FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Lawrence v Melbourne Football Club Ltd [2024] FCA 945
File number(s): VID 1011 of 2023 Judgment of: O’CALLAGHAN J Date of judgment: 22 August 2024 Catchwords: CORPORATIONS – where member of Australian Rules football club brought proceeding seeking a declaration pursuant to s 232 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) that certain conduct of the club was contrary to the interests of its members as a whole, and oppressive to members including himself and other “non-aligned” candidates seeking election to its board of directors and seeking orders pursuant to s 233 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) that certain of the club’s election rules be amended – role of courts in oppression actions where evaluative decisions are challenged considered – application dismissed Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 173, 232, 233
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 21
Cases cited: Aqua-Max Pty Ltd v MT Associates Pty Ltd (2001) 3 VR 473
Catalano v Managing Australia Destinations Pty Ltd [2014] FCAFC 55; (2014) 314 ALR 62
Hylepin Pty Ltd v Doshay Pty Ltd (2021) 288 FCR 104
Joint v Stephens [2008] VSCA 210; (2008) 26 ACLC 1467
Knights Quest Pty Ltd v Daiwa Can Company [2018] VSCA 349; (2018) 366 ALR 557
Lawrence v Melbourne Football Club Ltd (2022) 71 VR 202
MacKay Sugar Ltd v Wilmar Sugar Australia Ltd [2016] FCAFC 133; (2016) 338 ALR 374
New South Wales Rugby League Ltd v Wayde (1985) 1 NSWLR 86
Parker v Auswild [2022] VSCA 8; (2022) 403 ALR 111
RBC Investor Services Australia Nominees Pty Ltd v Brickworks Ltd [2017] FCA 756; (2017) 348 ALR 605
Saykan v Elhan [2006] VSCA 230
Soulos v Pagones [2023] NSWCA 243
Tzavaras v Tzavaras [2023] NSWCA 168
Wambo Coal Pty Ltd v SumisekiMaterials Co Ltd (2014) 88 NSWLR 689
Wayde v New South Wales Rugby League Ltd (1985) 180 CLR 459
Wilmar Sugar Australia Ltd v MacKay Sugar Ltd [2017] FCAFC 40; (2017) 345 ALR 174
Division: General Division Registry: Victoria National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency Number of paragraphs: 150 Date of last submission/s: 30 May 2024 Date of hearing: 1, 2, 13 and 15 May 2024 Counsel for the Plaintiff: J W S Peters AM KC with A Folie Solicitor for the Plaintiff: Holding Redlich Counsel for the Defendant: M I Borsky KC with K Raghavan Solicitor for the Defendant: Ashurst ORDERS
VID 1011 of 2023 BETWEEN: PETER JOHN LAWRENCE
Plaintiff
AND: MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB LIMITED (ACN 005 686 902)
Defendant
ORDER MADE BY:
O’CALLAGHAN J
DATE OF ORDER:
22 AUGUST 2024
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The plaintiff have leave to amend his originating process dated 4 December 2023 in accordance with Schedule C attached to his written closing submissions dated 14 May 2024.
2.The amended originating process be dismissed.
3.If the parties are unable to resolve the question of costs, then:
(a)the plaintiff file and serve a written submission about the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Lawrence v Melbourne Football Club Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] FCA 945
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the club's conduct in managing its board elections, as well as the specific election rules, were indeed oppressive, unfairly prejudicial, or unfairly discriminatory to certain members, including Lawrence. The court had to assess the reasonableness and fairness of the club's election procedures and rules, considering the club's objectives and the need for equitable and transparent election processes. Additionally, the court needed to determine the appropriate role of the judiciary in reviewing the club's evaluative decisions regarding its election rules and procedures.
The court found that the club's conduct and election rules were not oppressive, unfairly prejudicial, or unfairly discriminatory. The court emphasized the importance of the club's objectives and the board's discretion in managing the election process. The rationale behind the election rules, which aimed to ensure equity, fairness, and to prevent public campaigning that could harm the club's reputation, was deemed reasonable. The court also noted that the club's ongoing efforts to review and amend its election rules demonstrated a commitment to improving the process and addressing member concerns. Consequently, the court dismissed Lawrence's application for declarations and orders, finding no basis for the requested amendments to the election rules.
The final orders of the court included dismissing the amended originating process and directing that if the parties could not resolve the issue of costs, they should file written submissions for the court's decision.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The plaintiff have leave to amend his originating process dated 4 December 2023 in accordance with Schedule C attached to his written closing submissions dated 14 May 2024.
2. The amended originating process be dismissed.
3. If the parties are unable to resolve the question of costs, then:
(a) the plaintiff file and serve a written submission about the issue, not exceeding 5 pages, within ten days;
(b) the defendant file and serve a written submission about the issue, not exceeding 5 pages, within ten days of receipt of the plaintiff’s submission.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
By the time of closing submissions, Mr Lawrence instead sought the following relief (as set out in Schedule C attached to his written closing submissions):1.Pursuant to s 232 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act), Melbourne Football Club Limited (MFC)’s conduct of its affairs in relation to elections for its board of directors has been since 2022, and continues to be:a. contrary to the interests of the members as a whole; and b.oppressive to, unfairly prejudicial to and unfairly discriminatory against Peter Lawrence and other non-preferred candidates seeking election to the board of directors of MFC.2.Pursuant to s 233 of the Corporations Act, the following paragraphs of the MFC Election Rules dated 8 May 2024 be struck out:a. paragraph 13(b)(i);b. paragraph 13(c)(i)(C);c. paragraph 13(c)(i)(D)d. the words in parathensis [sic] in paragraph 13(d)(ii). Although Mr Peters did not formally seek leave to amend the originating process accordingly, I will make such an order, because (sensibly enough) no objection was made to the final form of relief being articulated in that way. The MFC submitted that, to the extent that paragraph 1 of Mr Lawrence’s proposed orders still sought declaratory relief, such an application was misconceived. In the end, for reasons that no longer matter, Mr Peters accepted that proposed order 1 set out in Schedule C to his written closing submissions was unnecessary. That leaves paragraph 2 of the final form of relief sought in Schedule C. By that paragraph, Mr Lawrence seeks an order that the following paragraphs of the election rules be struck out:(a)paragraph 13(b)(i), or the “disparagement” rule, which, at 8 May 2024, provided as follows (noting it has now been amended as outlined above):(b)Election material, Candidate Statements and any other written or oral statement by or on behalf of a Nominee or Candidate must not: i.disparage or otherwise reflect adversely on the standing of the Club or its players, Members, Directors, officers, staff, Nominees or Candidates;(b)paragraphs 13(c)(i)(C) and (D) which provide:(c)Except as provided for under these Rules, Candidates are not permitted to engage in any of the following kinds of electioneering conduct, either engaged in personally by the Candidate or by another person with the permission or authorisation of the Candidate:i.campaigning for the office of Director or drawing attention to the fact the Candidate is seeking to be appointed as a Director by:…C.giving an interview that is transmitted to the general public by way of the media, including radio, television, blog or vlog;D.posting to a website or to a social media platform material that can be viewed by the general public;(c)the words in parentheses in paragraph 13(d)(ii) which provides:(d)For the avoidance of doubt, the electioneering conduct restricted by the preceding paragraph does not include conduct that otherwise complies with these Rules and involves:…ii.publishing on the Candidate’s social media platform account the fact that they are a Candidate and the Candidate Statement of that person (in doing so the comments function must be turned off in connection with that publication and reference may be made that if a Member has any questions or comments concerning the election they may refer to the Club’s online election forum);