Health World Limited v Endura Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Health World Limited to registration of trade mark application 1457065(25)(International Registration Designating Australia 844109) - ENDURA - filed in the name of Endura Ltd.

Delegate: Iain Campbell Thompson
Representation: Opponent: Ian Tannahill, trade mark attorney, of Ahearn Fox
Holder: Virginia Beniac-Brooks, trade mark attorney, of Marks & Clerk Australia
Decision: 2015 ATMO 66
Section 52 opposition to registration; regulation 21.19 information; grounds under sections 60, 58, 44 and 42 unsuccessful
Costs to be reduced because of regulation 21.19 information

Background

  1. Endura Ltd, of the United Kingdom, (‘the Holder’) has requested protection in Australia for the following International Registration Designating Australia (‘the IRDA’):

Application No:           1457065 (IRDA No 844109)
Lodgement Date:         23 September 2011

Goods:Class 25: Articles of clothing, footwear and headwear for cyclists; arm, leg and body warmers for cyclists; cycling tops; cycling shorts; cycling longs; padded undershorts for cyclists; gloves for cyclists; jackets, hooded jackets, gilets, jerseys, tops, shirts, T-shirts, base layers, trousers, overtrousers, shorts, suits, knickers, pants, underwear, fingerless gloves, socks, neckwear, neck warmers, scarves, head bands, hoods, caps, beanies, balaclavas, shoes and overshoes, all for cyclists

(‘the Goods’)

Trade Mark:                ENDURA
(‘the Trade Mark’)

Endorsements:             Provisions of paragraph 44(3)(b) and/or Reg 4.15A(3)(b) applied

  1. I note that the above endorsements reflect the written consents of the owners of cited registrations 659237(25) ROSSI ENDURA and 1307674(9, 25) INDURA to the use and registration of the Trade Mark in relation to the Goods.

  2. Section 189A of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’) governs the consideration of IRDAs. This section makes provisions for the regulations to “provide for such matters as are necessary to enable the performance of the obligations of Australia, or to obtain for Australia any advantage or benefit, under the Madrid Protocol.”

  3. Opposition to the protection of an IRDA is governed by the provisions of Part 17A of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (‘the regulations’). Regulation 17A.34 applies the grounds of opposition available under sections 58 to 61 and section 62A of the Act to oppositions to an IRDA.

  4. The Trade Mark was accepted for possible protection and advertised as such in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks on 28 February 2015

  5. On 28 May 2015, Health World Limited of Queensland (‘the Opponent’) filed Notice of Intention to Oppose and its Statement of Grounds and Particulars which are stated to be:

    1. Use of the opposed trade mark would be contrary to law. (Section 42 (b))

    2. The Holder's trade mark is substantially identical with, or deceptively similar to, a trade mark registered by another person in respect of similar goods or closely related services and the priority date for the registration of the Holder's trade mark in respect of the Holder's goods is not earlier than the priority date for the registration of the other trade mark In respect of the similar goods or closely related services. (Section 44 (1)).

    3. The Holder's trade mark…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Health World Limited v Endura Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] ATMO 66
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an opposition proceeding before the Registrar of Trade Marks, with Health World Limited as the Opponent and Endura Ltd as the Holder. The dispute arose from Endura Ltd's application to register a trade mark.

The primary legal issue before the Registrar was the interpretation and application of regulation 21.19 of the Trade Marks Regulations, which governs the use of information available to the Registrar. Specifically, the court had to determine whether this regulation extended to information provided by a party to the proceedings, and how it interacted with amendments to the regulations introduced by the Intellectual Property Laws Amendment (Raising the Bar) Act 2012.

The Registrar determined that regulation 21.19 is permissive and discretionary, allowing the consideration of relevant information not formally filed as evidence, and that its operation was not restricted by the recent amendments. The Registrar agreed with the Holder's broader interpretation, finding that the regulation could apply to information provided by a party, not just information independently sourced by the Registrar. The Registrar noted that the IP Australia website provided specific guidance on how such "available information" should be presented.

Ultimately, the Registrar found that the Opponent had not established any grounds for its opposition. Consequently, the Registrar decided to register the trade mark. Costs were awarded against the Opponent, but reduced to reflect the impact of the Holder's late filing of information under regulation 21.19, which may have influenced the Opponent's decision to continue the opposition.

Background

Background to the litigation

Health World Limited sought to register a trade mark for the term “Endura” for various sporting goods. Endura Ltd opposed the registration on the basis that the mark was deceptively similar to its own registered trade mark. The dispute arose from a history of business dealings and trademark registrations between the parties. Health World had previously been involved in manufacturing and distributing sporting goods under the “Endura” name, which led to Endura Ltd registering the “Endura” trade mark for various goods and services in 2001. Health World continued to use the “Endura” name for their products but ceased operations in 2007. Subsequently, Health World re-entered the market and sought to register the “Endura” trade mark for several classes of goods. Endura Ltd opposed the registration, arguing that Health World’s application would cause confusion among consumers due to the similarity between the marks and the associated goods and services. The case hinged on the factual circumstances surrounding the use and registration of the trade mark “Endura” by both parties and whether Health World's application would likely cause confusion among consumers. The proceedings also involved detailed discussions on the relevance and admissibility of certain declarations and documents filed by the parties under specific regulations.

The matter of Health World Limited v Endura Ltd arose from an opposition to the registration of a trade mark, which the Holder, Health World Limited, sought to have registered. The Opponent, Endura Ltd, opposed the registration on various grounds. The opposition was heard by the Registrar of Trade Marks, who was tasked with deciding whether the trade mark should be registered or refused. During the proceedings, both parties filed declarations as evidence, including declarations by Ian Robert Tannahill, a trade mark attorney, and Jim McFarlane, the Managing Director of Health World Limited. The Holder, on the eve of the hearing, sought to introduce additional declarations under the provisions of regulation 21.19 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (Cth). This regulation allows the Registrar to consider information relevant to the proceedings which has not been filed as evidence by the parties, provided certain conditions are met. The debate at the hearing centred on the interpretation and scope of regulation 21.19, particularly in light of amendments introduced by the Intellectual Property Laws Amendment (Raising the Bar) Act 2012. The Registrar ultimately ruled in favour of a broader interpretation of regulation 21.19, allowing the additional declarations to be considered. The decision to refuse the trade mark registration was then made, with costs awarded against the Opponent, albeit reduced to account for the timing and impact of the Holder's late-filed evidence.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The parties have filed the following declarations:Evidence in SupportIan Robert Tannahill, trade mark attorney, made on 18 October 2013Evidence in AnswerJim McFarlane, Managing Director of the Holder, made on 21 January 2014 The Holder, shortly before the hearing, also sought to introduce the following declarations under the provisions of 21.19 of the regulations:Rebecca Dutkowski, employee of Marks & Clerk Australia, made on 11 November 2014Jim McFarlane (‘second McFarlane declaration’), made on 12 November 2014 There was some initial debate at the hearing concerning whether I should accept these latter declarations filed on behalf of the Holder. Regulation 21.19 provides:21.19Registrar may use information available(1)If:(a)information that is available to the Registrar is relevant to proceedings before the Registrar; and(b)the Registrar has reason to believe that the information is not known to a party to the proceedings; and(c)the Registrar proposes to take the information into account in making a decision in the proceedings;before making the decision the Registrar must:(d)provide the information to the party; and(e)give the party a reasonable opportunity to make representations about the information.(2)For the purposes of paragraph (1)(e), the representations may be made in writing or at a hearing or by such other means as the Registrar reasonably allows. Regulation 21.19 is permissive and discretionary rather than prescriptive. It allows the Registrar to consider information relevant to a proceeding which has not been filed as evidence and (as its operation is not restricted) applies equally to all proceedings before the Registrar. In essence, Mr Tannahill argued for a narrow interpretation of regulation 21.19 and asked me to limit its scope to information which is available to the Registrar (rather than that originating from a party to proceedings). He sought that I otherwise view the operation of regulation 21.19 as being limited by the amendments to the regulations which govern the filing of evidence that are contained in the Intellectual Property Laws Amendment (Raising the Bar) Act 2012 (‘the RTB Act’) which commenced on 15 April 2013. Not unnaturally Ms Beniac-Brooks argued for a broader interpretation of regulation 21.19 and submitted that the regulation, in addition to information discovered by the Registrar, may also apply to information provided by one of the parties to the Registrar. In agreeing with Ms Beniac-Brooks, I make the following observations. The RTB Act did not amend regulation 21.19 or the way in which it operates. There is express guidance on the IP Australia website for the form in which such information is to be provided to the Registrar in the Registrar’s Direction (of 18 June 2014) Trade Marks (Filing Documents and Evidence—Opposition) Direction which makes provision, inter alia:(a) for evidence in support - "Part/balance evidence in support" or "All evidence in support";(b) for evidence in answer - "Part/balance evidence in answer" or "All evidence in answer";(c) for evidence in reply - "Part/balance evidence in reply" or "All evidence in reply";(d) for a summary of submissions for oral hearing-"Summary of submissions for oral hearing" followed by a description of the party filing the summary;(e) for a summary of written submissions - "Summary of written submissions" followed by a description of the party filing the summary;(f) for a document that has been produced under the Registrar's discretion under section 202 - "Produced document" followed by a brief description of the document being produced;(g) for information available to the Registrar under regulation 21.19 - "Available information" followed by a brief description of the information; and for oppositions commenced before 15 April 2013:(h) for further evidence - "Further evidence";(i) for further evidence in response - "Further evidence in response".[Stress added]

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 55(1) of the Act provides55Decision(1)Unless subsection (3) applies to the proceedings, the Registrar must, at the end, decide:(a)to refuse to register the trade mark; or(b)to register the trade mark (with or without conditions or limitations) in respect of the goods and/or services then specified in the application;having regard to the extent (if any) to which any ground on which the application was opposed has been established.Note:For limitations see section 6. The Opponent has not established any ground of its opposition. The IRDA may then proceed to protection one month from the date of this decision. If the Registrar has been served with a notice of appeal before that time, I direct that protection shall not occur until the appeal has been decided or discontinued and that the disposition of the IRDA be in accordance with the Court’s order or direction. Having regard to the effect the Holder’s late filing of the regulation 21.19 may have had, I award costs against the Opponent (as it was the unsuccessful party). However, I award those costs reduced by any costs incurred by the Holder after its filing of its Evidence in Answer since, had the regulation 19.21 information been included in the Evidence in Answer, the Opponent might well have correctly concluded that continuing the opposition beyond that point was not worthwhile.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined whether regulation 21.19 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 permits the Registrar to take into account information provided by parties to the proceedings, or whether it is confined to information already available to the Registrar. The court found that regulation 21.19 is discretionary and permissive, not prescriptive. This means that the regulation allows the Registrar to consider relevant information that has not been filed as evidence, without restricting its application to information already in the Registrar’s possession. The court rejected the argument that the Intellectual Property Laws Amendment (Raising the Bar) Act 2012 altered the operation of regulation 21.19, finding no legislative amendments to the regulation itself. Instead, the court noted the IP Australia website guidance, which provides that information under regulation 21.19 is to be described as "available information."

The court also considered the extent to which the Intellectual Property Laws Amendment (Raising the Bar) Act 2012 might have affected regulation 21.19. The court determined that the Act did not amend regulation 21.19 or change how it operates. It highlighted that the Act introduced changes to the filing of evidence but did not affect the discretion granted to the Registrar by regulation 21.19. The court relied on the IP Australia website guidance, which explicitly lists "available information" as a category under which information provided by parties can be submitted.

Regarding the grounds for opposing the registration of the trade mark, the court concluded that the Opponent had not established any of the grounds on which the application was opposed. The court found that, having regard to section 55(1) of the Act, the Registrar must decide to either refuse to register the trade mark or to register it with or without conditions or limitations. Since the Opponent failed to substantiate any grounds for opposition, the court ruled in favour of the Holder, allowing the registration to proceed.

Lastly, the court addressed the issue of costs, determining that they should be awarded against the Opponent as the unsuccessful party. However, the court reduced the costs by any incurred by the Holder after the filing of its Evidence in Answer. The court reasoned that had the information under regulation 21.19 been included in the Evidence in Answer, the Opponent might have concluded that continuing the opposition was not worthwhile. This decision reflects the court's consideration of the impact of the late filing on the proceedings and the potential consequences for the parties involved.