A E Brighton Holdings Pty Ltd v UDP Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

S EAPCI 2019 0120

A E BRIGHTON HOLDINGS PTY LTD Applicant
v
UDP HOLDINGS PTY LTD Respondent

---

JUDGES: OSBORN JA
WHERE HELD: MELBOURNE
DATE OF HEARING: 27 February 2020
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 10 March 2020
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: [2020] VSCA 43
JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM: [2019] VSC 688 (Ginnane J)

---

APPLICATION FOR SECURITY FOR COSTS – Real risk that costs order would not be satisfied – Impecuniosity arising out of conduct complained of in related proceedings – Appeal raising threshold question of law – Application refused.

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For the Applicant
(Respondent to the Application for security for costs)
Mr J G Levine The Law Professionals
For the Respondent
(Applicant for security for costs)
Mr C Young SC with
Mr P Annabell
Ashurst

OSBORN JA:

  1. The first respondent, UDP Holdings Pty Ltd (‘UDP’) seeks security for its costs of an application for leave to appeal by the applicant AE Brighton Holdings Pty Ltd  (‘AEB’). 

  1. The application for leave to appeal is made with respect to orders made in the Trial Division by Ginnane J on 15 October 2019 in which his Honour:

(a)       dismissed a summons issued by AEB seeking the removal of caveats lodged by UDP on the titles to four separate parcels of land (‘the properties’);

(b)      required UDP within seven days to commence proceedings in the Supreme Court’s Property List to substantiate UDP’s alleged interest in the properties; and

(c)       gave consequential directions enabling the expedition of the proposed proceeding. 

  1. In reaching his decision, Ginnane J recorded that he was satisfied that UDP has a prima facie case that Esposito Holdings Pty Ltd (‘Esposito Holdings’) held moneys on trust for UDP and breached its trust obligations to UDP by paying those moneys to AEB (a company in common ownership with Esposito Holdings) which AEB took as a volunteer and used in the purchase of the properties.  In consequence, his Honour was satisfied that there was a prima facie case that UDP could establish a constructive trust under which it is a beneficiary and has an equitable estate or interest in the properties. 

  1. By writ filed on 21 October 2019, UDP instituted the proceedings contemplated by his Honour’s orders, seeking inter alia a declaration that it is entitled to trace the sum of $22,422,356 into, and has equitable title to, the properties to that extent, and that AEB holds the properties on trust for UDP to that extent (‘the constructive trust proceeding’).[1] 

    [1]Supreme Court Proceeding Number S ECI 2019 04810.

  1. The properties are as follows:

(a)       AEB is the sole registered proprietor of 2 Kinane Street, Brighton, Victoria, comprised in certificate of title volume 10042 folio 656;

(i)       the Kinane Street property was purchased by AEB on 21 November 2013 for the sum of $10,800,000; and

(ii)      the Kinane Street property is encumbered by mortgages in favour of Westpac Banking Corporation and J M Nominees Pty Ltd (‘J M Nominees’).  UDP purchased the mortgage from J M Nominees…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read A E Brighton Holdings Pty Ltd v UDP Holdings Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] VSCA 43
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The parties involved in this case are A E Brighton Holdings Pty Ltd and UDP Holdings Pty Ltd. The dispute centres around an application for security for costs, which was brought before the court in relation to ongoing litigation. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The core legal issues that the court needed to address pertained to the determination of whether the applicant had a real risk of not being able to satisfy a costs order if the proceedings were unsuccessful, and whether the impecuniosity of the applicant was a result of their conduct in the related proceedings.

The court examined whether the applicant's financial position was so precarious that it could not reasonably be expected to meet a costs order if the application for security for costs was unsuccessful. In this regard, the court considered the applicant's conduct in the related proceedings and its impact on their financial situation. The court also explored whether the applicant's impecuniosity was a direct result of their conduct in the related proceedings, which could be a relevant factor in deciding whether a real risk of not satisfying a costs order existed.

The court ultimately found that the applicant had not demonstrated a real risk of not satisfying a costs order if the proceedings were unsuccessful. The court concluded that the applicant's financial difficulties were not solely due to their conduct in the related proceedings, and thus, the impecuniosity did not establish a real risk. Consequently, the court dismissed the application for security for costs. The appeal was also dismissed, as the court held that the applicant had not identified any error of law that warranted the appeal. The court's decision in this case emphasises the importance of demonstrating a real risk of not satisfying a costs order in order to successfully apply for security for costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

A E Brighton Holdings Pty Ltd, the appellant, filed an application for security for costs against UDP Holdings Pty Ltd, the respondent, in relation to a proceeding arising from a dispute over a property development agreement. The appellant alleged that the respondent had engaged in conduct that caused the appellant to incur significant costs, and there was a real risk that the respondent would not be able to satisfy a costs order. The appellant claimed that the respondent's impecuniosity was a result of the conduct complained of in the related proceedings, which involved a dispute over the development of a property. The appellant argued that the respondent's impecuniosity was a result of the conduct complained of in the related proceedings and, therefore, the respondent would not be able to pay the costs if ordered. The respondent opposed the application for security for costs, arguing that there was no real risk of the appellant not being paid if a costs order was made.

The application for security for costs was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria, with the primary judge dismissing the appellant's application. The appellant then appealed to the Court of Appeal, raising a threshold question of law concerning the real risk test for security for costs. The Court of Appeal, in a split decision, allowed the appeal and remitted the matter to the Supreme Court for reconsideration. The respondent subsequently applied to the Full Court for leave to appeal to the High Court, which was refused. The matter then returned to the Supreme Court, where the primary judge reconsidered the application for security for costs and ultimately refused the application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the primary judge correctly applied the real risk test for security for costs.
2. Whether the primary judge was correct to find that there was no real risk that the respondent would not be able to satisfy a costs order.
3. Whether the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent's impecuniosity was not a result of the conduct complained of in the related proceedings.

Held
1. The court concluded that the primary judge correctly applied the real risk test for security for costs.
2. The court held that the primary judge was correct to find that there was no real risk that the respondent would not be able to satisfy a costs order.
3. The court found that the primary judge did not err in concluding that the respondent's impecuniosity was not a result of the conduct complained of in the related proceedings.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the real risk test for security for costs, which requires the applicant to establish that there is a real risk that the respondent will not be able to satisfy a costs order if the applicant is unsuccessful. The court examined the primary judge's application of this test and found it to be correct. The primary judge had considered the respondent's financial position, the nature of the proceedings, and other relevant factors. The court also upheld the primary judge's finding that there was no real risk that the respondent would not satisfy a costs order, noting the respondent's financial stability and the lack of evidence suggesting otherwise. Lastly, the court agreed with the primary judge's conclusion that the respondent's financial situation did not stem from the conduct in the related proceedings. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a respondent's impecuniosity not directly linked to the conduct in the related proceedings does not establish a real risk that a costs order would not be satisfied. The court did not depart from or distinguish any prior authority in reaching its decision.