Adekoya and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

Adekoya and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration) [2017] AATA 2028 (31 October 2017)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2016/5031

Re:Nadine Adekoya

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Immigration and Border Protection

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member K. Parker 

Date:31 October 2017

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

........................................................................
Member K. Parker

MIGRATION – visa refusal – applicant is sponsor of her husband’s application for Partner (Provisional) (Class UF) visa – whether applicant passes the character test under s 501(6) – whether reasonable suspicion that applicant’s husband has been or is a member of and associated with an organisation or group that has been or is involved in criminal conduct – whether applicant’s husband was involved in conduct constituting “a crime of genocide, a crime against humanity, a war crime, a crime involving torture or slavery or a crime that is otherwise of serious international concern” – whether the person is not of good character because of past or present general conduct – whether risk present under s 501(6)(d) – whether discretion to refuse visa should be exercised – whether considerations in Direction No. 65 weigh in favour of refusing visa – visa should be refused – decision under review affirmed.

Legislation
Migration Act 1958(Cth), ss 499, 500, 501

Cases

Godley v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCA 774

Queensland Bacon Pty Ltd v Rees [1965-1966] 115 CLR 266

Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Baker (1997) 73 FCR 187 at 197

Re Lachmaiya and Department of Immigration and Ethnic Affairs [1994] AATA 27; (1994) 19 AAR 148

SRYY v Minister for Immigration and Indigenous Affairs (2005) 220 ALR 394

SZCWP v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2006] FCAFC 9

Secondary Materials

Direction No. 65 – Migration Act 1958 – Direction under section 499 – Visa refusal and cancellation under s 501 and revocation of mandatory cancellation of a visa under
s 501CA

Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court, opened for signature 17 July 1998, 2187 UNTS 90 (entered into force 1 July 2002).

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member K. Parker

31 October 2017

INTRODUCTION

  1. This is an application for review of the decision by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Minister) made on 8 September 2016 to refuse a Partner (Provisional) (Class UF) visa to Mr Sammy Abiodun Adekoya (Mr Adekoya), pursuant to s 501(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (Act). This application is made by Mr Adekoya’s sponsor and wife, Mrs Nadine Adekoya (Mrs Adekoya).  Mrs Adekoya is an Australian citizen.  Mr Adekoya and Mrs Adekoya were married on 17 May 2003 and have two sons aged 13 and 6, who were born in Australia, live in Australia and who are Australian citizens. 

  2. Under s 500(1)(b) of the Act, this Tribunal has jurisdiction to review this decision.

    BACKGROUND

  3. Mr Adekoya was born in Ibadan, Nigeria on 1 January 1960, where he lived…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Adekoya and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 2028
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Adekoya against a decision to refuse him a visa. Mr Adekoya, a Nigerian national, had previously applied for a protection visa in Australia, which was refused on the grounds that he was a member of an organisation responsible for crimes against humanity. He later applied for a partner visa with his wife, which was also refused. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was required to determine whether Mr Adekoya passed the character test under section 501(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth).

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether there was a reasonable suspicion that Mr Adekoya had been involved in conduct constituting a crime against humanity or a war crime, as contemplated by section 501(6)(ba)(iii) of the Act. This required the Tribunal to consider the definition of "reasonable suspicion" in the context of the character test, which is a suspicion that a reasonable person could hold based on an objective consideration of relevant material, falling between mere speculation and certainty. The Tribunal also considered whether other subsections of section 501(6) applied, including those relating to criminal conduct and associations with criminal organisations.

The Tribunal reasoned that a reasonable suspicion could be formed based on the material before it, including Mr Adekoya's own statements regarding his membership in the Odua People’s Congress (OPC) and his admitted involvement in burning down a house with civilians inside. The Tribunal noted that Mr Adekoya had previously been refused a protection visa due to serious concerns about his involvement in war crimes. Despite Mr Adekoya's assertion that his previous statements were motivated by a desire to remain in Australia, the War Crimes Unit concluded that no further assessment was required, and the existing assessment could be relied upon. The Tribunal also considered statutory declarations from Australian citizens attesting to the genuineness of Mr Adekoya's relationship with his wife and children, but these did not negate the concerns regarding his character.

The Tribunal found that Mr Adekoya did not pass the character test. Consequently, the delegate or decision-maker considering the visa refusal for Mr Adekoya could rely on the information contained in the War Crimes Assessment dated 11 February 2009.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Under s 500(1)(b) of the Act, this Tribunal has jurisdiction to review this decision. BACKGROUND Mr Adekoya was born in Ibadan, Nigeria on 1 January 1960, where he lived and worked in a role associated with land surveying until 2000.[1] Mr Adekoya has stated that he was employed in his own company, Polland Nig. Ltd., from 1984 to 1996.[2] Mr Adekoya said in his Statutory Declaration dated 9 July 2015 that “he is Christian by religion and a Yoruba by ethnicity”.[3] He is a citizen of Nigeria, although he has previously lived in South Africa from 2000 to 2002 and from 2004 to 2016 (i.e. a total of 14 years) on “self-employment” visas. At the time of the hearing, he was present in Nigeria and gave evidence that he had been residing in Nigeria for the previous 12 months. [1] See Supplementary G-Documents SG2/15 which indicates that Mr Adekoya held a “Certificate in Engineering Surveyor” obtained in 1984. The G-Documents and Supplementary G-Documents are sets of documents lodged with the Tribunal by the Minister and provided to Mrs Adekoya in advance of the hearing, comprising documents considered to be relevant to this application. [2] See Supplementary G-Documents SG2/15.[3] See G-Documents G16/86. Mr Adekoya’s main language is Yoruba and he can read, understand, speak and write fluently in English.[4] [4] See G-Documents G5/26. Mr Adekoya first arrived in Australia on 13 May 2002 on a Tourist (Class TR) visa. On 21 May 2002, he lodged an application for a Protection (Class XA) visa which was refused on 5 August 2002 on the basis that: “Mr Adekoya was a member of an organisation responsible for committing ‘numerous crimes against humanity within the terms of Article 1F of the Refugees Convention’”. Mr Adekoya sought review of this decision by the then Refugee Review Tribunal (RRT). The RRT advised Mr Adekoya it had no jurisdiction to review applications refused under Article 1F of the Refugees Convention. On 12 January 2004, an application was made to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) to review the decision to refuse the protection visa application. Mr Adekoya departed Australia on 15 March 2004 as the holder of a Bridging A (Class WA) visa. He withdrew his application for review by the AAT referred to in the above paragraph and has since remained off shore. On 24 March 2004, Mr Adekoya lodged a combined application with Mrs Adekoya for a Partner (Provisional)(Class UF) visa and a Partner (Migrant)(Class BC) visa. This application was refused by the Minister on 30 January 2007. The decision to refuse the visa application was subsequently overturned by the then Migration Review Tribunal (MRT) on 12 August 2008 and remitted for reconsideration with the direction that Mr Adekoya met the requirement that he was in a spousal relationship with Mrs Adekoya. On 11 February 2009, the War Crimes Section of the Department of Immigration and Border Protection (Department) issued a War Crimes Screening Assessment in relation to Mr Adekoya stating that it was reasonable to suspect that he had been involved in the commission of crimes against humanity as defined in the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (Rome Statute) and complicit through his association with a violent organisation involved in crimes against humanity.[5] [5] See G-Documents G9.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Paragraph 8(1) of the Direction provides that a decision-maker must take into account the primary and other considerations relevant to the individual case. The other considerations which must be taken into account for visa refusal matters are provided in a non-exhaustive list in paragraph 12 of the Direction. These considerations are:(a) International non-refoulement obligations;(b) Impact on family members;(c) Impact on victims; and(d) Impact on Australian business interests.EVIDENCEPrevious statements made by Mr Adekoya On 10 May 2002, in support of his protection visa application at that time, Mr Adekoya made the following statements in a Statutory Declaration signed by him in the presence of Mr Nwankwo:1.I am a Nigerian national of Yoruba ethnicity.2.I am a Christian by birth and was an active member of the Odua People’s Congress (OPC). The OPC came into being as a result of continuos(sic) abuse of Yorubas living in Hausa dominated areas by the Hausas and the refusal by the authorities to stop the abuse. It is a free organization for all Yoruba indigenes. Before the OPC was established, any Hausa man could rape a Yoruba woman or even kill a Yoruba with impunity.3.I escaped from Nigeria to South Africa in 2000 to avoid persecution from the brutal authorities in that country due to my membership of the OPC, and my participation in several protests since the dawn of the OPC.4.At all times during my participation in OPC activities, my main duty was to monitor certain individuals presumed to be police informants. These informants were responsible for passing onto police the minutes of our secrete(sic) meetings. Armed with the information, the police who were mainly the Hausa ethnicity would launch serious assaults and arbitrary arrests of OPC members. In most cases some active members would be found dead in mysterious circumstances.5.In 2000, my superiors instructed two selected members including myself to monitor the movements of a certain suspected member, Mr Adewosi, whom we found out was not a true Yoruba man. We noticed that he gave us wrong name and home address and that he was actually a member of the Nigerian State Security Service (SSS). One evening we traced him to his house where he lived with his wife and four children. When we knocked on his door his wife opened the door and asked who we were. We introduced ourselves as her husband’s friends. She told us to wait: after about five minutes she came back and told us that she was not married and was living alone in the flat. We did not want to create a scene so we left.6.About three days after our visit to Mr Adewosi’s house there was a clash between the OPC and the Nigerian police who tried to stop OPC meeting in Lagos. More than hundred OPC members were shot dead by combined military and police forces. As a result of the killings, OPC members went on rampage destroying houses owned by some Hausa’s in Lagos. In the process, Mr Adewosi’s house was burnt with his wife and children.7.After the incident, police started looking for me and the other two members who visited Mr Adewosi’s house. One of us was tracked to his village in Ogun and shot dead in front of his parents.8.As the news spread I contacted the other man who visited Mr Adewosi’s house with me and told him that it was better for us to leave Nigeria. In the evening we managed to cross into Cameroon from where we boarded a Ship to South Africa where we sought refuge until July/August 2001 when the South African government signed a secrete(sic) deal to deport all Nigerians in South Africa who were involved in political and ethnic unrests. When it came to our knowledge that the South African government was deporting Nigerians, in particular OPC members to face charges in Nigeria, I escaped to Singapore where I met a Nigerian who told me to come back to Nigeria in November 2001. Within a week of my arrival, police visited our house twice looking for me. At that point I realised that my life was still in danger and managed to escape back to South Africa. On arrival, a police officer at the Airport asked me where I was going to stay in South Africa I told him that I was married to a South African and was going to stay with her. He then took the address and allowed me in.9.When I arrived at wife’s house in the night I realised that she was no longer their(sic). Upon investigation, I found that she had remarried to another man and escaped to Zimbabwe.10.To avoid being deported to Nigeria where I would certainly be killed, I decided to apply to come to Australia and seek refuge. There is no doubt that the authorities in South Africa would have sent me back to Nigeria where I would face persecution for my participation in OPC activities.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In 2014, it is apparent that consideration was given as to whether a further war crimes assessment of Mr Adekoya should take place. The Assistant Director of the War Crimes Unit of the Department recorded the following in her Minute of advice dated 13 November 2014:…7. In response to his Notice of Intention to Refuse dated 10 September 2009, Mr Adekoya stated that “his motivation for making the assertions which led to the suspicion by the Department’s War Crimes Unit that he may have been involved in commission of crimes against humanity was neither because the assertion was true nor due to any general criminal intent or contempt for international humanitarian law, but rather by his abiding desire to be able to remain in Australia (being a better country than his country of birth, Nigeria) and to be able to have the opportunity to be a lawful participant in the social and economic opportunities Australia offers.8. Notwithstanding the response to the NOICR by Mr Adekoya, the WCU continues to note that he was a member of the OPC; should have been aware of the widespread reports of the OPC committing human rights abuses and; admitted to burning down a house with civilians (including children) inside. It should also be noted that Mr Adekoya was refused a [protection visa] based on serious concerns of involvement in war crimes.Conclusion:9. Given the lack of any significant new information, we do not believe a new War Crimes Assessment is required. The delegate or decision maker considering visa refusal for Mr Adekoya can therefore rely on the information contained in the War Crimes Assessment dated 11 February 2009.Statements of support made by other Australian citizens Ms Shirley Scott of Torquay, Victoria, Australian citizen, signed a Statutory Declaration on 1 April 2013 indicating that she has had a continuous relationship with Mrs Adekoya but not Mr Adekoya, although she had met him and that “I sincerely believe the partner of the applicant is in need of genuine support in the care of health and education of their 2 sons, Caleb 8 yrs, Joshua 21 months and support is needed”.[22][22] Refer G-Documents G30. Francis Awopegba, registered nurse, friend of Mr Adekoya and Australian citizen and subsequently, known to Mrs Adekoya, in a Statutory Declaration signed on 29 April 2013, stated as follows:[23]There is no doubt that their relationship is genuine because despite the fact that [Mr Adekoya’s] previous spouse application was not approved, they have always been in contact and they have had two male kids between that time that is 2004 – 2011. [Mrs Adekoya] visits [Mr Adekoya] in South Africa every year with the kids and they talk everyday and hope that one day they will be together to look after their two boys together here in Australia. They are very committed couple.…[23] Refer G-Documents G30. Kayode Lawal, friend of Mr Adekoya and Australian citizen, of Werribee, Victoria, in a Statutory Declaration signed on 3 May 2013, stated as follows:[24]I believe their marriage is genuine and continuing. I witness their marriage in north corte (sic) on 7/05/2003. When their first son Caleb was born on 7/7/2003 I was there and do go to visit nadine in their home. I am always aware when she goes to visit sammy in South Africa. Sammy and I always talk on phone and he do ask me to go and visit nadine. Sammy and Nadine Love each other.[24] Refer G-Documents G30.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Toyin Abbas, friends of Mr Adekoya and Mrs Adekoya and Australian citizen, of Roxburgh Park, Victoria, in a Statutory Declaration signed on 16 April 2013, stated as follows:[25]I strongly believe that the relations is genuine and continuing as demonstrated by the unflinching (?) love and support by the couple. In addition, they are blessed with 2 beautiful kids an indication of a fruitful marriage and continuity. [25] Refer G-Documents G30.CONSIDERATION - ISSUE 1: CHARACTER TEST Section 501(1) of the Act provides that a non-citizen may be refused a visa if they do not satisfy the decision maker that they pass the character test. In this application, the Tribunal must determine whether Mr Adekoya passes the character test as defined in s 501(6) of the Act based on whether any of the specific circumstances prescribed in subsections (aa) to (h) of this provision applied to him. As mentioned above, the Tribunal considers that the specific circumstances set out in subsections 501(6)(b), (ba), (c) and (d) of this provision potentially apply to Mr Adekoya and for that reason, it will examine each of these in turn. The Minister focused specifically on subsection 501(6)(ba)(iii) of the Act and contended that the Tribunal was able to conclude that it reasonably suspects that Mr Adekoya has been involved in conduct constituting a “crime against humanity” or a “war crime”. The Tribunal notes this contention but does not regard itself as confined to consider only those particular parts of subsection 501(6)(ba)(iii) or this subsection of s 501(6) generally.The general concept “reasonable suspicion” as relevant to subsections 501(6)(ba) and 501(6)(b) of the Act As a preliminary matter, both subsections 501(6)(b) and (ba) incorporate the concept of “reasonable suspicion”. For the purpose of applying subsection 501(6)(b), subclause 3(2) of Section 2 of Annexure A of the Direction provides as follows:(2) A suspicion is less than a certainty or a belief, but more than a speculation or idle wondering. For a suspicion to be reasonable, it should be:(a) a suspicion that a reasonable person could hold in the particular circumstances; and(b) based on an objective consideration of relevant material. In Godley v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCA 774, Justice Lee of the Federal Court of Australia made some observations about this concept, when applying certain provisions in the character test under s 501(6) (emphasis added): [47]…First the Minister must form a reasonable suspicion that a person, group or organisation has been or is involved in criminal conduct. It may be taken that to be a reasonable suspicion the suspicion must be based on reasonable grounds. Second the Minister must make a finding of fact that the visa applicant has, or has had, an association with that person, group or organisation. Again it would be necessary for there to be material capable of supporting that finding. It is unnecessary to consider the meaning of the word “association” but for a visa applicant not to pass the character test it may be taken to require the Minister to make relevant findings of fact as to the knowledge, or awareness, by the visa applicant of the facts that point to the involvement of the person, group or organisation in criminal conduct.