Holmes v Balance Water Inc and Ors (No.2)

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

HOLMES v BALANCE WATER INC & ORS (No.2) [2015] FCCA 1093
Catchwords:
INDUSTRIAL LAW – Termination of employment – non payment of benefits – whether the applicant was an employee of one or more of the respondents, whether there was a transfer of employment between the respondents and if so, whether the employer was a National System Employer considered.

Legislation:

Annual Holidays Act 1944 (NSW)
Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)
Federal Circuit Court of Australia Act 1999 (Cth), s.17A
Industrial Relations Act 1988 (NSW)
Long Service Leave Act 1955 (NSW), s.4
Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth)

ACE Insurance Ltd v Trifunovski (2013) 295 ALR 407
Fair Work Ombudsman v Valuair Limited (No.2) [2014] FCA 759
Holmes v Balance Water Inc & Ors [2013] FCCA 1787

Johnson v Monti-Haitsma Enterprises Pty Ltd [2014] FCCA 259
Johnson v Monti-Haitsma Enterprises Pty Ltd(in External Administration) [2014] FCA 906

Mersey Docks & Harbour Board v Coggins & Griffith (Liverpool) Ltd [1947] AC 1

Applicant: KIERAN HOLMES
First Respondent: BALANCE WATER INC
Second Respondent: PETER JOHN MAHER
Third Respondent: BALANCE WATER COMPANY PTY LTD
Fourth Respondent: BALANCE WATER COMPANY LLC
File Number: SYG 1363 of 2013
Judgment of: Judge Driver
Hearing dates: 15-19 December 2014
Date of Last Submission: 16 March 2015
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 28 August 2015

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr I Latham
Solicitors for the Applicant: Toomey Pegg
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr G Hatcher SC, with Mr M Easton
Solicitors for the Respondents: Terrett Lawyers

ORDERS

  1. Within 28 days, the parties are to submit agreed short minutes of order consistent with these reasons or, in the absence of agreement, they are to submit alternative proposed short minutes of order with any necessary explanation.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT SYDNEY

SYG 1363 of 2013

KIERAN HOLMES

Applicant

And

BALANCE WATER INC

First Respondent

PETER JOHN MAHER

Second Respondent

BALANCE WATER COMPANY PTY LTD

Third Respondent

BALANCE WATER COMPANY LLC

Fourth Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction and background

  1. The applicant, Ms Holmes, claims to have been an employee of at least one of the corporate respondents.  By an amended application and statement of claim filed on 20 October 2014, she claims relief under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (Fair Work Act) and the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) (Workplace Relations Act) in respect of alleged failures to provide notice of termination of employment, to pay annual leave on termination of employment, to pay long service leave on termination of employment, to pay minimum rates of pay under the Fair Work Act, to pay appropriate rates of pay under the Workplace Relations Act, to pay remuneration in a timely manner under both Acts, breach of contract and failure to provide notice of termination of employment.

  2. The first, third and fourth respondents are related corporations.  The first respondent (Balance Water Inc) is a US corporation, as is the fourth respondent (Balance Water LLC).  The third respondent (Balance Water Company) is an Australian company.  The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Holmes v Balance Water Inc and Ors (No.2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCCA 1093
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Holmes v Balance Water Inc and Ors (No.2)*, the applicant, Mr. Holmes, sought to join a third party to proceedings against the respondents, Balance Water Inc and its directors. The dispute concerned allegations of misleading and deceptive conduct in relation to the sale of shares in Balance Water Inc.

The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the proposed third party, a company named "Balance Water Australia Pty Ltd," should be joined as a respondent to the proceedings. This required the Court to consider the principles governing the joinder of parties, particularly in circumstances where the applicant alleges the third party is directly liable for the conduct in question or is otherwise a necessary party for the just and convenient determination of the proceedings.

Judge Driver determined that the applicant had failed to establish that Balance Water Australia Pty Ltd was a necessary party for the just and convenient determination of the proceedings. The Court found that the applicant's claims against the existing respondents were sufficiently distinct and that the joinder of the third party was not essential for resolving the core dispute. The Court applied the principles that a party should only be joined if they are directly liable or if their presence is necessary to ensure a complete and final resolution of the controversy between the existing parties.

The application to join Balance Water Australia Pty Ltd as a third respondent was dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Kieran Holmes sought employment with Balance Water Inc in July 2006, but the business, being a start-up, could not afford to employ her at that time. A compromise was reached where Holmes would work on a voluntary unpaid basis from October 2006, with discussions to follow regarding formal remuneration. Holmes claims that Peter Maher made an oral offer of employment on 7 December 2006, later recorded in an email on 12 February 2007. The email outlined a salary of $100,000 per year, $80,000 of phantom shares, and a performance bonus. Despite this agreement, Holmes only received some payments in 2007 and 2008 before raising concerns about non-payment in April 2008. Holmes relocated to the USA and France in 2008 but claims to have continued working for the respondents remotely. In 2012, an agreement was made to provide Holmes with stock options in lieu of back pay, and she was later employed by Balance Water LLC from July to December 2012. Holmes asserts that she was employed by Balance Water Company for most of the relevant period and is entitled to various payments and entitlements under Australian law. The respondents deny Holmes was ever employed by any of the corporate respondents or that there was any transfer of her employment, and they assert that Holmes was fully compensated for her services. The key issues in the case revolve around whether Holmes was an employee of any of the respondents, if so, which one, whether there was a transfer of her employment, and what, if any, amounts are payable by the employer.

This case came before the Federal Circuit Court of Australia as a first instance hearing, following an earlier interlocutory judgment delivered by Judge Driver on 4 December 2013. In the present proceeding, the applicant, Ms Holmes, claims relief under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) in respect of alleged failures to provide notice of termination of employment, to pay annual leave on termination of employment, to pay long service leave on termination of employment, to pay minimum rates of pay, to pay appropriate rates of pay, to pay remuneration in a timely manner, breach of contract and failure to provide notice of termination of employment. The respondents deny that there was an employment relationship with Ms Holmes prior to 2012 or, if there was, that the employer was liable under Australian law. The respondents also assert that Ms Holmes has not suffered any loss. On 15 and 16 December 2014, the Court heard argument on an Application in a Case filed by the respondents seeking summary dismissal of the proceedings. The Court ordered that the claim for damages under the general law be dismissed summarily, pursuant to s.17A(2) of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia Act 1999 (Cth). The remaining claim to be dealt with arises under the Fair Work Act and the Workplace Relations Act.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was Ms Holmes an employee of any of the corporate respondents?
2. If so, which one of the corporate respondents was she employed by?
3. Was there a transfer of employment between Ms Holmes and the corporate respondents?
4. If any of the corporate respondents employed Ms Holmes, were they a National System Employer at the material times?
5. What amounts are payable by the employer, if any?
6. Has Ms Holmes suffered compensable loss?
7. Was Mr Maher an accessory for the purposes of the relevant Acts?
8. If so, what orders can be made against Mr Maher?
9. What penalties should be ordered, if any?
10. Who should the penalties be paid to?
11. What orders should be made as to costs?

Held
1. Yes, Ms Holmes was an employee of one of the corporate respondents.
2. Ms Holmes was employed by Balance Water Company from 13 November 2006 until 9 May 2012.
3. There was no transfer of employment between Ms Holmes and the corporate respondents.
4. Yes, Balance Water Company was a National System Employer at the material times.
5. Ms Holmes is entitled to receive the national minimum wage for 38 hours a week between 13 November 2006 and 9 May 2012, with deductions for any unpaid leave and with the addition of any unused paid leave.
6. Yes, Ms Holmes has suffered compensable loss.
7. No, Mr Maher was not an accessory for the purposes of the relevant Acts.
8. As Mr Maher was not found to be an accessory, no orders can be made against him.
9. Penalties are deferred pending resolution of liability and quantum.
10. The recipient of any penalties is deferred pending resolution of liability and quantum.
11. Orders as to costs are deferred pending resolution of liability and quantum.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court found that Ms Holmes was employed by Balance Water Company from 13 November 2006 until 9 May 2012. The Court rejected the respondents' argument that there was no employment relationship between Ms Holmes and any of the corporate respondents prior to July 2012. The Court found that an employment relationship was formed on or about 7 December 2006 when Ms Holmes and Mr Maher reached an agreement that Ms Holmes would be remunerated for her work.

The Court found that there was no transfer of employment from Balance Water Company to any of the other corporate respondents. There was no evidence of any document or conversation indicating that Ms Holmes consented to a transfer of her employment.

The Court found that neither Balance Water Inc nor Balance Water LLC was a National System Employer for the purposes of the Fair Work Act. The employment relationship between Ms Holmes and Balance Water LLC was not sufficiently linked with Australia.

The Court found that Ms Holmes was entitled to receive the national minimum wage for 38 hours a week between 13 November 2006 and 9 May 2012, with deductions for any unpaid leave and with the addition of any unused paid leave. The Court deferred consideration of costs and penalties.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that an employment relationship can be formed where parties reach an agreement that remuneration will be paid for work performed, even if the precise legal nature of the relationship was not initially agreed upon. However, an employee cannot be transferred from one employer to another without the consent of the employee.