Maio v City of Stirling [No 3]

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   MAIO -v- CITY OF STIRLING [No 3] [2018] WASC 276

CORAM:   LE MIERE J

HEARD:   11 DECEMBER 2017

DELIVERED          :   21 SEPTEMBER 2018

FILE NO/S:   CIV 2706 of 2013

MATTER: Section 140 of the Transfer of Land Act 1893

BETWEEN:   GIROLAMO MAIO

GLENYS JOY MAIO

First Plaintiffs

JVR PTY LTD

Second Plaintiff

LINEMARK INVESTMENTS PTY LTD

Third Plaintiff

AND

CITY OF STIRLING

First Defendant

VALMARL PTY LTD

PETER GRAHAM HEARN

Second Defendants

BANK OF QUEENSLAND LTD

Third Defendant

RAINWAVE NOMINEES PTY LTD

Fourth Defendant

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1447 of 2017

BETWEEN:   VALMARL PTY LTD

First Plaintiff

STEPHEN PATRICK HAUVILLE

KERRIE MARIA HAUVILLE

Second Plaintiffs

PETER GRAHAM HEARN

Third Plaintiff

SILVERVIEW HOLDINGS PTY LTD

Fourth Plaintiff

PRISTINE LAKES PTY LTD

Fifth Plaintiff

AND

GIROLAMO MAIO

GLENYS JOY MAIO

Defendants


Catchwords:

Real property - Lodgement and maintenance of covenants - Application for compensation pursuant to s 140 Transfer of Land Act 1893 (WA) - Application for compensation pursuant to undertaking as to damages - Whether caveats lodged without reasonable cause - Existence of honest belief that caveator had caveatable interest

Legislation:

Prescription Act 1832 (WA)
Property law Act 1969 (WA), s 11
Supreme Court Act 1935 (WA), s 32
Transfer of Land Act 1893 (WA), s 138B, s 140

Result:

Application allowed in part

Category:    B

Representation:

CIV 2706 of 2013

Counsel:

First Plaintiffs : Mr H R Robinson
Second Plaintiff : No appearance
Third Plaintiff : No appearance
First Defendant : No appearance
Second Defendants : Mr M C Hotchkin & Mr L Whitehurst
Third Defendant : No appearance
Fourth Defendant : No appearance

Solicitors:

First Plaintiffs : Haydn Robinson
Second Plaintiff : No appearance
Third Plaintiff : No appearance
First Defendant : No appearance
Second Defendants : Hotchkin Hanly
Third Defendant : No appearance
Fourth Defendant : No appearance

CIV 1447 of 2017

Counsel:

First Plaintiff : Mr M C Hotchkin & Mr L Whitehurst
Second Plaintiffs : Mr M C Hotchkin & Mr L Whitehurst
Third Plaintiff : Mr M C Hotchkin & Mr L Whitehurst
Fourth Plaintiff : Mr M C Hotchkin & Mr L Whitehurst
Fifth Plaintiff : Mr M C Hotchkin & Mr L Whitehurst
Defendants : Mr H R Robinson

Solicitors:

First Plaintiff : Hotchkin Hanly
Second Plaintiffs : Hotchkin Hanly
Third Plaintiff : Hotchkin Hanly
Fourth Plaintiff : Hotchkin Hanly
Fifth Plaintiff : Hotchkin Hanly
Defendants : Haydn Robinson

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Air Express Ltd v Ansett Transport Industries (Operations) Pty Ltd (1981) 146 CLR 249

Bedford Properties Pty Ltd v Surgo Pty Ltd [1981] 1 NSWLR 106

Bolton v Excell (Unreported, WASCA, Library No 930175, 22 February 1993)

Brogue Tableau Pty Ltd v Binningup Nominees Pty Ltd (2007) 35 WAR 27

European Bank Ltd v Evans (2010) 240 CLR 432

European Bank v Evans (2010) 240 CLR 432

Maio v City of Stirling [2015] WASCA 254

Maio v City of Stirling [No 2] [2015] WASC 189

Maio v City of Stirling…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Maio v City of Stirling [No 3] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] WASC 276
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Maio v City of Stirling [No 3], the applicants, Mr and Mrs Maio, sought compensation for damages they claimed were caused by the lodgement of caveats on a property. The respondents, the City of Stirling, opposed the application on the grounds that the caveats were lodged without reasonable cause. The applicants sought compensation under section 140 of the Transfer of Land Act 1893 (WA) and an undertaking as to damages. The central issue was whether the applicants could demonstrate a causal nexus between the lodgement of the caveats and the damages claimed. This required establishing that the applicants sustained specific damage, that the damage was caused by the lodgement of the caveats, that the damage was reasonably foreseeable, and that it was just to award compensation.

The applicants argued that they would have sold the property by 30 October 2014 if not for the caveats, and the delay caused them financial loss. They relied on the evidence of Mr Betlehem, who claimed that the caveats prevented him from raising necessary finance and that he would have settled the sale if not for the caveats. However, the court found Mr Betlehem's evidence to be unreliable and unsubstantiated. The court concluded that it was unlikely that Mr Betlehem and Rainwave would have completed the contract for sale on or about 30 October 2014, or at any other date, regardless of the caveats. Therefore, the court was not satisfied that the applicants had proven the required causal link between the caveats and the claimed damages.

The court ultimately rejected the applicants' claim for compensation, finding that the applicants had not demonstrated that the damages claimed were caused by the lodgement of the caveats. The applicants' submissions regarding the necessity of proving a causal nexus were noted, but the court's assessment of the evidence led to the conclusion that the applicants' claims were not substantiated. As a result, the application for compensation was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Applicants' written submissions stated that in order to persuade the court that it is just to award compensation, the Applicants must satisfy the court of the causal nexus between the lodgement of the caveat and the damage said to have been suffered. The applicants referred to the reasons of Jenkins J in Westpoint Corporation Pty Ltd v Registrar of Titles [2005] WASC 273, where at [12] her Honour said that before the court orders compensation it should be satisfied of the following matters:1.that the applicant sustained the damage, as particularised;2.that the damage was caused by the lodgement of the caveat;3.that the damage was reasonably foreseeable as a consequence of the lodgement of the caveat; and4.it is otherwise just to order the compensation. The Applicants submitted that that analysis requires a counter-factual exercise as to what would have happened if no caveats had been lodged. The Applicants say that if the caveats had not been lodged they would have sold Lot 604 no later than 30 October 2014. Settlement of the sale of Lot 604 did not occur until 21 July 2016, that is about 21 months after the date it would have been sold if Mr and Mrs Maio had not lodged their caveats. The Applicants say that as a result of the delay they sustained damage by paying interest on loans, loan service fees, land taxes, rates, Water Corporation fees and a Land 360 Environmental fee for discharging a Contamination Memorandum which they would not have incurred if the caveats had not been lodged by Mr and Mrs Maio and Lot 604 had sold on 30 October 2014. That date is based upon the contract of sale to Rainwave being settled on or about that date. I am not satisfied, on the balance of probabilities, that the Rainwave contract would have settled on or about 30 October 2014 if Mr and Mrs Maio's caveats had not been lodged or had been withdrawn by that date. I have referred earlier in these reasons to the contract for sale of land by offer and acceptance signed on 8 August 2014 by which Rainwave offered to purchase Lot 604 for $2,500,000. The Applicants' contention that settlement of the sale to Rainwave would have occurred on or about 30 October 2014 if the caveats had not been lodged and maintained rests on the evidence of Mr Betlehem. Mr Betlehem was the sole member, director and secretary of Rainwave. Mr Betlehem had undertaken a number of development projects prior to 2009. In 2009 he became bankrupt. He did not successfully complete any development project after that. Rainwave had a paid capital of $1. Rainwave was described by Mr Betlehem as a special purpose vehicle for a proposed development on Lot 604. Mr Betlehem did not claim to have any assets. Indeed he had packed up everything he owned and placed it into a sea container. There is no evidence that he had the capacity to borrow the funds necessary to complete the sale and undertake the development of Lot 604. The evidence is that he did not. Mr Betlehem gave evidence that he had approached investors about entering into joint venture agreements to undertake the project and had had some discussions with joint venture parties. Mr Betlehem claimed that the caveats lodged by Mr and Mrs Maio prevented him from raising the necessary finance and that he would have been able to do so if it had not been for the caveats. Mr Betlehem was an unimpressive and unreliable witness. At times he was belligerent and argumentative. His evidence that the caveats lodged by Mr and Mrs Maio prevented him from raising the necessary finance and that, if it had not been for the caveats, he would have been able to do so and would have settled the sale and proceeded with the project was unsubstantiated assertion. His evidence about the potential investors was nebulous. I am not satisfied that Rainwave would have completed the contract for sale on or about 30 October 2014 if the first caveat did not prevent dealings with the property. To the contrary, it is more likely than not that Mr Betlehem and Rainwave would not have completed the contract of sale on or about 30 October 2014, or on some other date, whether or not the caveats had been lodged and maintained.