Johnston Fear & Kingham & The Offset Printing Co Pty Ltd v The Commonwealth

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read
67 CLR 314

JOHNSTON FEAR &KINGHAM &THE

OFFSET PRINTING COMPANY PRO-

PRIETARY LIMITED

THE COMMONWEALTH Constitutional Law-Acquisition of property-Defence-National security

terms" - Judicial power - The Constitution (63 &64 Vict. C. 12), ss. 51 (vi.), (xxxi.), -National Security Act 1939-1940 (No. 15 of 1939-No. 44 of 1940), 8. 5-National Security (Supply of Goods) Regulations (S.R. 1939 No. 129 - 1942 No. 164).

The National Security (Supply of Goods) Regulations are invalid. Aug. 11.

So held, by Latham C.J., Rich, Starke and Williams JJ., on the ground that they provide for the acquisition of property by the Commonwealth otherwise than " "on just terms' " as required by S. 51 (xxxi.) of the Constitution, which is the source of the Commonwealth's power to legislate for the acquisition of property for defence purposes by McTiernan J., on the ground that they are not authorized by the National Security Act 1939-1940, which, in so far as it confers power to make regulations for the acquisition of property, should be interpreted as conferring power to make regulations providing for the acquisition of property upon the terms that just compensation is paid.

Per Starke J.: The Regulations do not impinge upon the judicial power of DEMURRER.

In an action in the High Court against the Commonwealth, the plaintiff company alleged in its statement of claim: (By pars. 1-5) On and prior to 27th July 1942 the plaintiff was the owner and in possession of one "Crabtree" three-colour offset press; on that day the defendant by notice in writing ordered the plaintiff to supply and deliver the press to the defendant; the notice purported to be given under the National Security (Supply of Goods) Regulations; on or about 21st August 1942 the defendant by its servants or agents

67 CLR 315

removed the press from the premises of the plaintiff and converted the same to its own use whereby the plaintiff suffered damage particulars whereof were: Value of the press, £10,432, loss of profit until plaintiff was able to replace the press, £9,900. (By par. 6) Upon their proper construction the Regulations did not authorize the giving of the notice or the taking or acquisition of the press. Alternatively (by par. 7), if the Regulations authorized the giving of the notice and the taking or acquisition of the press, they or reg. 5 thereof was or were beyond the powers conferred by the Constitution and void. The plaintiff claimed damages for conversion, £20,332 and, alternatively, (amongst other relief) declarations that the Regu- lations or reg. 5 thereof was or were ultra vires and void and that the plaintiff was entitled to receive compensation upon just terms for the acquisition of the press.

The defendant demurred to the statement of claim, and the demurrer now came on for hearing.

It was agreed that counsel for the plaintiff should begin. Dr. Coppel, for the plaintiff. The Regulations are invalid because they exceed the power of the Commonwealth under S. 51 (xxxi.) of the Constitution to acquire property…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Johnston Fear & Kingham & The Offset Printing Co Pty Ltd v T... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1943] HCA 18
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The parties to this matter were Johnston Fear & Kingham & The Offset Printing Co Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) and the Commonwealth (the defendant). The plaintiff sought damages for conversion of its printing press, alleging that the defendant had unlawfully seized and appropriated the property. Alternatively, the plaintiff sought declarations that the National Security (Supply of Goods) Regulations, under which the defendant purported to act, were invalid. The defendant demurred to the statement of claim. The case was heard in the High Court of Australia.

The central legal issues before the Court were whether the National Security (Supply of Goods) Regulations were validly made and, if so, whether they authorised the actions taken by the Commonwealth in acquiring the plaintiff's printing press. Specifically, the Court was required to determine if the Regulations provided for the acquisition of property on "just terms" as mandated by section 51(xxxi) of the Constitution, and whether the Regulations were otherwise authorised by the National Security Act 1939-1940.

A majority of the Court (Latham C.J., Rich, Starke, and Williams JJ.) held that the National Security (Supply of Goods) Regulations were invalid. Their reasoning primarily focused on section 51(xxxi) of the Constitution, which requires the acquisition of property by the Commonwealth to be on "just terms." The Court found that the Regulations, by providing only for a "price" or "remuneration" for goods and imposing a maximum limit on this price determined by the Commonwealth Prices Commissioner, failed to ensure just terms. This was because the term "price" was interpreted as the mere monetary value of the goods, not encompassing full and adequate compensation for any consequential loss or special circumstances of the dispossessed owner. McTiernan J. dissented on the validity of the Regulations, finding them to be authorised by the National Security Act and that the Act itself conferred power to make regulations for the acquisition of property on terms that included just compensation.

The demurrer was overruled, meaning the plaintiff's claim could proceed. The Court found the National Security (Supply of Goods) Regulations to be invalid on the ground that they did not provide for the acquisition of property on "just terms" as required by section 51(xxxi) of the Constitution.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Offset Printing Co Pty Ltd was the owner of a Crabtree three-colour offset press with auto feeder and electric equipment. On 27 July 1942, the Commonwealth ordered the company to supply and deliver the press to it. The order was made under the National Security (Supply of Goods) Regulations. On 21 August 1942, the Commonwealth removed the press from the company's premises. The company brought an action claiming damages for conversion of the press and loss of profits until it could replace the press. Alternatively, it claimed declarations that the Regulations or reg. 5 thereof was or were ultra vires and void and that it was entitled to receive compensation upon just terms for the acquisition of the press. The Commonwealth demurred to the statement of claim, arguing that the Regulations authorized the taking of the press and provided for just compensation. The court had to decide whether the Regulations were valid and authorized the Commonwealth to acquire the press on just terms.

The main issues were whether the Regulations provided for the acquisition of property on just terms as required by the Constitution and whether they were authorized by the National Security Act. The court found that the Regulations did not provide for just compensation because they only allowed for the payment of the price of the goods, not compensation for any loss caused by the taking of the goods. The price was also limited by a maximum set by the Commonwealth Prices Commissioner, which did not take into account any special circumstances. The court concluded that the Regulations were invalid because they did not comply with the requirement of just terms under the Constitution. The demurrer was overruled.

This case, Johnston Fear & Kingham & The Offset Printing Co Pty Ltd v The Commonwealth, came before the High Court on a demurrer filed by the Commonwealth against a statement of claim brought by the plaintiffs, Johnston Fear & Kingham and The Offset Printing Co Pty Ltd. The plaintiffs alleged that the Commonwealth had, pursuant to the National Security (Supply of Goods) Regulations, ordered the plaintiffs to supply and deliver a three-colour offset press, which they then removed from the plaintiffs' premises. The plaintiffs claimed damages for conversion and sought declarations that the Regulations were ultra vires and void, and that they were entitled to just compensation for the acquisition of the press. The Commonwealth demurred to the statement of claim on the basis that the Regulations were valid and authorised the taking of the press.

The demurrer was heard and ultimately dismissed by the High Court. The Court found that the Regulations were invalid for several reasons. Firstly, they did not provide for compensation that would be "just terms" as required by section 51(xxxi) of the Australian Constitution. Secondly, the Regulations were beyond the powers conferred by the National Security Act 1939-1940, which should be interpreted as only conferring power to make regulations providing for the acquisition of property upon the terms that just compensation is paid. The Court held that the Regulations, by limiting compensation to the price of the goods, did not provide just compensation in all cases. The demurrer was therefore overruled and the plaintiffs' statement of claim allowed to proceed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Do the National Security (Supply of Goods) Regulations provide for the acquisition of property on "just terms" as required by Section 51(xxxi) of the Constitution?
2. Are the Regulations authorized by the National Security Act 1939-1940?
3. Does the National Security (Supply of Goods) Regulations infringe upon the judicial power of the Commonwealth?
4. Does the term "price" in the Regulations refer to compensation or merely the market value of the goods?
5. Is the appointment of arbitrators by the Governor-General in case of disputes over the price of goods valid and in compliance with the Constitution?

Held
1. The National Security (Supply of Goods) Regulations do not provide for the acquisition of property on "just terms" as required by Section 51(xxxi) of the Constitution. Result: Regulations are invalid.
2. The Regulations are not authorized by the National Security Act 1939-1940. Result: Regulations are invalid.
3. The Regulations do not infringe upon the judicial power of the Commonwealth. Result: Regulations are valid in this regard.
4. The term "price" in the Regulations refers to the market value of the goods and not to compensation. Result: Regulations are invalid as they do not provide for just terms.
5. The appointment of arbitrators by the Governor-General in case of disputes over the price of goods is valid and in compliance with the Constitution. Result: Regulations are valid in this regard, but the overall Regulations are still invalid due to other issues.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The High Court of Australia, in its decision in Johnston Fear & Kingham & The Offset Printing Co Pty Ltd v The Commonwealth, held that the National Security (Supply of Goods) Regulations were invalid. The court's reasoning on this matter can be divided into five major issues:

1. The first issue addressed by the court was whether the Regulations provided for the acquisition of property on "just terms" as required by Section 51(xxxi) of the Constitution. The court held that the Regulations did not provide just terms, as they only provided for the payment of the price of the goods, without taking into account any special loss suffered by the owner as a result of the compulsory taking of their goods. The court emphasized that just terms involve full and adequate compensation for the compulsory taking of property.

2. The second issue was whether the Regulations were authorized by the National Security Act 1939-1940. The court found that the Regulations were not within the powers conferred by the Act, as the Act did not explicitly delegate any power to make regulations under which the subject might be deprived of their property without compensation. The court held that the Regulations were invalid for this reason.

3. The third issue was whether the Regulations infringed upon the judicial power of the Commonwealth. The court held that the Regulations did not impinge upon the judicial power of the Commonwealth, as the tribunal set up by the Regulations was within the legislative discretion and the appointment of an arbitrator by the Governor-General did not make the tribunal partial.

4. The fourth issue was whether the term "price" in the Regulations referred to compensation or merely the market value of the goods. The court found that the term "price" referred to the market value of the goods, and not compensation. The court emphasized that the price of goods depends on the characteristics of the goods and the state of the market for them, while just compensation to be paid to a person for compulsory taking of goods depends upon these circumstances but also possibly on particular circumstances which may vary in different cases.

5. The final issue was whether the appointment of arbitrators by the Governor-General in case of disputes over the price of goods was valid and in compliance with the Constitution. The court held that the appointment of arbitrators by the Governor-General did not make the tribunal partial and was within the legislative discretion.

In conclusion, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the National Security (Supply of Goods) Regulations are invalid as they do not provide for the acquisition of property on just terms as required by Section 51(xxxi) of the Constitution, and they are not authorized by the National Security Act 1939-1940. The court also found that the term "price" in the Regulations referred to the market value of the goods and not compensation, and the appointment of arbitrators by the Governor-General in case of disputes over the price of goods was valid and in compliance with the Constitution.