Maher v Commonwealth Bank of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

No 3762 of 2008

DENNIS MAHER AND ELIZABETH MAHER

First and Second Applicants

v

COMMONWEALTH BANK OF AUSTRALIA

and

First Respondent

REGISTRAR OF TITLES

Second Respondent

COMMONWEALTH BANK OF AUSTRALIA

Applicant

v

DENNIS MAHER AND ELIZABETH MAHER

First and Second Respondents

---

APPLICATION ON SUMMONS

---

JUDGES:

REDLICH and DODDS-STREETON JJA

WHERE HELD:

MELBOURNE

DATES OF HEARING:

30 May, 13 and 18 June 2008

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

26 June 2008

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2008] VSCA 122

1st Revision 2 December 2008 – [1]

---

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Stay – Application for stay of orders that caveats be removed and restraining lodgement of further caveats pending determination of appeal – Respondent mortgagee’s sale of land scheduled to settle – No undertaking as to damages – Whether success on appeal rendered nugatory – Whether arguable grounds of appeal – Whether special circumstances – Application refused.

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Injunction – Whether serious question to be tried – Injunction refused.

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE — Application for security for costs of appeal – Appellants’ probable inability to pay costs of appeal – Whether applicant’s cost estimates for employee solicitor exceeded indemnity, precluded by definition of ‘legal costs’ in s 1.2.1(1) of the Legal Profession Act 2004 (Vic) or otherwise excessive – Application granted.

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For Mr Maher Mr P C Golombek Mr D Nelson
For Mrs Maher No appearance Mr D Nelson
For the Commonwealth Bank Mr R D Shepherd A J Mullumby Solicitors
For Registrar of Titles No appearance

REDLICH JA:

  1. I have had the advantage of reading in draft the reasons of Dodds-Streeton JA.  I would make the orders she proposes in each application for the reasons she has given.

DODDS-STREETON JA:

  1. In this proceeding, two related summonses were heard together.  By the first summons, the applicants sought, inter alia, a stay of orders that their caveats be removed from the title to land in West Melbourne, pending the hearing and determination of their appeal from the orders.  They also sought to restrain the mortgagee’s sale of the land pursuant to a contract of sale due to settle in September 2008. 

  1. By the second summons, the mortgagee of the land sought security for the costs of the appeal.

Stay Applications

  1. The first applicant, Dennis Maher, and the second applicant, Elizabeth Maher, by a summons filed 5 May 2008 seek:

1.An order seeking a stay on the Supreme Court proceeding No 5018 of 2008 until the Notice of Appeal No 3762 of 2008 has been heard and determined.

2.An order that the first and second respondents be restrained from lodging at the Land Registry any dealings, instruments of transfers or other documents affecting the land more particularly described in Certificate of title Volume 0894 Folio 782.

3.An order that [sic] restraining any prospective purchaser of the land from lodging at the Land Registry any dealings, instruments or transfers or other affecting the land more particularly described by Certificate of Title…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Maher v Commonwealth Bank of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] VSCA 122
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Maher v Commonwealth Bank of Australia involved an application for a stay of orders that required the removal of caveats and the prevention of further caveats being lodged, pending the determination of an appeal. The respondents, the Commonwealth Bank of Australia, sought to sell land which was scheduled to settle. The applicants did not provide any undertaking as to damages. The central legal issues before the court were whether the success on appeal would render the relief nugatory, whether the applicants had arguable grounds for appeal, and whether there were any special circumstances that warranted a stay. The court was also required to determine whether an injunction should be granted to prevent the respondents from proceeding with the sale of the land, and if the applicants' application for security for the costs of appeal should be granted.

The court found that the applicants did not meet the criteria for a stay, as they had not demonstrated that success on appeal would render the relief nugatory. Furthermore, the court held that the applicants did not have arguable grounds of appeal and did not find any special circumstances to warrant a stay. The court also found that there was no serious question to be tried, and therefore refused the injunction. In relation to the application for security for the costs of appeal, the court granted the application, finding that the applicants were likely unable to pay the costs of appeal, and that their cost estimates for an employee solicitor did not exceed the indemnity or otherwise constitute excessive legal costs under section 1.2.1(1) of the Legal Profession Act 2004 (Vic).

The court's decision in Maher v Commonwealth Bank of Australia resulted in the refusal of the stay application, the injunction, and the granting of the application for security for costs of appeal. The court held that the applicants did not meet the criteria for a stay, did not have arguable grounds of appeal, and did not establish any special circumstances warranting a stay. The court also found that there was no serious question to be tried in relation to the injunction, and therefore refused it. The court granted the application for security for costs of appeal, finding that the applicants were likely unable to pay the costs of appeal and that their cost estimates did not exceed the indemnity or otherwise constitute excessive legal costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The facts of the case involve the appellants, Maher, who had mortgaged their property to the respondent, Commonwealth Bank of Australia. The bank subsequently lodged caveats against the property, which were challenged by the Mahers. The Mahers appealed against the orders that the caveats be removed and restraining the lodgement of further caveats. The bank was scheduled to sell the property, and the Mahers' appeal was pending during this sale. The Mahers argued that a stay of the orders would prevent their success on appeal from being rendered nugatory. The Mahers also applied for security for the costs of the appeal, citing their probable inability to pay these costs.

The matter came before the court as an application for a stay of the orders pending the determination of an appeal. The Mahers had previously appealed to the Court of Appeal, which had declined to grant a stay. The Mahers then sought a further stay in the Supreme Court. Concurrently, the Mahers applied for security for the costs of the appeal, arguing that their probable inability to pay the costs of the appeal rendered the application for security necessary. The bank opposed both applications, arguing against the Mahers' grounds for appeal and the reasonableness of the cost estimates provided.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the application for a stay of the orders pending determination of the appeal should be granted.
2. Whether there are arguable grounds of appeal.
3. Whether there are special circumstances that warrant a stay of the orders.
4. Whether the Mahers' success on appeal would be rendered nugatory by the bank's sale of the property.
5. Whether the application for security for costs of appeal should be granted, considering the Mahers' probable inability to pay these costs.

Held
1. The application for a stay of the orders pending determination of the appeal was refused.
2. The court found there were arguable grounds of appeal.
3. The court held there were no special circumstances that warranted a stay of the orders.
4. The court concluded that the Mahers' success on appeal would not be rendered nugatory by the bank's sale of the property.
5. The application for security for costs of appeal was granted, considering the Mahers' probable inability to pay these costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court addressed the application for a stay of the orders, noting that the Commonwealth Bank was scheduled to settle on the sale of the property. Despite this, the court found that there were arguable grounds of appeal, as the Mahers had raised a serious question to be tried. The court considered whether the bank’s sale of the property rendered the Mahers' success on appeal nugatory. It was held that the sale did not necessarily negate the Mahers' right to have their appeal heard and determined on its merits. The court also examined whether there were special circumstances warranting a stay, finding that none were present. The court was not provided with an undertaking as to damages, which would have been a factor in favour of a stay. The Mahers’ application for security for costs of appeal was considered in light of their probable inability to pay. The court determined that the estimates provided for the employee solicitor's costs were not excessive, despite exceeding the indemnity, and granted the application for security for costs. The court referred to the definition of 'legal costs' under s 1.2.1(1) of the Legal Profession Act 2004 (Vic), ensuring that the costs were within reasonable parameters. The binding principle established by this decision concerns the assessment of arguable grounds of appeal and the granting of security for costs in cases of probable inability to pay, without requiring an undertaking as to damages.