Kerle v BM Alliance Coal Operations Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Kerle v BM Alliance Coal Operations Pty Ltd & Ors (No 2) [2017] QSC 7

PARTIES:

HAROLD FREDRICK KERLE
(Plaintiff)

v

BM ALLIANCE COAL OPERATIONS PTY LTD

(ACN 096 412 752)
(First Defendant)

AND

HMP CONSTRUCTIONS PTY LTD (IN LIQUDATION)

(ACN 109 896 013)

(Second Defendant)

AND

AXIAL HR PTY LTD (ACN 110 799 034)

(Third Defendant)

FILE NO/S:

S528 of 2011

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Trial

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland

DELIVERED ON:

13 February 2017

DELIVERED AT:

Rockhampton

HEARING DATE:

30 January 2017

JUDGE:

McMeekin J

ORDERS:

  1. The judgment and orders will be in accordance with the draft initialled by me and attached to these reasons.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – COSTS – RECOVERY OF COSTS – MULTIPLE DEFENDANTS – where plaintiff was successful in suit for damages – where the amount of damages had earlier been agreed between the parties – where there is a dispute as to the appropriate costs orders – where liability as between the defendants as well as between the plaintiff and the defendants was in issue – whether the plaintiff’s costs should be on the indemnity or standard basis – whether there are differences between an mandatory final offer made under a statutory regime and a Calderbank offer – whether the defendants should be ordered to pay the plaintiff’s costs in proportions consistent with the apportionment of liability – whether any certification for senior and junior counsel should extend to the whole of the matter or be limited to the trial.

Law Reform Act 1995 (Qld) s 6, s 7
Personal Injuries Proceedings Act
2002 (Qld) s 4, s 20, s 22, s 23, s 25, s 37, s 39, s 40(8), s 41
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) r 360, r 363, r 703
Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation Act
2003 (Qld) s 292, s 312, s 316, s 318B, s 318D

2040 Logan Road Pty Ltd v Body Corporate for Paddington Mews CTS 39149 (No 2) [2016] QSC 65 distinguished
Aircraft Technicians of Australia Pty Ltd v St Clair; St Clair v Timtalla Pty Ltd [2011] QCA 188 considered
Australand Corporation (Qld) Pty Ltd v Johnson & Ors [2007] QSC 128 applied
Baxter v Obacelo (2001) 205 CLR 635 considered
Bulsey v State of Queensland
[2016] QCA 158 cited
Chaina v Alvaro Homes Pty Ltd [2008] NSWCA 353 distinguished
Colgate Palmolive Co v Cussons Pty Ltd (1993) 46 FCR 225 cited
Cosgrove & Anor v Johns [2000] QCA 157 cited
Gibbings-Johns v Corliss (No 2)
[2010] QSC 78 distinguished
Hazeldene’s Chicken Farm Pty Ltd v Victorian WorkCover Authority (No 2) [2005] 13 VR 435 considered
Hobbs v Oildrive (No 2) [2008] QSC 52 cited
J & D Rigging Pty Ltd v Agripower Australia Limited & Ors [2014] QCA 23 cited
James Hardie & Co Ltd v Wyong Shire Council (2000) 48 NSWLR 679; (2000) 19 NSWCCR 679; [2000] NSWCA 107 applied
Lawes v Nominal Defendant [2007] QSC 103 cited
OverseaChinese Banking Corporation v Richfield Investments…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kerle v BM Alliance Coal Operations Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] QSC 7
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Kerle v BM Alliance Coal Operations Pty Ltd (No 2) involved the plaintiff, Mr Kerle, who had successfully sued the defendants for damages. The amount of damages had been previously agreed upon between the parties. The court was tasked with resolving disputes regarding the appropriate costs orders and the basis on which the plaintiff's costs should be awarded. The plaintiff sought indemnity costs on the basis of the defendants' alleged imprudent rejection of settlement offers, a well-recognised ground for such an award. The defendants, however, argued that the plaintiff's costs should be on the standard basis. Additionally, the court needed to determine whether the costs should be apportioned according to the defendants' liability and whether the certification for senior and junior counsel should cover the entire proceedings or just the trial.

The court examined the distinctions between mandatory final offers made under statutory regimes and Calderbank offers, recognising that the former are not generally considered in determining costs on the indemnity basis. The court also considered the defendants' offers to each other and the plaintiff, which were all nil amounts. The court found that the plaintiff was entitled to indemnity costs unless the third defendant could show that a different order was appropriate. The court concluded that the plaintiff was entitled to indemnity costs from the first and second defendants and standard costs from the third defendant. The costs were to be apportioned according to the defendants' liability, and the certification for senior and junior counsel was to cover the whole of the matter.

The court's final orders were to be in accordance with the draft initialled by the judge and attached to the reasons for judgment. This comprehensive resolution ensured that the plaintiff received the costs he was entitled to, based on the established legal principles and the specific circumstances of the case.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The judgment and orders will be in accordance with the draft initialled by me and attached to these reasons.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The judgment and orders will be in accordance with the draft initialled by me and attached to these reasons. McMeekin J: I delivered reasons in this matter on 16 December 2016[1] (“the Reasons”). Mr Kerle was successful in his suit for damages. The amount of damages had earlier been agreed between the parties. I directed that the parties confer in an endeavour to agree on the orders that should be made to give effect to my reasons. There is a dispute as to the appropriate costs orders. It is not in issue that the plaintiff should receive his costs. [1]Kerle v BM Alliance Coal Operations Pty Ltd & Ors [2016] QSC 304. It is relevant to note that liability as between the defendants as well as between the plaintiff and the defendants was in issue. I am advised that the parties have essentially agreed on the form of orders subject to the resolution of the following matters: The basis of the plaintiff’s claim to be entitled to an order for indemnity costs is the alleged imprudent rejection of his offers to settle by each of the defendants. That is a well-accepted ground for the awarding of costs on the indemnity basis: see Colgate Palmolive Company & Anor v Cussons Pty Limited [1993] FCA 536 at [24]; Cosgrove & Anor v Johns [2000] QCA 157. The effect of my findings is that the plaintiff is entitled to judgment against the first and second defendants for the sum of $1,250,000 and as against the third defendant in the sum of $685,683.94. The defendants are jointly and severally liable. On 11 June 2013 following a joint PIPA/WCRA compulsory conference the plaintiff made mandatory final offers to each defendant. To the first and second defendants the plaintiff offered to settle in the sum of $1,050,000 plus costs pursuant to section 39 PIPA. To the third defendant the plaintiff offered to settle in the sum of $500,000 clear of the statutory refund to WorkCover plus regulation costs pursuant to s 292 WCRA. Under the respective pieces of legislation governing the respective proceedings the conference is required to be held in the pre-litigation stage but here the plaintiff had obtained leave to deliver, and had delivered, a Claim and Statement of Claim to the PIPA defendants. No pleading had been delivered to the third defendant. On 21 March 2016 the plaintiff made formal offers to settle separately to each defendant purportedly pursuant to Chapter 9, Part 5 of the UCPR. To the first and second defendants the plaintiff offered to settle in the sum of $1,000,000 plus standards costs and outlays. To the third defendant the plaintiff offered to settle in the sum of $444,000 (clear of the statutory refund to WorkCover) plus standards costs. I note that the defendants each offered a nil amount to the plaintiff following the compulsory conference and made an offer of a nil amount to each other in respect of contribution proceedings. It is common ground between the plaintiff and the third defendant that given the result of the trial the plaintiff is entitled to an award of costs on the indemnity basis unless the third defendant demonstrates that some other order is appropriate: see ss 312; 318B(2) WCRA.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.