JSDW and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration) [2017] AATA 2420 (1 November 2017)
Division:GENERAL DIVISION
File Number: 2016/4779
Re:JSDW
APPLICANT
AndMinister for Immigration and Border Protection
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal:Deputy President Dr Christopher Kendall
Deputy President Stephen BoyleDate:1 November 2017
Place:Perth
The decision under review is affirmed
............[sgd].........................................................
Deputy President Dr Christopher Kendall
CATCHWORDS
IMMIGRATION – whether applicant is a person to whom Australia has protection obligations – applicant found guilty of people smuggling and sentenced to term of imprisonment in Australia – credibility finding -- serious reasons for considering applicant has committed a serious non-political crime -- decision under review affirmed
LEGISLATION
Anti-People Smuggling and Other Measures Act 2010 – s 8
Migration Act 1958 – ss 5(1), 5H(1)-(2), 29, 36(1A), 36(2), 36(2C), 46A(1), 91L, 189, 195A, 500(1)(c), 501K
Migration Regulations 1994 – Sch 2, subcl 785
CASES
Al-Habr and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [1999] AATA 150
Applicant NADB of 2001 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2002] FCAFC 326
Arquita v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2000) 106 FCR 465
Dhayakpa v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1995) 62 FCR 556
FTZK v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2014] HCA 26
Hapugoda v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1997) 46 ALD 659
Ovcharuk v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1998) 88 FCR 173
Ramirez v Canada (Minister of Employment and Immigration) (1992) 2 FC 306
SRYYY v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2005] FCAFC 42
SZCWP v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2006] FCAFC 9
SZRMQ v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2013) 139 ALD 436
WAKN v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCA 1245
YYMT and MQCR and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2010] AATA 447
SECONDARY MATERIALS
1951 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees as Amended by the 1967 Protocol – Articles 1A, 1F
UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), Guidelines on International Protection No. 5: Application of the Exclusion Clauses: Article 1F of the 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees, 4 September 2003, HCR/GIP/03/05, available at:
UNHCR Handbook and Guidelines on Procedures and Criteria For Determining Refugee Status, Reissued Geneva, December 2011
UNCHR Guidelines On International Protection: Application of the Exclusion Clauses: Article 1F of the 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees
Background Note on the Application of the Exclusion Clauses: Article: 1F of the 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees,
Guy S, Goodwin‑Gill and Jane McAdams, The Refugee in International Law, Oxford University Press 3rd ed, 2007
REASONS FOR DECISION
Deputy President Dr Christopher Kendall
1 November 2017
INTRODUCTION
Section 501K of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the “Migration Act”) provides that when a review by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the “Tribunal”) relates to a person who seeks or has a protection visa, the Tribunal will not publish any information that identifies that person or any…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read JSDW and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Mig... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] AATA 2420
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the AAT were whether JSDW was a person to whom Australia owed protection obligations, and specifically, whether the crime for which he was convicted constituted a serious non-political crime. This determination was crucial because if the crime was found to be serious and non-political, it would disqualify JSDW from meeting the criteria for a protection visa, even if he faced a real risk of significant harm if returned to Afghanistan. The AAT was required to assess the nature and circumstances of the people smuggling offence in light of Article 1F of the Refugees Convention and section 36(2C) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth).
The AAT reasoned that JSDW's conviction for facilitating the unlawful entry of Ms. [A] and her children, which involved receiving payments and arranging their transport to Australia, was a serious offence. While the sentencing judge noted JSDW's role was low-level and not for purely commercial purposes, the AAT found that the act of organising and facilitating illegal maritime arrivals, which carries significant risks to human life and undermines Australia's immigration laws, was inherently serious. The AAT concluded that this crime was non-political in nature. Therefore, applying Article 1F of the Refugees Convention and section 36(2C)(a)(ii) of the Migration Act, JSDW was taken not to satisfy the criterion for protection, as he had committed a serious non-political crime before entering Australia.
Consequently, the AAT affirmed the decision under review, finding that Australia did not have protection obligations towards JSDW under the Refugees Convention and that he did not satisfy the criterion for complementary protection due to his conviction for a serious non-political crime.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Accordingly, if the Tribunal finds that JSDW committed a serious non-political crime before entering Australia, he does not satisfy the criterion in s 36(2)(aa), and will not be a person in respect of whom Australia has protection obligations under that provision, even if there is a real risk he will suffer significant harm if he were to be removed to Afghanistan.CONSIDERATIONWas the crime for which JSDW was convicted under s 233A of the Migration Act a serious non-political crime? On 5 September 2014, JSDW was convicted of organising or facilitating the unlawful entry of a second person into Australia contrary to s 233A of the Migration Act (ST3 at 682). JSDW contends that, when considering the offence and all surrounding circumstances together, the crime for which he was convicted was not serious enough to warrant exclusion under Article 1F of the Refugees Convention or s 36(2C) of the Migration Act (paragraph 34 of JSDW’s amended SoFIC). JSDW pleaded not guilty to the relevant charge. A hearing took place in the District Court of Western Australia before Herron DCJ between 25 August 2014 and 5 September 2014 (ST3 at 682). Another individual involved with the unlawful entry vessel on which JSDW arrived was tried at the same time as JSDW and the charges against both accused were heard together. In sentencing JSDW, Judge Herron made the following comments. (Note that the Tribunal has changed reference in the transcript to JSDW’s name and the names of other individuals involved to protect their identity and has deleted the comments by His Honour relating only to the other accused person)(ST2 at 667-680):[JSDW] and [other accused], you were both charged on indictment dated 21 August 2014.[JSDW], you were charged with one count, of between 1 January 2012 and 6 May 2012, in Indonesia and seas between Indonesia and Australia, you organised or facilitated the bringing or coming to Australia of a person who was a non-citizen, namely Ms [A], where it said that Ms [A] had no lawful right to come to Australia.……you each pleaded not guilty to the charge on the indictment. Your trial commenced on 25 August 2014. On 5 September, the jury returned verdicts of guilty to the charge against each of you.…In relation to the offence of which you have each been convicted and consistently with the verdict of the jury, I find the facts as follows, and [JSDW] I'll deal with you first.While Ms [A] was staying in …. Indonesia with her three children, in about February 2012, she met you. You were also known as [M]. Initially, you spoke with Ms [A]’s brother as to whether she wanted to travel any further, and you were told she didn't. However, she later decided she did want to travel to Australia and she discussed with you travelling to Australia for her and her three children. You paid - you said you would - I'll start that again.You said you would arrange their travel from Indonesia to Christmas Island if she paid you $16,000. Ms [A] told you she only had access to $10,000. You told her you would accept payment of $10,000 immediately and the remainder of $6,000 could be paid after she had come to Australia and been released from detention.Ms [A] then arranged through her brother, who was living in Malaysia, for the $10,000 to be paid. There were two separate payments; one of $8,000 and one of $2,000. The $8,000 was sent by Ms [A]’s brother to her mother who was in Indonesia as well, and then given to you in the presence of Ms [A] at the house she was staying in, in Bogor. The second amount of $2,000 was transferred directly from Ms [A]'s brother in a different person's name.You later confirmed with Ms [A] you had received the amount of $2,000 and told her they would be leaving soon to travel to Australia. That was in about May of 2012. You then came to Ms [A]'s house and told her to come with you, with her children, so that they could commence their travels. They went with you in a car to where you told them a boat would be leaving that night.Ms [A] then got onto a boat which left Indonesia for Australia. You travelled on the same boat. That boat, SIEV 326, was later intercepted by the Australian Navy about 70 nautical miles north of Christmas Island after information was received the boat was in distress.It was the Crown case you assisted Ms [A] to travel to Australia by (1) receiving money paid on her behalf and arranging for her to travel to Australia; (2) arranging and assisting with her transport from her house to get onto a boat to travel to Australia. I find you assisted Ms [A] and her children to travel to Australia as alleged by the Crown.That is the same boat which was later given the label by the Australian Navy SIEV 326. I find you [other accused] assisted Mr [H] as alleged by the Crown. By assisting Ms [A] and Mr [H] to get onto the boat SIEV 326 which was later intercepted by the Australian Navy, you each intended that by that assistance Ms [A] and Mr [H] Ms [A] would be brought to Australia and you each organised or facilitated the bringing or coming of a person to Australia.Can I come back to you, [JSDW]? [JSDW], when you collected Ms [A] and her children and told her they had to leave the house and they were leaving that night that while they were travelling in the taxi she asked what would happen to her other family members who were in Bogor. You told her there wasn't room on that boat and they would come on another boat a few days later.Her family other than her children didn't in fact come on that boat as you told her. The payment of a deposit in Indonesia with a balance to be paid in Australia was consistent with the evidence of Federal Agent [C] as to his experience and how people smugglers operate. The amount Ms [A] paid to you was also consistent with the evidence of Federal Agent [C] as to the amounts charged by people smugglers.In Indonesia when you took Ms [A] to your co-accused, [other accused]'s house, you said that you worked for [other accused]. In your record of interview you said you helped [other accused]. You said in your record of interview that your co-accused, [other accused], charged you $4,000 to arrange for you to come to Australia. You paid $2,000 and because you didn't have the extra $2,000 you agreed to work for [other accused].…You told Mr [H] that when the boat was ready someone else would come and pick him up and take him to the boat and that is in fact- what happened. As I've already explained, Mr [H] was first taken to a villa where he stayed overnight with others who were also intending to illegally travel to Australia.From those circumstances I draw the inference that each of you knew or were aware of the purpose and destination of the voyage and facilitated the travelling of Ms [A] and Mr [H] intentionally. You each denied he organised or facilitated the coming or bringing to Australia of Ms [A] or Mr [H].You both said that you were in the same position as each of them in that you yourselves had paid people smugglers to organise and facilitate your own entry to Australia on SIEV 326. In sentencing each of you for the offence that you have committed I am required to impose a sentence which is of a severity appropriate in all of the circumstances of the offence.When sentencing you I must consider the following matters; the nature and circumstances of the offence, the degree to which you have cooperated with law enforcement agencies in the investigation of the offence, the need to ensure that you're adequately punished for the offence, personal deterrence, your character and background including any physical or mental condition, your prospects of rehabilitation and the effect on family or dependents.I must also consider general deterrence. General deterrence is an important sentencing consideration in cases of this type. I must place weight on the need to impose a sentence that is capable of acting as a deterrent to others who might be tempted to engage in the type of conduct that you have engaged in. ...A necessary consequence giving effect to the sentencing consideration of general deterrence is that less weight must be given to mitigating circumstances that are personal to you. That is not to say that - such mitigating circumstances are irrelevant. They are not, however, they assume less weight than might otherwise be the case.I must only pass a sentence of imprisonment if after having considered all other available sentences I am satisfied that no other sentence is appropriate in the circumstances. The role of general deterrence in cases of this kind cannot be doubted.People smuggling threatens the orderly administration of immigration laws, imposes a financial burden on the Australian public, necessitates the deployment of military, customs and other governmental resources, encourages official corruption in other nations and exploits and imperils the health and lives of those carried or attempted to be carried into Australia. The statutory maximum penalty for people smuggling is 10 years' imprisonment or a fine of $110,000 or both.In assessing the seriousness of your offending, I take into account the following matters in sentencing you.[JSDW], again, I'll deal with you first.You played a central role in the arrival of Ms [A] who was an unlawful non-citizen of Australia, to Australia, but I accept you were a low-level participant in the facilitation of the illegal bringing or coming to Australia of Ms [A].When you initially spoke with Ms [A]'s brother in Indonesia, whether they wanted to travel further, they said they didn't, but she later told you she did want to come to Australia. Had you not initially approached her, she would probably not have later contacted you about coming to Australia.Initially, when she spoke to you, she said she didn't have enough money. You then negotiated payment of a significant amount of US$16,000 for Ms [A] and her three children. In due course, a payment of US$10,000 was made to you, and an agreement was reached that the remaining amount of US$6,000 would be paid to you after arrival in Australia. You directly arranged for the transfer of Ms [A] and her children from the home they were living in, in Indonesia, to the boat which ultimately travelled to Australia. You travelled on the same boat.Although the boat was able to travel to near Christmas Island, it was overcrowded and barely in a seaworthy condition. The vessel was intercepted by the Australian Navy after a distress signal from the vessel sent by Ms [A] was given because of difficulties being' experienced on the boat. The health and life of Ms [A] and her children was placed at risk by travelling aboard the boat.While at the detention centre on Christmas Island, you told Ms [A] not to give your name to the immigration authorities. Your involvement directly led to the successful entry into Australia of Ms [A]. I also take into account the following matters: prior to coming to Australia, you paid $10,000 to travel from Pakistan to Indonesia in the expectation, for that sum, you would continue on to Australia.However, you were arrested by Indonesian police as an unlawful entrant and spent six months and 20 days in an immigration detention facility in Indonesia. You had US$2,000 in cash with you which was confiscated by police and not returned. You were registered with the UNHCR in Indonesia and accepted as a refugee on 30 December 2010.You were released from immigration detention on 21 January 2011 and then sent to an immigration camp in Medan, where you spent approximately 12 months before then moving to Bogor where you tried to organise your own travel to Australia.Because you lost contact with your original people smuggler, you had to make further arrangements to travel onto Australia and pay a further sum of $4,000. Because you weren't able to afford the full sum, you agreed to assist people smugglers in return for being promised that arrangements would be made for you to be taken to Australia. I'm satisfied your role was a low-level assistant for other agents higher up in the people smuggling network.I accept the submission of your counsel that your role was like a scout or an agent to contact passengers and collect money. Your involvement in people smuggling was necessitated by your own circumstances, by being in Indonesia without the required moneys to arrange to be transferred to Australia. I accept there is no evidence that you retained the moneys received by Ms [A], and it is likely you passed the moneys on to other people. Your role in organising Ms [A]'s travel to Australia was not for commercial purposes, but was to assist you in also being able to travel to Australia. You were in a similar position to Ms [A] and travelled on the same boat.…I now turn to deal with each of your personal circumstances and background, and again, [JSDW] I'll come to you first.You were aged 32 years. You are from the Hazara ethnic group. Your first language is Hazaragi, but you also speak Urdu, which is the language in which you spoke with the interpreter when you gave evidence at the trial.You were born in Afghanistan. You left Afghanistan in 2008, and then lived in Quetta, in Pakistan until you left for Indonesia in 2010. Because of threats to Hazara people in Pakistan, you decided to travel to Australia.You spoke to an agent in Quetta who told you it would cost $12,000 US to get you to Australia. You travelled from Quetta to Karachi, then to Thailand, then Malaysia, and then to Indonesia. You were in Indonesia for about two years.As I've already outlined, you were arrested in Indonesia and handed over to immigration authorities and spent the next six months and 20 days in a detention centre in Indonesia. You were then accepted as a refugee and sent to a camp in Maydan. You then lived in Jakarta and in Bogor for about four months before you took the boat to Christmas Island, which was intercepted by the Australian Navy.The fact that you were in Bogor for four months I have taken into account in assessing the extent to which you were involved in a people smuggling network. I accept the submission of your counsel that because of the short time you were in Bogor, you could not have had sufficient time to get significantly involved in people smuggling activities.I have also taken into account that your own financial circumstances were poor, and that while in Bogor you were baking and selling bread to support yourself. The payment for you to travel to Indonesia and payment of the $12,000 was made by your brother with a people smuggling representative in Pakistan. Your brother paid $10,000 US and a further $2,000 was paid to cover any extra expenses, which would be reimbursed if there was a difference.You travelled from Karachi with three friends. A Visa and passport was arranged for you by an agent, and then taken off you when you got to Bangkok. You were arrested in Indonesia on 9 June 2010 because you didn't have a passport or Visa or any travel documents. You didn't have a Visa to come to Australia.You were later advised by the UNHCR that it would take another two years to be processed as a refugee. You became frustrated at the time involved and then travelled to Jakarta without telling anyone, when you then renewed your refugee card. You then travelled to Bogor, where there were many other Hazara people, all of whom had the sole objective to get to Australia. Everyone was asking for the names of agents who could help them get to Australia.…Neither of you have a prior record in Australia. You have each been detained in an immigration detention centre since your arrival on Christmas Island on 6 May 2012.You each pleaded not guilty to the offence of which you have been convicted, as was your right. The fact that you pleaded not guilty does not aggravate the seriousness of your offence. However, it does mean that you do not attract the significant mitigatory benefit and associated reduction in sentence which comes with a guilty plea.The prosecution does not contend that either of you are at high risk of re-offending, or that there is an increased need for personal deterrence.[JSDW], I have been provided with a reference by [Ms R], dated 24 September 2014. She says she has known you for over two years and met you through her work as a volunteer with the Coalition for Asylum Seekers, Refugees and Detainees, visiting refugees and asylum seekers at the Yongah Hill Immigration Detention Centre in Northam in 2012.[Ms R] first met you in August 2012, and you were one of a number of mainly Hazara men she met with on a regular basis. She said that because of your English language skills you were always looking out for other detainees, particularly older men without good English language skills, to ensure that any issues confronting them were discussed and raised.After she stopped visiting Yongah Hill she continued to regularly communicate with you by email. You often raised issues about some of the other detainees, providing them with advocacy, relationship and support advice.After you were transferred to the Perth Immigration Detention Centre for a period of weeks, [Ms R] regularly visited you and discussed your situation. She describes you as a person of great personal inner strength who cares for those around you. You have a positive attitude to life despite the extreme hardship you have experienced. You have good written and spoken English language skills. You are polite and well-spoken. Each of you are in good physical and mental health. The object of the Migration Act is to regulate in the national interest the coming into and the presence in Australia of non-citizens.The unlawful entry of non-citizens into Australia is a serious violation of this country's sovereignty and national security. Australia is particularly at risk from such offences due to its large coastline. Illegal immigration poses significant health and quarantine risks, and presents obvious social problems to the fabric of Australian society.In addition to the significant impact of such offences on the Australian public, people smuggling also threatens the orderly administration of Australia's immigration laws. Many other deserving people who might otherwise have secured lawful entry into Australia are the indirect victims of illegal people smuggling.The passengers who are brought to Australia in illegal people smuggling operations are also exploited, paying large sums of money and often risking safety and health in un-seaworthy vessels in the promise of a better life in Australia.Generally, a conviction for people smuggling only justifies a sentence of immediate imprisonment. In determining the length of the non-parole period, or the period before release, pursuant to a Reconnaissance Release Order, a court is required to fix a term that justice requires the offender to serve, having regard to all of the circumstances of the offending.In my view, in the case of each of you, only a term of imprisonment can, in all of the circumstances, be justified.[JSDW], I will deal with you first.I sentence you to three years and six months' imprisonment.And I order that you are to be released after serving two years, five months' imprisonment, upon you giving security by reconnaissance in the sum of $2,000 to be of good behaviour for a period of 12 months.…The purpose of this order is intended to reflect the serious nature of the offence and hopefully its effect will reinforce the deterrent effect of the sentence.If you agree to be bound by the order you will be released from custody having already served two years and five months in detention and provided that you are of good behaviour for the balance of the term, you will not be subject to any further penalty in respect of the offence of which you have each been convicted.But if you fail without reasonable cause to comply with the conditions of the order, you may be brought back before the court and the court may then revoke the order, order that you forfeit the amount of the security, that is, the sum of $2,000…