended Originating Application for Review. The Minister, who was represented by Mr D Hughes of counsel, did not oppose the grant of leave and the hearing proceeded on the basis of the two grounds that were raised therein. Both grounds contend that the decision of the Minister was vitiated by reason of jurisdictional error. The first on the basis that the decision was legally unreasonable, the second on the basis that the Minister misconstrued the statutory…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Makasa v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:
In the Federal Court of Australia, Makasa sought judicial review of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection's decision to cancel his visa. The decision to cancel was based on Makasa's substantial criminal record, which included convictions for domestic violence, driving offences, sexual intercourse with a minor, and a failure to report offence. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Minister's decision was legally unreasonable. Makasa argued that the Minister had failed to properly consider his prospects for rehabilitation, the strength of his ties to Australia, and the hardship that would be imposed on his family if he were to be removed from Australia.
The court considered whether the Minister's decision was so unreasonable that no reasonable person could have made it. The court found that the Minister had considered the relevant factors, including the seriousness of Makasa's criminal history, the risk of reoffending, and the best interests of Makasa's children. The court noted that the Minister had found that Makasa represented an ongoing likelihood of non-sexual reoffending, despite acknowledging that he was a low risk of sexual reoffending. The court concluded that the Minister's decision was not so unreasonable as to be outside the scope of the statutory powers. The court also rejected Makasa's argument that the Minister had misconstrued the statutory operation of s 501 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The court found that the Minister had properly considered the relevant factors and had made a decision that was within the scope of the statutory powers.
The application for review was dismissed, and Makasa was ordered to pay the Minister's costs. The court found that the Minister's decision to cancel Makasa's visa was not legally unreasonable and was within the scope of the statutory powers. The court noted that the Minister had considered the relevant factors, including the seriousness of Makasa's criminal history, the risk of reoffending, and the best interests of Makasa's children. The court also found that the Minister had properly considered the strength of Makasa's ties to Australia and the hardship that would be imposed on his family if he were to be removed from Australia. The court concluded that the Minister's decision was not so unreasonable as to be outside the scope of the statutory powers.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The application for review be dismissed.
2. The applicant pay the respondent’s costs.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
At the hearing of the application, Mr Makasa, who was represented by Mr J Donnelly of counsel, sought leave to rely on an Amended Originating Application for Review. The Minister, who was represented by Mr D Hughes of counsel, did not oppose the grant of leave and the hearing proceeded on the basis of the two grounds that were raised therein. Both grounds contend that the decision of the Minister was vitiated by reason of jurisdictional error. The first on the basis that the decision was legally unreasonable, the second on the basis that the Minister misconstrued the statutory operation of s 501 of the Act and thereby misconceived the nature of the function that he was to perform. 2. BACKGROUND Mr Makasa is a citizen of the Republic of Zambia. He arrived in Australia in 2001 on a student visa when he was 18 years of age. He has committed a number of offences since his arrival in Australia. In 2005, he was convicted of three counts of common assault against his former partner, for which he was sentenced to a good behaviour bond for 18 months on each count. In 2006, he was convicted of negligent driving, driving with a high range prescribed concentration of alcohol (PCA) and driving without a licence. In 2009, Mr Makasa was found guilty of three charges under s 66C(3) of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW) (Crimes Act) of having had sexual intercourse on 31 August 2006 with a female over the age of 14 and under the age of 16 years (the underage sex offence) for which he was sentenced to two years’ imprisonment with a non-parole period of one year. It was accepted that Mr Makasa did not use violence or coercion with respect to these offences and the trial judge commented that the jury’s verdict did not go so far as to support a finding that the complainant had not consented to having sex with Mr Makasa. The initial conviction was also for aggravated sexual assault under s 61J of the Crimes Act, but this was quashed by the NSW Court of Criminal Appeal on 8 October 2010. The Crown lodged an appeal on the basis that the sentence was manifestly inadequate, but it was dismissed by the NSW Court of Criminal Appeal. Mr Makasa then appealed his three convictions under s 66C(3) of the Crimes Act. His application for an extension of time to appeal in relation to these offences was refused by the NSW Court of Criminal Appeal on 14 August 2015. In 2011, a delegate of the Minister cancelled Mr Makasa’s Visa under s 501(2) of the Act. That decision was ultimately set aside by the AAT on 8 November 2013 (the 2013 AAT decision), following a successful judicial review of the 2011 decision in this Court before Perram J, whose decision was upheld on appeal by the Full Federal Court of Australia (Jacobson, Siopis and Murphy JJ). On 24 January 2017, Mr Makasa was convicted of failing to comply with reporting obligations (failure to report offence) and was fined $300 (Mr Makasa is obliged to report to police until discharged in 2025). This related to Mr Makasa’s failure to advise the police in a timely fashion that he had downloaded the social media application “Snapchat” which he used to communicate with his daughter. The Magistrate noted that, on any view, his conduct fell at the very lowest end of the range of sentencing for such an offence and imposed a very modest fine to ensure that he knew in future that he has a time limit within which to report actions of this nature.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Mr Makasa instituted proceedings in this Court on 21 November 2017 against the Minster’s decision pursuant to s 476A(1)(c) of the Act. 3. THE MINISTER’S DECISION In the Statement of Reasons for Cancellation of Visa, the Minister states that Mr Makasa does not pass the character test defined by s 501(6) of the Act because he has a substantial criminal record, as defined by s 501(7)(c) of the Act, and that Mr Makasa has not satisfied the Minister that he passes the character test. The Minister elected not to exercise his discretion not to cancel Mr Makasa’s Visa, taking into account the following matters: protecting the Australian community; the risk to the Australian community; the best interests of minor children; Mr Makasa’s ties to Australia and the extent of impediments facing Mr Makasa should he be removed from Australia. In considering the Government’s commitment to protecting the Australian community from harm as a result of criminal activity by non-citizens, the Minister considered Mr Makasa’s criminal convictions as outlined above. He found the convictions for domestic violence and driving offences to be “serious”, and his conviction for sexual intercourse with a person under the age of 16 years to be “very serious” The Minister noted that at trial, Mr Makasa had been convicted of the more serious offence of “aggravated sexual assault”, but that this offence was quashed on appeal. That offence concerned events that took place on 30 August 2006. The conduct for which Mr Makasa was convicted took place during the following day. The Minister noted at [25] that he makes no findings in relation to the events of the evening of 30 August 2006 and has given this no weight in considering the seriousness of Mr Makasa’s conduct. The Minister then noted that on 24 January 2017 Mr Makasa was convicted of failing to comply with reporting obligations of his parole, for which he was fined $300. He took into account that this offence, which concerned the failure to advise the police in a timely fashion that he had downloaded a social medial application which he used to communicate with his daughter (who lives in Perth, Mr Makasa was located in Sydney), was noted by the Magistrate to be “at the very lowest end of the range” and warranted a “very modest fine”. The Minister also noted that on 3 May 2017 Mr Makasa was convicted of “drive with middle range PCA – 1st offence” for which he was disqualified from driving for 12 months and fined $1,200. The Minister then considered whether Mr Makasa poses a risk to the Australian community through reoffending. In this regard he took into account the following matters:(1)That the majority of Mr Makasa’s offending, including his most serious offending occurred when he was in his early 20s and he is now 34 ([30]);(2)That alcohol has been a factor in Mr Makasa’s criminal conduct to date. He stated:[31]Alcohol has been a factor in Mr MAKASA’s criminal conduct to date. I note in 2005, Mr MAKASA caused a motor vehicle accident whilst under the influence of alcohol, and he has recently been convicted of a further drink driving offence in 2017. The trial judge presiding over Mr MAKASA’s sexual offences observed that Mr MAKASA had been drinking the evening prior to the sexual offences and highlighted his mother’s evidence that he was drinking a lot more than he should have at the time of the offences.(3)The Minister then noted that the trial judge in 2009 had found Mr Makasa to be a “very different person” from the person he was at the time of the offences in 2006, and that his Honour had found Mr Makasa had “good prospects for rehabilitation”, was “very unlikely to reoffend” and “highly likely” to lead a “fruitful and productive life” (at [32]). He noted that Mr Makasa had abided by his bail conditions and that he maintained satisfactory conduct whilst in prison and in immigration detention. He noted that the AAT record indicates that Mr Makasa participated in an offenders program organised by the Hillsong Church whilst in jail. The Minister accepted at [34] that this was “a step towards rehabilitation”. The Minister also noted (at [36]) that in 2013 the AAT had found Mr Makasa to be a “relatively low risk of reoffending”, that he had extremely strong family support, and that he had expressed genuine regret for having involved his family in the events arising from his offending. The AAT found that this would act as a substantial deterrent, and the Minister accepted that these experiences should have had a salutary effect on Mr Makasa. (4)The Minister also noted that Mr Makasa had been in the community for about three and a half years since his release from immigration detention after receiving a favourable outcome from the AAT in 2013, and takes into account that Mr Makasa has reoffended since then by committing the 2017 offences. (5)The Minister then accepted that the 2017 offences took place more than 10 years after his more serious offending in 2005 and 2006, that they did not involve violent or aggressive behaviour, and that they are relatively minor and did not attract any sentence of imprisonment. (1) In relation to the 2017 PCA offence the Minister said:[43]In relation to his most current conviction for drive with middle range PCA – 1st offence, I note Mr MAKASA states he takes full responsibility and that he believed he had let enough time pass and consumed enough water after drinking alcohol to enable him to drive. However, I also note that Mr MAKASA’s most recent offending involves drink driving in the mid-range, and I considered this is his second drink driving offence, albeit 11 years apart. I find the repeat drink driving offence demonstrates disregard for community safety and that further rehabilitative progress with respect to alcohol is required.(6)It is appropriate to set out the balance of the Minister’s reasons on the subject:[44] Mr MAKASA is now 34 years of age and I accept that his most serious conduct, the sexual offences, occurred approximately eleven years ago when he was aged in his early twenties. I have taken into account Mr MAKASA’s submissions regarding his offending and I note that in relation to the offences of sexual intercourse with a person above the age of 14 years and under the age of 16 years, Mr MAKASA states he takes full responsibility for his actions. I have also had regard to his expressed remorse in his statements.[45] I have considered the assessment made by Psychologist, Dr Peter Ashkar on 12 August 2013 regarding Mr MAKASA’s risk of recidivism. I note that he reported that Mr MAKASA does not constitute a serious risk to the Australian community and that Mr MAKASA’s offending was limited to three sequences of offences between November 2005 and August 2006. I also note he reports the offending occurred during a time when Mr MAKASA was consuming large amounts of alcohol to manage stress. He reported Mr MAKASA had matured considerably and had reduced his alcohol consumption. He concluded Mr MAKASA was not a violent man and did not have an antisocial personality or a juvenile offending history. Dr Ashkar considered these factors placed him at the low end of the spectrum in terms of violence risk. His risk of sexual recidivism was estimated to be nine percent over a five year period which he also believed to be an overestimate inflated by Mr MAKASA’s conviction for common assault.[46] I note that Dr Ashkar reported Mr MAKASA required treatment for significant symptoms of anxiety and depression to minimise his risk of sexual recidivism. He identified that Mr MAKASA also required psychological treatment for management of his negative mood to minimise the risk of recidivism and that he would benefit from psychological treatment to assist with management of aspects of his personality that contribute to poor regulation.[47] I have had regard to Dr Ashkar’s conclusion that Mr MAKASA has a strong prosocial orientation which is reflected in his commitment to ‘education, employment, family and church.’ He states that Mr MAKASA has strong cognitive resources and considerable vocational potential with further education which can lead to satisfying employment allowing him to make a positive contribution to the community.[48] I have had regard to Mr MAKASA’s present circumstances which include his focus on trying to ‘better himself’ and ensuring that he provides support to his family and in particular his children. I note Mr MAKASA sought counselling and support through church groups and has contacted groups such as Beyond Blue and Mensline for assistance. Mr MAKASA also receives ongoing support from Pastor Alosio from the Hillsong Church who has been a support person for Mr MAKASA. I note that Mr MAKASA has attended a men’s support group which assists individuals who have been in prison or immigration custody in reintegrating back into society and becoming productive members of the community. I accept this may assist Mr MAKASA in his ongoing rehabilitation.(7)The Minister’s conclusion at [49] is significant to the grounds of review advanced by Mr Makasa. It provides:[49] Taking the above matters into account, I acknowledge that Mr MAKASA is a low risk of sexual reoffending, however I find Mr MAKASA to represent an ongoing likelihood of non-sexual reoffending. I find that Mr MAKASA’s ongoing family support, his past term of imprisonment and visa cancellation matters have not had the deterrent effect considered by the AAT, and I therefore view his long term prospects with some caution. While Mr MAKASA’s recent offences are less serious, I am concerned that he still requires further progress with respect to alcohol rehabilitation. If Mr MAKASA were to commit further sexual offences against a minor he could cause very serious physical and psychological harm to a member of the Australian community. If Mr MAKASA were to commit further domestic violence there is a risk he may cause physical harm or psychological harm to members of the Australian community. If Mr Makasa were to commit further driving offences whilst under the influence of alcohol there is a risk he could cause an accident resulting in physical harm or financial loss to members of the Australian community.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Minister then considered the strength, nature and duration of Mr Makasa’s ties to Australia. This included the fact that Mr Makasa has resided in Australia for approximately 16 years. He has been employed in Australia since his arrival and his regular employment has enabled him to support his family and make a contribution to the Australian community through the taxation system. He also has ties to the community through his association with the Hillsong Church in Sydney, which the Minister recognised as a positive connection to the community. The Minister acknowledges that Mr Makasa’s partner and step-daughter are Australian citizens; he plans to marry and start a family with his partner, who has demonstrated longstanding support for him, including through his court proceedings and immigration detention; his children and former partner are in Perth; and that he has a relationship with his mother and step-father who also reside in Australia. The Minister accepted that Mr Makasa’s immediate family in Australia, particularly his partner, mother and step-father, would experience emotional hardship, psychological hardship and some financial hardship if he were removed from Australia. The Minister then considered the impediments that Mr Makasa will face if removed from Australia to Zambia in establishing himself and maintaining basic living standards in the context of what is generally available to other citizens of Zambia. He notes Mr Makasa’s submission that since coming to Australia he has kept very little contact with Zambia and concludes:[95]While I accept that Mr MAKASA’s immediate family reside in Australia, I am also aware that Mr MAKASA does have extended family in Zambia. I note that he has an aunt who resides in Zambia and while he does not have a relationship with her and while the support of his extended family in Zambia may be limited it will go some way to assisting with his adjustment to life in Zambia. Nonetheless given the economic situation in Zambia, and taking into account Mr MAKASA’s skills and employment prospects I accept that he will face practical and financial hardship in adjusting to life in Zambia. Taking the above-mentioned matters into account, the Minister concludes:[99] In considering whether or not to cancel Mr MAKASA’s visa, I gave primary consideration to the best interests of Mr MAKASA’s two minor Australian citizen children, Tiana Fredericks and Rashon Makasa and his minor Australian citizen stepdaughter Mena Rhodes and found that their best interests would be served by not cancelling the visa.[100] Mr MAKASA has committed a very serious crime, that of sexual intercourse with a person above the age of 14 years and under the age of 16 years, which is of a sexual nature, and involved a vulnerable member of the community, that being a minor, and Mr MAKASA and non-citizens who commit such an offence should not generally expect to be permitted to remain in Australia.[101] I find that the Australian community could be exposed to great harm should Mr MAKASA reoffend in a similar fashion. I could not rule out the possibility of further offending by Mr MAKASA. The Australian community should not tolerate any further risk of harm.[102] I found the above consideration outweighed the countervailing considerations in Mr MAKASA’s case, including the best interests of the child, being his two children and stepdaughter, treated as a primary consideration and the impact on family members. I have also considered the length of time Mr MAKASA has made a positive contribution to the Australian community, taking into account that he has lived in Australia for some 16 years.[103] I find that in Mr MAKASA's case the risk of further harm is of such a seriousness that even the strong countervailing considerations outlined above are insufficient for me not to cancel the visa.[104] In reaching my decision I concluded that Mr MAKASA represents an unacceptable risk of harm to the Australian community and that the protection of the Australian community outweighed any countervailing considerations above.4. STATUTORY FRAMEWORK