Joseph Colombo and Australian Postal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

[2015] AATA 10

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2013/1014, 2013/4612, 2014/1416

Re

Joseph Colombo

APPLICANT

And

Australian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal Mr P W Taylor SC, Senior Member
Date 13 January 2015
Place Sydney

The decisions under review are affirmed.

....................[sgd]..............................................

Mr P W Taylor SC, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – employee of licensed corporation – disc herniation – pain – underlying cervical spine degeneration – whether applicant has a compensable injury as defined by the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 – decisions affirmed

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ss 5A, 5B

CASES

Australian Postal Corporation v Bessey (2001) 32 AAR 508; [2001] FCA 266

Comcare v Canute (2005) 148 FCR 232; [2005] FCAFC 262
Comcare v Sahu-Khan (2007) 156 FCR 536; [2007] FCA 15
Commonwealth v Beattie (1981) 35 ALR 369
Federal Broom Co Pty Ltd v Semlitch (1964) 110 CLR 626
Kennedy Cleaning Services Pty Ltd v Petkoska (2000) 200 CLR 286
Mellor v Australian Postal Corporation (2009) 108 ALD 159; [2009] FCA 504
Ogden Industries Pty Ltd v Lucas (1967) 116 CLR 537
Re Bessey and Australian Postal Corporation (2000) 60 ALD 529; [2000] AATA 404
Re Garcia and Comcare [2014] AATA 320
Re Mellor and Australian Postal Corporation [2010] AATA 502
Re Rutledge and Comcare (2011) 130 ALD 94; [2011] AATA 865
Re Tran and Comcare (2010) 52 AAR 449; [2010] AATA 719
Re Zomer and Telstra Corporation Limited [2012] AATA 601
Tippett v Australian Postal Corporation (1998) 27 AAR 40

Treloar v Australian Telecommunications Commission (1990) 26 FCR 316

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr P W Taylor SC, Senior Member

13 January 2015

  1. On about 8 November 2012 Mr Colombo made a compensation claim for a right shoulder injury, which he said occurred at work on 4 September 2012.  The Respondent refused the claim and, in a February 2013 reviewable decision, it affirmed that refusal.

  2. In the meantime, following the diagnosis referred to in paragraph 19 below, on 13 December 2012, Mr Colombo had an anterior cervical discectomy, and C6/C7 fusion, at Sydney Southwest Private Hospital.  The operation was performed to alleviate severe radicular pain in his right shoulder and arm.  In June 2013, after substantially recovering from the December 2012 surgery, Mr Colombo claimed compensation, for permanent impairment and non-economic loss, for a neck injury, he said resulted from “repetitive and strenuous work activities”.  The Respondent refused that claim in July 2013, on the basis that Mr Colombo “[did] not have an accepted compensation claim for a neck injury”, and affirmed the refusal in a reviewable decision made on 26 August 2013.

  3. On 28 February 2014 Mr Colombo lodged a claim for a right-sided C6/7 disc herniation, affecting his neck and right shoulder, which he said he had first noticed near the end of his work shift on 4 September 2012.  On 10 March 2014 the Respondent also decided that Mr Colombo’s, right-sided C6/7 disc herniation and associated neck and shoulder pain, was not attributable to the nature…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Joseph Colombo and Australian Postal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] AATA 10
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Joseph Colombo brought a claim against the Australian Postal Corporation (APC) for workers' compensation following an injury sustained in the course of his employment. The claim centred on whether Mr Colombo's work as a mail sorter caused or significantly contributed to his disc herniation and associated pain, or whether it merely aggravated an underlying cervical spine degeneration. The dispute was heard and determined by the Australian Government Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The primary legal issue before the tribunal was whether the work activities of Mr Colombo, specifically the repetitive movements involved in sorting and distributing mail, either caused his disc herniation or significantly aggravated an existing degenerative condition. This required a detailed examination of the nature of Mr Colombo's job duties, the movements he performed, and the medical evidence concerning the causation of his injury.

The tribunal meticulously evaluated the evidence, including the video footage of Mr Colombo's co-workers performing similar tasks, testimonies from Mr Colombo and his colleagues, and medical reports. It found that while Mr Colombo likely worked at a faster pace and with more extensive movements than shown in the videos, his job duties were not characterised by extreme or frequent twisting and turning. The tribunal also considered the testimony of Ms Pepper, a colleague who had performed similar work for many years without reporting any injuries, to support its view that the movements involved in mail sorting were not exceptionally hazardous. Moreover, the tribunal found that Mr Colombo's evidence regarding the onset of his pain was unreliable and that there was no specific work event that he could identify as the cause of his pain. The medical evidence did not convincingly link his work activities to the onset of his symptoms.

In conclusion, the tribunal held that while Mr Colombo did experience some shoulder pain at work, it was not satisfactorily proven that his employment significantly contributed to the occurrence of that pain or the aggravation of his underlying degenerative condition. Therefore, the tribunal affirmed the decisions of the APC, dismissing Mr Colombo's claim for workers' compensation. The tribunal found that the work activities did not meet the criteria for a compensable injury under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Once the mail has been sorted into its appropriate pigeonholes, Mr Colombo’s duties required him to collect the sorted items from the pigeonholes and then distribute the sorted bundles. In the case of bundles with post office box addresses, he had to sort them by placing them in the post office boxes at the Parramatta Mail Centre. In other instances a particular addressee organisation might have its own designated tub or bag for their mail. There were also occasions, typically towards the end of a shift, where Mr Colombo would have to deliver parcels to another delivery area within the centre.THE VIDEO EVIDENCE OF WORK ACTIVITIES In order to provide a more meaningful illustration and description of Mr Colombo’s scope of work as a mail sorter the Respondent provided videos of other people performing mail sorting activities at the Parramatta Mail Centre. Those videos showed one or other of Mr Colombo’s co-workers undertaking various activities of the kind he would typically have performed during the course of his work shifts. One part of the video footage showed a co-worker sorting mail at a frame similar to the one Mr Colombo used for sorting letters. Other videos showed workers sorting mail at a large, approximately 190 cm high, wall array of “pigeonholes” – such as one can readily envisage behind the bank of customer accessible “post office boxes” commonly found at major general post offices. The remaining video showed the process involved in collecting trays of unsorted mail from large pallet type bins – called “unit load devices”. The Respondent submitted that the videos fairly illustrated the kinds of mail sorting duties that Mr Colombo carried out in the course of his work. Mr Colombo agreed that the activities and movements shown in the videos were broadly the same as the work he did. He complained, however, that he had worked, and had been required to work, at a much faster pace than the people in the video film. He complained that the extent of the movements shown was understated in comparison with what he actually did. He also complained that the large pigeonhole “array” shown in the video was only one of four such areas, and that one of the others had more pigeonholes, and was slightly higher. Finally, he complained that the activities involved in collecting mail trays from the “unit load devices” required somewhat more bending than was shown in the videos. In response to Mr Colombo’s complaints, I accept that he probably did work at a faster pace than the people shown in the various films, and that his work regularly required him to be able to reach the more distant “pigeonholes” in both the sorting frame and the large pigeonhole “array” that I have described. I accept also that he generally worked as fast and as efficiently as he reasonably could. However, I do not regard his criticisms as materially detracting from the proposition that movements involved in the mail sorting operations, though repetitive, were comparatively limited in their range. Those movements were essentially similar in nature, although I accept not in frequency, to the ordinary movements frequently and typically performed, unremarkably, by many people in the course of their daily activities. Specifically, it is my view that the movements involved are not fairly described as involving either extremes of movement, or frequent twisting and turning. In support of that view I note, and accept, the evidence of Ms Pepper, one of Mr Colombo’s co-workers who has worked at the Parramatta Mail Centre since 2002. Ms Pepper, who is much shorter than Mr Colombo, gave evidence that she and other APC employees at the Parramatta Mail Centre have, for many years, been engaged in mail sorting duties similar to those undertaken by Mr Colombo. Some of the employees have been doing that work for much longer periods than Mr Colombo’s approximately 12 years’ service. Ms Pepper said that no other APC employee at Parramatta had reported any injury associated with mail sorting work. CAUSE: WORK NEITHER CAUSED HERNIATION NOR AGGRAVATED AN UNDERLYING CONDITION

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the present matter Mr Colombo’s evidence about the events of 4 September 2012 is slender, general and unreliable (to the extent that it conflates a recollection of shoulder pain on that day with subsequent symptoms of nerve pain – see paragraphs 26 and 27 above). As I have previously found, he did experience shoulder pain towards the end of his shift that day, but it appears not to have been significant enough to interfere with his activities after he left work. Indeed, it was not until later that evening, when he says he was woken by pain, that it was a matter that troubled him. He had an underlying degenerative condition which was likely to lead to the symptoms he did experience. There was no particular event at work that he could recall as having precipitated his pain. Consistent with that fact, he returned to work shortly afterwards, and did not himself associate his shoulder pain with his work activities. In addition, as I have earlier found, none of the medical evidence reliably pointed to a significant causal connection between his work activity and the shoulder pain he experienced. In the totality of those circumstances, whilst I accept that Mr Colombo suffered some shoulder pain at work on 4 September 2012, and from time to time thereafter, both at work and when he was not at work, I am not satisfied that his employment contributed “to a significant degree” to the occurrence of that pain, and involved an aggravation of his underlying degenerative condition.DECISION Each of the decisions under review is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.