Lawrence v Melbourne Football Club Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Lawrence v Melbourne Football Club Ltd [2024] FCA 945

File number(s): VID 1011 of 2023
Judgment of: O’CALLAGHAN J
Date of judgment: 22 August 2024
Catchwords: CORPORATIONS – where member of Australian Rules football club brought proceeding seeking a declaration pursuant to s 232 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) that certain conduct of the club was contrary to the interests of its members as a whole, and oppressive to members including himself and other “non-aligned” candidates seeking election to its board of directors and seeking orders pursuant to s 233 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) that certain of the club’s election rules be amended – role of courts in oppression actions where evaluative decisions are challenged considered – application dismissed
Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 173, 232, 233

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 21

Cases cited:

Aqua-Max Pty Ltd v MT Associates Pty Ltd (2001) 3 VR 473

Catalano v Managing Australia Destinations Pty Ltd [2014] FCAFC 55; (2014) 314 ALR 62

Hylepin Pty Ltd v Doshay Pty Ltd (2021) 288 FCR 104

Joint v Stephens [2008] VSCA 210; (2008) 26 ACLC 1467

Knights Quest Pty Ltd v Daiwa Can Company [2018] VSCA 349; (2018) 366 ALR 557

Lawrence v Melbourne Football Club Ltd (2022) 71 VR 202

MacKay Sugar Ltd v Wilmar Sugar Australia Ltd [2016] FCAFC 133; (2016) 338 ALR 374

New South Wales Rugby League Ltd v Wayde (1985) 1 NSWLR 86

Parker v Auswild [2022] VSCA 8; (2022) 403 ALR 111

RBC Investor Services Australia Nominees Pty Ltd v Brickworks Ltd [2017] FCA 756; (2017) 348 ALR 605

Saykan v Elhan [2006] VSCA 230

Soulos v Pagones [2023] NSWCA 243

Tzavaras v Tzavaras [2023] NSWCA 168

Wambo Coal Pty Ltd v SumisekiMaterials Co Ltd (2014) 88 NSWLR 689

Wayde v New South Wales Rugby League Ltd (1985) 180 CLR 459

Wilmar Sugar Australia Ltd v MacKay Sugar Ltd [2017] FCAFC 40; (2017) 345 ALR 174

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency
Number of paragraphs: 150
Date of last submission/s: 30 May 2024
Date of hearing: 1, 2, 13 and 15 May 2024
Counsel for the Plaintiff: J W S Peters AM KC with A Folie
Solicitor for the Plaintiff: Holding Redlich
Counsel for the Defendant: M I Borsky KC with K Raghavan
Solicitor for the Defendant: Ashurst

ORDERS

VID 1011 of 2023
BETWEEN:

PETER JOHN LAWRENCE

Plaintiff

AND:

MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB LIMITED (ACN 005 686 902)

Defendant

ORDER MADE BY:

O’CALLAGHAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

22 AUGUST 2024

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The plaintiff have leave to amend his originating process dated 4 December 2023 in accordance with Schedule C attached to his written closing submissions dated 14 May 2024.

2.The amended originating process be dismissed.

3.If the parties are unable to resolve the question of costs, then:

(a)the plaintiff file and serve a written submission about the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lawrence v Melbourne Football Club Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 945
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Peter Lawrence brought proceedings against Melbourne Football Club Limited, seeking a declaration under section 232 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) that the club's conduct regarding its board elections was contrary to the interests of its members as a whole and oppressive to certain members, including himself. Lawrence also sought orders under section 233 of the Corporations Act to amend certain election rules he deemed restrictive and unfair. The court was tasked with determining whether Lawrence's claims of oppressive conduct were valid and whether the requested amendments to the election rules were justified.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the club's conduct in managing its board elections, as well as the specific election rules, were indeed oppressive, unfairly prejudicial, or unfairly discriminatory to certain members, including Lawrence. The court had to assess the reasonableness and fairness of the club's election procedures and rules, considering the club's objectives and the need for equitable and transparent election processes. Additionally, the court needed to determine the appropriate role of the judiciary in reviewing the club's evaluative decisions regarding its election rules and procedures.

The court found that the club's conduct and election rules were not oppressive, unfairly prejudicial, or unfairly discriminatory. The court emphasized the importance of the club's objectives and the board's discretion in managing the election process. The rationale behind the election rules, which aimed to ensure equity, fairness, and to prevent public campaigning that could harm the club's reputation, was deemed reasonable. The court also noted that the club's ongoing efforts to review and amend its election rules demonstrated a commitment to improving the process and addressing member concerns. Consequently, the court dismissed Lawrence's application for declarations and orders, finding no basis for the requested amendments to the election rules.

The final orders of the court included dismissing the amended originating process and directing that if the parties could not resolve the issue of costs, they should file written submissions for the court's decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The plaintiff have leave to amend his originating process dated 4 December 2023 in accordance with Schedule C attached to his written closing submissions dated 14 May 2024.

2. The amended originating process be dismissed.

3. If the parties are unable to resolve the question of costs, then:

(a) the plaintiff file and serve a written submission about the issue, not exceeding 5 pages, within ten days;

(b) the defendant file and serve a written submission about the issue, not exceeding 5 pages, within ten days of receipt of the plaintiff’s submission.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Both Mr Lawrence and Mr Rennick were cross-examined.THE FACTSThe MFC and its constitution The MFC is an Australian Rules football club, limited by guarantee. As at 31 October 2023, it had over 70,000 members. It operates under a license from the Australian Football League (AFL) and is a participant in the football competitions of the AFL, AFL Women’s (AFLW), Victorian Football League (VFL) and VFL Women’s (VFLW). The MFC is governed by a constitution, which provides that its primary objective is preserving and fostering the ideals and tradition of Australian Rules football, and promoting the playing of Australian Rules football in general, including maintaining, providing, supporting and controlling a team or teams of footballers to compete in the AFL men’s and women’s competitions. The constitution, at all relevant times, has also provided that:(a)in order to stand for election to the position of a director and be appointed as a director of the club, the member must be a “voting member”;(b)the election of directors is to take place by ballot, and is to be conducted by “secret ballot”;(c)all “voting members” (since October 2022, those “[v]oting [m]embers who held a membership ticket for the season immediately prior to the election”) will be entitled to cast a vote, being a number of votes “which is equal to the number of vacancies”; (d)subject to (c), among other things, the board “in its absolute discretion and from time to time may determine the form, timing and conduct of the ballot”; and(e)the board has the power to “make, amend or repeal any ‘Rules’ as it sees fit for the proper conduct and management of [the MFC], its business, membership and affairs … provided the Rules are not inconsistent with” the constitution. Eight members currently serve on the club’s board of directors. Board members are unpaid.Mr Lawrence Mr Lawrence has been a member of the MFC since 1992 and gave evidence about his extensive involvement with it. In cross-examination, Mr Rennick described Mr Lawrence as a “significant donor” who is held in “high regard” by the club. Mr Lawrence has also been a member of a number of associations connected to the MFC, including the President’s Club, the Inner Sanctum, the Women’s Foundation and the Demon Army. He has donated significant amounts of money to the club, as a “Foundation Legend” with “Gold” status, something that is granted to donors who have made total contributions between $150,000 and $249,000. Mr Lawrence has also sponsored both AFL and AFLW players. The 2020/2021 election and the introduction of the election rules On 17 July 2020, Mr Lawrence attended a “Zoom” meeting with Mr Glenn Bartlett and Mr Mohan Jesudason, then Chairman and Co-Vice Chair of the MFC respectively, where he first raised his interest in joining the board. Mr Lawrence’s evidence was that he was told at that meeting by Mr Bartlett and Mr Jesudason that while a line had not been ruled through his name, his nominating for election would not help as the board did not want publicity, and that the process of a contested election would cost $200,000.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Sixthly, shortly after the trial had concluded, the board resolved further to amend the election rules to make clear that the prohibition on candidates making statements in the course of elections which “disparage or otherwise reflect adversely on the standing of the Club or its players, Members, Directors, officers, staff, Nominees or Candidates” does not prevent reasonable or constructive criticism.THE EVIDENCE Mr Lawrence read two affidavits affirmed by him on 4 December 2023 and 18 April 2024 respectively. Mr Lawrence is a former finance professional. He is now retired. He has been a member of the MFC since 1992. In his first affidavit, he gave evidence about: (a)the MFC’s constitution;(b)his extensive personal involvement with the club (including significant sponsorship and donations);(c)the circumstances surrounding his nominations to become a director of the board in elections held between 2020/2021, 2021/2022, 2022/2023 and in December 2023;(d)the board election rules as they existed at the relevant times and the various amendments made to them between 2020 and 2023;(e)correspondence between solicitors for the parties regarding Mr Lawrence’s concerns about the election rules and the openness, fairness and transparency of the December 2023 election;(f)his continuing concerns about the election rules as they existed at 4 December 2023, and the club’s conduct of elections more broadly; and(g)the board election rules of other Australian Rules football clubs. In his second affidavit, Mr Lawrence responded to the evidence filed by the MFC. He also gave evidence about the changes the board had resolved to make to the club’s election rules in April 2024, which Mr Lawrence said addressed some, but not all, of the concerns he had been raising with the club since 2021. The MFC read four affidavits of Mr David Rennick, director and Vice-President of the club, affirmed on 4 March, 5 April, 2 May and 10 May 2024 respectively. After the trial, the club (with leave) filed a further affidavit of Mr Rennick affirmed on 19 June 2024. Mr Rennick has been a director of the club since November 2020 and Vice-President since September 2023. He has over 30 years of experience in the legal and property industries, and over 10 years’ experience serving on boards of both commercial and non-for-profit organisations. In his affidavits, Mr Rennick gave evidence about the rationale for the introduction of the club’s election rules, and the decision-making process underpinning the various amendments that have been made to them. In his 4 March 2024 affidavit, Mr Rennick deposed about those matters, including as follows:During my time as a director of MFC, it has been the Board’s practice to perform a review of the election procedures each year to identify what worked well and what could be improved. The Board is continuously looking to improve these procedures, and, where appropriate, has made and will continue to make adjustments which we consider to be in the best interests of the Club and its members.….The need for the Election Rules to contain a restriction on electioneering was discussed and considered by the Board at a meeting on 10 January 2022, which I attended. The meeting occurred in the context of the Board considering amendments to the electioneering restrictions including those contained in the election rules subsequently sent to candidates for the 2021/22 election on 11 January 2022 … The minutes of the meeting record the following matters in relation to the Board’s consideration of the purpose of the electioneering restrictions:A discussion was held about the two purposes of the Election Rules insofar as electioneering is concerned. One is to restrict an inflammatory public campaign outside the club and the second is to create a level playing field.The Board noted that no advantage should be given to wealthy candidates who could afford:(a) the $60,000 cost of postal communications; and/or(b) to pay for media relations and lobbying consultants, etc.It was also noted that electioneering reduced the likelihood of the best candidates with appropriate diversity running because they might not be willing or able to pay for those things and might not want to be caught up in the spectacle of a media circus.I consider that the matters recorded in the minutes are important for alignment of the election process to the Club’s values.The minutes also record the following as to the Board’s reasons for including the electioneering restrictions in the rules:(f)the restrictions on electioneering as contained in the existing Director Election Rules and clarified by the Proposed ER Amendments (as agreed to be further amended at the meeting) are necessary and appropriate for the following reasons:(i)the restrictions provide for equity and fairness in the election process for the candidates including with respect to candidate material to be published;(ii)the restrictions provide a process to attract the best candidates, including (i) not favouring those with financial resources or the financial backing to run public campaigns which will discourage suitable candidates without those resources to seek nomination, and (ii) not reducing the likelihood of the best candidates with appropriate diversity running because they may not want [to] be caught up in the spectacle of a media circus;(iii)the restrictions do not permit prospective board candidates to campaign and broadcast additional election material in the public domain via a multitude of digital or online platforms or publications which extend far beyond a written statement to members increases the risk of the Company’s good standing, image and reputation being adversely affected or damaged as a consequence of the unsubstantiated, false or misleading statements, criticisms or claims being publicly made about or against the Club Board, the management of the Company or candidates;(iv)current directors of the Board are restricted from publicly discussing, promoting or advertising their candidacy due to their strict board obligations (which includes a duty to maintain confidentiality) and the Company’s media policy only allowing the President to speak publicly about Company matters. In the interest of ensuring a fair and impartial election, it is imperative that all prospective board candidates be treated equally in that they are all required to abide by the same rules and restrictions and no prospective board candidate is given an unfair competitive advantage over another;…

Decision

Reasons for decision

I should say something briefly about one issue that occupied some considerable time at the hearing. Both parties tendered into evidence the rules of various other AFL football clubs, and went through them in submissions in some detail, with a view to establishing that the relevant rules of the MFC were, or were not, reasonable. In my view, and intending no disrespect to the parties, that was to invite me to conduct a wholly arid exercise, and I decline to have regard to them.CONCLUSION For those reasons, the amended originating process is to be dismissed. If the parties are unable to resolve the question of costs between themselves, I will order that they file written submissions on the issue, which I will decide on the papers.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

By the time of closing submissions, Mr Lawrence instead sought the following relief (as set out in Schedule C attached to his written closing submissions):1.Pursuant to s 232 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act), Melbourne Football Club Limited (MFC)’s conduct of its affairs in relation to elections for its board of directors has been since 2022, and continues to be:a. contrary to the interests of the members as a whole; and b.oppressive to, unfairly prejudicial to and unfairly discriminatory against Peter Lawrence and other non-preferred candidates seeking election to the board of directors of MFC.2.Pursuant to s 233 of the Corporations Act, the following paragraphs of the MFC Election Rules dated 8 May 2024 be struck out:a. paragraph 13(b)(i);b. paragraph 13(c)(i)(C);c. paragraph 13(c)(i)(D)d. the words in parathensis [sic] in paragraph 13(d)(ii). Although Mr Peters did not formally seek leave to amend the originating process accordingly, I will make such an order, because (sensibly enough) no objection was made to the final form of relief being articulated in that way. The MFC submitted that, to the extent that paragraph 1 of Mr Lawrence’s proposed orders still sought declaratory relief, such an application was misconceived. In the end, for reasons that no longer matter, Mr Peters accepted that proposed order 1 set out in Schedule C to his written closing submissions was unnecessary. That leaves paragraph 2 of the final form of relief sought in Schedule C. By that paragraph, Mr Lawrence seeks an order that the following paragraphs of the election rules be struck out:(a)paragraph 13(b)(i), or the “disparagement” rule, which, at 8 May 2024, provided as follows (noting it has now been amended as outlined above):(b)Election material, Candidate Statements and any other written or oral statement by or on behalf of a Nominee or Candidate must not: i.disparage or otherwise reflect adversely on the standing of the Club or its players, Members, Directors, officers, staff, Nominees or Candidates;(b)paragraphs 13(c)(i)(C) and (D) which provide:(c)Except as provided for under these Rules, Candidates are not permitted to engage in any of the following kinds of electioneering conduct, either engaged in personally by the Candidate or by another person with the permission or authorisation of the Candidate:i.campaigning for the office of Director or drawing attention to the fact the Candidate is seeking to be appointed as a Director by:…C.giving an interview that is transmitted to the general public by way of the media, including radio, television, blog or vlog;D.posting to a website or to a social media platform material that can be viewed by the general public;(c)the words in parentheses in paragraph 13(d)(ii) which provides:(d)For the avoidance of doubt, the electioneering conduct restricted by the preceding paragraph does not include conduct that otherwise complies with these Rules and involves:…ii.publishing on the Candidate’s social media platform account the fact that they are a Candidate and the Candidate Statement of that person (in doing so the comments function must be turned off in connection with that publication and reference may be made that if a Member has any questions or comments concerning the election they may refer to the Club’s online election forum);