SZCWP v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs
Link copied
CaseCopied
77 min read
Full text
FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
SZCWP v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2006] FCAFC 9
IMMIGRATION – Refugees – Application for protection visa – Applicant Nepalese citizen who was associated with Maoist insurgents – Applicant held to be excluded from application of Refugees Convention on the basis of serious reasons for considering he had committed war crimes and crimes against humanity – Whether Administrative Appeals Tribunal erred in law in determining that question – Tribunal’s application of definitions in Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court – Whether Tribunal failed to have regard to particular requirements of definitions.
1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees, Article 1F
Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court, Articles 7(1), 8(2), 9
SZCWP v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AND INDIGENOUS AFFAIRS NSD 1321 OF 2004
WILCOX, GYLES and DOWNES JJ 20 FEBRUARY 2006 SYDNEY
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
NSD 1321 of 2004
BETWEEN:
SZCWP APPLICANT
AND:
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AND INDIGENOUS AFFAIRS RESPONDENT
JUDGES:
WILCOX, GYLES, DOWNES JJ
DATE OF ORDER:
20 FEBRUARY 2006
WHERE MADE:
SYDNEY
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The application be dismissed.
2. The applicant pay the costs of the respondent.
Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
NSD 1321 of 2004
BETWEEN:
SZCWP APPLICANT
AND:
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AND INDIGENOUS AFFAIRS RESPONDENT
JUDGES:
WILCOX, GYLES, DOWNES JJ
DATE:
20 FEBRUARY 2006
PLACE:
SYDNEY
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
WILCOX J:
This is an appeal, pursuant to s 44 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (‘the AAT Act’), from a decision of a Deputy President of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (‘the AAT’).
Background
The learned Deputy President affirmed a decision of a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (‘the Minister’) refusing to grant to the applicant a Protection (Class XA) visa. The delegate’s refusal was based upon findings that the applicant:
‘(a)is excluded from protection under the 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees as amended by the 1967 Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees, ("the Refugees’ Convention"), there being strong reasons to consider that he has been complicit in and has committed war crimes and crimes against humanity within the meaning of article (1) F of the Refugees’ Convention whilst an active member of the Nepalese Maoists; and
(b)is not a person to whom Australia has protection obligations under the Refugees’ Convention and does not meet the prescribed criterion in subclause 866.221 for the grant of a subclass 866 (Protection) Visa.’
This finding was relevant because s 36(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) makes it a criterion for a protection visa that the applicant is a non-citizen to whom the Minister is satisfied Australia has protection obligations under the Refugees’ Convention.
As the Deputy President explained, on 15…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read SZCWP v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indig... and more:
The case of SZCWP v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs involves a Nepalese citizen who has applied for refugee status in Australia. The applicant claims asylum on the basis of fear of persecution in Nepal due to his involvement with a Maoist group. The Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs rejected the applicant’s claim, arguing that his involvement with the Maoist group constituted crimes against humanity and war crimes, thus falling under the exclusions in Article 1F of the Refugees’ Convention. The applicant appealed this decision to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT), which upheld the Minister’s decision. The applicant then sought judicial review of the AAT’s decision in the Federal Court of Australia.
The central legal issue in this case is whether the AAT correctly determined that the applicant’s involvement with the Maoist group constituted crimes against humanity and war crimes under Article 1F of the Refugees’ Convention. Specifically, the court had to examine whether the applicant’s actions, as defined in the Rome Statute, fell within the categories of crimes against humanity or war crimes. The court also had to consider whether the applicant’s actions were of a sufficiently political nature to avoid exclusion under Article 1F(b) for serious non-political crimes.
The court examined the AAT’s reasoning and concluded that the AAT had correctly applied the law in determining that the applicant’s actions constituted crimes against humanity and war crimes. The court found that the AAT’s interpretation of the Rome Statute and its application to the applicant’s conduct was consistent with the legal standards required. The court also noted that the applicant’s motives, while political, did not absolve him from the legal definitions of the crimes he committed. Therefore, the court upheld the AAT’s decision that the applicant was ineligible for refugee status under Article 1F of the Refugees’ Convention.
In light of the above, the court dismissed the applicant’s appeal and ordered that the applicant pay the costs of the respondent. This decision reinforces the stringent criteria under international law for granting refugee status and highlights the importance of adhering to the definitions and standards set out in the Rome Statute and the Refugees’ Convention.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The application be dismissed.
2. The applicant pay the costs of the respondent.
Background
Background to the litigation
Article IF of the Refugees’ Convention provides:‘The provisions of this Convention shall not apply to any person with respect to whom there are serious reasons for considering that:(a)he has committed a crime against peace, a war crime, or a crime against humanity, as defined in the international instruments drawn up to make provision in respect of such crimes;(b)he has committed a serious non-political crime outside the country of refuge prior to his admission to that country as a refugee;(c)he has been guilty of acts contrary to the purposes and principles of the United Nations.’The facts(i) General information At the AAT hearing, the applicant and the Minister were each represented by counsel. No oral evidence was adduced. The evidence was entirely documentary. It was received and considered against the background of some undisputed facts. It was common ground before the AAT that the applicant is a Nepalese citizen, having been born to a family in what he described as ‘the privileged class’. The applicant attended university, graduating with a degree in commerce. While at university, the applicant joined a Maoist group. At [12]-[13], the Deputy President described what then happened:‘Following his graduation in 1998 he became more active in the Maoist movement and by 1999 began to move around with them from district to district becoming intimately involved in their insurgency activities. He was, he said, a part "of the second line of defence".It was as a consequence of the Applicant being in fear of arrest (a warrant had been issued against him for terrorist activities), that following the Maoist attack on the village Mahaghat he left Nepal in 1999, escaped into India and entered Australia in October of that year on a false passport.’ The Deputy President went on, at [15], to quote passages in the delegate’s decision, which he apparently adopted as background facts.‘Nepal is a nascent democracy, having been ruled as a kingdom until about 1992. The country then became a democracy. The applicant belongs to the privileged, educated class, but at university he was exposed to the Maoist ideas. He became concerned by the corruption and exploitation of the poor, especially by wealthy rural landowners. When the applicant joined the Maoist group he was an undergraduate university student. At that time the Maoists group was a single group espousing general Maoist communist philosophy. The applicant participated in distributing information and attended talks and meetings. After a couple of years the group split into two factions. One faction supported change through the ballot box, and the other felt that the corruption in the country was such that no election could be fair and open, and this faction supported a change of government by force. Initially the applicant believed that change through the voting system was possible, however, he became disillusioned by the corruption and following an election in 1995 he then sided with the "hardline" group which advocated change using force and the bullet. The Maoist who supported change through elections achieved electoral success in various areas. In the areas where there was overwhelming support for the Maoists, the government bureaucracy chose to live outside the area. The government maintained a presence in these Maoist areas in the form of police stations. Upon completing university the applicant went "underground" to serve the group. His main activities involved talking to people to try to convince them of the ideology of the group. The applicant stated at interview that the landowners were often dishonest. In a kind of mortgage system, landowners and wealthy people would lend money to the poor in exchange for their land held as security. The poor were illiterate, and these contractual relationships were frequently misrepresented in the deeds. Commonly this was done by misrepresenting amounts owed to the lender by adding zeros to the amounts owed when documents were being signed. (The signatures consisted of a thumbprint due to the illiteracy of the poor.) Due to their illiteracy the borrowers did not know that the documents that they signed misrepresented the actual debts, and would often later find that a small debt was actually recorded as a massive debt that they could not possibly repay in their whole lifetime...making them slaves to the wealthy for their entire lives. The applicant was involved in various activities, including two projects in which landowners were asked to meet with the Maoists to present all of their debt documents. The landowners involved complied with the request. The applicant believes they knew that they would be forced by the Maoists to comply if they refused, however no threats were made during the incidents in which he was involved. The Maoists publicly burned all of the debt documents, thereby releasing the poor from the onerous debts. Often the Maoists would force a landowner who held unused land to allow the poor to work the land and to take a share of the produce in order to survive (proportional to the number of hours that they worked the land). The landowner would maintain the ownership of the land and would be given the balance of the income from this unused land. In other circumstances the Maoists would educate the poor about their rights then place them on unused land, and armed with knowledge of their rights, the poor would then stand up to the landowners by themselves. The applicant claims that he was involved in a fight with a landlord, and used his knife against someone who ran away.He was also involved in an incident that involved violence in a village in Rukum district before fled Nepal. This incident occurred in September 1999. The applicant claims that it was a battle that lasted for about three hours from 9 pm. This incident was arranged by the central command. One way in which the Maoists worked was to have members collect information about particular districts. Such information involved an assessment of the local support for the Maoists, the nature and size of the government presence in the district, the security situation and other information that may be useful for trying to take control of a region. For instance, if there were 5 policemen with five rifles and five bullets each, an assessment would be made that more than 25 Maoists would be needed to be successful in a campaign against them. Thus 25 Maoists killed would use all of the bullets and there would still be Maoists advancing. This information would be sent to central command which would relay orders about the timing and type of attacks. The applicant was involved in this information gathering strategy for the group. He entered the village and moved around the village representing himself as a local. It was a village of about 30,000 people, so it was possible for the applicant to pretend to be a local. He assessed the level of support for the Maoists...and as it was an area in which 75% of the population had voted for a parliamentary Maoist representative, the support was high. No bureaucrats lived within the village, and he found that only a police station represented the government. The applicant therefore gathered information about the police station and the local area, and in the evenings went to the Maoist camps that had been set up in the surrounding jungle. For about five days the Maoists observed the area from the camps and used the applicant’s information to decide what action to take. The applicant understood that his information would be used to launch an attack operation to make the police and government officials flee the area, so that the Maoists could take control. A warning was sent by mail telling the government people and police to leave the area, but the police stayed. About three hundred Maoists were involved in the operation on the police station during the evening of 22nd September 1999. During the attack the applicant stayed in the camp in the jungle to provide defence against any attacks by government forces from outside the village, and to provide reinforcements if needed for those fighters going ahead. The fighters approached the police station with loudspeakers in an attempt to make the police give themselves up. The applicant believes that had the police given themselves up the Maoists would have captured them and would then have used these captives to negotiate with the government to release the Maoists who were in prison. However the police did not surrender, and the police started the shooting. The fighting continued for three hours from about 9 o’clock at night. The Central District Officer ...surrendered. The applicant understands that after being kept captive for a month and a half the [Central District Officer] was released after negotiations with the government. After three hours of fighting the Maoists received news that a large contingent of government soldiers was on its way to the area, and the Maoists were not in a situation to defend themselves against such a large group. So they fled. The applicant fled to India because he believed his identity would be known to all of the villagers with whom he had spoken while gathering information. Many Maoists had been killed in this battle.’
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Fourth, the AAT was correct in confining its attention to only three of the matters specified in paras (a), (b) and (c) of the Article 1F of the Refugees’ Convention: ‘war crimes’, ‘crimes against humanity’ and ‘serious non-political crimes’.The AAT’s conclusions The AAT concluded there were serious reasons for considering that the applicant did commit and was, within the meaning of the Rome Statute, criminally responsible for committing crimes against humanity and war crimes. The AAT also concluded that the applicant’s motives for committing the crimes were significantly political in character. Consequently, para (b) of Article 1F concerning ‘serious non-political crimes’ did not apply to him. No challenge is made to this finding. The only issue in this application is whether the AAT erred in law in concluding adversely to the applicant in relation to ‘war crimes’ and ‘crimes against humanity’. In argument before us, Mr D Burwood, counsel for the applicant, contended that the AAT erred in its conclusions in relation to both war crimes and crimes against humanity. He said that, as a matter of law, the admitted conduct of the applicant is not capable of being regarded as falling within either of these categories of conduct, as they are defined in the Rome Statute. In its reasons for decision, the AAT dealt first with crimes against humanity and then with war crimes. I will follow the same course.Crimes against humanity(i) The Rome Statute definition Article 7.1 of the Rome Statute defines the term ‘crime against humanity’ as being any one of eight acts ‘when committed as part of a widespread or systematic attack directed against any civilian population, with knowledge of the attack’. The eight acts are as follows:‘(a) Murder;(b) Extermination;(c) Enslavement;(d) Deportation or forcible transfer of population;(e) Imprisonment or other severe deprivation of physical liberty in violation of fundamental rules of international law;(f) Torture;(g) Rape, sexual slavery, enforced prostitution, forced pregnancy, enforced sterilization, or any other form of sexual violence of comparable gravity;(h) Persecution against any identifiable group or collectivity on political, racial, national, ethnic, cultural, religious, gender as defined in paragraph 3, or other grounds that are universally recognized as impermissible under international law, in connection with any act referred to in this paragraph or any crime within the jurisdiction of the Court;(i) Enforced disappearance of persons;(j) The crime of apartheid;(k)Other inhumane acts of a similar character intentionally causing great suffering, or serious injury to body or to mental or physical health.’ Article 7.2(a) defines the term ‘attack directed against any civilian population’ as meaning ‘a course of conduct involving the multiple commission of acts referred to in paragraph 1 against any civilian population, pursuant to or in furtherance of a State or organizational policy to commit such attack’. The word ‘organizational’ is not defined.