Mecrus Pty Ltd v Industrial Energy Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Mecrus Pty Ltd v Industrial Energy Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 103

Citation: Mecrus Pty Ltd v Industrial Energy Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 103
Parties: MECRUS PTY LTD (ACN 088 126 756) v INDUSTRIAL ENERGY PTY LTD (ACN 080 687 681) and HRL LIMITED (ACN 061 930 756)
File number: VID 476 of 2014
Judge: MURPHY J
Date of judgment: 23 February 2015
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Application for security for costs – relevant factors and guidelines in exercise of discretion – ability of plaintiff to meet an adverse costs order – strength of plaintiff’s claims in the proceeding – unity of issues in plaintiff’s claims and respondent’s cross-claims – whether respondent assumed the risk of plaintiff’s poor financial position – whether respondent’s wrongful actions materially contributed to plaintiff’s lack of means
Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Cases cited: ACN 006 577 162 Pty Ltd (formerly Harrop Engineering Australia Pty Ltd) as Trustee for Harrop Family Trust v Beauville Pty Ltd [2014] VSC 298
Australian Equity Investors, An Arizona Limited Partnership v Colliers International (NSW) Pty Ltd [2012] FCAFC 57
B L O’Shea Pty Ltd v Australian Mutual Provident Society Ltd (Unreported, Supreme Court of Victoria, Hedigan J, 15 February 1994, BC9400983)
Beach Petroleum NL v Johnson and Others (1992) 7 ACSR 203
Bell Wholesale Co Ltd v Gates Export Corporation (1984) 2 FCR 1
Bray v F Hoffman-La Roche Ltd and Others (2003) 130 FCR 317
Bryan E Fencott & Associates Pty Ltd v Eretta Pty Ltd and Others (1987) 16 FCR 497
Coca-Cola Amatil Victoria Ltd v PAA Enterprises Pty Ltd [2003] VSCA 135
Cornelius and Others v Global Medical Solutions Australia Pty Ltd and Others (2014) 98 ACSR 301
Denward Lane Pre-Cast Panels Pty Ltd v Cornerstone Constructions Australia Pty Ltd [2008] VSC 144
Equity Access Ltd v Westpac Banking Corporation (1989) ATPR 40-972
Fiduciary Ltd and Others v Morningstar Research Pty Ltd (2004) 208 ALR 564
Gentry Bros Pty Ltd v Wilson Brown and Associates Pty Ltd and Others (1992) 8 ACSR 405
Health Information Pharmacy Franchising Pty Ltd v Khoo [2010] FCA 438
Idoport Pty Ltd v National Australia Bank Ltd [2001] NSWSC 744
Impex Pty Ltd v Crowner Products Ltd (1994) 13 ACSR 440
Industrial Conveying (Aust) Pty Ltd v SKM Recycling Pty Ltd [2012] VSC 588
Interwest Ltd v Tricontinental Corporation Ltd and Another (1991) 5 ACSR 621
Jazabas Pty Ltd and Others v Haddad and Others (2007) 65 ACSR 276
Keary Developments Ltd v Tarmac Construction Ltd and Another [1995] 3 All ER 534
KP Cable Investments Pty Ltd v Meltglow Pty Ltd and Others (1995) 56 FCR 189
Letore Pty Ltd v Associated International Finance Pty Ltd (Unreported, Supreme Court of Victoria, McDonald J, 28 May 1993, BC9303883)
LivingspringPty Ltd v Kliger Partners (2008) 20 VR 377
Meni’s Tailoring & Alterations Pty Ltd v Jeanswest Corp Pty Ltd [2003] FCA 1108
P S Chellaram and Co Ltd v China Ocean Shipping Co and Another (1991)…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mecrus Pty Ltd v Industrial Energy Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCA 103
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mecrus Pty Ltd (“Mecrus”) opposed an application for security for costs brought by Industrial Energy Pty Ltd and HRL Limited (the “IEPL parties”) pursuant to s 56 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) and s 1335 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Mecrus brought seven claims against the IEPL parties for breach of contract, breach of a collateral contract, misleading or deceptive conduct, unconscionable conduct and estoppel. The IEPL parties denied each of the claims and filed cross-claims. The primary issue for the court was whether the discretion to order security for costs should be exercised in favour of the IEPL parties, and if so, the quantum of security that should be ordered.

The court found that the IEPL parties had the burden to demonstrate that Mecrus was unable to meet an adverse costs order if it was unsuccessful in the litigation. The court accepted that Mecrus’ financial position was precarious but found that there were factors against an order for security. These included the strength of Mecrus’ claims, the unity of issues between Mecrus’ claims and the cross-claims, and the fact that the IEPL parties had materially contributed to Mecrus’ financial position. The court found that the balance of factors weighed in favour of Mecrus and against an order for security for costs. The court dismissed the application and ordered the IEPL parties to pay Mecrus’ costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for security for costs is dismissed.

2. The Respondents pay the costs of the application.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The respondents, Industrial Energy Pty Ltd (“IEPL”) and HRL Limited (“HRL”) (“the IEPL parties”), seek an order for security for costs pursuant to s 56 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (“Federal Court Act”) and s 1335 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (“Corporations Act”). The applicant, Mecrus Energy Pty Ltd (“Mecrus”), opposes the application.The factual background Mecrus’ claims arise against the backdrop that in December 2003 a briquette plant in Morwell, Victoria owned by Energy Brix Australia Corporation Pty Ltd (a related party to the IEPL parties) (“Briquette Plant”) was destroyed by fire. In 2004 Mecrus entered into a written agreement with the IEPL parties (“Agreement”) and sub-leased the Briquette Plant from IEPL. In broad terms the Agreement provided that Mecrus undertake a $3,000,000 rebuilding and reinstatement of the plant and commence manufacturing briquettes for supply to IEPL. The plant is located adjacent to a coal-fired power station owned and operated by a subsidiary of HRL. The Agreement obliged IEPL to supply coal and ancillary services to Mecrus on specified terms and conditions, and to pay an annual “Service Fee” to Mecrus. The “Minimum Service Fee” payable per Contract Year (as defined) was the fee payable for delivery of 80,000 tonnes of briquettes. IEPL is a subsidiary of HRL, and HRL agreed to guarantee the performance of IEPL’s obligations. Mecrus alleges that in 2004 the parties also entered into a collateral contract in which IEPL agreed that the coal it provided would be sourced from Loy Yang and would be of a composition and quality to enable Mecrus to manufacture briquettes in accordance with the terms of the Agreement. It alleges that it rebuilt and reinstated the plant specifically to receive and process coal sourced from Loy Yang. It also says that in 2006 the collateral contract was varied to provide that the coal would be comprised of a mixture of coal sourced from Loy Yang and Morwell, and Mecrus would be paid reasonable compensation for the additional costs and increased risks of loss arising as a result. It alleges that in January 2014 the parties agreed that the rate of compensation payable to Mecrus for the supply of coal that was not 100% Loy Yang coal was $750 per day of manufacture. From January 2014 IEPL paid that amount to Mecrus. On 25 March 2009 the Agreement was extended for a further term. It is uncontroversial that the parties understood that the Agreement would come to an end on or about 31 August 2014. Mecrus makes seven claims in its Amended Fast Track Statement for breach of the Agreement, breach of the collateral contract, misleading or deceptive conduct, unconscionable conduct and estoppel. IEPL denies each of the claims in its Fast Track Response and has filed a Fast Track Cross-Claim making five cross-claims. The issues for determination in the present application are:(a)whether the discretion to order security for costs should be exercised in favour of the IEPL parties; and(b)if so, the quantum of security that should be ordered.For the reasons I set out below, in the exercise of my discretion I refuse the application for security for costs.THE EVIDENCE

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The issues for determination in the present application are:(a)whether the discretion to order security for costs should be exercised in favour of the IEPL parties; and(b)if so, the quantum of security that should be ordered.For the reasons I set out below, in the exercise of my discretion I refuse the application for security for costs.THE EVIDENCE Both sides adduced affidavit evidence which goes to the exercise of the discretion to order security for costs, and as to the party-party costs and disbursements the respondents will incur. The IEPL parties rely on three affidavits of Gina Wilson, a partner of Maddocks (the solicitors for the IEPL parties), sworn on 3 November 2014, 17 November 2014 and 3 February 2015 respectively. Ms Wilson attaches the correspondence between the parties regarding security for costs, and Mecrus’ preliminary accounts for the financial years ended 30 June 2013 and 30 June 2014 together with its audited accounts for the year ended 30 June 2012. She deposes that Mecrus is unlikely to be able to meet the IEPL parties’ costs if it is unsuccessful in the proceeding. Ms Wilson does not estimate the overall party-party costs which the respondents will incur in defending the proceeding, but she estimates that the respondents’ party-party legal costs to the end of the first day of trial will be $126,000. She estimates a six day trial. I accept Ms Wilson’s estimate of the respondents’ party-party legal costs to the end of the first day of trial and, for the purposes of the application, I infer that the respondents’ party-party costs overall will be at least $250,000. The respondents also filed a report of Jennifer Young, costs lawyer, dated 27 January 2015. Ms Young provides a higher estimate of the respondents’ party-party legal costs to the end of the first day of trial. This report was served only a few days prior to the hearing, well outside the timetable set, and Mecrus had no opportunity to respond to it. Mecrus objected to its admission into evidence, and the respondents do not rely upon Ms Young’s estimates. I have used the report only to check my acceptance of Ms Wilson’s estimate of party-party legal costs to the end of the first day of trial. The respondents also rely upon an affidavit of Geoff Ternes, the Financial Controller of IEPL, sworn 9 December 2014, responding to an affidavit of Shay Madzikanda filed on behalf of Mecrus regarding a telephone conversation on 8 July 2014 about non-payment of some Mecrus invoices. This issue is not material to my decision. Mecrus relies on:(a)an affidavit of Michael Hazell, a director of Kelly Hazell Quill (the solicitors for Mecrus) sworn 12 November 2014. He criticises Ms Wilson’s estimate of the respondents’ party-party costs, and suggests that the respondents’ estimate of $126,000 is overblown. As I have said, I accept Ms Wilson’s estimate;(b)an affidavit of Barry Richards, the Managing Director of Mecrus, sworn 13 November 2014. His evidence goes to the background to the Agreement including the fact that at the relevant times Mecrus and IEPL had a joint director, the terms of the Agreement, and the nature of the claims. He attaches Mecrus’ preliminary accounts as at 30 September 2014 and deposes that Mecrus is trading profitably and will be able to meet the respondents’ costs if it is unsuccessful in the proceeding; and(c)an affidavit of Shay Madzikanda sworn 13 November 2014 regarding the telephone conversation with Mr Ternes to which I earlier referred.THE LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK

Decision

Reasons for decision

If Mecrus was paid for the stockpile as it sought in September 2014 its financial position would be improved by about $3.7 million, and there would be no question that it was able to satisfy an adverse costs order if it was unsuccessful in the litigation. As I have said, my preliminary view is that Mecrus enjoys better than reasonable prospects of success in its Stockpile claim. It may therefore be said that the IEPL parties have materially contributed to Mecrus’ impecuniosity.CONCLUSION The factor in favour of an order for security for costs is the credible evidence of Mecrus’ inability to meet an adverse costs order if judgment is given against it in the proceedings. There is no other factor of significance in favour of an order. The strength of some of Mecrus’ claims, the unity of issues between some of Mecrus’ claims and some of the cross-claims, the respondents’ assumption of risk, and the fact that IEPL’s actions have materially contributed to Mecrus’ financial position weigh against an order for security. In my view the balance weighs in favour of Mecrus and against an order for security for costs. The respondents had the onus and in my view they failed to discharge it. I have dismissed the application and ordered the respondents to pay the applicant’s costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Even so, the burden rests on the defendant, from first to last, to persuade the court that the order for security should be made: LivingspringPty Ltd v Kliger Partners (2008) 20 VR 377 at [21] per Maxwell P and Buchanan JA. The plaintiff does not bear the ultimate burden of proof in the application for security but it must raise for consideration the matters that favour it if it wishes them to be taken into account in the determination of the case. The evidential burden to raise such matters is distinct from the legal onus of proving entitlement to an order for security for costs, which rests with the defendant: Cornelius and Others v Global Medical Solutions Australia Pty Ltd and Others (2014) 98 ACSR 301 at [18]–[20] per Macfarlan JA.CONSIDERATION The IEPL parties were prompt in bringing their application for security. There is no suggestion that Mecrus’ claim is not bona fide. Mecrus contends only that it will deepen its existing cash flow problems if it is ordered to provide security and there is no evidence that an order of security will stultify the litigation. There is no evidence of any person standing behind Mecrus that stands to benefit from the litigation, including any litigation funder. These factors are not relevant.The evidence as to Mecrus’ ability to meet an adverse costs order I approach this question on the basis that the respondents’ party-party legal costs at the conclusion of the trial will be at least $250,000. The respondents contend that there is credible testimony such that the Court has reason to believe that Mecrus will be unable to pay the respondents’ costs if it is unsuccessful in the litigation. Mecrus denies that it will be unable to pay and it argues that the evidence as to its financial position falls short of the threshold of “credible testimony”. I respectfully adopt the explanation of Lee J in Warren Mitchell Pty Ltd v Australian Maritime Officers’ Union and Others (1993) 12 ACSR 1 at 5 where his Honour said that credible testimony amounts to an obligation:…to show that the material before the court is sufficiently persuasive to permit a rational belief to be formed that, if ordered to do so, the corporation would be unable to pay the costs of that party upon disposal of the proceedings. In Beach Petroleum NL v Johnson and Others (1992) 7 ACSR 203 at 205 von Doussa J explained the requirement ins 1335 in the following terms:In my opinion the power of the court under s 1335 arises if credible evidence establishes that there is reason to believe there is a real chance that in events which can fairly be described as reasonably possible the plaintiff corporation will be unable to pay the costs of the defendant on service of the allocatur, if judgment goes against it. This will be so even if in other events which can also be fairly described as reasonably possible the plaintiff corporation would be able to pay the costs. The degree of likelihood of the plaintiff corporation being unable to pay the costs along with all the circumstances, actual and possible, about its financial position, would then be taken into account in the exercise of discretion, and in framing the orders of the court if the decision is to order security.See also Stelmag Pty Ltd v Tifferly Manufacturing Pty Ltd [2002] ACTSC 99 per Connolly M; Meni’s Tailoring & Alterations Pty Ltd v Jeanswest Corp Pty Ltd [2003] FCA 1108 per Merkel J.