Bropho v State of Western Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Bropho v State of Western Australia [2007] FCA 519

SUMMARY

BELLA BROPHO on behalf of the Members of the Swan Valley Nyungah Community Aboriginal Corporation and Aboriginal inhabitants of Reserve 43131 v STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA, ABORIGINAL AFFAIRS PLANNING AUTHORITY and BARRY CHARLES JAMESON
WAD 157 of 2003

BELLA BROPHO on behalf of the Members of the Swan Valley Nyungah Community Aboriginal Corporation and Aboriginal inhabitants of Reserve 43131 v STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA, ABORIGINAL AFFAIRS PLANNING AUTHORITY and BARRY CHARLES JAMESON
WAD 204 of 2004

NICHOLSON J
13 APRIL 2007
PERTH


SUMMARY

In accordance with the practice of the Federal Court in some cases of public interest, importance or complexity, the following summary has been prepared to accompany the announcement of reasons.  This summary is intended to assist in understanding the outcome of this proceeding and is not a complete statement of the conclusions reached by the Court.  The only authoritative statement of the Court’s reasons is that contained in the published reasons for judgment which will be available on the internet at together with this summary. 

The applicant in both claims, Bella Bropho, is an Aboriginal person of Nyungah origin.  She has been at all relevant times a Governing Committee member, Vice-Chairperson, spokesperson and member of Swan Valley Nyungah Community Aboriginal Corporation (the SVC).  As applicant, Ms Bropho claims to represent all persons who are Aboriginal persons of Nyungah origin and members of the SVC who were Aboriginal inhabitants of reserve 43131 (the Reserve) at any time during the period 14 May 2003 to 13 June 2003 (the applicants).  She was such an inhabitant. 

The claims in these cases are in respect of alleged racial discrimination.  The claims are brought by the applicant on behalf of former Aboriginal inhabitants of the Reserve in respect of the enactment of the Reserves (Reserve 43131) Act 2003 (WA) (the Reserves Act) and actions taken under it. It is said the consequences of the Act and actions under it are that the Aboriginal inhabitants are no longer able to manage or reside at the Lockridge Camp of the SVC. It was claimed the Reserves Act and the actions were contrary to the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) (the RDA).

Various public inquiries have been held relating to conduct on the Reserve, including a Coronial Report on the death of Susan Taylor in 2001; the Gordon Inquiry on 31 July 2002; and the Hooker Inquiry in 2003. 

On 15 May 2003 the Reserves Bill was introduced into the Parliament of Western Australia where it was subsequently passed and became effective from 13 June 2003 as the Reserves Act.

RESERVES ACT

The claims which Bella Bropho brings to the Court are directed to the legality of the Reserves Act. That Act came into effect on 12 June 2003 and expired on the second anniversary of that date.

Relevantly the Reserves Act purported to do the following:

(1)revoke the 2002 Management Order which placed the care, control and management of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bropho v State of Western Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FCA 519
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Bropho v State of Western Australia involved the applicants, who were Aboriginal inhabitants and members of the South Verdent Community (SVC), contesting the constitutionality of certain provisions in the Reserves Act, which allowed property owned by Aboriginals to be managed by another person without their consent. The applicants argued that these provisions violated their rights under the Racial Discrimination Act (RDA) and the Land Act (LAA). The Federal Court was tasked with determining the validity of these claims.

The court had to decide several key legal issues. First, whether the provisions in question applied to persons generally without regard to race, colour or national or ethnic origin, which would potentially exclude the application of s 10(3) of the RDA. Second, if the applicants had property in the Reserve as Aboriginal inhabitants or members of the SVC, whether the provisions were 'by reason of' race or involved a distinction, exclusion, restriction or preference 'based on race'. Third, whether the measures adopted were reasonable and proportionate given the circumstances, and finally, whether the provisions were a special measure under the RDA.

The court found that the provisions in the Reserves Act applied generally to all reserves, and therefore to persons generally, without regard to race. It was determined that s 10(3) of the RDA did not apply in this context. The court also found that the applicants did not have a right to property in domestic law or a human right to the ownership of property, which was a fundamental difficulty with their claim. The court concluded that the Reserves Act and the actions taken under it were not 'by reason of' race or based on race. Additionally, it was established that the measures adopted were reasonable and proportionate given the circumstances, and they were a special measure to secure adequate advancement for individuals requiring such protection.

In light of the above findings, the court dismissed the application. The court ordered that the application be dismissed and reserved the decision on costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

2. Costs reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

NICHOLSON J
Were this not the case the respondents would contend that s 10(3) of the RDA does not apply where the provisions in question (being the provision in ss 4 and 5 of the Reserves Act which authorises property owned by an Aboriginal to be managed by another person without their consent) applies to persons generally without regard to their race, colour or national or ethnic origin. I have already determined that if the applicants had property in the Reserve as Aboriginal inhabitants of the Reserve then ss 46 and 50 of the LAA inherently provided for that property to be managed by a management body chosen by the Minister, and that applied generally to all reserves (and therefore to persons generally, without regard to race). Hence it is argued s 10(3) has no application. If the applicants had property in the Reserve as members of the SVC the respondents would contend s 10(3) of the RDA can have no application because, on their own case, the Reserves Act did not result in that property being managed by other persons; rather they say the removal of the SVC as management body deprived them of the property altogether. As I consider the sub-section cannot apply, consideration of these additional arguments is unnecessary.CONCLUSION The applicant’s claim has raised many issues and I have endeavoured in these reasons to address them all. However the fundamental difficulty with the claim as I apprehend it is that it does not have a foundation of a right to property in domestic law or a human right to the ownership of property. What the applicants had in relation to the Reserve was the care, control and management under the 2002 Management Order. In my view examination of the nature of that right discloses that it is not enough to sustain the claims which have been brought. Even if that seminal difficulty could be overcome, I do not think that the applicant has made out a case that the Reserves Act or actions taken under it were ‘by reason of’ race or involved a distinction, exclusion, restriction or preference ‘based on race’. Additionally I have found that in the circumstances where there were no viable alternatives, the measures adopted were, although unusual, reasonable and proportionate. Further it has been established that the Reserves Act and the actions were taken for the sole purpose of securing adequate advancement of individuals requiring such protection to ensure equal enjoyment of human rights and fundamental freedoms and so was a special measure to which ss 9 and 10 of the RDA do not have application. Accordingly, for the above reasons I consider the claims should be dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: NICHOLSON J