Kelsey v Logan City Council & Ors (No 7)

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:

Kelsey v Logan City Council & Ors (No.7) [2019] QIRC 085

PARTIES:  

Kelsey, Sharon Rae Marie
(Applicant)

v

Logan City Council
(First Respondent)

&

Smith, Timothy Luke
(Second Respondent)

&

Dalley, Cherie Marie
(Third Respondent)

&

Lutton, Russell Bruce
(Fourth Respondent)

&

Swenson, Stephen Frederick
(Fifth Respondent)

&

Smith, Laurence William
(Sixth Respondent)

&

Pidgeon, Philip Wayne
(Seventh Respondent)

&

Schwarz, Trevina Dale
(Eighth Respondent)

&

Breene, Jennifer Rachael Julie
(Ninth Respondent)

CASE NO:

PID/2017/3

PROCEEDING:

Application in existing proceedings

DELIVERED ON:

4 June 2019

HEARING DATES: 

29 May 2019

MEMBER:

HEARD AT:

O'Connor VP  

Brisbane

ORDERS:

1.    Application dismissed  

2.    Costs be reserved  

CATCHWORDS:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – PUBLIC INTEREST DISCLOSURE – PROCEDURE – COMMISSION PROCEDURE – PRACTICE UNDER TRIBUNAL RULES – STAYING PROCEEDINGS – where Second to Ninth Respondents have been criminally charged – where criminal proceedings not yet determined – whether commission proceedings should be stayed until disposal of criminal proceedings determined

LEGISLATION:

CASES:

Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld) ss 285, 451, 452, 539

Industrial Relations (Tribunals) Rules 2011 (Qld) r 41

Public Interests Disclosure Act 2010 s 48

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Managed Investments Limited & Ors (No 5) [2013] QSC 313

Australian Securities Commission v Cavanagh (1993) 12 ACSR 69

Commissioner of the Australian Federal Police v Zhao (2015) 225 CLR 46; [2015] HCA 5

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (2016) 242 FCR 153

Gypsy Fire v Truth Newspapers Pty Ltd (1987) 9 NSWLR 382

McLachlan v Browne (No 9) [2019] NSWSC 10

McMahon v Gould (1982) 7 ACLR 202

Osric Investments Pty Ltd v Probst and Anor [2007] QSC 293

R v Ferguson; Ex parte Attorney-General (Qld) (2008) 186 A Crim R 483

Re AWB Ltd (No 1) (2008) 21 VR 252

State of Queensland v Bush [2003] QSC 375

White v Australian Securities and Investments Commission & Ors (2013) 237 A Crim R 83; [2013] QCA 357

APPEARANCES:

Mr C Murdoch QC with Ms H Stephanos of Counsel instructed by Minter Ellison Lawyers for the Applicant.

Mr A Herbert of Counsel, instructed by King & Company Solicitors for the First Respondent.

Mr J Hunter QC with Mr M Trim instructed by Gadens Lawyers for the Second Respondent.

Mr W Friend QC with Mr C Massy of Counsel, instructed by McInnes Wilson Lawyers for the Third to Ninth Respondents.

Reasons for Decision

  1. The Second to Ninth Respondents seek a stay of the current proceedings before the Commission until the hearing and determination of criminal charges against both the Second Respondent and each of the Third to Ninth Respondents.

  2. The Second Respondent contends that the stay of the existing proceedings should be granted because:

(a)   If a stay is granted in relation to the proceedings against the Third to the Ninth Respondents (and it should be) then there is no additional prejudice arising from the stay of the proceedings against him and the proceedings cannot and should not sensibly continue in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kelsey v Logan City Council & Ors (No 7) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QIRC 85
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Kelsey v Logan City Council & Ors (No 7) involved the applicant, Kelsey, who had commenced proceedings against multiple respondents, including the Logan City Council. The dispute arose under industrial law, specifically concerning public interest disclosures, and the procedural aspects of the proceedings within the Industrial Commission. The Second to Ninth Respondents sought to stay the commission proceedings on the basis that they had been criminally charged, and the criminal proceedings were yet to be determined. The key legal issue before the court was whether the commission proceedings should be stayed until the outcome of the criminal proceedings was determined. The Second to Ninth Respondents argued that there was an inevitable overlap between the criminal charges and the commission proceedings, which could prejudice the criminal proceedings and cause irreparable harm to the Respondents.

The court carefully considered the history and chronology of the proceedings, noting that the commission proceedings were at an advanced stage while the criminal proceedings were in their early stages. The court highlighted that there would likely be a significant period before the criminal trial, providing some separation between the outcomes of the two sets of proceedings. The court also observed that the proceedings had already attracted significant media attention, suggesting that a stay would not mitigate the Respondents' concerns about publicity. The court rejected the argument that the jury would not be able to disregard extraneous material or follow the trial judge's directions, emphasising the expectation that jurors would discharge their duties properly. The court concluded that the Respondents' submissions asked it to undermine the presumption of jury robustness and the effectiveness of trial judge directions, which the court was not prepared to accept. Based on these considerations, the court dismissed the application for a stay and reserved costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Application dismissed

2. Costs be reserved

Decision

Reasons for decision

It is not in contention that the Second to Ninth Respondents costs associated with the defence of these proceedings have been met by the First Respondent's insurer.Conclusion In considering this matter I have had regard, amongst other things, to the history of these proceedings. In particular, I note that proceedings commenced on 1 December 2017 against the First and Second Respondents with an amended application filed on 23 March 2018 joining the Third to Ninth Respondents. The chronology of this matter indicates that there have been a multitude of interlocutory steps, including a substantial and ultimately unsuccessful reinstatement application. The substantive hearing commenced on 17 December 2018. The hearing of the evidence was spread over two periods of time concluding on 15 February 2019. Written submissions from all parties have been filed in the Industrial Registry. The principal basis upon which the Second to Ninth Respondents seeks to justify the stay is that, as submitted by the Second Respondent there is "…an inevitable overlap between the criminal charges against all of the Second to Ninth Respondents and this proceeding". As such, it is argued that it gives rise to a real risk of prejudice to the conduct of the criminal proceedings against the Second to Ninth Respondents. Coupled with that is the argument that the publicity arising out of these proceedings would cause the Second to Ninth Respondents irreparable harm in defending the criminal proceedings. I do not accept that submission. As I have observed above, the distinguishing feature of this matter is that the civil proceedings are at an advanced stage. The criminal proceedings are "embryonic". There is likely to be a significant period of time before the criminal trial is set down for hearing giving some degree of separation between the outcome of these proceedings and the hearing of the criminal charges. Moreover, these proceedings have already been the subject of significant media attention and much of it in the public arena. The granting of a stay in these proceedings is not likely to address any concerns the Second to Ninth Respondents might have in that regard. The submissions of the Second to Ninth Respondents, in effect, ask me to abandon the presumption that juries are robust and have an ability to put material extraneous to the evidence in the proceeding before them out of mind and to assume that they will disregard the direction given to them by the trial judge in the criminal proceedings. They ask me to assume that a juror or jurors will not be true to their oath or affirmation to conscientiously try the charge against the accused according to the evidence. I do not accept that proposition. As was observed by McMurdo P, Keane and Muir JJA in R v Ferguson; ex parte A-G (Qld):[30] R v Ferguson; Ex parte Attorney-General (Qld) (2008) 186 A Crim R 483, 502. [58]. See also: The Queen v Glennon (1992) 173 CLR 592.As our discussion of the authorities shows, juries are expected to discharge their duties properly even after sensationalised and prejudicial media reporting of quite horrific crimes. That expectation is informed, both by the necessity to accept, if jury trials are to be maintained, that jurors will be true to their oaths and follow the trial judge's directions, and the justified confidence that jurors do routinely meet that necessity. It may be that, on occasion, orders for a change of venue or an adjournment of a trial may be necessary to defuse potential prejudice from pre-trial publicity.[30]