Health Information Pharmacy Franchising Pty Ltd v Khoo

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Health Information Pharmacy Franchising Pty Ltd v Khoo [2010] FCA 438

Citation: Health Information Pharmacy Franchising Pty Ltd v Khoo [2010] FCA 438
Parties: HEALTH INFORMATION PHARMACY FRANCHISING PTY LTD v WILLIAM KHOO, RONALD KHOO, WILLIAM LEE-LING KHOO, HUI LIONG ANG AND KEN WONG and WILLIAM LEE-LING KHOO, HUI LIONG ANG
File number: NSD 1386 of 2009
Judge: YATES J
Date of judgment: 10 MAY 2010
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – security for costs
Held: Security ordered  
Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 1335(1)
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), s 56
Cases cited: Allstate Life Insurance Co v Australia & New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (No 19) (1995) 134 ALR 187
Beach Petroleum NL v Johnson  (1992) 7 ACSR 203
Bell Wholesale Co Pty Ltd v Gates Export Corporation (No 2) (1984) 2 FCR 1
Brundza v Robbie & Co [No. 2] (1952) 88 CLR 171
Bryan E Fencott and Associates Pty Ltd v Eretta Pty Ltd (1987) 16 FCR 497
Central Bayside General Practice Association Ltd v Commissioner of State Revenue (2006) 228 CLR 168
Concrete Constructions Pty Ltd v Dalma Formwork Pty Ltd (Administrator Appointed) [1999] NSWCA 16
Estates Property Investment Corporation Ltd v Pooley (1975) 3 ACLR 256
Epping Plaza Fresh Fruit & Vegetables Pty Ltd v
Bevendale Pty Ltd [1999] 2 VR 191
Equity Access v Westpac Banking Corporation (1989) ATPR ¶40-972
Gentry Bros Pty Ltd v Wilson Brown & Associates Pty Ltd (1992) 8 ACSR 405
Harpur v Ariadne Australia Limited [1984] 2 Qd R 523
Instyle Contract Textiles Pty Ltd v Good Environmental Choice Services Pty Ltd (2009) 181 FCR 360
Jazabas Pty Ltd v Haddad (2007) 65 ACSR 276
KP Cable Investments Pty Ltd v Meltglow Pty Ltd (1995) 56 FCR 189
Livingspring Pty Ltd v Kliger Partners (2008) 20 VR 377
MA Productions Pty Ltd v Austarama Television Pty Ltd (1982) 7 ACLR 97
MHG Plastic Industries Pty Ltd v Quality Assurance Services Pty Limited [2002] FCA 821
PS Chellaram & Co Ltd v China Ocean Shipping Co (1991) 102 ALR 321
Reinsurance Australia Corporation Limited v HIH Casualty and General Insurance Ltd (in liquidation) [2003] FCA 803
Smart Co Pty Ltd v Clipsal Australia Pty Ltd [2009] FCA 1253
Soul Pattinson Telecommunications Pty Ltd v Subex Americas Inc [2009] FCA 651
Southern Cross Exploration NL v Fire & All Risks Insurance Co Ltd (1985) 1 NSWLR 114
Sydmar Pty Ltd v Statewise Developments Pty Ltd (1987) 73 ALR 289
Total Development Supplies Pty Ltd v GRD Building Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 844
Tran v The Commonwealth (2009) 111 ALD 111; [2009] FCA 921.
Date of hearing: 9 March 2010, 14 April 2010
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 84
Solicitor for the Applicant: Mr J Hassett of Hassett Dixon Solicitors and Attorneys
Solicitor for the Respondents: Bell Partners Legal Pty Limited
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr P Knowles

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Health Information Pharmacy Franchising Pty Ltd v Khoo and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 438
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Health Information Pharmacy Franchising Pty Ltd, the applicant, brought an action against several respondents seeking declarations, specific performance, and damages for breach of contract arising from the termination of franchise agreements. The respondents argued that the termination was justified under the terms of the agreements or at general law. The court was tasked with deciding whether to order the applicant to provide security for the respondents' costs in light of the applicant's financial circumstances.

The primary issue for the court was whether the applicant, Health Information Pharmacy Franchising Pty Ltd, would be able to meet an adverse costs order if the respondents were successful in their defence. The court considered the applicant's financial position, which included its negative equity and recent losses, alongside the respondents' submissions that the applicant's cash holdings were insufficient to cover potential costs. The court found that there was a reasonable belief that the applicant might be unable to pay the respondents' costs if they were successful. The court also considered the merits of the applicant's claim and the respondents' defence, finding that the strength of the applicant's claim was a neutral factor.

The court concluded that the applicant's impecuniosity was not solely attributable to the actions of the respondents and, therefore, the court would not order security for costs based on this factor alone. Given the applicant's financial difficulties and the potential for significant costs, the court ordered the applicant to provide security for the respondents' costs.

In light of the findings, the court ordered that within seven days, the parties were to endeavour to agree on the form of orders giving effect to these reasons. If agreement could not be reached within this period, the parties were to re-list the proceeding at the earliest possible time by arrangement with the court's Associate.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Within seven days the parties are to endeavour to agree on the form of orders giving effect to these reasons. If agreement cannot be reached in that time, the parties are to re-list the proceeding at the earliest possible time by arrangement with my Associate.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

It may be a matter of debate whether in Beach Petroleum von Doussa J did place an impermissible gloss of the words of s 1335(1): Reinsurance Australia Corporation Limited v HIH Casualty and General Insurance Ltd (in liquidation) [2003] FCA 803 at [12]-[21]. Be that as it may, I propose to follow the approach in Livingspring and Smart, by focussing on the words of the statutory provision itself. BACKGROUNDThe applicant’s pleaded case In summary, the case pleaded by the applicant is as follows. The applicant is the franchisor and owner of the Health Information Pharmacy franchise. It has entered into written franchise agreements with, and provides various services to, Health Information Pharmacy franchisees operating pharmacies in New South Wales, Queensland and Victoria. The franchise agreements are in standard form, having relevantly identical terms and conditions. The applicant has entered into various individual franchise agreements with each of the respondents and has carried out its obligations under each of those agreements. On 5 November 2009 the respondents purported to terminate their respective franchise agreements by giving notices in writing. By giving the notices the respondents breached the franchise agreement because, in each case, they failed to follow the procedure of clause 23.2. Clause 23.2 provides as follows: 23.2Termination after notice of breachEither party may terminate this Agreement, effective immediately, by written notice to the other party where:(1)the other party breached a provision of this Agreement;(2)the first party gave written notice (Notice of Breach) to the other party which specified:(a)the breach;(b)the fact that the first party proposed to terminate this Agreement as a result of the breach unless the other party remedied the breach within a reasonable period (being not more than 30 days); and(c)the action required by the first party to remedy the breach; and(3)the other party failed to remedy the breach in accordance with the Notice of Breach. The applicant contends that it is a precondition to giving notice of termination of the franchise agreement that the party to whom the notice is given be afforded the opportunity to remedy the breach, as provided by the clause. It alleges that no such opportunity was given by any of the respondents and that, for that reason, the notices were invalid and of no legal effect. The applicant claims declarations and orders for specific performance as well as damages for breach of contract. On the hearing of the motion I was informed that the applicant itself had given notices of termination, with the consequence that the only relief that might be pursued was damages. The respondents, by their defence, contend that, on its proper construction, clause 23.2 does not require the giving of notice as stipulated by that clause (a) where the respondents had already put the applicant on notice of its breaches, the actions required to remedy the breaches and their intention to terminate the franchise agreements if the breaches were not remedied; or (b) where the breaches were incapable of remedy; or (c) where the applicant had repudiated the relevant franchise agreement. The unpleaded assumption in (b) and (c) is that the applicant breached the franchise agreements in a way or in ways that were incapable of being remedied and that the applicant had thereby repudiated the franchise agreements. The respondents also contend that clause 23.2 did not operate, in any event, to prevent the respondents from exercising a right to terminate their respective franchise agreements at general law.The respondents’ cross-claim

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The respondents submitted that the fact that the HCL Group had cash assets of approximately $500,000 as at 31 December 2009 did not remove the risk that the applicant will be unable to meet an adverse costs order (on the assumption that HCL and the applicant are treated as one). They submitted that any cash held by the HCL Group must be considered in light of the group’s overall negative equity. Therefore, it is likely that some or all of the cash assets will be required to meet existing liabilities. Moreover, given the losses sustained by the HCL Group in the six months to 31 December 2009, it could not be assumed that any cash currently held by the HCL Group would be available in the future to meet an adverse costs order. In this regard the respondents submitted that it was notable that the HCL Group’s independent auditor had expressed the view that the profits projected and negotiations with various parties who were prepared to invest in HCL, as mentioned in the Interim Financial Report, were circumstances that were “unlikely to eventuate”. I accept these submissions.Conclusion I am satisfied on the evidence that there is reason to believe that the applicant will be unable to pay the costs of the respondents if they are successful in their defence of this proceeding. I have reached this conclusion by considering the applicant’s financial position alone and also by treating the applicant and the HCL Group as one and the same financial entity. It follows that the threshold requirement of s 1335(1) of the Corporations Act has been met. I now turn to consider those matters that have been brought forward by the parties for consideration as factors relevant to the exercise of the discretion whether or not to order the giving of security. DISCRETIONARY CONSIDERATIONSMerit The strength and bona fides of the applicant’s claim are relevant considerations: KP Cable Investments Pty Ltd v Meltglow Pty Ltd (1995) 56 FCR 189 at 197; Equity Access v Westpac Banking Corporation (1989) ATPR ¶40-972 at 50,636. However, at this stage of the proceeding, it is not possible for me to form any sure view as to the likelihood of success of the applicant’s claim. The respondents accepted, correctly in my view, that the applicant’s claim is bona fide and raises triable issues. However, they submitted that the respondents have raised a bona fide defence to the applicant’s claim, including a claim by way of set-off that the respondents are owed money by the applicant under the relevant franchise agreements: Bryan E Fencott and Associates Pty Ltd v Eretta Pty Ltd (1987) 16 FCR 497 at 514. They submitted that, in these circumstances, the strength of the applicant’s claim is a neutral factor in the exercise of the Court’s discretion and that the Court ought not to inquire further into the merits of the claim: Jazabas Pty Ltd v Haddad (2007) 65 ACSR 276 at 296. The applicant on the other hand submitted that the defence propounded by the respondents was “obviously hopeless” when confronted by the plain language of clause 23.2 of the franchise agreement.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I now turn to consider those matters that have been brought forward by the parties for consideration as factors relevant to the exercise of the discretion whether or not to order the giving of security. DISCRETIONARY CONSIDERATIONSMerit The strength and bona fides of the applicant’s claim are relevant considerations: KP Cable Investments Pty Ltd v Meltglow Pty Ltd (1995) 56 FCR 189 at 197; Equity Access v Westpac Banking Corporation (1989) ATPR ¶40-972 at 50,636. However, at this stage of the proceeding, it is not possible for me to form any sure view as to the likelihood of success of the applicant’s claim. The respondents accepted, correctly in my view, that the applicant’s claim is bona fide and raises triable issues. However, they submitted that the respondents have raised a bona fide defence to the applicant’s claim, including a claim by way of set-off that the respondents are owed money by the applicant under the relevant franchise agreements: Bryan E Fencott and Associates Pty Ltd v Eretta Pty Ltd (1987) 16 FCR 497 at 514. They submitted that, in these circumstances, the strength of the applicant’s claim is a neutral factor in the exercise of the Court’s discretion and that the Court ought not to inquire further into the merits of the claim: Jazabas Pty Ltd v Haddad (2007) 65 ACSR 276 at 296. The applicant on the other hand submitted that the defence propounded by the respondents was “obviously hopeless” when confronted by the plain language of clause 23.2 of the franchise agreement. I do not accept the applicant’s submission in this regard. On its face the respondents’ defence and cross-claim raises a number of issues which strike at the enforceability of the franchise agreements or speak as to their termination by the respondents, notwithstanding the terms of clause 23.2 thereof. The defence and cross-claim also raise claims by way of set-off for the damages claimed by the applicant. I am satisfied that those matters are raised bona fide by the respondents. I am not satisfied that they are “obviously hopeless”. In all the circumstances, based on my present understanding of the competing claims, the merits of the applicant’s claim stands as a neutral factor in the exercise of the discretion.Cause of impecuniosity The respondents submitted that the applicant might more easily resist an order for security if it could show that the respondents were the cause of its impecuniosity: MA Productions Pty Ltd v Austarama Television Pty Ltd (1982) 7 ACLR 97 at 100; KP Cable Investments at 197; Equity Access at 50,635. In this context the word “impecuniosity” must be given a relative meaning. It must be taken to refer to the financial position in which the applicant finds itself, which is the reason why an order for security should be made. In Jazabas at [95] the following passage from Law of Costs, G E Dal Pont was quoted with approval: [T]he plaintiff must be able to support the allegation with relatively straightforward and unambiguous evidence of a fairly compelling nature, because otherwise the hearing of the issue of security might become a trial within a trial. For this reason, it is not enough that the defendant’s conduct is merely a contributing factor — it must be the material contributor to or cause of the plaintiff’s impecuniosity.