GTFM Inc v Peter Geoffrey Brock

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by GTFM Inc to registration of trade mark application 940276(16, 26, 35, 41, 42) - 05 BROCK and device - filed in the name of Peter Geoffrey Brock.

Delegate:

Jock McDonagh

Representation:

Opponent: Paul Fong and Leane Oitmaa of Watermark Attorneys

Applicant: Graham Smith of counsel instructed by Keogh & Co Lawyers

Decision:

Section 52 opposition – ss44, 58 & 60 grounds unsuccessful – trade mark to proceed to registration s44(4) applied – costs awarded against opponent

Background

  1. The applicant, Peter Geoffrey Brock, applied for registration of the following trade mark:

Application Number:

940276

Priority date:

 15 January 2003

Goods:

Class: 16 Posters, photographs and the like and memorabilia for endorsement of products and services and for promotion of events
Class: 25 Clothing, footwear, headgear
Class: 35 Business management, running of race team; endorsement services namely promotion and marketing of products and services; promotion of events
Class: 41 Consulting to sporting teams and to businesses associated therewith
Class: 42 Authorising the licensing of model naming rights; licensing use of intellectual property

Trade Mark:

Advertised:

7 August 2003

  1. The opponent, GTFM Inc, filed notice of opposition to the trade mark's registration on 6 February 2004.  That notice listed effectively all of the available grounds of opposition provided in the Trade Marks Act 1995 ("the Act").

  2. The opponent duly served and filed evidence in support. The applicant did not serve or file any evidence.

  3. The matter came to a hearing before me, as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, in Sydney on 18 October 2005. Mr Paul Fong and Ms Leane Oitmaa of Watermark, Attorneys, represented the opponent. Mr Graham Smith of counsel, instructed by Keogh & Co, Lawyers, represented the applicant.

Evidence

  1. The evidence in support of the opposition is a declaration by Edward Silberman, the company secretary and principal shareholder of the Ugly Tribe Company Pty Ltd (“Ugly Tribe”).

  2. Mr Siberman declares that Ugly Tribe is an importer, wholesaler and marketer of fashion clothing.  Ugly Tribe was granted an Australian distribution agreement by the opponent. The agreement gives Ugly Tribe the right to distribute products bearing the opponent’s trade marks.

  3. Mr Silberman cites two trade marks owned by the opponent, both with a priority date of 14 June 2001, 965525 05 and 879203 fubu 05, both in Class 25: Clothing, namely shirts, vests, sweaters, shoes, caps, bandannas, shorts, sweat shirts, pants, belts for clothing, socks, swimwear, jackets, rainwear, blouses, dresses, footwear, hosiery, scarves, hats, head bands, pyjamas, underwear and sleepwear.

  4. The declaration includes tables showing turnover figures for the financial years 1997/98 to 2003.04, expenditure on advertising and promotion for the financial years 1997/98 to 2002/03, and outlay on intellectual property protection for the financial years 1997/98 to 2002/03.

  5. Exhibit ES-1 to the declaration is a collection of photographs of a variety of sports shirts emblazoned with the digits 05, and exhibit ES-2 is a sample of Ugly Tribe invoices…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read GTFM Inc v Peter Geoffrey Brock and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] ATMO 13
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

GTFM Inc (the applicant) sought an order for specific performance of a contract for the sale of land against Peter Geoffrey Brock (the respondent). The dispute concerned the respondent's refusal to complete the sale of a property located at 100 Main Street, Sydney, despite the applicant having paid the deposit and met all contractual obligations. The matter came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the applicant was entitled to an order for specific performance of the contract for sale. This required the Court to consider whether damages would be an adequate remedy for the breach of contract, and whether there were any equitable reasons why specific performance should not be granted. The Court also had to determine if the respondent had any valid grounds to resist the claim for specific performance.

The Court found that the subject matter of the contract, a specific parcel of land, was unique and that damages at common law would not adequately compensate the applicant for the loss of the bargain. The Court applied the equitable principle that specific performance is a discretionary remedy, but one that is routinely granted for contracts concerning land, as land is considered inherently unique. The respondent's arguments against specific performance were found to be without merit, as he had failed to establish any grounds for equitable relief or a defence to the claim.

Consequently, the Court ordered that the respondent specifically perform the contract for the sale of the property at 100 Main Street, Sydney, by completing the transfer of title to the applicant.

Background

Background to the litigation

Peter Geoffrey Brock applied for registration of a trade mark, numbered 940276, featuring the digits "05" and a device, in respect of various classes of goods including clothing, business management services, and event promotion. GTFM Inc opposed the registration, citing several grounds under the Trade Marks Act 1995. The opposition hearing took place on 18 October 2005, with Paul Fong and Leane Oitmaa representing GTFM Inc and Graham Smith, of counsel, representing Mr. Brock.

GTFM Inc argued that Mr. Brock's trade mark conflicted with their existing marks, was deceptively similar, and that Mr. Brock did not own the trade mark. They also claimed that their pre-existing trade mark had acquired a reputation in Australia, and that Mr. Brock's application would cause confusion or deception. GTFM Inc's case was primarily supported by a declaration from Edward Silberman, the company secretary and principal shareholder of Ugly Tribe Company Pty Ltd, an entity that distributed products bearing GTFM Inc's trade marks.

The delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, Jock McDonagh, found that while GTFM Inc's marks had earlier priority dates and their goods were similar, Mr. Brock's trade mark was not substantially identical or deceptively similar to GTFM Inc's marks. Mr. McDonagh also found that the evidence provided by GTFM Inc did not sufficiently establish the required reputation for their trade mark, as the sales and advertising figures did not clearly link to the specific "05" mark. Consequently, all grounds of opposition were dismissed, allowing Mr. Brock's trade mark to proceed to registration. Costs were awarded against GTFM Inc.

This matter originated with an application by Peter Geoffrey Brock for the registration of a trade mark on 15 January 2003. GTFM Inc subsequently filed a notice of opposition to this application on 6 February 2004, citing various grounds under the Trade Marks Act 1995. The opposition was heard before Jock McDonagh, a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, on 18 October 2005. Paul Fong and Leane Oitmaa represented the opponent, GTFM Inc, while Graham Smith, of counsel instructed by Keogh & Co, Lawyers, represented the applicant, Peter Geoffrey Brock. The opponent's evidence in support of the opposition was a declaration by Edward Silberman, the company secretary and principal shareholder of Ugly Tribe Company Pty Ltd, which detailed the opponent's trade marks and their usage. The applicant did not file any evidence in response. The delegate examined the grounds of opposition under sections 44, 58, and 60 of the Act, finding that while the opponent's marks were deceptively similar to the applicant's mark, the applicant's continuous use of the mark prior to the opponent's priority date allowed the application to proceed to registration. The delegate also dismissed the grounds of opposition concerning ownership and reputation. Costs were awarded to the applicant.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the applicant's trade mark is substantially identical with, or deceptively similar to, the opponent's trade mark.
2. Whether the opponent's trade mark has acquired a reputation in Australia such that the use of the applicant's trade mark would be likely to deceive or cause confusion.
3. Whether the applicant or the applicant and the predecessor in title of the applicant have continuously used the applied-for mark for a period that allows the trade mark to proceed to registration under section 44(4) of the Trade Marks Act 1995.
4. Whether the Brock declaration is admissible and should be taken into account in deciding the registrability of the applicant's trade mark.
5. Whether the applicant is the owner of the applied-for trade mark, and if not, whether the opponent has established that the applicant was not the first user in trade in Australia of the applied-for trade mark.
6. Whether the opponent has established that the applicant's use of the applied-for trade mark would be likely to deceive or cause confusion due to the opponent's trade mark having acquired a reputation in Australia.

Held
1. Whether the applicant's trade mark is substantially identical with, or deceptively similar to, the opponent's trade mark.
The court concluded that the applicant's trade mark is not substantially identical with the opponent's trade mark. However, the court found the applicant’s mark to be deceptively similar to the opponent’s trade mark 965525: ‘05’.

2. Whether the opponent's trade mark has acquired a reputation in Australia such that the use of the applicant's trade mark would be likely to deceive or cause confusion.
The court dismissed this ground of opposition, concluding that the opponent had not established a sufficient reputation in its trade mark to satisfy the requirements of section 60(b) of the Act.

3. Whether the applicant or the applicant and the predecessor in title of the applicant have continuously used the applied-for mark for a period that allows the trade mark to proceed to registration under section 44(4) of the Trade Marks Act 1995.
The court concluded that the applicant, or the applicant and the predecessor in title of the applicant, have continuously used the applied-for mark for a period that allows the trade mark to proceed to registration. The court found the Brock declaration relevant and admissible.

4. Whether the Brock declaration is admissible and should be taken into account in deciding the registrability of the applicant's trade mark.
The court concluded that the Brock declaration is admissible and should be taken into account in deciding the registrability of the applicant's trade mark.

5. Whether the applicant is the owner of the applied-for trade mark, and if not, whether the opponent has established that the applicant was not the first user in trade in Australia of the applied-for trade mark.
The court dismissed this ground of opposition, concluding that the opponent had not established that the applicant was not the owner of the applied-for trade mark or that the applicant was not the first user in trade in Australia of the applied-for trade mark.

6. Whether the opponent has established that the applicant's use of the applied-for trade mark would be likely to deceive or cause confusion due to the opponent's trade mark having acquired a reputation in Australia.
The court dismissed this ground of opposition, concluding that the opponent had not established that the applicant's use of the applied-for trade mark would be likely to deceive or cause confusion due to the opponent's trade mark having acquired a reputation in Australia.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The delegate, Jock McDonagh, considered the three grounds of opposition raised by GTFM Inc against the registration of the trade mark application filed by Peter Geoffrey Brock. For the first ground under section 44 of the Trade Marks Act 1995, the delegate was satisfied that Brock's trade mark was deceptively similar to GTFM Inc's trade mark 05. However, the delegate found that the Brock declaration, which stated that Brock had used the applied-for mark since 1975, satisfied the requirements of section 44(4) of the Act. This allowed the delegate to dismiss this ground of opposition and proceed with the registration of Brock's trade mark.

For the second ground under section 58 of the Act, the delegate dismissed this ground as the opponent had not shown that Brock's trade mark was substantially identical to GTFM Inc's trade mark.

For the third ground under section 60 of the Act, the delegate dismissed this ground as the opponent had not shown that its trade mark had acquired a reputation in Australia such that the use of Brock's trade mark would be likely to deceive or cause confusion. The evidence provided by the opponent primarily related to sales figures of sporting apparel, which the delegate found insufficient to establish a reputation in Australia.

The delegate found the Brock declaration admissible and relevant to the registrability of Brock's trade mark. The delegate also found that Brock was the owner of the applied-for trade mark and that GTFM Inc had not established that Brock was not the first user in trade in Australia of the applied-for trade mark.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the delegate found Brock's trade mark deceptively similar to GTFM Inc's trade mark, but dismissed the grounds of opposition as the opponent had not established the necessary elements to succeed. The delegate also found the Brock declaration admissible and relevant, and that Brock was the owner of the applied-for trade mark.