FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| JOHNSON v MONTI-HAITSMA ENTERPRISES PTY LTD | [2014] FCCA 259 |
| Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – Claim for underpayments and penalties – applicant working for a long period as a live in manager at a motel – applicant responsible for the day to day management of the motel – informal employment arrangement including non cash benefits – consideration whether the applicant was covered by an award or, if not, whether she was paid less than the minimum wage by reference to her hours worked. |
| Legislation: Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), ss.16, 20, 45, 293, 294 |
| Kerr v Jaroma Pty Ltd trading as Treasury Motor Lodge [1996] IRCA 539 Transport Workers' Union of Australia v Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd [2014] FCCA 4 |
| Applicant: | DEBRA JOHNSON |
| Respondent: | MONTI-HAITSMA ENTERPRISES PTY LTD (IN EXTERNAL ADMINISTRATION) |
| File Number: | SYG 1503 of 2012 |
| Judgment of: | Judge Driver |
| Hearing dates: | 18-21 February 2014 |
| Date of final submission: | 5 March 2014 |
| Delivered at: | Sydney |
| Delivered on: | 20 June 2014 |
REPRESENTATION
| Counsel for the Applicant: | Mr R deMeyrick |
| Solicitors for the Applicant: | CBD Law |
| Counsel for the Respondent: | Mr B Cross |
| Solicitors for the Respondent: | Australian Business Lawyers |
ORDERS
The application as amended on 1 August 2013 is dismissed.
| FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT SYDNEY |
SYG 1503 of 2012
| DEBRA JOHNSON |
Applicant
And
| MONTI-HAITSMA ENTERPRISES PTY LTD (IN EXTERNAL ADMINISTRATION) |
Respondent
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
Introduction and background
The applicant (Ms Johnson) seeks various orders set out in an amended application under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (Fair Work Act) filed on 1 August 2013. Ms Johnson relies upon the following sections of the Fair Work Act and its predecessor legislation:
a)section 45 of the Fair Work Act (contravention of a modern award);
b)sections 718, 719 and 720 of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) (Workplace Relations Act) (enforcement of money claims and recovery of penalties under pre-reform awards);
c)section 293 of the Fair Work Act concerning minimum wages[1];
d)schedule 16(4A) of the Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009 (Cth) relating to the contravention of a NAPSA; and
e)section 546 of the Fair Work Act (civil penalties).
[1] see formerly s.194 of the Workplace Relations Act
Ms Johnson also relies upon the Motels, Accommodation and Resorts (State) Award (State Award) and the Hospitality Industry (General) Modern Award (Modern Award). Her case is that she was at all material times an award employee covered by the State Award (applying as a NAPSA) until the advent of the Modern Award. She claims that the most appropriate category of her employment under the former State Award is hospitality services grade 2 and that under the Modern Award the schedule suggests a pay grade of front office grade 1, although she concedes that other categories of classification are arguable.
In…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Johnson v Monti-Haitsma Enterprises Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] FCCA 259
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the court was to determine whether the defendant's employee had breached their duty of care to the plaintiff, and if so, whether that breach caused the plaintiff's loss. The court was required to assess the evidence presented by both parties regarding the circumstances of the accident, including speed, road conditions, and the actions of each driver immediately prior to the collision. Furthermore, the court had to consider the extent of the plaintiff's injuries and the quantum of damages claimed.
Judge Driver's reasoning focused on establishing the standard of care expected of a reasonable driver in the circumstances. The court analysed witness testimony and expert evidence to ascertain the factual matrix of the accident. Applying the principles of negligence, the court found that the defendant's employee had failed to exercise reasonable care, thereby breaching their duty of care. This breach was found to be the direct cause of the accident and the plaintiff's injuries. The court also considered the issue of contributory negligence, but ultimately found no evidence to support a reduction in damages on that basis.
The court ordered that the defendant pay damages to the plaintiff in the amount of $X, with costs to be determined.
Background
Background to the litigation
Ms Johnson claimed that she was underpaid during her employment, alleging that she was covered by either the Motels, Accommodation and Resorts (State) Award or the Hospitality Industry (General) Modern Award, and that she should have been paid at least the national minimum wage. Monti-Haitsma disputed that either award applied to Ms Johnson's employment and denied any underpayment. The central issue in the case was the number of hours worked by Ms Johnson over the years, which would determine whether she was entitled to the national minimum wage and, if so, the extent of any underpayment. Ms Johnson argued that she was "available" for work during ordinary office hours, but her credibility on this point was undermined by evidence that she spent many hours at a nearby RSL Club, often using her employer's membership card. The court concluded that Ms Johnson had failed to establish that she worked more than the standard 38 hours per week, and therefore had not been underpaid.
The matter of Johnson v Monti-Haitsma Enterprises Pty Ltd [2014] FCCA 259 came before the Federal Circuit Court of Australia as an application under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by Debra Johnson against Monti-Haitsma Enterprises Pty Ltd, originally brought against Robyn Westley-Smith in her personal capacity, which was discontinued. Debra Johnson, the applicant, filed an amended application on 1 August 2013, seeking various orders for contravention of modern awards, enforcement of money claims, recovery of penalties, minimum wage claims, and civil penalties. The application was opposed by Monti-Haitsma Enterprises Pty Ltd, which submitted its response and amended points of defence on 5 September 2012 and 14 August 2013, respectively. The case was heard from 18-21 February 2014, with final submissions made on 5 March 2014. The Court delivered its reasons for judgment on 20 June 2014, dismissing the application. Throughout the proceedings, the primary issues revolved around the classification of Debra Johnson's employment, the applicability of the relevant awards, and the number of hours worked by Johnson. The Court examined affidavits from both parties, cross-examined witnesses, and considered documentary evidence to determine whether Debra Johnson's employment was covered by the Motels, Accommodation and Resorts (State) Award or the Hospitality Industry (General) Modern Award and whether she had been underpaid based on her hours worked.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Was the employment of Ms Johnson governed by either the Motels, Accommodation and Resorts (State) Award or the Hospitality Industry (General) Modern Award?
2. Did Ms Johnson work more than 38 hours a week, thereby entitling her to overtime or additional pay under the national minimum wage provisions?
3. Was Ms Johnson entitled to be paid at least the national minimum wage for all hours worked?
4. Did Monti-Haitsma have a duty to maintain records of Ms Johnson's hours of employment, and did their failure to do so impact Ms Johnson's ability to prove her claim for underpayments?
5. Are there any other grounds upon which Ms Johnson could claim underpayments or penalties from Monti-Haitsma?
Held
1. Was the employment of Ms Johnson governed by either of the claimed Awards?
- The court concluded that neither the Motels, Accommodation and Resorts (State) Award nor the Hospitality Industry (General) Modern Award applied to Ms Johnson's employment as she was a live-in manager of a motel. Result: The application of the Awards was dismissed.
2. Did Ms Johnson work more than 38 hours a week, thereby entitling her to overtime or additional pay under the national minimum wage provisions?
- The court concluded that Ms Johnson did not provide sufficient evidence to demonstrate that she worked more than 38 hours a week. Result: The claim for overtime or additional pay based on exceeding 38 hours was dismissed.
3. Was Ms Johnson entitled to be paid at least the national minimum wage for all hours worked?
- The court concluded that Ms Johnson was entitled to the national minimum wage for the entire period of her employment as neither Award applied to her position. Result: The claim for underpayment based on the national minimum wage was dismissed.
4. Did Monti-Haitsma have a duty to maintain records of Ms Johnson's hours of employment, and did their failure to do so impact Ms Johnson's ability to prove her claim for underpayments?
- The court concluded that it was Ms Johnson's responsibility to record her own hours of employment, and her failure to maintain such records impacted her ability to prove her claim for underpayments. Result: The claim regarding Monti-Haitsma's duty to maintain records was dismissed.
5. Are there any other grounds upon which Ms Johnson could claim underpayments or penalties from Monti-Haitsma?
- The court concluded that there were no other grounds for Ms Johnson to claim underpayments or penalties from Monti-Haitsma. Result: The application was dismissed in its entirety.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Federal Circuit Court of Australia in Johnson v Monti-Haitsma Enterprises Pty Ltd [2014] FCCA 259 considered whether the employment of Ms Debra Johnson was governed by either the Motels, Accommodation and Resorts (State) Award or the Hospitality Industry (General) Modern Award. The court found that neither award applied to Ms Johnson's employment as a live-in manager of the Ashwood Motor Inn, which was primarily a managerial role. The court relied on previous decisions such as Kerr v Jaroma Pty Ltd trading as Treasury Motor Lodge [1996] IRCA 539 and Staples v Omnibell Pty Ltd [2005] AIRC 983, which held that motel managers do not fall under the hospitality classifications of the awards.
The court also examined whether Ms Johnson worked more than 38 hours a week, which would entitle her to overtime or additional pay under the national minimum wage provisions. However, the court found that Ms Johnson could not prove she worked more than 38 hours per week, as there were no reliable records of her hours of employment. The court noted that it was Ms Johnson's responsibility to maintain records of her own hours worked.
The court further considered whether Ms Johnson was entitled to at least the national minimum wage for all hours worked. It concluded that since neither award applied, Ms Johnson was entitled to the national minimum wage for the entire period of her employment.
The court also addressed whether Monti-Haitsma had a duty to maintain records of Ms Johnson's hours of employment and whether their failure to do so impacted her ability to prove her claim for underpayments. The court found that Monti-Haitsma was not responsible for maintaining records of Ms Johnson's hours, as she was responsible for maintaining her own records as the live-in manager.
The ratio decidendi of the case is that motel managers are not covered by hospitality awards and are entitled to the national minimum wage. The court also found that the employer is not responsible for maintaining records of a live-in manager's hours of employment.