Mitolo Wines Aust Pty Ltd v Vito Mitolo & Son Pty Ltd (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Mitolo Wines Aust Pty Ltd v Vito Mitolo & Son Pty Ltd (No 3) [2019] FCA 2116

File number: SAD 340 of 2016
Judge: BESANKO J
Date of judgment: 16 December 2019
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE — application for a stay of various orders pending the hearing and determination of an appeal to the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia — whether grounds of appeal are arguable — whether the applicants will be deprived of the full benefits of the judgment in their favour — whether the respondents will be deprived of fruits of their appeal if a stay is refused and the appeal is successful — where the respondents contend they will suffer non-financial prejudice — whether the appeal will be rendered nugatory — where the respondents have not offered security — where there was delay in the filing of the respondents’ application
Legislation:

Australian Consumer Law (Schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth))

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 36.08

Cases cited:

Alexander v Cambridge Credit Corp Ltd (1985) 2 NSWLR 685; (1985) 10 ACLR 42

Citrus Queensland Pty Ltd v Sunstate Orchards Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 1867

Maher v Commonwealth Bank of Australia [2008] VSCA 122

Mitolo Wines Aust Pty Ltd v Vito Mitolo & Son Pty Ltd [2019] FCA 902

Mitolo Wines Aust Pty Ltd v Vito Mitolo & Son Pty Ltd (No 2) [2019] FCA 1140

Powerflex Services Pty Ltd v Data Access Corp (1996) 67 FCR 65; (1996) 137 ALR 498

Wealthsure Pty Ltd v Selig [2013] FCA 628

Date of hearing: 27 November 2019
Registry: South Australia
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Trade Marks
Number of paragraphs: 72
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr P Bullock
Solicitor for the Applicants: Minicozzi Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr M Murphy
Solicitor for the Respondents: Georgiadis Lawyers

ORDERS

SAD 340 of 2016
BETWEEN:

MITOLO WINES AUST PTY LTD (ACN 089 233 312) AS TRUSTEE OF THE MITOLO WINE TRUST

First Applicant

MITOLO WINES PTY LTD (ACN 112 011 560)

Second Applicant

AND:

VITO MITOLO & SON PTY LTD (ACN 166 447 605)

First Respondent

VITO MITOLO

Second Respondent

ANTHONY MITOLO

Third Respondent

JUDGE:

BESANKO J

DATE OF ORDER:

16 DECEMBER 2019

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The operation of paragraphs 16–21 inclusive of the orders of the Court made on 25 July 2019 be suspended until further order. 

2.The respondents’ interlocutory application dated 8 November 2019 be otherwise dismissed.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

BESANKO J:

INTRODUCTION

  1. On 8 November 2019, the respondents to this proceeding filed an interlocutory application in which they seek an order for a stay of orders made by the Court on 25 July 2019 and 10 October 2019 pursuant to r 36.08 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) (the stay application). The respondents seek a stay pending the hearing and determination…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mitolo Wines Aust Pty Ltd v Vito Mitolo & Son Pty Ltd (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 2116
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter involved an application by Vito Mitolo & Son Pty Ltd and Vito Mitolo for a stay of various orders pending an appeal to the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia. The primary dispute arose from a decision made by the Court in Mitolo Wines Aust Pty Ltd v Vito Mitolo & Son Pty Ltd (No 2), where certain orders were made in favour of the plaintiff. The respondents sought a stay to prevent enforcement of these orders during the pendency of their appeal. The court was tasked with determining whether the grounds for appeal were arguable and whether the applicants would be deprived of the full benefits of their judgment if the stay was not granted. Additionally, the court considered whether the respondents would suffer significant prejudice if the stay was refused, particularly in light of the potential financial impact on Vito Mitolo & Son Pty Ltd and Vito Mitolo himself.

The court examined the evidence provided by the respondents, which included financial statements and affidavits detailing the precarious financial situation of Vito Mitolo & Son Pty Ltd and Vito Mitolo. Vito Mitolo argued that if the costs order was enforced, it could lead to the liquidation of the company and the forced sale of his personal property. The court weighed these concerns against the potential prejudice to the appellants if the stay was not granted and the appeal ultimately failed. The court also considered the delay in filing the respondents’ application and the lack of security offered by the respondents.

In its decision, the court determined that while there was a risk of financial prejudice to the respondents if the stay was not granted, the primary concern was the potential for wasted costs and the impact on the ongoing litigation process. The court noted that the delay in filing the application was not wholly satisfactory but did not deem it sufficient to warrant a stay of all orders. Specifically, the court found that the Programming Orders could be suspended to allow for the appeal process without causing undue financial harm to the respondents. The court concluded that a stay of certain orders was necessary to prevent potential financial ruin for the respondents while balancing the interests of the appellants.

The final orders of the court were that the operation of paragraphs 16–21 of the orders made on 25 July 2019 be suspended until further order, effectively staying those specific orders pending the outcome of the appeal. The court dismissed the respondents’ interlocutory application in all other respects. The court emphasised that if circumstances changed materially, the applicants could reapply for the orders to be re-engaged. The orders were to be entered in accordance with Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The operation of paragraphs 16–21 inclusive of the orders of the Court made on 25 July 2019 be suspended until further order.

2. The respondents’ interlocutory application dated 8 November 2019 be otherwise dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between Mitolo Wines Aust Pty Ltd and Vito Mitolo & Son Pty Ltd. The applicants sought a stay of various orders pending an appeal to the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia. The applicants argued that the appeal had arguable grounds and that they would be deprived of the full benefits of the judgment in their favour if a stay was not granted. The respondents contended that they would suffer non-financial prejudice if the stay was not granted and that the appeal would be rendered nugatory if not stayed. The respondents did not offer security and there was a delay in filing their application. The applicants relied on the financial statements of Vito Mitolo & Son Pty Ltd which showed significant losses and negative net assets, indicating a high risk of liquidation if the costs order was enforced. Vito also expressed concern that a liquidator would not continue with the appeal.

The matter originated from orders made by the Court on 25 July 2019. The respondents subsequently filed an interlocutory application on 8 November 2019 seeking a stay of those orders pending an appeal to the Full Court. The applicants opposed the stay application on the basis that the appeal did not have arguable grounds and that the respondents had not demonstrated sufficient prejudice. The respondents provided affidavits to support their application, which included financial statements and evidence of potential non-financial prejudice. The Court considered the arguments and evidence presented before deciding to suspend certain orders pending the outcome of the appeal while dismissing other parts of the interlocutory application.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Conversely, where there is a real risk that a successful appellant would be deprived of the fruits of their appeal if a stay is not granted such that the appeal is rendered nugatory, this is a strong reason for granting a stay. This includes circumstances in which there is a real risk that the enforcement of the judgment below would result in the successful appellant being unable to be substantially restored to its former position.THE EVIDENCE The respondents relied on the following evidence in support of their application:(1)the first affidavit of Vito sworn on 8 November 2019;(2)the affidavit of Tony Mitolo sworn on 14 November 2019;(3)the affidavit of Nathan Lee Marshall sworn on 14 November 2019; and (4)the second affidavit of Vito sworn on 25 November 2019.Vito In his first affidavit, Vito gives evidence about the financial position of the first respondent and his own financial position. Vito produces a copy of the first respondent’s balance sheet as at 30 June 2019 and a profit and loss statement for the period from 1 July 2018 to 30 June 2019. These documents indicate that as at 30 June 2019, the first respondent had net assets of negative $11,046.33 and that for the year ended 30 June 2019, the first respondent made a loss of $1,710.15. Vito also produces a copy of the first respondent’s balance sheet as at 30 September 2019 and a profit and loss statement for the period from 1 July 2019 to 30 September 2019. These documents indicate that as at 30 September 2019, the first respondent had net assets of negative $18,614.85 and that for the period 1 July 2019 to 30 September 2019, the first respondent made a loss of $7,568.52. Vito states in his affidavit that if the orders sought in the stay application are not made, and the Costs Order is enforced, “it is likely that the first respondent will need to be liquidated and wound up”. He also states that given the assets of the first respondent, he is concerned that a liquidator would not continue with the first respondent’s “portion” of the appeal. Vito states that if the orders sought in the stay application are not made, “it is likely that I will sustain non-financial prejudice”. He states that he is the registered proprietor of 135 Oakley Road, McLaren Vale and that if the Costs Order is enforced, he will need to sell the property in order to comply with the order. He states that, in the event that the appeal is successful and the Costs Order is overturned, then he will have sold the property with no realistic prospect of being able to re-purchase it. The Oakley Road property is referred to extensively in the substantive reasons (beginning at [84]). Vito also states that the continued litigation in this proceeding, being the claim for an account of profits, will result in financial resources being expended by the respondents which, if the appeal is successful, will be wasted costs for both the applicants and the respondents. In his second affidavit, Vito gives evidence in response to various matters raised in the affidavit of Ms Kathryn Ann White sworn on 21 November 2019. I will return to this when I consider her evidence.Tony

Decision

Reasons for decision

I consider that different considerations apply to a stay (more accurately, a suspension) of the Programming Orders. The issue here relates to costs to be incurred. Had I been asked promptly to suspend the second stage of the proceeding pending an appeal, I may well have done so on the respondents’ undertaking to prosecute the appeal expeditiously. Whilst the explanation for the delay is not wholly satisfactory, the delay itself and the fact that the appeal will be heard in May 2020 rather than February 2020 is not sufficient to persuade me that the parties should incur costs in relation to an exercise which involves, as I understand it, a closed period. I will suspend the Programming Orders until further order while there is an appeal pending. If circumstances change in a material respect, then the applicants can apply for the orders to be re-engaged.CONCLUSION The operation of paragraphs 16–21 inclusive of the orders of the Court made on 25 July 2019 are suspended until further order. The respondents’ interlocutory application dated 8 November 2019 is otherwise dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In considering the application for a stay of various orders pending the hearing and determination of an appeal, the court assessed the arguability of the grounds of appeal, the potential prejudice to the applicants if a stay was not granted, the potential prejudice to the respondents if a stay was not granted and the appeal was successful, and whether the appeal would be rendered nugatory if a stay was not granted. The court concluded that the grounds of appeal were indeed arguable, as there was a reasonable possibility that the appeal would succeed. Regarding the potential prejudice to the applicants if a stay was not granted, the court found that the applicants would not be deprived of the full benefits of the judgment in their favour. With respect to the potential prejudice to the respondents if a stay was not granted and the appeal was successful, the court held that the respondents would not be deprived of the fruits of their appeal, despite their contention of non-financial prejudice. Lastly, the court determined that the appeal would not be rendered nugatory if a stay was not granted. The court relied on the evidence presented by the respondents, including the financial position of the first respondent and the personal financial situation of Vito, to make its determination. The court also considered the delay in the filing of the respondents' application and the lack of security offered by the respondents. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that courts must consider the arguability of the grounds of appeal, potential prejudice to both parties, and the possibility of rendering the appeal nugatory when deciding on an application for a stay of orders pending an appeal.