Maio v City of Stirling [No 2]

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT :   THE COURT OF APPEAL (WA)

CITATION:   MAIO -v- CITY OF STIRLING [No 2] [2016] WASCA 45

CORAM:   MARTIN CJ

BUSS JA
MURPHY JA

HEARD:   27 JANUARY 2016

DELIVERED          :   16 MARCH 2016

FILE NO/S:   CACV 92 of 2015

BETWEEN:   GIROLAMO MAIO

First-named First Appellant

GLENYS JOY MAIO
Second-named First Appellant

JVR PTY LTD
Second Appellant

LINEMARK INVESTMENTS PTY LTD
Third Appellant

THE OWNERS OF STIRLING VILLAGE STRATA PLAN NO 11718
Fourth Appellant

AND

CITY OF STIRLING
First Respondent

VALMARL PTY LTD
First-named Second Respondent

PETER GRAHAM HEARN
Second-named Second Respondent

BANK OF QUEENSLAND
Third Respondent

RAINWAVE NOMINEES PTY LTD
Fourth Respondent

ON APPEAL FROM:

Jurisdiction              :  SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Coram  :LE MIERE J

Citation  :MAIO -v- CITY OF STIRLING [No 2] [2015] WASC 189

File No  :CIV 2706 of 2013

Catchwords:

Deed - Proper construction - Party claiming benefit of deed not a party to the deed - Claimed entitlement to enforce deed by virtue of s 11(2) of the Property Law Act 1969 (WA) - Proprietary rights allegedly conferred on the non­party - Alleged proprietary rights by way of easement for car parking - Easements - Easements by prescription - Doctrine of lost modern grant - Whether use of neighbouring property 'as of right'

Legislation:

Prescription Act 1832 (UK)
Property Law Act 1969 (WA), s 11(2)
Town Planning and Development Act 1928 (WA), s 7, s 24
Transfer of Land Act 1893 (WA), s 63A, s 65(3), s 69

Result:

Appeal dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

First-named First Appellant   :     Mr J Thomson SC

Second-named First Appellant    :    Mr J Thomson SC

Second Appellant          :     Mr J Thomson SC

Third Appellant             :     Mr J Thomson SC

Fourth Appellant            :     Mr J Thomson SC

First Respondent           :     Mr K Pettit SC & Mr P Wittkuhn

First-named Second Respondent     :        Mr D Jackson

Second-named Second Respondent         :        Mr D Jackson

Third Respondent          :     No appearance

Fourth Respondent        :     No appearance

Solicitors:

First-named First Appellant   :     Haydn Robinson

Second-named First Appellant    :    Haydn Robinson

Second Appellant          :     Haydn Robinson

Third Appellant             :     Haydn Robinson

Fourth Appellant            :     Haydn Robinson

First Respondent           :     McLeods Barristers & Solicitors

First-named Second Respondent     :        Hotchkin Hanly Lawyers

Second-named Second Respondent         :        Hotchkin Hanly Lawyers

Third Respondent          :     No appearance

Fourth Respondent        :     Hotchkin Hanly Lawyers

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Attorney‑General v Simpson [1901] 2 Ch 671

Bakewell Management Ltd v Brandwood [2004] 2 AC 519

Codelfa Construction Pty Ltd v State Rail Authority of New South Wales [1982] HCA 24; (1982) 149 CLR 337

Dalton v Henry Angus & Co (1881) 6 App Cas 740

Delohery v Permanent Trustee Co of New South Wales [1904] HCA 10; (1904) 1 CLR 283

Gardner v Hodgson's Kingston Brewery Co Ltd [1903] AC 229

Kitching v Phillips [2011] WASCA 19; (2011) 278 ALR 551

KPMG LLP v Network Rail Infrastructure Ltd [2007] EWCA Civ 363

Maio v City of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Maio v City of Stirling [No 2] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] WASCA 45
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter of Maio v City of Stirling [No 2] involved a dispute between Mr and Mrs Maio, who owned a supermarket, and the City of Stirling, regarding the alleged existence of an easement for car parking on a neighbouring property. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The Maios sought to enforce a deed executed in 2010 by virtue of section 11(2) of the Property Law Act 1969 (WA), which they claimed conferred upon them proprietary rights in the form of an easement. The City of Stirling disputed the existence of any such easement, arguing that the use of the neighbouring property was not "as of right" and therefore could not form the basis of an easement by prescription or lost modern grant.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Maios had established the existence of an easement by prescription or lost modern grant over the neighbouring property for car parking purposes. The court also had to determine whether the use of the neighbouring property was "as of right" and if the 2010 deed constituted a contract under section 11(2) of the Property Law Act. The Maios argued that they had established the elements necessary to demonstrate the existence of an easement by virtue of the doctrine of lost modern grant or prescription, except for the point regarding the use of the neighbouring property "as of right." The City of Stirling contested the claim, asserting that the use was not "as of right" and thus could not form the basis of an easement.

The court found that the 2010 deed was indeed executed as a deed, and the City had not contended that the deed was not a contract within the meaning of section 11(2) of the Property Law Act. The judge accepted that the Maios had established the elements necessary for the existence of an easement by virtue of the doctrine of lost modern grant or prescription, except for the requirement that the use of the neighbouring property occurred "as of right." The court held that the Maios had not established this element, and thus the claim for an easement by prescription or lost modern grant failed. Consequently, the Maios' appeal was dismissed, and the City of Stirling's cross-appeal was allowed. The court found that the use of the neighbouring property was not "as of right" and that the development approval of August 1986 required the owner of lot 604 to "maintain" reciprocal parking and access rights, not create them. The court also held that the development approval did not create reciprocal rights but referred to rights derived from the 1983 deed.

In light of the court's decision, the final orders were that the Maios' appeal was dismissed with costs. The City of Stirling's cross-appeal was allowed, and the judgment of the primary judge was affirmed with costs. The court ruled that there was no easement by prescription or lost modern grant in favour of the Maios over the neighbouring property for car parking purposes.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The 2010 deed was executed as a deed. There is no mention of consideration provided by the City. Section 11(2) of the PLA applies to 'a contract'. The second respondent did not contend, either in this court or below, that the 2010 deed was not a 'contract' within the meaning of s 11(2) of the PLA.[47][47] cf The Bell Group (in liq) v Westpac Banking Corporation [No 9] and [No 10] [2008] WASC 239; (2008) 39 WAR 1 [3351] ‑ [3373]. Subject to one point the subject of grounds 3A and 3B, the judge found that the appellants had established the elements necessary to demonstrate the existence of an easement by virtue of the doctrine of lost modern grant or prescription.[48][48] Primary reasons [51] ‑ [73]. The easement which the judge found could have been established but for the point under appeal, was related to an area which he described as the 'Use Area' and related to the use of the Use Area for access, egress and parking by occupiers of and visitors to the supermarket in favour of the registered proprietors of the land on which the supermarket was situated, ie, Mr and Mrs Maio.[49][49] Primary reasons [67]. The point on which the appellants failed was that they had not established that the use of the Use Area occurred 'as of right'.[50] In ground 3A, the appellants contend that his Honour made findings relevant to the subjective state of mind of the owners of lot 604 and of Mr and Mrs Maio when those matters were not litigated. The appellants contend that his Honour found that:(a)the owners of Lot 604 during the period of the service station allowed the use of the Use Area because they understood that they were obliged to do so by the terms of their development consent; and(b)the Maios believed that they and their customers were entitled to use the Use Area by reason of the reciprocal rights contained in the development consent for the service station.[51] (emphasis added)[51] Substituted appellants' submissions, par 72; WB 25 ‑ 26. In ground 3B, the appellants contend that the judge implicitly found that the development approval of August 1986 created reciprocal parking and access rights, whereas on its proper construction, it required the owner of lot 604 to 'maintain' reciprocal parking and access rights. It is alleged that par 6 of the development approval was, in its context, properly construed as a reference to the 1983 deed, and that the rights referred to in the development approval were rights derived from the 1983 deed. For the purpose of considering this ground, it is useful to set out the following relevant passages of the development approval:[52][52] GB 91.Approval to commence development in accordance with the Application dated 15 JUL 1986 is granted subject to the Schedule of Conditions specified hereunder.This approval is valid for a period of two years only. If development is not completed within this period, a fresh approval must be obtained before commencing or continuing development.…Should the applicant be aggrieved by this decision, a right of appeal may exist pursuant to the provisions of Clause 33 of the Metropolitan Region Scheme or Clause 1.6 of the City of Stirling District Planning Scheme No 2, as the case may be. Such an appeal shall be made in accordance with Part V of the Town Planning and Development Act 1928 (as amended).SCHEDULE OF CONDITIONS…3The Service Station being constructed in the same materials and in a similar design as the adjoining Shopping Centre.4All access to the site to be via Sanderling Street. Egress only to Cedric Street in accordance with the City Engineer's requirements.5The extension of the island in Cedric Street south past the egress point with associated road widening to the satisfaction of the City Engineer.6.Reciprocal parking and access rights with the adjoining Shopping Centre to be maintained. No boundary fencing to be erected between the Service Station and Shopping Centre.