Muscat and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

Muscat and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) [2016] AATA 13 (19 January 2016)

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Numbers

2014/3716 and 2014/4318

Re

Christina Muscat

APPLICANT

And

Australian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Dr Damien Cremean

Date 19 January 2016
Place Melbourne

Decisions under review set aside and the respondent is liable to pay compensation in respect of both conditions in accordance with law.

........... .[sgd

Senior Member

COMPENSATION—ailments - plantar fasciitis – osteoarthritis - whether compensable –aggravation - significant - decisions under review set aside

Legislation

Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) sections 5A, 5B, 14

Cases

Colombo and Australian Postal Corporation [2015] AATA 10

Comcare v Lofts [2013] FCA 1197

Comcare v Reardon [2015] FCA 1166

Comcare v Sahu-Khan [2007] FCA 15

Commonwealth of Australia v Beattie (1981) 35 ALR 369

Federal Broom Co Pty Ltd v Semlitch (1964) 110 CLR 626

March v E & MH Stramare - Pty Ltd (1991) 171 CLR 506

Re Su and Comcare [2011] AATA 934

Tippett v Australian Postal Corporation (1998) 27 AAR 40

Wiegand v Comcare Australia [2002] FCA 1464

REASONS FOR DECISION

Dr Damien Cremean

19 January 2016

  1. The applicant Christina Muscat has made an application to review two decisions of the Respondent

  2. The first decision (AAT application no. 2014/3716) was made on 29 May 2014 and affirmed a determination made on 16 December 2013 that the Respondent was not liable to pay compensation to the Applicant under section 14 of the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (the SRC Act) in respect of a bilateral plantar fasciitis condition associated with calcaneal spurs on both feet.

  3. The second decision (AAT application no. 2014/4318) was made on 23 June 2014 and affirmed a determination made on 11 March 2014 that the Respondent was not liable to pay compensation to the Applicant under the SRC Act in respect of a condition identified as tendinitis right and left thumbs

  4. Both reviews were heard together at a hearing in which the Applicant gave sworn evidence.

    OUTLINE OF EVIDENCE

    Applicant  

  5. The Applicant was born on 28 October 1959 and is aged 55. She left school when she was 16 and went to secretarial college. At 18 she was working as an administrative assistant and then as a personal assistant.

  6. She commenced work with Australia Post in about 1993. She was working in the State Mail Centre in mail processing. This required her to operate mail processing machines –feeding letters from letter trays and removing processed items. There were also some heavier duties involved in her work including lifting and tipping mailbags.

  7. From the end of 1993 until the earlier part of 1995 the Applicant was on maternity leave. On her return to work she was located for a short time in the State Mail Centre but was then transferred to the Eastern Parcels Facility and was engaged in parcels work

  8. From about 2004 the Applicant worked at the Melbourne Parcel Facility. For a short time between 2005 and 2006 she…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Muscat and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 13
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Muscat and Australian Postal Corporation, the Applicant, a former employee of the Respondent, sought compensation for injuries she claimed were sustained during her employment. The Applicant alleged that she suffered from plantar fasciitis and osteoarthritis in her thumbs, which she claimed were aggravated by her work duties. The decision under review by the court was the rejection of her claim for compensation by the Respondent. The Applicant's claims were rejected on the basis that her conditions were not compensable under the relevant statutory provisions.

The legal issues that arose in this case included whether the Applicant's conditions of plantar fasciitis and osteoarthritis in her thumbs were compensable under the statutory provisions. This required the court to determine whether the Applicant's employment had contributed to a significant degree to her conditions, as required by the statutory provisions. The court also needed to consider whether the Applicant's employment caused or aggravated her conditions.

The court found that the Applicant's conditions were compensable under the statutory provisions. The court held that the Applicant's employment had contributed to a significant degree to her conditions and that her workplace caused aggravation of her ailments. The court found that the Applicant's work with the Respondent contributed to a significant degree and that the requirement that an injury occur in the course of employment was satisfied. The court set aside the decisions under review and held that the Respondent was liable to pay compensation in respect of both conditions in accordance with law.

In conclusion, the court found that the Applicant's conditions of plantar fasciitis and osteoarthritis in her thumbs were compensable under the statutory provisions. The court held that the Applicant's employment had contributed to a significant degree to her conditions and that her workplace caused aggravation of her ailments. The Respondent was held liable to pay compensation in respect of both conditions in accordance with law.

Orders

Orders of the court

Decisions under review set aside and the respondent is liable to pay compensation in respect of both conditions in accordance with law.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Both reviews were heard together at a hearing in which the Applicant gave sworn evidence. OUTLINE OF EVIDENCEApplicant The Applicant was born on 28 October 1959 and is aged 55. She left school when she was 16 and went to secretarial college. At 18 she was working as an administrative assistant and then as a personal assistant. She commenced work with Australia Post in about 1993. She was working in the State Mail Centre in mail processing. This required her to operate mail processing machines –feeding letters from letter trays and removing processed items. There were also some heavier duties involved in her work including lifting and tipping mailbags. From the end of 1993 until the earlier part of 1995 the Applicant was on maternity leave. On her return to work she was located for a short time in the State Mail Centre but was then transferred to the Eastern Parcels Facility and was engaged in parcels work From about 2004 the Applicant worked at the Melbourne Parcel Facility. For a short time between 2005 and 2006 she performed administrative duties on a full time basis. She then returned to part-time afternoon shift work as a parcel processor. In early 2012 the Applicant suffered a serious injury to her left shoulder when working on a conveyor belt. At the time she was reaching, grabbing and pushing parcels from left to right. She recalls picking out one particular parcel from the Utility Loading Device because the rollers on the conveyor were not working properly - and pulling it towards her and in the course of doing so feeling a pull and a pain in her shoulder. Subsequently, she had arthroscopic surgery and a rotator cuff repair operation on her shoulder. The Applicant was off work for about 8 months convalescing. She returned to work in February 2013, working 25 hours per week on reduced duties not involving use of her upper body and particularly her left arm. In that month, however, and in March and April 2013 also, she was off work on sick leave on various occasions. She recalls feeling fatigued and unable to perform all her duties when required The Applicant says that over the months following her return to work she noticed a burning sensation in her feet while standing. This foot pain came on while she was at work. She says that as the weeks continued, and the more she was standing on her feet to do her work, the worse the pain got. She would even stand on alternate feet to ease the pain. Australia Post supplied work boots to help alleviate the symptoms By 1 October 2013 the Applicant says that the pain in her feet had become so unbearable that she had to stop work. She reported her condition to her superiors and the following day she saw a Dr Shumba and was referred for x-rays or ultrasound or both. She was told she had a spur on both feet and was given analgesics. On 31 October 2013 the Applicant made a claim for compensation under the SRC Act in respect of pain in both her feet. This condition was later diagnosed as plantar fasciitis and it was this condition which was rejected as non-compensable under the SRC Act by the determination made on 16 December 2013.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Khan mentioned that more females than males tend to suffer both conditions. He said osteoarthritis tends to occur when sufferers are aged in their 50’s. This was also Dr Reiter’s view. But from this she concluded that the Applicant’s employment with the Respondent had played no role in her conditions. In light of the evidence, however, I consider there is no warrant for this view. As a general proposition, in the absence of statistical evidence being supplied, it may well be true that females aged in their 50’s are likely to develop either or both conditions. The Respondent in submissions sought to make much of this point in an unflattering description of the Applicant. But the Applicant is as she is. In any event, that does not mean that performing workplace duties may not be a cause of an ailment or a cause of an ailment’s aggravation, even if it is a given that she is a middle aged post-menopausal female .CONCLUSION I am satisfied for the reasons I have given that the Applicant’s conditions of plantar fasciitis and osteoarthritis in the thumbs are both compensable under section 14 of the SRC Act. Each is an injury under the SRC Act by being a disease. In the case of her plantar fasciitis it is an ailment in itself but, if not, her workplace caused aggravation of that ailment. Her osteoarthritis is an ailment that was aggravated by her workplace. In respect of both her plantar fasciitis and her osteoarthritis her work with the Respondent contributed to a significant degree and the requirement that an injury occur in the course of employment is satisfied. Accordingly, the decisions under review must be set aside and the respondent is liable to pay compensation in respect of both conditions in accordance with law.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Respondent on the other hand, also in lengthy submissions, contends that the Tribunal should find on the evidence that the Applicant’s employment did not contribute by way of cause or aggravation to either such condition (or if there was a contribution to either it was not significant); and that accordingly both such decisions should be affirmed. CONSIDERATION By section 14 of the SRC Act the Respondent is liable to pay compensation in accordance with the SRC Act in respect of any injury suffered by an employee if the injury results in death, incapacity for work, or impairment. The Respondent mentions that this has often been called a “gateway” provision: Comcare v Lofts [2013] FCA 1197 at [8]. By section 4(9) of the SRC Act an incapacity for work means an incapacity for work suffered by an employee as a result of an injury being an incapacity to engage in any work or to engage in work at the same level the employee was engaged in immediately before the injury occurred. An injury is defined in section 5A(1) as a disease suffered by an employee or an injury (other than a disease) suffered by an employee that is a physical or mental injury arising out of or in the course of such employee’s employment. A “disease” is defined in section 5B(1)of the SRC Act as an ailment suffered by an employee or an aggravation of such an ailment that was contributed to, to a significant degree, by the employee’s employment. An “ailment” is defined in section 4(1) of the SRC Act as any physical or mental ailment ,disorder, defect or morbid condition (whether of sudden onset or gradual development) A significant degree is defined in section 5B(3) of the SRC Act as a degree that is substantially more than material. Matters which may be taken into account by the Tribunal are set out in section 5B(2) of the SRC Act. They include the duration of an employee’s employment and the nature of, and particular tasks involved in, that employment (see sections 5B(2) (a) and (b)). Other matters also may be taken into account and section 5B places no limit on those. I am satisfied it is correct to describe the Applicant as suffering bilateral plantar fasciitis in her feet and osteoarthritis (not tendinitis) in the thumbs of both her hands. It is not in issue, as far as the Respondent is concerned, that both conditions satisfy the descriptor of an ailment under section 4(1) of the SRC Act. It is also not in issue that, subject otherwise to satisfying section 5B of the SRC Act, each meets the definition of a disease; and likewise, subject otherwise to satisfying section 5A of the SRC Act, each is thus an injury under the SRC Act. The question for me to determine, as I see it, is whether the correct or preferable decision is that the Applicant’s two conditions are, or one of them is, compensable under section 14 of the SRC Act. In light of the Respondent’s rightful concession that each is an ailment, this requires me to consider whether her conditions are strictly ailments or aggravations of ailments contributed to, to a significant degree, by her employment. But should her conditions be ailments or aggravations of ailments contributed to a significant degree by her employment, -- it follows she has diseases under the SRC Act (and thus injuries) which are compensable, providing such diseases (or injuries) arose out of or in the course of her employment.