HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
MASON CJ, BRENNAN, DEANE, DAWSON, TOOHEY, GAUDRON AND McHUGH JJ
HEALTH INSURANCE COMMISSION v PEVERILL
9 March 1994
Constitutional Law (Cth)
Constitutional Law (Cth)—Powers of Commonwealth Parliament—Medical benefits—Acquisition on just terms—Entitlement of medical practitioner to fee for assigned benefit—Reduction of fee by retrospective legislation—Whether acquisition of property otherwise than on just terms—Laws imposing taxation to deal only with taxation—Whether imposition of tax on practitioner—The Constitution (63 and 64 Vict. c. 12), s. 51(xxiiiA), (xxxi), 55—Health Insurance Act 1973 (Cth), ss. 20, 20A—Health Insurance (Pathology Services) Amendment Act 1991 (Cth).
Orders
Appeals allowed.
Set aside the orders of the Federal Court. In lieu thereof, declare that the Health Insurance (Pathology Services) Amendment Act 1991 (Cth) is a valid Act of the Commonwealth and is not a law imposing taxation contrary to s.55 of the Constitution, and order that the respondent pay the costs of the Health Insurance Commission in the proceedings in the Federal Court.
Judgment in the proceedings for the Commission.
The respondent to pay the appellant's costs.
Decisions
MASON CJ, DEANE AND GAUDRON JJ The facts and the relevant statutory provisions are set out in the reasons for judgment prepared by Dawson J As his Honour points out, the effect of the Health Insurance (Pathology Services) Amendment Act 1991 (Cth) ("the Amending Act") was to reduce, with retrospective effect, the benefit of $34.50 which was previously payable under item 1345 of the schedule for what was known as the ELISA test. The Amending Act was expressed to operate retrospectively from 1 January 1980 being a date prior to the provision of those medical services by Dr Peverill which are relevant to these proceedings. The Amending Act excluded the ELISA test from item 1345. Instead, the Amending Act inserted items 2294 and 2295 covering ELISA tests for rubella and prescribed a fee for that test of $15.40 which was amended upwards over time culminating for relevant purposes in a fee of $17.20. Hence, the amounts payable to Dr Peverill for ELISA tests which he performed for patients were reduced retrospectively from $34.50 to the fees prescribed in item 2294.
2. The reason for the enactment of the Amending Act with retrospective effect, as stated by the Minister in his second reading
speech, was ((1) Commonwealth, House of Representatives, Parliamentary Debates (Hansard), 11 April 1991, at 2464.):
"to validate certain recommendations made by the Medicare Benefits Advisory Committee relating to the payment of Medicare benefits that were not given legal effect through failure to make necessary ministerial determinations".The Health Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) ("the Principal Act") provided for the establishment of that Committee to advise the Minister about the contents of the table in the schedule of benefits to that Act. A determination by the Minister on the basis of the Committee's recommendation to vary the schedule requires certain steps to be taken to give effect to the recommendation. For a period of time these steps were not…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Health Insurance Commission v Peverill and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1994] HCA 8
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the consultation provided by Mr Peverill constituted a "professional service" as defined by section 3(1) of the *Health Insurance Act 1973* (Cth). Specifically, the court had to determine if the exclusion in the definition, which stated that a professional service does not include a service rendered in circumstances where the patient is entitled to a benefit from a registered health benefits organisation, applied to the facts of the case. This required an interpretation of the interaction between the *Health Insurance Act 1973* and the provisions of the *National Health Act 1953* (Cth) relating to registered health benefits organisations.
The High Court, by majority, held that the exclusion did not apply. The majority reasoned that the entitlement to a benefit from a registered health benefits organisation, for the purposes of the exclusion, must be an entitlement to a benefit that is *equivalent* to the Medicare benefit. The court found that the benefits provided by private health insurance funds under the *National Health Act 1953* were not necessarily equivalent to Medicare benefits, and therefore, the exclusion did not operate to prevent the consultation from being a professional service. The court emphasised that the *Health Insurance Act 1973* was intended to provide a universal health insurance scheme, and the exclusion was designed to prevent double dipping, not to disqualify services that were otherwise eligible for Medicare benefits simply because a private insurance benefit might also be available.
The appeal was dismissed.
Background
Background to the litigation
The factual background leading to the enactment of the Amending Act began in 1984 when the Department of Health recommended new fees for pathology services. In 1990, the Federal Court held that certain pathology services should be paid at higher rates. Dr. Peverill then sued the Commission for the higher benefits. While this case was pending, the Amending Act was passed to reduce the benefits payable for certain tests. Dr. Peverill challenged the validity of the Amending Act, claiming it deprived him of benefits payable under s.20A of the Principal Act.
The case raised questions about whether the Amending Act constituted an acquisition of property under s.51(xxxi) of the Constitution and whether it imposed a tax under s.55. The Court examined whether the statutory entitlement to Medicare benefits was property subject to protection under s.51(xxxi). It concluded that the entitlement was not property as it was subject to alteration or revocation at any time. The Amending Act merely exercised the power to alter the entitlement under s.51(xxiiiA), not acquiring property under s.51(xxxi). The Court also held that the Amending Act was not a tax as it did not impose a compulsory exaction of money.
The appeal was allowed, setting aside the orders of the Federal Court and declaring that the Amending Act was a valid Act of the Commonwealth. The Court held that the Amending Act did not provide for the acquisition of property on terms that were not just, contrary to s.51(xxxi) of the Constitution, and was not a law imposing taxation contrary to s.55. The Amending Act was a valid exercise of the power under s.51(xxiiiA) to make laws with respect to sickness and hospital benefits, medical and dental services.
This matter came before the High Court of Australia as an appeal against a decision of Burchett J in the Federal Court of Australia. The Federal Court had jurisdiction pursuant to the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) and the Health Insurance Act 1973 (Cth). The appeal was removed into the High Court under section 40 of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth). The Health Insurance Commission appealed against Burchett J's decision that the Health Insurance (Pathology Services) Amendment Act 1991 (Cth) was beyond the power of the Commonwealth Parliament and thus invalid. Dr Peverill cross-appealed against Burchett J's failure to find that the Amending Act was also invalid for breaching section 55 of the Constitution. The High Court allowed the appeal and set aside Burchett J's decision, finding that the Amending Act was a valid exercise of legislative power under section 51(xxiiiA) of the Constitution.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the Health Insurance (Pathology Services) Amendment Act 1991 (Cth) provide for the acquisition of property on just terms as required by s.51(xxxi) of the Constitution?
2. Does the Health Insurance (Pathology Services) Amendment Act 1991 (Cth) contravene s.55 of the Constitution by imposing a tax?
Held
1. The court concluded that the Health Insurance (Pathology Services) Amendment Act 1991 (Cth) does not provide for the acquisition of property on just terms as required by s.51(xxxi) of the Constitution. The appeal was allowed, the orders of the Federal Court were set aside, and it was declared that the Amending Act is a valid Act of the Commonwealth.
2. The court concluded that the Health Insurance (Pathology Services) Amendment Act 1991 (Cth) does not contravene s.55 of the Constitution by imposing a tax. The Amending Act does not impose a tax but rather alters the statutory entitlement to payment or, on one view, abolishes that entitlement and substitutes another entitlement of lesser value.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The High Court, in a unanimous judgment, upheld the validity of the Health Insurance (Pathology Services) Amendment Act 1991 (Cth) against Dr Peverill's challenge. The Court found that the Amending Act did not contravene s.51(xxxi) of the Constitution by failing to provide for the acquisition of property on just terms and did not contravene s.55 of the Constitution by imposing a tax.
The Court held that the statutory rights conferred by the Health Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) to patients and medical practitioners were not property for the purposes of s.51(xxxi). The Court found that s.51(xxxi) applies only to the compulsory acquisition of property, not voluntary assignments. The statutory rights were gratuitous entitlements that could be altered, reduced or revoked by the Parliament at any time, even before payment was made. Therefore, the Amending Act, which reduced the medicare benefits payable to Dr Peverill, did not constitute an acquisition of property requiring just terms.
The Court also found that the Amending Act did not impose a tax as defined in s.55 of the Constitution. A tax involves an obligation to pay money, but the Amending Act merely altered the statutory entitlement to payment without imposing any new obligation on Dr Peverill. The Court held that the Amending Act was a valid exercise of the Parliament's power under s.51(xxiiiA) to make laws with respect to medical and hospital benefits.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that statutory entitlements to welfare benefits, even if they confer rights or choses in action, are not property for the purposes of s.51(xxxi) of the Constitution if they are gratuitous and subject to alteration or revocation by the Parliament. The Court distinguished this case from those where the Commonwealth acquires property through compulsory acquisition or requisition, which does fall within s.51(xxxi).