Mackay Sugar Ltd v Wilmar Sugar Australia Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Mackay Sugar Limited v Wilmar Sugar Australia Limited [2016] FCAFC 133

Appeal from: Wilmar Sugar Australia Limited v Queensland Sugar Limited, in the matter of Queensland Sugar Limited [2016] FCA 20
File number: NSD 223 of 2016
Judges: GILMOUR, JAGOT AND WHITE JJ
Date of judgment: 6 October 2016
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – Queensland Sugar Industry – Second Respondent engaged in marketing of raw sugar for export – amendment of Constitution to vary members’ rights – whether any error shown in trial Judge’s conclusion that amendments were oppressive to, unfairly prejudicial to, and unfairly discriminating to, First Respondent – no error shown – appeal dismissed.

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – appellants did not participate in the trial – leave granted to appeal.

Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 232, 233

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 24

Foreign Acquisitions and Takeovers Act 1975 (Cth)

Sugar Industry (Real Choice in Marketing) Amendment Act 2015

Cases cited:

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Australian and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd [2015] FCAFC 103; (2015) 236 FCR 78

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Malaysian Airlines System Berhad [2010] FCA 757; (2010) 271 ALR 91

Branir Pty Ltd v Owston Nominees (No 2) Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 1833; (2001) 117 FCR 424

Campbell v Backoffice Investments Pty Ltd [2009] HCA 25; (2009) 238 CLR 304

Catalano v Managing Australia Destinations Pty Ltd [2014] FCAFC 55; (2014) 314 ALR 62

Commonwealth v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2000] FCA 453; (2000) 98 FCR 31

Cuthbertson v The Mayor, Aldermen and Citizens of the City of Hobart (1921) 30 CLR 16

Hunter v Organic & Natural Enterprise Group Pty Ltd [2012] QSC 383; (2012) 92 ACSR 183

Joint v Stephens [2008] VSCA 210

JR Consulting & Drafting Pty Limited v Cummings [2016] FCAFC 20; (2016) 329 ALR 625

Morgan v 45 Flers Avenue Pty Ltd (1986) 10 ACLR 692

Re Broadcasting Station 2GB Pty Ltd [1964-5] NSWR 1648

Re Ledir Enterprises [2013] NSWSC 1332; (2013) 96 ACSR 1

Re M Dalley & Co Pty Ltd v Sims [1968] 120 CLR 663

Re Quest Exploration Pty Ltd (1992) 6 ACSR 659

Reid v Bagot Well Pastoral Co Pty Ltd (1993) 12 ACSR 197; (1993) 61 SASR 165

Sidebottom v Kershaw, Leese and Company Limited [1921] 1 Ch 154

Sutherland v National Roads and Motorists’ Association Ltd [2003] NSWSC 829; (2003) 47 ACSR 428

Thomas v HW Thomas Ltd [1984] 1 NZLR 686

Warren v Coombes (1979) 142 CLR 531

Wayde v New South Wales Rugby League (1994) 180 CLR 459

Date of hearing: 12 August 2016
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 86
Counsel for the Appellants: Mr M Hodge with Ms F Lubett
Solicitor for the Appellants: McCullough Robertson
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr J Giles SC with Mr S Fitzpatrick
Solicitor…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mackay Sugar Ltd v Wilmar Sugar Australia Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCAFC 133
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mackay Sugar Limited (QSL) and Wilmar Sugar Australia Limited (WSA) were involved in a dispute concerning amendments made to QSL's constitution, which altered the rights of its members, including WSA. The dispute was heard by the Federal Court of Australia. The primary issue before the court was whether the amendments to QSL's constitution were oppressive, unfairly prejudicial, and unfairly discriminatory to WSA. The court needed to determine whether the trial judge's conclusion on these points was correct or if there was any error in his findings.

The court reviewed the application of the relevant legal principles to the specific circumstances of the case, focusing on the trial judge's assessment of the impact of the constitutional amendments on WSA. The court found that the trial judge had correctly applied the relevant principles and that no error was evident in his conclusions. The amendments significantly affected WSA's ability to participate in the management of QSL, despite its substantial economic interest in the company's activities. The court upheld the trial judge's findings that the amendments were oppressive, unfairly prejudicial, and unfairly discriminatory to WSA.

The Federal Court dismissed the appeal, confirming the trial judge's decision. The appellants, QSL and others, were granted leave to appeal but the appeal was ultimately dismissed. The court's decision was based on the trial judge's thorough analysis of the commercial fairness of the situation and the potential impact on WSA's rights and interests. The court did not find any grounds to overturn the trial judge's findings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Appellants are granted leave to appeal.

2. The appeal is dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

It was not suggested that the trial Judge had misstated or misconstrued these principles. Instead, the appellants’ contentions on appeal concerned the Judge’s application of these principles in the circumstances of the present case.Background QSL is a public company limited by guarantee which operates on a not for profit basis. The trial Judge accepted the description of QSL’s Chief Executive Officer (CEO) that QSL is the present incarnation of the former Queensland Sugar Board, which had been established in 1923 to market sugar on behalf of the Queensland sugar industry. In 1991, the Queensland Sugar Board was replaced by the Queensland Sugar Corporation (QSC), a statutory authority, and in 1999, QSL was incorporated to replace QSC and to take over its contractual arrangements for export marketing. QSL’s members comprise seven mill owners (who together own 21 mills) and 23 Grower Representative Members. The seven mill owners are: (a) Wilmar (which owns eight sugar mills);(b) Bundaberg;(c) Isis;(d) Mackay;(e) MSF Sugar Limited (MSF) (which owns four sugar mills);(f) Tully Sugar Limited (Tully) (which owns one sugar mill); and(g) WH Heck & Sons Pty Ltd (Heck). Wilmar is the largest of the mill owners as it owns and operates eight sugar mills located in the Herbert, Burdekin, Proserpine and Plane Creek cane growing regions of North Queensland. It is the largest producer of raw sugar in Australia, producing approximately 2.2 million tonnes each year. Wilmar supplies about 2 million tonnes of this production to QSL for on‑sale in the export market. Wilmar was previously owned by CSR Limited (CSR) and was known as Sucrogen Limited. Sucrogen was acquired by Wilmar Australia Pty Ltd on 22 December 2010, after the Federal Treasurer had given approval, subject to conditions, under the Foreign Acquisitions and Takeovers Act 1975 (Cth) (the FA and T Act). Heck stands slightly differently from the other mill owners as it supplies all of its raw sugar to domestic markets, but has a supply agreement with QSL with respect to any sugar it may wish to export in the future. The 23 Grower Representative Members comprise one person appointed by Australian Cane Farmers Association Limited (ACFA); one person appointed by Queensland Cane Growers Organisation Limited (Canegrowers); and 21 elected persons who are sugar cane growers in QSL’s 21 designated mill areas. QSC owned six bulk sugar terminals (BSTs) in Queensland from which raw sugar was exported to overseas customers. When QSL was established in 1999, ownership of the BSTs was transferred to Sugar Terminals Limited (STL), a publicly listed company. QSL now operates the six BSTs pursuant to lease arrangements. It stores sugar in the BSTs and makes the exports from them. STL is entitled to terminate the lease of the BSTs if the tonnage of sugar delivered to them falls below a specified amount. Raw Sugar Supply Agreements Mill owners acquire the raw sugar from growers. The Judge found that the supply agreements between the mill owner and grower typically provide that, in exchange for milling, the mill owner will keep approximately one‑third of the net sale proceeds with the balance going to the grower, at [19].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

At the trial, QSL submitted that the 2015 amendments to Art 22(h) did not have the effect of removing any right of Wilmar, having regard to Art 22(e). It was, instead, Wilmar’s notice of termination of its RSSA which had had that effect. The Judge rejected that contention. Although the appellants’ notice of appeal complains of the correctness of that finding, they did not pursue that ground at the appeal hearing, and it is not necessary to address it. The decision of the trial Judge The Judge found that the amendments to Art 31 by the resolutions passed on 8 December 2015 were oppressive to, unfairly prejudicial to, and unfairly discriminatory against Wilmar for a number of reasons:(a)As Wilmar remains obliged until 30 June 2017 to supply 100% of its production of raw sugar for export to QSL, it has an economic interest in QSL marketing that sugar for the best economic return and, accordingly, a “real and significant continuing commercial interest” in the way in which QSL’s affairs are conducted. Despite those interests, it is now precluded from participating in the conduct of QSL’s affairs, at [120];(b)Although QSL says that the amendments to Art 31 are justified by the competition which it will now face from Wilmar (and from MSF and Tully), it already faces competition of that kind in respect of the SEIS. That is particularly so given that approximately one‑third of the raw sugar supplied by Wilmar, MSF, Tully, Isis and Mackay is SEIS and Wilmar’s SEIS alone is greater than the production of raw sugar (including SEIS) supplied by the BIM Mills to QSL. Such conflicts of interest as may have arisen in the past from competitive marketing in relation of the SEIS, have been managed adequately (through the existence of an independent Board of Directors) and the Judge considered that it was not easy to see why such conflicts as may arise in the future could not be managed in a similar way, at [121]‑[122];(c)QSL’s argument that Wilmar had not in the past exercised its right to appoint Mill Owner Directors and, inferentially, had thereby chosen not to participate in its affairs was not persuasive. Wilmar had not appointed Mill Owner Directors but that was because of its preference that QSL’s Board be comprised of independent directors. The fact that Mill Owner Directors have not been appointed since 2008 was a reflection of Wilmar’s potential voting power, at [123];(d)Had Wilmar exercised its voting power to appoint Mill Owner Directors, those directors, once appointed, would have had fiduciary and statutory duties to QSL and not to Wilmar, at [124];(e)QSL’s submissions underestimated the significance of the entrenched dominant position given to the BIM Mills in the appointment of Mill Owner Directors under the new Art 31 and overlooked that, because of the potential for a growers’ nomination in respect of GEIS, Wilmar may well continue to have a significant commercial involvement with QSL, at [125]. The trial Judge made this assessment by reference to the circumstances which existed as at the time of his decision (1 February 2016) and as they were expected to be until 30 June 2017. This is an important consideration given that Wilmar is contractually bound until 30 June 2017 to supply all the sugar it mills (other than GEIS) to QSL. If the constitutional amendments were not to take effect until after 1 July 2017, it is possible that the Judge’s assessment of the commercial fairness of the situation may have been different. That is not a matter which this Court need address.The Appellants’ contentions

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.